It says I'm short one but I have all the provinces in the colonial region.
Make a bug report?
Missing a province for No Pirates in my Caribbean?
- Thread starter Pieman90
- Start date
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Check the region mapmode. I'm fairly sure that there used to be (at CoP release) some weird crossover between the regions but I'm not sure that's still the case.
Hover over the green bar or the 26/27 in the achievement browser, a tooltip will show you what you are missing.
What area would you put it in then? All provinces must belong to areas and all regions are made of areas. There can be no overlap.
Currently Bermuda is grouped in an island area, in order to belong to one of the Eastern America regions (there is no big region named eastern America but there is one called southeastern America and one called northeastern America) it would have to be in a mainland area (areas must also have atleast 3 provinces).
IMO grouping Bermuda with the islands to its south makes a lot more sense than grouping it with, say Georgia).
- 12
- 3
Optimally I'd see it grouped in with Macaronesia (yeah, yeah, no connection), as Bermuda just seems more like a Falklands than anything else XD
- 2
Why ?
This is especially interesting for Bermuda - why not be in colonial region caribbean when its in region caribbean ?
PS Ive made a bug report of this a couple of days ago.
- 1
Be coherent...
Regions and colonial regions should be identical to avoid something like that.
Bermuda is in the carib region and eastern america colonial region. Both of them having regions/colonial region and vice versa. Moving bermuda to either colonial carib or to the northeastern america region would be coherent and solve such topics.
And yes, it makes sense to group it with the carib region. But if you do it, you should also group it to the carib colonial region.
Cheers
- 8
Now that the region system is non-overlapping, is there even a reason to have "colonial regions" as a separate thing in the first place? Couldn't colonial regions just be those regions that are in the New World?
- 7
What I was hinting at is the absurdity of requiring Bermuda for an achievement that has nothing to do with it, flavour-wise.
Yeah.
TBH, I don't mind it being grouped with the Caribbean for the achievement. There is some historical justification for it, anyway. But keeping it in the Eastern American Colonial Region just underscores an inconsistency.
The more elegant solution for Bermuda would be to remove it, completely, from any Colonial Region. Make it like Falklands (and now Greenland).
- 7
Hi I've noticed that and since you brought it up I wanna ask - is there a particular reason for that limit? I understand it may be a design choice for having a hard rule for, but I'm wondering if it affects anything else under the hood, eg having more of them confuses the AI or something.
Bermuda is closest to North America than Caribbean. just seem odd to place it in Caribbean region.
It's just by choice. Right now it's only used for some event effects (applying effects in the entire area of a semi-random province), naming and victory cards in mp. So there is no reason for it for someone in their own mod. It's not a rule that will change in the base game though.
That was an advantage of the old messy system then...
- 1