• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Hello to all! I bought EU2 recently and have had a lot of fun with it. The forums here are great and I have read several of the AARs with great interest. So I would like to try my hand in one.

This will be a rookie AAR. By that I mean not that I am a rookie writer, but more to the point, a rookie player! So all you veterans can see the silly things I do and foolish mistakes I make along the way.

Details: I am playing Muscovy in the Grand Campaign. So far I have written material up to about 1540 and I have played to 1600. At this point I am confident of survival at least as a significant power, but whether or not I reach the historical power of Russia is very much in doubt.

Goals:

1. Unite the minor Russian powers and form Russia.
2. Destroy the Golden Horde.
3. Expand to form an empire roughly similar to the historical Russia (although much of the Czar's expansion was not until the mid 1800s).
4. Have fun!

The AAR will be written from the point of view of a hereditary family of advisors. Generally speaking, my writing style is mostly interpretive narration. While many other AARs feature very rich character development and conversations, to be honest that is not my strength so my AAR will have very little of it.

I'll post the first one or two chapters soon.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Chapter 1 1419-1424

This is the record of Ivan Wolf, an honorable Muscovite from a family noted for zeal in service for our country and our beloved monarch, Vasily. My grandfather had fought with distinction in a series of skirmishes against Novgorod during the turbulent years after the terrible plague struck in 1350. My father's skills were more on the administrative side. As he advanced in service, he was rewarded with a noble title and from my youngest days I was raised in the royal court.

Vasily, our king, was a dreamer, a visionary. He would be the one to throw off the terrible yoke of Mongol oppression which had enslaved us for some 200 years. He would be the one to unite the squabbling fiefdoms of Muscovy, Suzdal, Tver, Ryazan, and Novgorod -- yes, Vasily dreamed of being the Czar, a Caesar for our time and land.

In the year of our Lord 1419 Vasily set into motion his plans to put us on the path to the glory that would be Russia. Following the recent death of my beloved father, Vasily appointed me as advisor in his place. I felt inadequate, unprepared -- how could I fill my father's shoes? I hoped for success but feared failure; for Vasily was a great king, and I knew well how he rewarded the one and punished the other.

So it was with much apprehension that I, and for that matter all the nobles, heard Vasily boast of his plans. He would sever the hated vassalage with the Golden Horde. We all wanted this above all else, but could we dare? For two centuries the Horde had terrorized us. Their soldiers were countless and powerful. The nobles pressed Vasily, imploring him to wait. When a courier brought the news early in 1419 that Suzdal had broken their vassalage to the Horde, that brought us the opportunity we needed to watch and wait. We would see how the Khan would react.

For months we waited -- and waited -- for the Mongols to strike in punishment at Suzdal. They moved an army into Kazan as if preparing for an attack, but then moved it back to their capital in Samara. Evidently they had more pressing problems. Finally we were confident that we could follow Suzdal's move, which we did early in 1420. Ryazan did the same the next year, and still no reaction from the Horde.

We spent the early years building and preparing for a confrontation with Novgorod. Our insolent cousins dared to think themselves as the natural leader of the Russian people, and Vasily eagerly sought for an opportunity to correct their error. I counseled patience, saying we are not yet strong enough. But a man who would be Caesar does not count patience among his virtues. Vasily showed his displeasure by demoting me to Baronet. With shame and dismay I sought my spiritual mentor, Father Zossima, the man who raised me in the faith. The kind priest knew well what Vasily intended, and he gently set me straight. "Remember the parable of the talents, my son," he said. "The Lord rebuked the one who hid his money but blessed the ones who invested it for good return. You have been given authority to set policy for our country -- to wage war or peace, as our king desires. Vasily gave you this authority for a reason." Father Zossima's rebuke stung me into action. On April 1, 1422 (no joke!) I sent an emissary to Novgorod with a declaration of war. Our armies began to march toward Olonets.

The the other shoe dropped. Tver joined Novgorod. Their action triggered a bewildering series of declarations of war against us by allies of Tver and Novgorod near and far. Our simple intent of a war with Novgorod brought us against a vast coalition: Novgorod, Tver, Denmark, Genoa, Trebizond, and Byzantium. Even Vasily trembled at the news, though only those who knew him well could see it. That night Father Zossima joined me for dinner. He appeared strangely calm while I could scarcely contain my terror. I wondered aloud how can we possibly survive this? The good Father smiled kindly: "Let not your heart be troubled. The news we heard today is not all the news there is." I could not get any more out of him, though I pressed him sorely. It is true that those who serve the Lord have avenues of information that others do not possess. In any case we had crossed our Rubicon.

The courier arrived April 3 with the news that Zossima must have suspected earlier. Countering the coalition arrayed against us was another fantastic alliance of powers we barely knew: Pskov first, then the Teutonic Order, Prussia and Saxony. Ryazan joined them four months later, although they never even moved their army. Mecklenburg joined the other Germans in December. Not our friends, exactly, but they would take the pressure off. The fighting stayed local: Muscovy and Suzdal against Novgorod and Tver. Pskov and Tver fought each other to a standstill while Suzdal fought against small Novgorod forces in the far north. Gradually our armies made progress besieging one province after another. As each new conquest was made I dispatched an ambassador with a generous peace proposal to Novgorod. But the fools always rejected us! What does it take to get them to listen?

Novgorod's continued intransigence brought out the anger of Caesar in our king. Vasily ordered the conquest and occupation of every single Novgorod province, and Tver as well for good measure. The years 1423 and 1424 brought one victory after another: Olonets in February 1423, Novgorod June 1423, Tver June 1423, Ingermanland August 1424, and Kexholm September 1424. Having defeated Tver utterly, Vasily wanted to annex them. But Father Zossima strongly argued against this, saying it would upset our relations with other Orthodox nations. Vasily reluctantly agreed to offer Tver vassalization instead, which they accepted gladly.

There remained the problem of Novgorod. How would we ever get them to listen to a reasonable peace proposal? Vasily and the nobles argued into the night until finally one man spoke up. "They will hear what I say." All stopped to listen to this man, who spoke both rarely and bluntly. His grandfather was awarded noble rank for some service -- no one ever really knew what, though rumors were plentiful -- back in 1337. That man had taken the title of the Duke of Leet in that year, and the title passed on from father to son, to the man speaking before us on September 15, 1424. "Leave it to me, Vasily, they will listen to me."

So the Duke of Leet was sent out, and the news returned soon after: the Novgorodians finally accepted! We received the provinces of Olonets and Kexholm, a frozen trading post in Karelia, and payment for services rendered. When the Duke returned, Vasily held a great banquet in celebration. As the drinks flowed freely, we all laughed and smiled, remembering our brief terror two years before. Many asked the Duke what did he say, what did he do? But he merely smiled ironically as he took another drink. Finally Vasily himself asked, and it was not a question, but a command.

"What did you tell them, my cousin?"

The Duke replied, "All your base are belong to us."

The wine was good that night.

But Novgorod had the last laugh. Somehow during the war, even as their provinces were taken one by one, they saw fit to join a war far away. From time to time our courier brought news of fantastic wars throughout the Mediterranean, wars between giant coalitions of powers both great and small. As if we needed further proof that our Novgorodian cousins were a bit odd, we learned that they joined a war against Albania. Better yet, they won! Yes, even while their homeland was in our possession, Albania accepted peace with Novgorod, paying them in silver and even changing religion! The news brought a merry twinkle to Father Zossima's eye.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Chapter 2 1425-1440

Our joy over our victory was tempered by the news of Vasily's death in February 1425. His son Vasily II Temny set me to the task of planning for the incorporation of Ryazan into our hegemony. During the Novgorod war Vasily I had reinstated me to my former rank, but Vasily II did not need to tell me that the threat was still there if my performance ebbed. I did persuade him to wait several years in order to give our country time to recover and invest in our new provinces. Early in 1429 I spent all my conscious thought trying to create a diplomatic scenario which would leave Ryazan vulnerable but our other neighbors distracted. After many nights of little sleep I sat at my desk, musing aloud......

The peace treaty between Pskov and Tver several years before allowed Pskov military access. During 1429 Pskov cancelled that access and declared war on Tver. When Novgorod entered on the side of Tver, Ryazan followed and that gave us our opening. With Vasily Temny's blessing we declared war on Ryazan and quickly conquered and annexed their land. The war in Tver was settled with no change in territory, and our neighbors' armies were bled down to less frightening levels. I was pleased with the development of events, knowing I would be rewarded by Vasily, when all of a sudden I heard a loud crash.

Ouch! My head! Oh, it hurt -- what happened? I was sitting at my desk, my head hurt, too groggy to think ... what? I must have fallen asleep, I was dreaming, and then my head crashed onto the desktop. My beautiful scheme -- all for naught! Only a dream!

The next day, I sheepishly admitted my dream to Father Zossima, to his great amusement. "Is clever plan, my son, but you need more rest. And to live by dreams is wishful thinking." But soon thereafter we received the news that Pskov cancelled their military access to Tver, just as in my dream. The next step should be a Pskov-Tver war, any day now -- but it didn't happen. At that point reality diverged from my dream; although I convinced Vasily to wait several years, no such declaration of war was forthcoming. It was apparent that Muscovy would have to initiate the action herself. We were delayed by a royal turmoil during 1433, when Yuri IV briefly usurped Vasily Temny's position until Vasily was restored in June of that year. As we waited for a more stable central administration we showered Tver with gifts in order to bring them into our alliance with Suzdal, to which they agreed in 1439.

Meanwhile, on April 4, 1436, we discovered Ethiopia. Who, how, why, no one knows. But they were allied with Scotland in one of the many unintelligible wars in the Mediterranean.

Finally, in January 1440 we seized our opportunity. With Novgorod and Lithuania busy fighting the Golden Horde, Muscovy declared war on Ryazan. Novgorod and Tver fought each other while Suzdal joined us in crushing Ryazan. Peace was settled amicably with Novgorod, while we debated Ryazan's fate. Father Zossima begged Vasily not to annex it, saying it would badly hurt our relations with other Orthodox nations, notably Tver and Suzdal. But our relations with Ryazan were bad from the start and certainly no better now, so Vasily was unwilling to take them in as a vassal. Our kingdom grew to 7 provinces.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Thanks for the comments. I had a couple of other CTDs later on which didn't really matter because they happened just a few months after a save and nothing major was going on then. But I was annoyed with a recent CTD in about 1580. The big bad guys I was really afraid of (Austria and France) both got hit with horrible civil wars in the same year. So I thought: great, they won't be a problem for a LONG time! Then, crash, and when I replayed that section no civil wars. :(
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Chapter 3 1441-1452

For my successful service to king and country I was promoted to Count in 1441. After 20 years I was proud of how far I had come; I only wished my father could have seen me. My son, a young lad of 10, would have a bright future, far more than we could have imagined in 1419.

For several years during the 1440s Vasily II kept us out of wars as we invested in our economy which was woefully primitive. Vasily attempted to incorporate Suzdal and Tver officially into our kingdom, but unfortunately these efforts were unsuccessful. Suzdal declined our invitation to become our vassal in 1446; Tver, already our vassal, declined annexation in 1450 and broke off their vassalization soon thereafter. With hindsight I must admit that the Duke of Leet was not the best ambassador to use for these purposes.

Our real target during these years was the Golden Horde. Muscovy was now strong enough that we could consider waging war against the hated Mongols. With Tver and Suzdal allied with us, even if they were unwilling to be officially part of Muscovy, we waited only for a favorable turn of diplomatic events. This was a long process which began in 1444 when Denmark declared war on the Golden Horde. We did not understand why they wanted to do this, but when their ambassador arrived a few months later and requested military access, we agreed. If anyone wants to fight our most hated enemy, we won't ask questions. We watched the small Danish armies with amusement as they marched from Finland to the Black Sea to do battle with the Horde, usually returning much depleted to march back to Scandinavia. These fools do not know how to fight in the plains, but if they are hurting our enemy we are glad for them.

By 1448 most of our neighbors were involved in a war between Pskov and Wallachia on the one side and Novgorod, Poland, and Lithuania on the other. Sensing that the time was ripe, I initiated a declaration of war on the Golden Horde in February 1448. Our allies Tver and Suzdal joined, but they accepted separate peace offers from the Horde after a few months. Although the Horde fielded much larger armies than ours, their provinces were in turmoil with near constant revolts. Our commanders in the field had mostly easy battles against them as their main armies were sent to confront rebels rather than us.

By August 1449 our armies had captured Tambow, Saratov, Voronezh, and Bogutjar. At that point the Nogai entered the war on the side of the Golden Horde. We had never heard of them, but whoever they are, they appear like locusts, huge armies out of nowhere. Nevertheless we held our gains, but it was clear that only the many rebels kept the Horde and the Nogai from crushing us. We added Ufa to our gains in 1450.

The war changed complexion again in 1451. First, our allies in Tver declared war on their Pskovian neighbors. Although Suzdal dishonored our alliance I was unwilling to do so, and at my urging Vasily joined Tver's war although we were completely occupied with the Golden Horde and really contributed nothing to Tver's battles. We accepted a white peace with Pskov at the end of 1451, but Tver persisted and annexed Pskov in 1452. Meanwhile, the Golden Horde finally settled with Denmark in May 1451, ceding to them the province of Astrakhan. With all of our allies out of the war it was clear we needed to settle soon. The Horde successfully reconquered Ufa in May, but we countered by taking Kazan in October. At that point we negotiated a peace settlement with the Mongols: although we held five of their provinces we asked for only three, namely Kazan, Saratov, and Voronezh. While not a definitive victory it was clear that we had ended the former supremacy of the Golden Horde. No longer were they a dominant power as they had been in an earlier age.

After four years of war Muscovy was victorious but tired. I looked forward now to a period of peace, investment in our new provinces, and further economic development. Alas! It was not to be. On Christmas Eve, 1452 -- oh, how can a Christian nation do this? -- on Christmas Eve, with no provocation whatsoever, the treacherous swine of Lithuania declared war on us. Although our allies Tver and Suzdal fought bravely for us, allied to Lithuania were Novgorod, Poland, and Pommern. As the war progressed it was quickly apparent that we were vastly outnumbered in the field. This was the fight of our lives; sheer survival was at stake.

Early in 1453 our Tverian and Suzdalian allies set siege to Novgorod and the Lithuanian province of Welikia. As the Lithuanian armies marched through Ukraine toward Moscow, our commanders attempted to fight them but victories were few and defeats many. We would scrape together everything we had to field an army of 10 or 15 thousand, only to see the Lithuanians counter with 20 or even 25 thousand. We were unable to prevent them from arriving in Moscow and laying siege to it. King Vasily fled with his family to Vologda as I was appointed to stay behind and direct the defenses of Moscow. The Lithuanian army was large but not insurmountable; our scouts estimated its strength at no more than 30 thousand. I knew we could amass that many troops in the provinces before Moscow would fall. It would be tough, but we could survive.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Chapter 4 1453-1456

This is the record of Ivan Wolf II, the son of the man who served Vasily I and Vasily II for more than 30 years. It is with tears that I write the account of the Lithuanian war, for it brought ruin to our country. The siege of Moscow resulted in utter misery and many deaths. Scarcely any family was spared, and with so much calamity it may seem selfish to focus on one man, but that one man's death brought me more sadness than any other, for that one man was my father.

As my father wrote in our country's official record, the Lithuanians set siege to Moscow in February 1453. At first we were hopeful that we could collect an army powerful enough to defeat the siege forces and relieve our capital. To our sorrow and ruin, that was not to be. For the Lithuanian army was soon joined by a huge force from Novgorod. As if that were not enough, our scouts reported a large Polish army of 20 thousand marching toward Moscow, and soon after that, another 20 thousand Pommeranians. The Lithuanians added more for good measure, and we were powerless even to intercept the reinforcements, let alone relieve the city. At its height the siege force numbered more than 130 thousand from four nations. Moscow was doomed.

All the while we were recruiting and training what troops we could, hoping against hope that we would have a chance to inflict at least some local defeats on the Lithuanians. The news of Moscow's fall in October 1453 brought first shock, then grief, then anger to our soldiers. We swore to retake it whatever the cost, though to be honest it seemed to me that only a miracle would revive our chances.

When our fortunes revived -- was it a miracle? I would have asked Father Zossima, but my childhood priest had died years before -- yes, our fortunes did revive, in a way I had not foreseen. Soon after the fall of Moscow, Pommern offered us a white peace. You treacherous dogs, why then did you fight against us? Having seen Moscow, now you have had your fill of war? Be that as it may, I accepted their offer, and our enemies were reduced to three. Immediately thereafter, we received a peace proposal from Novgorod. No white peace, they demanded tribute in the form of Karelia, which we had taken from them in 1424. Well, it was nothing but a wasteland of ice and reindeer; if that was all it took to get them out of the war, they could have it.

Let me also give credit to our allies. Suzdal fought mainly in Novgorod, and not too well, but the Tverians fought fiercely to defend Pskov and to besiege Welikia. By the time Moscow fell, Tver clearly had the upper hand, so the Lithuanians sent the bulk of their army to fight against Tver. Our enemies left a medium sized Polish army to hold Moscow. This was our chance to fight back, at last! For once, when we absolutely had to have a battlefield victory, our troops held and we defeated the Poles. While most of the Polish-Lithuanian forces fought against Tver and Suzdal in Pskov and Welikia, our siege army held against small enemy attacks. We recovered Moscow in August 1454, and then conquered Tula in April 1455.

Soon after that each side's allies settled; only Muscovy and Lithuania remained. After some skirmishing, Lithuania offered a white peace in December. We still held Tula and out of revenge Vasily II wanted to press for harder terms. But we were broken after seven years of war. We could fight no longer. Though we choked on our words, we accepted the Lithuanians' offer, and at last our land had peace.

Vasily and I returned to Moscow soon thereafter. We hardly recognized our beloved homeland. What had been a prosperous city had become ruin and devastation. As the royal procession marched through the city, Muscovites lined the streets to hail us. But there was little cheer; this was a broken, defeated people. Vasily stopped at the side of an old man with tears on his face: "My son died during the Battle of Moscow." Nearby, a woman sobbed: "My husband died at the walls." Others joined in, telling of sons, fathers, and husbands who had paid the ultimate price in defense of their beloved country. Worse were the accounts of those who had lost their loved ones to starvation during the siege, for this included women and children as well as old men. Vasily kept himself composed as a king should, but I broke down and wept. And as I wept I swore to myself that we would have revenge on the hated Lithuanians. Yes, we hated the Mongols, but they were a known enemy, not operating by deceit and treachery. Looking at my king I sensed that he was sharing the same thought. Someday, somehow, Lithuania, you will pay for this.

At last I entered my father's chamber, now the home of a dead man. Knowing my father, I was certain he had left a record, and I searched until I found it -- yes! here it is, the journal of a faithful servant, a broken and dying man. I dismissed all who were with me as I read my father's journal, with trembling hands and vision blurred with tears.

The record of the city's suffering during the siege was painful and direct. Just as we in Vologda could see hope extinguished as the siege army doubled and doubled again, so those trapped in the city also understood that there would be no relief. One by one our defenders perished at the walls; one by one the Muscovites starved as food ran short. But that much I had known already. What I wanted to know was what was my father's fate? How did he die? I had to know. The late entries finally told the tale:

September 5, 1453. Starvation in the city. Even the young die. I cannot bear it. Today I met a young woman with two small girls. She begged me for food, not for herself, but that her children would not die. I gave her a ring and told her to show it to the Mayor. I am old; I cannot live at the expense of the young.

So it went, day after day, my father sacrificing himself to save those he could. I had found the truth. My father, the ruler of Moscow, starved.

Very slowly Moscow came back to life as relief supplies were brought in from the provinces. Fortunately, aside from Moscow itself there had been only small clashes elsewhere, and little damage. In time the normal routines reestablished themselves, and Moscow was once again a city.

As I directed the rebuilding of Moscow, it happened one day that my guards told me a woman wanted to see me -- no, she insisted on it. I was preoccupied with my work and did not even notice as she entered the room. Her voice both startled and soothed me with its sweetness.

"My Lord, forgive my intrusion, but I have something that belongs to you."

"Young woman, I have never met you. How can you have something of mine?" I was still focused on my work, barely paying attention to her.

"Forgive me, my Lord, but it is something your noble father gave me. It saved my life, and the lives of my two daughters." And with that, she held out a ring for me to take. Now she had my attention. I looked in amazement and saw that she spoke the truth. It was my father's ring.

Stunned, I was unable to move my lips to give voice to the questions that sprang into my mind. So she told me her story. She was the young woman my father met as he walked in the doomed city shortly before its fall. The Mayor, upon seeing her with the official ring, gave her a generous ration, which brought life to her and her children. Unable to thank the man who had saved her, she showered praise and thanks upon the man's son, who was completely unworthy of any such honor.

As she spoke, I marveled at her courage and her beauty. Her husband, as so many others, had fallen in battle. I could not bear to leave her a widow, so she and I were married. I adopted her two young daughters, and our son Ivan was born in 1457. He was named Ivan not for me, but in memory of my dear father.

On May 1, 1456, our king Vasily II Temny presided over a memorial service for all who had fallen in the city. Many spoke in loving remembrance of those who had sacrificed themselves. Finally, it was our king's turn, and as he addressed the people he swore vengeance upon our enemies:

"Woe to you, Novgorod! Your nation will fall as Muscovy will rise. The destiny of all Russians lies with Muscovy and not Novgorod. Behold! Even now your glory is fading."

"Woe to you, Pommern! And woe to you, Poland! For what cause did you fight against us? What profit did you obtain? I say to you, woe! Just as you caused the ruin of an innocent nation for no cause and no profit, so shall it be for you. At a time of crisis you will be attacked by a distant power which will destroy you for no motive."

"And woe to you, Lithuania! As you have sown, so shall you also reap. When you are in need, weak and alone, at that time you will be stabbed in the back by a great power who will show you no mercy. Though it not be until the time of my grandson's grandson, we will crush your bones."
 

Eochaid

CareBear
70 Badges
Dec 25, 2001
2.956
0
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Hearts of Iron II: Beta
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Pillars of Eternity
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Knight (pre-order)
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Cities: Skylines - Natural Disasters
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Cities: Skylines - Mass Transit
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Crusader Kings Complete
  • Europa Universalis 4: Emperor
  • Divine Wind
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Diplomacy
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis III: Chronicles
  • Cities in Motion
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Warlock: Master of the Arcane
  • War of the Roses
  • 500k Club
Hello jwolf.


It's a nice AAR you got there. Clear and esay to read. :)

I hope you'll visit the bAAR so we get a chance to know you a little better.

The bAARtender. :)
 

unmerged(547)

Knight of Naught
Dec 16, 2000
1.174
0
www.freewebs.com
This is good stuff! :D

Waiting until 1448 until warring on the GH. Quite patient, most do it a lot sooner (and to questionable results).
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
As a novice player I am probably doing things way out of order or just plain differently from the standard approach, whatever that is. And I was really lucky with my timing vs. the Golden Horde. Shortly after the war started, in the message log I saw something like

"Golden Horde chooses XXXXX in the Destruction of the Golden Horde Event."

I didn't really know what that meant, but it sounded good, and no doubt that's why they were so badly plagued with revolts just when I was attacking them. Better to be lucky than good!

Chapter 5 to come tomorrow!
 

unmerged(547)

Knight of Naught
Dec 16, 2000
1.174
0
www.freewebs.com
Allright! I am looking forward to it. :)

I once played Russia and allied with the Teutonic Order (after their alliance dissolved). By RM with them (and a couple of bribes), I developed a most potent alliance between Russia, the Order and Denmark. Any possibilities of this developing in your strategy? What of your alliances?
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
As you will see in Chapter 5 and later, Denmark has been my enemy for a long time. No alliance with them! As my game developed, I found I was consistently unable even to vassalize the other Russian states, let alone annex them. The best I could do was to form an alliance with them, and as you will see that's how my political structure is for the next 100 years and beyond.

I think it's fair to say that diplomacy has been my weakest element in my game.
 
Last edited:

Norgesvenn

LurkAAR
95 Badges
Jun 13, 2001
3.522
1
Visit site
  • Pillars of Eternity
  • Supreme Ruler: Cold War
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • 500k Club
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Cities: Skylines Deluxe Edition
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Knight (pre-order)
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Pride of Nations
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Semper Fi
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
  • Europa Universalis 4: Emperor
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Darkest Hour
  • Deus Vult
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Arsenal of Democracy
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • For the Motherland
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria: Revolutions
Don't be bummed out by the diplomacy.

When you get only 1 diplomat a year, it's really hard doing much. Of course, going full aristocracy might help you! :)

A good read it is too.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Chapter 5 1456-1473

Muscovy finally was at peace. Though we lost no territory in the Lithuanian war, economically we were set far behind. Gradually we were able to make small improvements during the next several years, while we kept a deliberately low profile internationally.

Novgorod fell into civil war in January 1457. Serves them right.

And now I come to a painful subject, the downfall of our beloved king, Vasily Temny. Even with hindsight it is difficult to say when we noticed trouble. Was it the strain of seeing Moscow fall, helpless to prevent its ruin? Or was the madness in his blood all the time? Alarming incidents, totally out of character, became more and more commonplace. But how does one tell his king that he needs help? I had lived my whole life under his reign and I loved him not only as my king, but truly he acted like a father to me after the Lithuanian war.

Out of love and respect for my dear former master I will not tell of the scandalous details of his madness. He reigned in Moscow for 37 years and his reign should be remembered for what was noble, not what was base. Early in 1462 we in the palace could hide Vasily's madness no longer; the political crisis became acute. Fortunately our time of turmoil was brief, though it seemed ages at the time! At the end of March, 1462, Ivan III Veliky was acclaimed king, and I had the honor to serve him for the rest of my life.

Ivan Veliky continued our policies of economic development and our internal position appeared to be improving dramatically, when events forced our hands to focus on the military. Denmark had been given military access to our land years earlier, but suddenly in October 1463 they sent notice that they were cancelling their access, and immediately they declared war on us! The Danes' war against us began a long cycle of wars that did not end until ten years later. When we made peace with one foe, another immediately attacked -- or more properly, the second foe's presence compelled us to make any reasonable peace with the first. We fought against Denmark, then Lithuania, the Golden Horde, Denmark again, then Lithuania for the third time. Never did we initiate a declaration of war. During this period our commanders fought bravely and I am proud to report that we held against the Danes and Lithuanians, and actually expanded at the Golden Horde's expense when they attacked us.

Following the initial declaration of war by the Danes, much of the year 1464 saw back and forth fighting in our province of Kexholm at the Swedish border. The Danes attempted to besiege it several times, but each time we beat them back. It appeared that we could hold our own against them, but other events forced us into a second war late in that year, when Novgorod declared war on our ally Tver. Novgorod was joined by Poland and Lithuania; although Suzdal dishonored our alliance, we could not abandon little Tver to this mighty coalition. So we fought alongside our Tverian brothers, and to get the Danes off our backs we paid the Judases their 30 pieces of silver (50 ducats) and the went home.

Early in 1465 Tver and Muscovy began sieges in Novgorod and Tula. The local enemies (that is, Novgorod) were overwhelmed and it took some time for the Poles and Lithuanians to field a significant army in this theater. We were content to press our advantage as far as we could, but then in February the Golden Horde declared war on us! Although we certainly did not want war with them, not now, at least we could understand that they had legitimate reason to hate us. This put us under enormous pressure but our army was able to make a quick strike at the Mongols in Tambow, winning a victory before regrouping to defend Moscow and Kexholm.

To our great relief, Novgorod made peace with Tver in July 1465, ending the threat on that side. We finally had clearance to bring our armies around to counter the Mongols, who were besieging Kazan and in fact took it in December. However, at that point the Horde's allies -- Nogai, Sibir, and Khazaks -- made a white peace with us. Better yet, in February 1466 Lithuania declared war on the Golden Horde.

Now we were in a perfect political situation. We were at war with the Golden Horde, and them only. Meanwhile, we were assured of peace with Denmark and Lithuania, and in fact Lithuania was fighting the Horde. We were not allied, of course, but the more pressure on them, the better. Further, the Mongols' locust allies in Central Asia were at peace with us, but fighting the Lithuanians! The icing on the cake was that the Golden Horde faced revolt after revolt as their country was thrown into turmoil.

The years 1466 and 1467 brought one victory after another against the Golden Horde. Yet the reports from the field seemed so optimistic, so bizarre, that to be honest we in Moscow read them with amazement and disbelief. Eventually Ivan Veliky's suspicion was aroused so much that he sent me to investigate personally the battlefield situation and either confirm or refute these reports (and, in the latter case, to execute the commanders).

Our commanders claimed to have taken Tambow, Bogutjar, and Lugansk by the end of 1466. In March 1467 I traveled south and saw that the reports were true. Tambow was indeed ours, and as I passed through we received word that we had retaken neighboring Kazan. Bogutjar and Lugansk were held by our army as well. In Lugansk I had the following interview with our senior commander in the field:

Q. What opposition did you face in Bogutjar and Lugansk?

A. None.

Q. None? Where are the Mongols?

A. Our scouts report that the Golden Horde faces constant revolts. Even their capital in Samara seethes with rebellion. So the only Mongols we see are the Nogai and Khazaks who pass through in order to attack the Lithuanians in Belgorod, or the rebels in Donetsk.

Q. Do the Central Asians really honor our truce? (I was skeptical).

A. Yes, incredible as it sounds, they are true to their word. Their honor has been without reproach. Yet if war broke out between us they would attack without hesitation.

Next, I traveled to Azov, where we supposedly were besieging the city, aided by the Lithuanians, of all people. Our commander there sensed my incredulity at this news, but he assured me it was all true:

Q. What opposition do you face here?

A. None.

Q. Where are the Mongols?

A. Far away from here.

Q. How goes the siege?

A. The city will fall in 4 to 5 months. It would have taken us longer but having the Lithuanian army here as well has greatly intensified the siege.

Q. When did they arrive?

A. About one month after we did. Their army is four times our size, but their commander simply said he was ordered to assist us in our siege here. They have been true to their word. Every Saturday night we drink vodka with them in order to improve our fraternal relations.

I stayed in Azov long enough to experience one of their drinking parties, and despite my skepticism I have to admit that everything he said was true, although it was hard to remember anything very clearly. I returned to Moscow and reported the good news to Ivan Veliky.

By the end of 1467, we had taken Volgograd and Azov. Having control over 5 of their provinces, we pressed for peace with the Horde, demanding 3 of them. But they refused. Though their country was ruined, they stubbornly refused to make peace. Their only army of note was a large force of 30 thousand stationed at their capital. The years 1468-1470 saw constant fighting in Ufa, Samara, and Volgograd as the Mongols attempted to use their army, but we had scouts following it constantly so it was easy for our commanders to stay out of its way while we destroyed smaller armies and began sieges in order to force the Mongols' hand. If they moved their big army from Samara in order to retake a province, we threatened Samara in return. Once they began to move back to defend the capital, with the advance reports of our scouts it was easy to retreat from Samara before they got there. The Golden Horde, once mighty, was helpless. The only question was how to force them to accept our peace demands.

Early in 1471 Ivan Veliky found a way to accomplish this. In an earlier era we would have used the Duke of Leet, but he had died long ago without heir. Nevertheless, in Leet's honor Ivan ordered the heads of 1337 slain Mongol warriors to be loaded into a wagon and delivered to Samara with our demands. The Golden Horde got the message, and we got Tambow, Bogutjar, and Lugansk.

For the first time in more than 7 years, we were at peace. The peace lasted 36 days. The Judas Jutes declared war on us again in February 1471. Our allies Tver and Suzdal joined us, and this war shaped up much as the previous one with Denmark, although we were worn down from many years of war. The situation became grave, however, in October when the Lithuanians, too, declared war on us.

During 1472 there were several battles against the Danes in our provinces of Kexholm and Olonets, with the Danes unable to keep a foothold in order to maintain a siege. Meanwhile, unfortunately, the Poles and Lithuanians were beating us and set siege to Moscow. Once again our government had to retreat to Vologda. Unlike my father, I went with my king rather than stay in Moscow. Late in 1472 the news was grim as our Tverian and Suzdalian allies dropped out of the wars and Moscow's fall was imminent.

Moscow fell to the Poles early in 1473, and in order to have any chance to recover it we needed to make peace with Denmark. We gave the Judases their pieces of silver (25 ducats) and they went home. With Denmark out of the war we redeployed our army, beat the Poles, and recovered Moscow. The Lithuanians laid siege to Bogutjar, however, and conquered that city in September. By December 1473 we were anxious for any reasonable way out of the war, so when the Lithuanians offered peace for 8 ducats -- our entire treasury -- we accepted their offer.
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
Since I don't expect to post during the weekend, I'll put up the next chapter now. Enjoy!

Chapter 6 1474-1490

Except for 36 days early in 1471, we had been at war continuously from October 17, 1463 to December 2, 1473. Knowing that neither the Golden Horde nor Denmark nor Lithuania could attack us for several years, at last we could count on a few years to rebuild. We were deep in debt, inflation had soared, and we faced numerous revolts in the former Golden Horde provinces now in our possession. Slowly we made improvements, but we were exhausted. We needed a full generation of peace, and I say truly that not one Muscovite had even a hint of longing for any more war!

The truce with Lithuania expired December 2, 1478. To their credit, they honored the truce. They did not declare war again until four months later, on April 11, 1479. Oh, how generous of them! Oh, how I hate them!

As before, we were joined by our allies Tver and Suzdal, while Lithuania was joined by its allies Poland and Novgorod. As it took some time before the Lithuanian and especially the Polish armies made their presence felt, initially the fighting was in Novgorod, and we pressed them hard. Novgorod fell to us late in 1479; the next year it fell back to Novgorod, but we reconquered it early in 1481. Novgorod then offered us peace for 253 ducats. Though we were tempted to press for territory, this was a huge amount of money for us and we jumped at the offer. One loan down.

Throughout 1480-1482 there was seesaw fighting with neither side being able to press a permanent advantage except for our victory over Novgorod. By the end of 1482 Tver, Suzdal, and Poland had dropped out. Now it was one on one, just Muscovy vs. the hated, despised, treacherous Villains of Vilnius, the Lithuanians. This was our golden opportunity. Now we would get our revenge! Now we would crush them! Now at last we would make them pay for four wars!

Fighting was intense and brutal, with neither side giving in to the other. The Lithuanians obtained the first concrete success, taking Bogutjar late in 1483. But our armies turned the tide; though the process was slow, we took Tula in 1484, and in 1485 we reconquered Bogutjar and took Kursk as well.

September 1485 -- at this time, I now admit with great shame, I failed my king. I had served my country for 30 years, and in all that time none could fault my governance. Whether in war or peace I stood faultless before my king. But, oh the shame, oh the grief, in September 1485 I made a calamitous decision that ruined our country. After we took Kursk the Lithuanians offered peace for 175 ducats. Not as much as we got from Novgorod, but still a lot of money which we needed badly. But I was blinded by hatred and thought only of revenge! These were the ones who killed my father 30 years before, and I would never give in to them! I insisted to Ivan Veliky that we never accept peace without territory. At the very least, the Lithuanians must give up Tula, so that never again would they be in one step striking distance of Moscow. So I declined the Lithuanians' offer, and to all subsequent offers, no matter what the battlefield situation, I said: no Tula, no peace.

It is five years later as I write this, and now I see how dreadfully wrong I was. Though I did not know it at the time, our conquest of Kursk was our high water mark; the Lithuanians turned the tide almost immediately, and we never recovered. Moscow fell just before Christmas, 1485. We fought back desperately, but for every victory there were two defeats. Lithuania regained Tula and took Ryazan in 1486; the next year, they retook Kursk. We managed to retake Moscow late in 1487 but we never recaptured Ryazan or even threatened Tula and Kursk again. From 1488-1490 Bogutjar fell to the Lithuanians and we lost Lugansk and Tambow to rebels, unable to spare any forces to counter them. Our enemies took Moscow again in 1490, and today, October 22, 1490 came the news that Voronezh also has fallen.

O woe! Why do not our soldiers fight? The dogs, they panic at the mere sight of a Lithuanian! They will not stand and fight, but run like women! My plans were perfect! At Ryazan, at Tula, at Bogutjar, yes even at Moscow, our troops should have won! It is not my fault! No, no, no, a thousand times no!

And now, at the news of our latest defeat, our king Ivan Veliky has demoted me. Oh the shame! I cannot stand before anyone now without dishonor. But blood washes dishonor.......
 

unmerged(12594)

Second Lieutenant
Dec 10, 2002
187
0
Visit site
jwolf:) sorry to not read your AAR before but i was kind of busy with my own, thanks for your posts again. as for your AAR, it's great. I enjoy reading it all the time. but i have a question, what patch are you playing because those weird alliances don't form a lot in the latest patches. here a tip: if you have any money, say 100 ducats, don't waste it on loans but bribe lithuania and denmark. also, when u have to repay a loan, take a new one and pay the old one off, less interest. good luck
 

Syt

Holstein's Envoy in Vienna
139 Badges
Jan 26, 2001
6.771
237
  • 500k Club
  • 200k Club
  • Crusader Kings III
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Knight (pre-order)
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Fury
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Crusader Kings II: Jade Dragon
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Deus Vult
  • Victoria 3 Sign Up
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Imperator: Rome Sign Up
  • Imperator: Rome Deluxe Edition
  • Imperator: Rome - Magna Graecia
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Stellaris Sign-up
  • Stellaris: Federations
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Stellaris: Lithoids
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Stellaris: Megacorp
  • Stellaris: Apocalypse
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Stellaris: Distant Stars
  • Stellaris: Ancient Relics
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Stellaris: Necroids
  • Stellaris: Synthetic Dawn
  • BATTLETECH
  • BATTLETECH - Backer
  • BATTLETECH: Flashpoint
  • BATTLETECH: Season pass
  • BATTLETECH: Heavy Metal
Nice to see someone play out failure in his AAR, a rare thing and very well written! :)

Ah, yes, sometimes one should settle for what one has, and not strive too far... ;)
 

unmerged(15337)

Field Marshal
Mar 6, 2003
3.699
1
Visit site
NotALlama -- By the way, did anyone ever say you WERE a llama? Anyway, I am playing the original 1.00 version that came in the box. As I posted in the main forum even with some bugs there my own errors will cause much more severe problems. And I have invested so much time with this game I would like to finish it before I update.

As for loans, yes, I noticed that too. Taking a new loan just before you have to repay the old one gives much better interest rates than extending the old loan. The only downside is another point of inflation.

Sytass -- thanks for the compliment. My greed for revenge cost me at least 15 years in economic development, I'm sure. But it is so hard to mix vengeance with patience!