leader/minister skills working?

[unmerged(27287)]

Is there any plans to make the leader/minister skills not working working again? I mean for example the tank buster and carpet bombing traits, or the research and leaderskills traits for ministers? Or are they working properly with the latest patch? Or do I have to wait until I order Doomsday to get those working?

 

[Mork]

Not all bonii shows up even though they do work. Tank Buster for example works (IIRC).

 

[blue emu]

Count the modifiers.

Count the modifiers.

Count the modifiers.

Count the modifiers.

Tank Buster, Fleet Destroyer and Superior Tactician all work as advertised... +10% to combat efficiency when engaged in the proper mission (Ground Attack, Naval Strike and Air Superiority respectively). They just don't display properly in the list of modifiers... except for Superior Tactician.

Presumably Carpet Bomber works, too... I have no reason to think it doesn't.

 

[unmerged(27287)]

Ok. How about the minister skills then? Is the -10% leader skill working? or the +5% research working?

 

[Mork]

Ok. How about the minister skills then? Is the -10% leader skill working? or the +5% research working?

IIRC the -10% skill ain't. Not sure.
The +5% is working, again not completely sure, it is working in DD.

 

[Long Lance]

Ok. How about the minister skills then? Is the -10% leader skill working? or the +5% research working?

The only trait which is not clear is the -10 % leader skill I think, and it is not clear how it should work. Does it mean 10 % absolute, so a skill 2 land commander would not get +10 % combat modifier, but +0, or should it work relative, so skill two would get (10 %* 0,9) = + 9 % modifier. And it is not clear if it works at all...

All other leader/minitster traits should work so far, none here around reported something different.

 

[GAGA Extrem]

What about the new officer skills (desert rat, hill fighter etc.)?
I never noticed a +% tooltip in the combat screen for that...

 

[blue emu]

IIRC the -10% skill ain't. Not sure.
The +5% is working, again not completely sure, it is working in DD.

Correct as far as I know... the +5% Research Minister works fine, the -10% leader skill Minister seems to do nothing obvious... not working, AFAIK.

What about the new officer skills (desert rat, hill fighter etc.)?
I never noticed a +% tooltip in the combat screen for that...

Same as Tank Buster and Fleet Destroyer were in HOI-2 (see the above screen-shots)... it works, and is included in the total modifier... but is not displayed seperately in the list of modifiers.