• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I can't wait for the next AAR. I hope you ask for requests....

I already know that the next one will be a Kaiserreich AAR as I have actually come to like it more then the base game. I already have the mod for HOI2 but I may download Darkest Hour and the mod and play it in that game instead as it seems to be greatly expanded in that game. I am undecided on the nation I will play but I have some ideas that I may put to a vote and you are of course welcome to give suggestions for what nations you think would be fun.
 
I already know that the next one will be a Kaiserreich AAR as I have actually come to like it more then the base game. I already have the mod for HOI2 but I may download Darkest Hour and the mod and play it in that game instead as it seems to be greatly expanded in that game. I am undecided on the nation I will play but I have some ideas that I may put to a vote and you are of course welcome to give suggestions for what nations you think would be fun.

I'm going to hold off on asking for a National Populist AUS one since I talk about it all of the time, unless that's fine.
 
I'm going to hold off on asking for a National Populist AUS one since I talk about it all of the time, unless that's fine
That particular nation wasn't actually on the list of nations I was considering, but feel free to make your pitch to me about why I should play it if you wish.
 
That particular nation wasn't actually on the list of nations I was considering, but feel free to make your pitch to me about why I should play it if you wish.

I'd go with Entente Delhi, reverse Clive and have the Peshawar Lancers ride through London in triumph! From the North-West Frontier to Northhampton!
 
That particular nation wasn't actually on the list of nations I was considering, but feel free to make your pitch to me about why I should play it if you wish.

I was thinking of seeing you play as the AUS and be a total Wild Card. To hell with everyone else unless it benefits you. I find that the AUS is in a rather versatile position.
 
Well, for a game like this one you would have to pick a country with which to take over much of the world and then switch to another after the deed is complete.

I for example played a Constitutional Monarchist Russia with which I conquered all of Europe, much of Asia and could potentially go on but go rather tired of it. I noticed that the CSA (combined Syndicates of America) had won the american civil war and emerged as a Communist nation in control of Canada, Mexico and parts of South America... kind of reversed Cold War really. (Fortunately they never allied with the International)

I then had the thought of Switching to the CSA and engage in a crusade to restore socialism! XD but never got around to doing it...

Another experiment I made was to play each of the fighting nations of the American civil war one Month at a time and give each enough aid to keep them in the war if I saw that I was beating one of them at the time. In this way the war went on for a very long time... and I had a lot of fun. You could potentially play one side in the American civil war (Such as MacArthur dictatorship) to the point where victory is almost assured and then switch to another faction to fend him off. I did that too but lost to his overwhelming industry.

If you want another total conquest game then you could conquer the world with the USA and then Switch to another nation... maybe Japan? It really does depend, the options are after all limitless! :)


By the way on the Chinese matter, I don't know much but I encountered a similar problem once before. At the time I solved it by changing the game date back to the 30's ( I was trying to mod the game era)

Maybe because you are playing such a year advance game Nationalist China is no releasable? if that is the case you might have to do a bit of modding to get her back up.
 
Well, for a game like this one you would have to pick a country with which to take over much of the world and then switch to another after the deed is complete.

I for example played a Constitutional Monarchist Russia with which I conquered all of Europe, much of Asia and could potentially go on but go rather tired of it. I noticed that the CSA (combined Syndicates of America) had won the american civil war and emerged as a Communist nation in control of Canada, Mexico and parts of South America... kind of reversed Cold War really. (Fortunately they never allied with the International)

I then had the thought of Switching to the CSA and engage in a crusade to restore socialism! XD but never got around to doing it...

Another experiment I made was to play each of the fighting nations of the American civil war one Month at a time and give each enough aid to keep them in the war if I saw that I was beating one of them at the time. In this way the war went on for a very long time... and I had a lot of fun. You could potentially play one side in the American civil war (Such as MacArthur dictatorship) to the point where victory is almost assured and then switch to another faction to fend him off. I did that too but lost to his overwhelming industry.

If you want another total conquest game then you could conquer the world with the USA and then Switch to another nation... maybe Japan? It really does depend, the options are after all limitless! :)


By the way on the Chinese matter, I don't know much but I encountered a similar problem once before. At the time I solved it by changing the game date back to the 30's ( I was trying to mod the game era)

Maybe because you are playing such a year advance game Nationalist China is no releasable? if that is the case you might have to do a bit of modding to get her back up.

Well, I actually didn't think about doing a scenario similiar to this one. The idea for this one sort of just came to me out of the blue from an old game I played of this a long time ago. When I got turned onto AARs, the idea came back to me.
 
If you want a challenge then I think a smaller power would be the better choice however the problem is that those tend to lack the amazing event chains of the larger nations in KR.

Maybe one of the Italy's? you could potentially mod Germany not to protest against the French, South Italian invasion of the federation and face them on your own. That should be a hard game. An alternative would be to play South Italy (the syndicalist one) or even the Union of Britain with the intention that the Commune of France be defeated.

There is also the possibility of Metalafrika, One of the Spanish governments, Mexico or one of the larger south Amerikan countries. Germany, UoB, Russia, Japan, China, CoF and all those tend to be too easy unless you make restrictions for yourself on gameplay.
 
I'd go with Entente Delhi, reverse Clive and have the Peshawar Lancers ride through London in triumph! From the North-West Frontier to Northhampton!

I second this. I've been thinking of doing one as Delhi, but I'd rather do my MDS2 US idea.

So if you do this I'll have an excuse not to :p
 
\
By the way on the Chinese matter, I don't know much but I encountered a similar problem once before. At the time I solved it by changing the game date back to the 30's ( I was trying to mod the game era)

Maybe because you are playing such a year advance game Nationalist China is no releasable? if that is the case you might have to do a bit of modding to get her back up.

I have changed the release date to 1964 last I checked. That was a problem I encountered earlier as well but I do not think it is the problem here.
 
Can we see the world map as it stands?

EDIT: Also, take a look at the first page of the AAR...
 
Last edited:
EDIT: Also, take a look at the first page of the AAR...

6qk114.jpg

Truman not only liberated the world, he freed people from having to use these Third Reich-approved stamps. :laugh:
 
Truman not only liberated the world, he freed people from having to use these Third Reich-approved stamps. :laugh:

I have seen that before. I have no idea where it came from but I do not have the picture that was supposed to be there on my current computer. I think it might have been a prank by one of my roommates, who hijacked my computer while I was out of the room and changed some of what I wrote.

Ok, I have simply decided I have had enough of this stupid problem delaying my finishing this AAR. In light of that, it is time to invent a reason why China is not released in game.

The War was finally over. For the people of America, it was something that they had trouble believing. For 13 years they had poured there blood sweat and tears into defeating the forces of Germany and there allies. At the time, it had seemed an impossible task. The American David taking on the German Goliath who had already conquered the most of the World. After 13 years of struggle, that notion had finally been proved wrong. Despite fighting against long odds and at the cost of Hundreds of Thousands of dead, Germany and her allies lay beaten. Even Japan, which had continued the struggle against all of the odds, now had to admit that it was beaten. For the rest of the World, this had an even great significance. They had been fighting Germany since 1939, meaning that this war for them had been going on for 22 years. An entire generation had thus grown up knowing nothing but war, death, and occupation. That had all ended when the Americans finally decided to take a stand. They had sacrificed the flower of their youth in order to free the rest of the World from the yoke of Fascism. These people now owed there freedom and their lives to those brave Americans who had given there lives so that they could have freedom. But America had not done it alone. Canada had been with them since the beginning and many more countries later joined the struggle after America and her allies gave them their freedom. What had started as the brave Americans taking on the rest of the World eventually became a grand crusade with almost the entire world arrayed against the Germans and their allies. It was largest and bloodiest war in the history of humanity and all of there other wars combined had not cost as much in blood as this one war did. For America, the toll had been among the greatest. The bloody slog across Spain alone had cost more men then the entire American Civil War, what had formerly been the bloodiest War America had ever fought. America, with its massive army of over 8 million men, was now without a doubt the most powerful nation in the world and one question now remained. What would America do with that power? Would it take advantage of that massive army to behave like the World Hegemon that it had become, or would it trade on the good will it had won by liberating all of the Old World from the forces of fascism to try and build a lasting peace. To Truman, however, there was never any question. "We did not just fight a war to rid the World of Fascist domination to replace it with our own" was his response to the question. As such, Truman went about deciding just what the world would look like after the War. He started by handing over several small territories that America had seized during the war. For the most part, these territories were given to their original owners. The only exception was Konigsberg and the neighboring Suwalki region, which were given to Lithuania, Germany having given up all claim to them. Poland of course objected, wanting the land themselves, but being in no position to mount any serious armed challenge with its people wholly sick of war, they let the situation pass.

After that, the next big question to face would be what to do with the two behemoths of Russia and China. For China, the problem was even bigger. The Japanese occupation, hated as it was, had managed to do the one thing the Nationalist government that preceded it had never managed to do. It had utterly destroyed the forces of the Chinese warlords who had ruled most of the country. With both the Nationalists and Communists thoroughly discredited, the big question was how would rule the massive nation. This proved any even bigger problem then anyone could have imagined, as the Japanese dismantling of Warlord rule along with the both the Nationalists and the Communists, had left a massive power vaccuum. Before they were ejected, the Japanese had filled this power vaccuum with their own occupational administration. With that gone, the Americans had taken up the administration of the country. Now they lacked any idea of what to do with the Country. Putting the Nationalists back in charge was not an option, as They were widely hated by the Chinese people both for the rampant corruption that had plagued their regime and the utter incompetence with which they had conducted the war with China. They and the Communists had failed to stop the Japanese from conquering their nation and subjecting it to unspeakable horrors. As for the Warlords, they could not be restored either because of the fact that the Japanese had utterly destroyed their old power bases. Surprisingly, their was actually a very vocal minority of people in Congress who actually wanted to break China up into several different, thus weakening it and ensuring that mighty China would never again pose a threat to America. Truman quickly rejected that idea, as it would only lead to interminable wars of unification and whoever won those wars would be in possession of both a war economy and the world's largest population, all of whom would hate America's guts. Since no one knew who to put in power in China, the decision was made to let the Chinese people decide for themselves. The announcement that a Constitutional Assembly would be assembled so that the Chinese people could draw up a new Constitution to decide how they would govern themselves. The Assembly would be composed of one representative from every province, chosen by the people of each province. In the meantime, the Americans would continue to administer the country until the Chinese had decided what form of government they wanted to have. Meanwhile, they would seek out capable locals to administer the regions. Then, when the government had formed, the Americans would turn the country over to them.

The Constitutional Assembly, when formed, was a motley group and would prove incredibly volatile. This was owed to the fact that it was composed of people from all across China and included former Nationalists who were not high up enough to be tainted by its defeat or had reputations for incorruptableness, former Communists who still had some adherents among the peasantry, Republicans, and even a few monarchists. None could seem to agree what kind of government China should have. The Communists wanted a return to the old Communist form of rule through a single party Communist State, the Nationalists wanted a new Authoritarian government, the Republicans wanted a fully democratic China, and the Monarchists wanted a restoration of the Emperors of old. Of these groups, the Republicans had the most members, but not enough to constitute a true majority. Of course, with all of these groups being so diametrically opposed, compromise was made very difficult. For a while, it looked like the Assembly might desolve into an interminable deadlock, each group shouting at each other and never able to reach a consensus. That deadlock was eventually broken by Sun Fo, the Son of the Late Republican hero, Sun Yat-Sen.
2ilk4ts.jpg

Fo had been a prominent member of the Koumingtang, even briefly serving as Premier when Chiang Kai Shek had been forced to briefly retire in 1931 as a result of the Japanese invasion of Manchuria. Afterwards, he had served as the head of China's Legislature, the Legislative Yuan where he had proved an outspoken critic Chiang's Authoritarian policies, even advocating cooperation with the Communists against the Japanese. This earned him the somewhat grudging respect of the Communists, as he had been one of the few members of the Nationalist Government to realize that the Japanese were really the greatest threat to China. Despite having served in the Nationalist Government, Sun now supported the Republicans, eventually becoming the leader of the Republican faction. Realizing that if Consensus was not reached soon, China stood a very real chance of descending into Civil War, Sun Fo set out to break the deadlock. Correctly identifying the Monarchists as the weakest faction, he set out to win them over first. This he managed to do through two methods. First, he pointed out that they had no chance of getting any where in the Assembly with out support and offered his own support, but with a price. He would throw his support behind The restoration of the Emperor, but only on two conditions. The first condition was that while the Emperor would be Zhu Rongji, the last member of the former Ming imperial house.
zt8bp5.jpg

Zhu Rongji pictured here with his wife Lao An
This was a no brainer, however as the former Qing Emperor, Pu Yi, had sided with the invading Japanese and had served as leader of Manchuria. This made him the most unpopular man in China. Overjoyed, the Monarchists accepted. What they did not know, however, is that while Sun Fo was perfectly willing to install Zhu Rongji as the new Emperor, he was only willing to do so on one condition: that the new emperor would be a figure head without any real power. Indeed, Sun Fo was actually counting on the people, being disillusioned with the idea of being ruled by an Emperor, rejecting the appointment of an Emperor after the Constitution had been ratified. This would then have allowed him to simply abolish the position, with the powerless emperor being completely unable to stop him from doing so. While he knew this betrayal would lose him the support of the monarchists, he believed that the act would win the vast majority of the people over to his side. With the people firmly behind him, the monarchists would be completely unable to react and the new Republic would be firmly established in the hearts and minds of the Chinese people. Future events, however, would prove this to be both unnecessary and unwise and lead him to eventually abandon the plan. With his block now controlling a slight majority in the Constitutional Assembly, Sun Fo proposed his new Constitution. The Constitution would be a mix of both the British and American Constitutions. From the British, the idea of Constitutional Monarchy was taken. The Emperor position would have only ceremonial responsibilities with no real power and would serve as a figure head and symbol of the nation. Below him, would be a popularly elected President, in whose hands all executive power would reside. The President's term was set at 8 years, with a limit of 2 terms. Legislative Power would rest in the hands of the newly reconstituted Legislative Yuan, which would be composed of two houses. The Yuan would be based largely upon the United States Congress. Whereas the last body had been unicameral, the new Yuan would be Bicameral. The lower house, known as the Council of People's Representatives, would be composed of popularly elected delegates who would be allocated by each province according to population with each member serving a 4 year term. The upper house, Known as the Grand Council of State would be composed of a group of delegates which were appointed by the President, on the advice of the governors of each province and requiring the Yuan to confirm every appointment. Each Province would receive 1 representative in this body and the Representatives would serve for 6 years. Instantly the Communists and Nationalists both attacked the doctrine. Communists disliked it because they believed it a step backward to the old days of the Emperors and believed that the extreme reverance given to the Emperor meant that even without any formal power, he would still have far too much influence with the branches that did have power. The Nationalists also disliked it because they did not trust the Democratic principles it was based upon, believing the average Chinese citizen too undereducated to use their votes responsibly or even understand how the system worked. they advocated a return to the "Political Tutelage" that had always been espoused by Chiang Kai-Shek's government, with One leader holding power until the masses could be educated enough to properly participate in the democratic process. Sun Fo, who had seen this system in action, refused to consider it, as he believed that it could all to easily devolve back into the authoritarian state that Chiang Kai-Shek had governed. However, Sun Fo was able to assuage the fears of many by offering himself as the first President. While Sun Fo was a Republican, he had started his career as a Nationalist. This meant that he was a known quantity to them and many of them believed that with him in charge, they would have a man they could work with in power. This caused the Nationalists to fracture, as many of them, won over by this promise, switched their votes to support of the Constitution. That left only the communists as the sole remaining voice of dissent in the Assembly. However, they were too few in number to block ratification and thus Sun Fo's new Constitution was passed.

The Next day, Sun Fo made the announcement of the new Constitution and Proclaimed the foundation of the newly minted Chinese Nation to roaring applause. After doing so, he handed proceedings over to Zhu Rongji, informing the people that he had been chosen as the new Emperor. At this news, they got very quiet. They were unsure what to think about this, as the idea of the emperor was largely discredited. That was when Zhu Rongji got up and presented the following speech.

"People of China, I have been selected for the honor of serving as your new Emperor. Though my position is largely a symbolic one, I still feel that I am unequal to and unworthy of this position.This is not because I doubt my own ability, but because I believe there is no one who is worthy of leading such a great people as you. I am aware that my family lost the throne centuries ago. We had become corrupt and we deserved the fate that befell us. However, until our family was corrupted with their power, we served with pride and dignity. Further, we did not disgrace our good name by turning to foreigners to try and impose us on our people against their own will. No, we took our deposition with dignity. The Aisin Goro clan has not done so. When you threw them out, their last emperor, Pu Yi, sullied his name and that of his ancestors by going to the Japanese to reinstall him. He willingly allowed himself to become a puppet that the Japanese used to oppress our people and subject them to unspeakable horrors. In doing so, he sullied not only his own name and honor, but that of my own ancestors who served this nation with pride. He has sullied the very name of Emperor with his dishonorable actions and has proven himself to be worthy of nothing but scorn. The sight of my ancestors good name being smeared in the mud by this man fills me with rage. And when his masters the Japanese, invaded to try and inflict him on the people of Manchuku and impose their will on the rest of us, you turned to your government, led by the Koumingtang, the people who had overthrown him before, to save you. However, their leaders proved unworthy of the great legacy bequethed to them by Sun Yat Sen and they failed you. You put your trust in them, and they let you down. Despite their best efforts, they failed to protect you from the Japanese and the result was that you had suffer innumerable indignities and atrocities at the hands of the Japanese oppressors. However, despite enduring horrors that by rights should have broken you, you did not break. You persevered and refused to have your spirit broken by 12 years of brutal occupation. you waited and you hedged your bets, you resisted with brave guerilla acts for as long as possible. You never gave into despair, though by all rights, you should have done so. Their can be no greater indication of the true greatness of a people then their ability to persevere in the face of such horror, and you have passed this test. This has convinced me that you are the finest people in the world and it fills me with pride to be chosen to lead such a people. Their is no greater honor that could be given to me. Though I am unworthy of leading such a great people as you, I will do my best to prove worthy of you. In the end, I hope I shall prove worthy of the trust that has been placed in you by me. You have put your trust in so many people in the past and they have betrayed that trust. I only hope that I will prove to be more worthy then my predecessors."

2a7vn7a.jpg


When he concluded, their remained none in the crowd or listening on the radio who was not swayed by the speech. Any who had been unwilling to accept the idea of a new emperor being appointed were won over by the sincerity that they heard from their new emperor and the crowd in attendance began to shout his name until they made themselves hoarse. The following day, Sun Fo, with the emperors endorsement, was elected the nations first President in a land slide. Over the course of his term, he and the Emperor would prove to be an unbeatable team. Sun Fo set his sights on educating the peasantry, setting up schools in every village with a rigorous curriculum and compulsory education till the age of 16. In addition, he set up numerous universities all over the country that were open to all. In order to encourage the best and brightest from all backgrounds to go to these institutions, he also set up an extensive system of aid to them. Every year, the Ministry of Education would compile a list of all Graduates in the country. They would then place them into one of 4 tiers. The top tier was composed of the top 25% of all graduates based on an evaluation of all their work from when they first enrolled, till graduation. This group would, regardless of background, be given full rides to any college of their choice to pursue any career they wished if they so chose. The second tier was the top 50%, the 25% of students who were still above average, but not quite the best of the best. This group would have the state cover half of their education costs, having to make up the rest with either the abundant independent scholarships that had been set up or out of their own pocket. The third tier were the students who only ranked in at average, the middle 25%. These students received a quarter of their education payed for. The bottom tier, the bottom 25%, would have no public aid for their education. This ensured that the best and brightest, regardless of background, would find no trouble going to higher education if they chose, as all of the money they would receive would require no repayment. If a student in the top tier refused to go to college, their full ride would be given to the top student in the second tier. This helped to motivate the students to push themselves, as if they did well enough, they could rise up in the world regardless of background. With this system, China would go from having a vast, largely uneducated peasant class to having one of the highest literacy rates in the World.

To ensure that all government officials were highly qualified, the Constitution also required that every person who wanted to run for public office or hold a position in the state bureaucracy had to have a college degree or pass an examination that showed they had an equivalent amount of knowledge they would have received in a university. In addition, all those seeking a position in one of the government bureaucracies would also have to pass two examinations. The first was to demonstrate basic competency, of which the vast majority of applicants would usually pass without trouble. The second was to determine how knowledgable you were in the field the agency you wished to join dealt with. Only those who displayed at least a rudimentary grasp of the position were allowed entrance. This helped to weed out corruption and incompetency in the government, both problems that had plagued the nationalist government.

Sun Fo also sought to reform the army, which had been plagued with organizational problems and incompetency during the nationalist era. He set up a new system of organization that largely resembled that of the American army to solve the first problem. To solve the problem of competency, he also instituted a new evaluation process for promotions. When someone was recommended for promotion, their performance up to that point would be reviewed by a superior. If the evaluator was confident that based on that information, they would be able to fulfill their new duties, the promotion was approved. If the evaluator could not find sufficient grounds to approve or deny the petition, the candidate would be given an opportunity to demonstrate their competency with an examination. If the examination results proved that they were competent enough to hold the new rank, they were then promoted. This method would eventual result in the Chinese army being regarded as one of the more professional and disciplined armies in the world.

The majority of Sun Fo's two terms in office, however, would be dominated by one project: the rebuilding of China's industrial capabilities. What little industry China had had been devastated in the war and would have to be rebuilt. China would need to industrialize rapidly if it wanted to catch up to other nations and Sun Fo was determined to do just that. In order to do so, he gave massive subsidies to perspective industrialists to set up new factories and other such industries in the country. He also gave massive incentives for foreign companies to set up branches in China. He also set up a vast array of state run factories in much of China that would later be sold to private individuals once they had been made profitable. This policy would prove very effective and by the time Sun Fo would leave office, China's industrial capacity had already surpassed their pre-war levels of development and was continuing to grow.

Thus, despite suffering one from a long costly war with Japan and an even more brutal 12 occupation, China would emerge from the ashes as a strong nation united behind its strong and dedicated leaders. However, while the issue of what to do with China had been solved, their still remained the issues of what to do with Russia, Japan, and the various territories that still remained under American control. These issues would prove to be the subjects of even more bitter debate then the issue of what to do with China.

Alright, at long last, an update. The next one will deal with Russia but I do not know when it will come out
 
Last edited:
That civil service requirement sounds like there'll be a similar "overeducation" problem as in OTL's Korea.
 
That was a good update.:)
 
Is China ruled by the Illusive Man or something? :p
 
I already read this AAR from start to finish before, but I'm reading it again for advice on my current game, which is starting to look a lot like this (although I didn't set it up that way).

What happened was, I started a game as the US in order to try our the ahistorical Communist USA route. I set AI aggressiveness to Furious, which may have influenced some of the ridiculousness that occurred.

So I got the revolution to occur, and then things went pretty much historically for the first few years, except that the US joined the Allies in 1936. Then things went ahistorical in 1938. Instead of giving up the Sudetenland to Germany without a fight as in RL, the Czechs chose to fight. A few days later, the UK declared war on Germany, starting WW2 in September 1938.

Well, Germany conquered the Czechs (as well as Poland and Yugoslavia, which also joined the war) and then declared war on the Low Countries and finished off France. Same as RL, except one year early. But then, more ahistoric events happened when Nationalist Spain, Portugal, and Greece all joined the Axis.

But then the real kicker happened. Germany didn't declare war on the Soviets. Instead, the Soviets declared war on the Allies. On the Allies. Germany and the USSR are both at war with me and not at war with each other, making for a very tricky situation indeed.

Japan also conquered China and turned them into an unfair puppet like they usually do in Arma. It's 1945 and the Axis have around 600 divisions, the Comintern around 500, and the Japanese 400. Because my buildup was a little slow, I have around 200 divisions to face the 1500+ divisions of my enemies. God help me.

If you're wondering what I was doing the whole time, I was conquering Latin America. Now I control both North and South America, but the Axis+Comintern forces pretty much control all of Eurasia. Since the situation is quite similar to this AAR, I went back to reread it. :laugh:

EDIT: My situation differs from this AAR in that the UK has not fallen and the Allies still hold Africa and Oceania, although Australia is already being invaded. Nevertheless, Germany plus the USSR plus Japan is a fearsome force to fight. If this AAR is any indication, I'm in for a long war extending up to the 1950s at least.
 
Last edited:
That civil service requirement sounds like there'll be a similar "overeducation" problem as in OTL's Korea.

It might. I must admit to being rather uninformed about this issue despite at one point having a room mate from Korea, so I cannot really comment that extensively on this point

That was a good update.:)

Thank you very much.
Is China ruled by the Illusive Man or something? :p

No, I really do not know what happened there. I put in pictures for Sun Fo and Zhu Rongji into the file, but they simply did not show up. The Republic of China is actually an entirely separate nation that I actually had to create. Basically, I took one of the unused minor nations added in Armageddon, in this case Jamaica, and modded it so that it would be the Republic of China. The name, flag and color changes when fine, but the pictures for the ministers did not for some reason. Therefore, the ministers are all named Blue_Shadow, which is the default name.

I really like your China update. Well done.

thank you very much. I worked very hard to come up with a reasonable way China could be constructed post war and I am glad you liked the result.

I already read this AAR from start to finish before, but I'm reading it again for advice on my current game, which is starting to look a lot like this (although I didn't set it up that way).

What happened was, I started a game as the US in order to try our the ahistorical Communist USA route. I set AI aggressiveness to Furious, which may have influenced some of the ridiculousness that occurred.

So I got the revolution to occur, and then things went pretty much historically for the first few years, except that the US joined the Allies in 1936. Then things went ahistorical in 1938. Instead of giving up the Sudetenland to Germany without a fight as in RL, the Czechs chose to fight. A few days later, the UK declared war on Germany, starting WW2 in September 1938.

Well, Germany conquered the Czechs (as well as Poland and Yugoslavia, which also joined the war) and then declared war on the Low Countries and finished off France. Same as RL, except one year early. But then, more ahistoric events happened when Nationalist Spain, Portugal, and Greece all joined the Axis.

But then the real kicker happened. Germany didn't declare war on the Soviets. Instead, the Soviets declared war on the Allies. On the Allies. Germany and the USSR are both at war with me and not at war with each other, making for a very tricky situation indeed.

Japan also conquered China and turned them into an unfair puppet like they usually do in Arma. It's 1945 and the Axis have around 600 divisions, the Comintern around 500, and the Japanese 400. Because my buildup was a little slow, I have around 200 divisions to face the 1500+ divisions of my enemies. God help me.

If you're wondering what I was doing the whole time, I was conquering Latin America. Now I control both North and South America, but the Axis+Comintern forces pretty much control all of Eurasia. Since the situation is quite similar to this AAR, I went back to reread it. :laugh:

EDIT: My situation differs from this AAR in that the UK has not fallen and the Allies still hold Africa and Oceania, although Australia is already being invaded. Nevertheless, Germany plus the USSR plus Japan is a fearsome force to fight. If this AAR is any indication, I'm in for a long war extending up to the 1950s at least.

That does sound about what I faced. In fact, you might have it a little worse because you are facing the Soviets as well. At least you did not have your army all ten different kinds of disorganized when you first loaded up like I did. That was so ridiculous I didn't know whether to laugh or cry at the AI's spectacular lack of confidence. In addition, I am glad that this AAR could be of help to you.

With the China issue settled, Truman now had to move onto the issue of what to do with Russia, where he would face the complete opposite problem he had with China. Whereas China had been and issue because no one knew what to do with it, Russia was a problem because everyone had a different opinion of what to do with it. The Controversy, however, was largely centered around two main camps. One was championed by many of the Presidents political advisors and the other by his victorious generals, many of whom had gone into retirement after the wars conclusion. The Former plan had been first proposed by the Vice President, John F. Kennedy while the military plan was first proposed by General Marshall, who remained a close confidant and advisor to the President, despite being replaced as Secretary of Defense by the now retired General Bradley.

The controversy rested on the question of whether Russia was to remain as one nation or be divided up into its constituent parts. Most of the Presidents political advisors favored the "One Russia" option. The military, however, counseled him to go with the "Many Russia's" Option. There argument was both strategic and political in nature. The strategic dimension of the debate centered around the strength of a unified Russia. To these generals, a Unified Russia was far to powerful and unpredictable to be released as one unified whole. If this was done, then they feared Russia might one day come to rival the United States in terms of strength. The resulting struggle for dominance could imperil the peace they had fought for, which they refused to consider. When their opponents asked why they had not raised similar concerns with China, they responded by saying that pro-American sentiment had always been high in that country and the liberation from Japan had only increased it. Further, China remained as underdeveloped as ever. They thus felt confident that it would be years, if not decades, before China caught up the United States in terms of economic power, by which point, they projected that the United States massive head start would make the Chinese catching up to them difficult. Russia, on the other hand, still had lingering memories of US intervention in the Russian Civil War, along with the other allies. Furthermore, they still considered the "Ghost of Communism" to be haunting Russia. In addition to these concerns, they also pointed out that Russia had been an industrial powerhouse before the war. This meant, unlike China, which would have to build up its infrastructure and industry from scratch, something that would take considerably longer with their resources diminished by the war and Occupation, Russia merely faced the problem of rebuilding their ruined infrastructure and industry. this would be a much quicker process, they argued, as the Russians already had a foundation to start off with and, once the they had repaired their factories and infrastructure, they could expand upon it much more quickly. That meant that Russia was in a much better position to challenge the Americans much more quickly. While the "One Russia" faction could not argue that a unified Russia would be an economic and military powerhouse, they contested the claim that it would be a natural rival of the United States. They laughed off the notion that the "Ghost of Communism" still haunted Russia, as they claimed that the notion of Communism had been thoroughly discredited when the Communist Russian Government had first started a war with Germany that they were totally ill-equipped to deal with and then proceeded to get trounced rather handily by the Germans. Furthermore, they claimed that Americans role as liberators had led to a rise in pro-American sentiment in Russia which would make it difficult for any Russian government to convince its people to support a policy of opposition to American. They therefore hoped that a United Russia could be turned into a powerful US ally that could help prevent any more world wars from breaking out. No sane man or government, they argued, would want to challenge the combined might of Russia and the United States. They therefore pinned their hopes on cultivating ties with the Russians and ensuring their lasting support.

To this the advocates of the military plan argued that it was folly to entrust the safety and security of the United States to an attempt to maintain good will with a power that could decide that it did not want to maintain good relations with them. "It takes two nations to want peace to ensure peace, but it only takes one for war", they argued.
The other facet of their argument was that Russia was simply in no position to support the large expanse of territory it formerly had in its current position. Siberia, while rich in natural resources, was woefully unable to feed itself, despite all the efforts of the Soviets to make it productive. This meant that virtually the entire region, roughly 77% of Russia's land mass, had to be supported with food and other goods from the rest of the country even in the best of times. With much of the region ravaged by war and Russia proper even worse off, this was a task that the new Russian government would be unequal to. With Russia's industrial and agricultural production ruined by war and occupation, it could be years before Russia's production returned to what it was before the war. The lowest estimate put the recovery time at one year and the longest put it at 10. While Russia was recovering, it would struggle to supply the basic needs of the great mass of Siberia, which could potentially lead to thousands starving to death as the Russians tried to get their own house in order while simultaneously supporting the region. Their solution to this problem was to split Russia into two parts. The Western portion, which corresponded roughly to European Russia, would remain under the name of Russia. The eastern portion, meanwhile, corresponding roughly to Siberia and the rest of Asian Russia, would be split off from the main country. This country, with a port on the Pacific, would then be subsidized in its build up by the still thriving American economy. Indeed, the thinking was that in order to avoid overproduction after the war, they could retool the war factories to produce goods that would be needed to develop the Siberia region. This support would keep the Siberians in supply with the materials they needed to both survive and set up their own industries to take advantage of their abundant natural resources. The stream of supplies and materials coming in could then gradually be phased out as the Siberian industries expanded to replace the goods given to them by the Americans. It was hoped that by this strategy, Siberia would be secured as a strong and loyal American ally. While it was doubtfull if they would ever have the manpower reserves to match the Russians, the belief was that if the country was properly supported by American, and especially Chinese, arms, they could fend off any attempt by Russia to take back the territory. The problem would be whether Siberia could construct its own national identity separate from Russia. If they could, then they would ensure the loyalty of their people, a large amount of whom were Russian in origin. If they failed in this task, however, the Russian people of Siberia would, in the case of an invasion, side with the invaders, making any attempt to hold the region impossible. It was therefore essential that Siberia not be regarded as its people as an American puppet, and as such, American involvement in their political structure would be strictly forbidden and American troops would only be allowed to enter the country in cases of invasion or at the express invitation of the Siberian government. To this, their adversaries claimed that the nation of Siberia would fail because of two reasons. First they stated that, even with American support, Siberia lacked the resources to become a truly viable state economically. While it had natural resources, it could not feed itself and would be totally dependent on outside support for food. With Russia no longer supplying the food to the Siberians, they would need a new source. The most logical choice, as one of the world's leading agricultural producers, would be the Americans. However, feeding the great mass of Siberia as well as itself could very easily strain the American's agricultural base. Furthermore, it was doubtful whether the American people would be willing to feed the Siberian people, given the fact that they did not have the close ethnic and cultural ties with the Siberians that the Russians did. The Siberians were mostly Russians, meaning the Russian government had more incentive to feed them and the Russian people were more willing to do it as they saw them as their kin. This tie did not exist for most Americans and if the American people rejected the idea, Siberia would have two options: Starve, or look for another source to feed its people. The only options in this case would have to be either the Chinese or the Russians. It was doubtful if the Chinese would want to feed the Siberian people, and if they did, it would certainly strengthen their ties with the Chinese at the expense of the Americans. This would only strengthen the Chinese hand in dealings with the Americans, which could lead to a struggle for dominance with China that the advocates of the military's plan wanted to avoid with Russia. If the Chinese did refuse, their only option would be to ask the Russians for the food they needed. That would drive them right back into Russia's camp, possibly leading to re-annexation, exactly the thing this plan aimed to avoid.
The second charge the opponents of the military's plan laid out was that they believed that regardless of whether Siberia could sustain itself, it would be doomed to fail from the inside. The fact that it was created by the Americans and had never existed as an independent state before, they argued, would make it appear a puppet in its people's eyes, regardless of what the Americans did to try to prove the contrary. This would create a divide between the government and the people that the Russians could then exploit to try and get the land back without ever having to fight. If that happened, all this plan would accomplish was a fully united Russia that instead of being a friend, now had every reason to hate America and the resources to back it up.

As the argument raged among the American people, the proponents of the military's plan, largely known as the Marshal Plan, began to realize they had a problem. That problem was the lack of a public face to champion their cause. While the proponents of Kennedy's plan had the hugely popular Kennedy behind them as well as the famous General Bradley, liberator of Africa, on their side, the Marshal plan supporters had no such high profile figure. Despite serving as a high level advisor to the President, Marshal had never served in any prominent leadership war during the war. The only "campaign" he had led was the one to evict the Germans from the Caribbean, which had met with zero resistance. After that he served only as a subordinate to the infinitely more popular Patton, whose prima donna nature meant that he had tended to hog the spotlight as much as possible. Realizing that their campaign was doomed to failure unless they could get a figure whose clout could match that of the Vice President and Bradley, Marshal turned to his old commander, General Patton.
With the war largely over and with his advancing age catching up with him, Patton had decided to retire from the military. In his farewell address to the troops, he summarized his reasons for leaving. "I have served my Country for most of my life as best as I knew how. Now I have done my part to help guide it through the greatest conflict ever known to man. However, While I am a tough old bastard, I can no longer deny that my age and the rigors of the campaign have taken their toll. While I would gladly keep serving despite this, It seems the need for old soldiers like me has now passed. The war, at long last, is over and now the peace we all so craved has come. There is little for a soldier to do in such times, so I have decided to hang up my gun and enjoy what time I have left to me in peace until such a time, and I pray that time never comes, that men such as me are needed again. I hope I shall never be called out of this retirement, as it would mean that all I have fought for was in vain and all that our men accomplished had been squandered. To do so would be the greatest shame this country could ever undergo and I would not be able to face the family members of those who had died knowing we had failed them so. For now, however, I believe I can hold my head up with pride in the confidence that I have done some good in my time on this earth and in this army by getting rid of what was possibly the worst regime in all of human history and helping to redeem my nation for the mistake of remaining idle while the rest of the World needed us. I take comfort in that and I now can retire without any regrets and say that you are the finest men I have ever had the honor of serving with and it was my honor to serve as your commander." When he had finished, the great man had been reduced to tears as had all the soldiers in attendance as they began to shout his name in triumph and adolation. Many of them had been with him since the beginning and regarded him as something of a father figure. To finally see him go had been a harowing experience. Patton had intended to live out the remainder of his days in peace and quiet, if not in obscurity, but found himself called into the debates over Russia. As it happened, Patton shared his former subordinates views on how the Russian situation should be handled. In light of this, he lent his voice to the debate. As such, he gave many a speech in support of Marshal and was often interviewed by reporters for both the radio and the Newspapers on his stance. The support of possibly the most famous American General of World War II greatly swelled support for the Marshal plan. As such, the plan's advocates, who weeks before had been all but certain to be defeated, now stood on even ground with the supporters of the Vice President. The crowning moment of the campaign was an actual debate between Patton and Bradley, the old military rivals turned political adversaries. The debate was ferocious with both repeatedly eviscerating the opponents argument. Patton, by far the most profane and ruthless of the two, viciously attacked Bradley at every turn, while Bradley tried with all his might to keep his composure and argue strictly based on the facts on the ground. When it was over, everyone had a different opinion of who had won the debate, as Bradley was believed to have had the most well reasoned argument, but Patton more then made up for this lack with pure passionate belief and vitriol. As the Congressional vote on the issue drew nearer and nearer, no one was sure who would win it.

Alright people, now for a little surprise. Rather then simply decide this issue myself, I am giving my readers a chance to vote on this particular issue. Which position do you support: Kennedy and Bradley, or Marshall and Patton. Post your opinions in the comments and we will see how the vote shakes out. Voting will last until this time next week, at which point I will tally up the votes and declare which side is the winner.
 
Last edited:
I support the unified Russia plan. We run the risk of revanchist mentality rising if we split apart Russia. As long as we don't force Shock Therepy on Russia's economy and sow the seeds of anti-Americanism as we did OTL after the fall of the USSR, I don't see any real problems. At the very least have referendums for the various areas to stay in Russia or not.