I vote yes, the game is a failure. I've played it on and off, but the awkward gameplay always stops me from enjoying it. Between stability issues(now, mostly fixed, I admit) and silly gameplay (such as England making peace with the Fatamids, then a huge fatamid army takes over the Duchy of Norfolk) I've had never made it past 1200 in CK. Theres lots of other games out right now, and as with all paradox games, it will get better over time. Perhaps 1.05 or 1.06 will help make the game decent. I'm sure I'll break it out in a month or two and give it a whirl for a couple hours.