De Maillac waited a while before answering the many questions coming at him, out of respect for the representatives of the electorate. When all the questions had been raised, he spoke up.
"I bless your Lordships for letting me speak in such important times. And I hope my knowledge will help you understand what is going on, and most importantly, take an informed decision regarding the current events."
He hesitated. "... but... perhaps a piece of advice. Lotharingia is important, yes, but our Empire, our Faith even, is much more important. And so, though the events in Lotharingia have a definitive impact on your decision, I would like to stress that important matters are going on elsewhere, much more crucial than the fights in Lotharingia. I can just think of Rome right now, stuck in an eternal war with a bunch of Muslim warlords... this is the reason the Empire exists..."
He smiled. "But perhaps I sound paternalistic, your Lordships, and I hope you will find within yourselves to accept my limits."
"What to make of the events in Lotharingia, especially of the succession. I have talked with the abbots in Morimond. As some of you may know, these monks are used to dealings with treaties and interpretations. They do not talk much, and when they done, one should listen. These are the words I bring to you from these men of Faith, whose sole purpose are to serve God. Should someone find falsehood in my words, they would have to answer to God Himself." he said, and bowed deeply.
"Your Lordships, you ask the question whether the man who currently wears the crown of Lotharingia is Philippe du Berry, missing son of the late Marie du Berry, queen of Lotharingia. To this question, I cannot answer with certainty. What we do know is that there is a physical resemblance between him and Her Majesty Éléanore du Berry. Also, a document, yet to be interpreted and analysed by the monks, reveal that Jean de Montpetit, Cardinal of Auvergne and overall Church representative at the Court of Lotharingia, attested of the origin of the boy. Apparently, and this is UNCONFIRMED by the monks, Jean de Montpetit saw the boy on a regular basis, in Rome, and in the Lower Counties."
He paused for a few seconds. "In his testament, Jean de Montpetit confirms giving an object to Philippe, which in turn would prove to anyone that he was indeed linked to the late Marie de Berry, the late Jean du Berry and Éléanore herself... What this object is... we do not know."
"Many believe that Philippe du Berry is an usurper to the throne. I believe this as well, as logically, there are not much evidence to support his origins, except for coincidences. “
”What we do know, for certain, from witnesses, and documents, and seals, et cetera, is that before his death, Louis de Montpensier, consider by most amongst you as King of Lotharingia, signed his abdication…”
He looked around and repeated loudly. ”HIS ABDICATION”.
”He gave back to the members of the Directoire to choose the rightful heir to Lotharingia. This cannot be denied. It was signed, the Directoire would have to choose.”
”The Constitution of Lotharingia confers to the King the right to give his power to who he sees fit, and he obviously saw fit to give to the Directoire the choice of its next rulers. After all, we did when Louis de Montpensier came to power. We also accepted Marie du Berry, at the time…”
”Some people throw away the claim of Philippe du Berry. They do not, however, doubt the claim of Louis de Montpensier.”
He paused to let the idea sink in.
”And yet, who here have the proof that Louis de Montpensier was the legitimate heir of Marie du Berry?” he asked.
”She never talked of him in any document, never talked of him as his heir, not even in her testament. There are coincidences, at most… like Philippe du Berry.” he admitted.
”This IS the main point of most members of the Directoire. We were asked to choose a new king, and no one…”
He paused.
”NO ONE will tell us how to do our duty. We MUST choose, between all possible heirs, all claims, be them hardly supported by well known facts or by mere coincidence.”
”So you will ask us why we sided with Anne de Savoie in her fight against Philippe du Berry. Here, it is a matter of principle. My duke, and some of his allies, accept the CLAIM of Anne and her daughter, the same way they accept the claim of Philippe du Berry. They do want to study the claims, and then be able to decide who will be the next person to wear the crown. But Philippe went one step further than Anne: he crowned himself.”
He smiled.
”He imposed the choice on us… and for that we fight for the right to choose.”
”We can have two views regarding Louis de Montpensier and his abdication. First, if we believe he WAS the legitimate son of Marie du Berry, then his abdication stands, and the choice of a new heir falls upon the Directoire.”
He moved his left hand to show a second choice.
”Or, we can view Louis de Montpensier as illegitimate. Then, his abdication means nothing, as his own coronation meant nothing… he was simply an usurper, and then the Directoire would need to look at claims, and choose the new King.”
”In both cases, we find ourselves with the Directoire having to choose.”
He rubbed his hands together. ”And this leaves me to answer the second important question as to who Lotharingia supports in the upcoming IMPERIAL election.”
”First, let me state that Philippe du Berry imposed a choice on us, and for that, we fight him. Frankly, he just didn’t get it… he didn’t understand the implication of his move, he didn’t respect the crown of Lotharingia, and thus the nobility of Lotharingia… There is a second group of nobles who didn’t get it….”
He paused again, to let people figure them out themselves.
”All the nobles that signed the treaty of Zupten just didn’t get it… They, in turn, are trying to impose a choice on the Directoire. Louis de Montpensier abdicated… Louis de Montpensier ASKED the Directoire to choose a new heir. HOW DARE THEY QUESTION HIS WILL?”
”And here we are, signing this piece of paper, imposing a new lord for Lotharingia. Lotharingia doesn’t tell who the new King of England should be, or impose its will to the papacy? Who are these lords that impose their choice on the GOD GIVEN RIGHT of the Lords of the Directoire?”
”Beware of he who tramples on God given rights, for he believes himself superior to GOD Himself!”
”I admit, some were fooled in signing this document. I do not believe that His Majesty Louis the XI of France had bad intentions signing this document. Perhaps he was pressured to do so… But these are things that should come naturally to the Empire…”[/I¸
”Any Imperial that has signed Zupten CANNOT be trusted by the Directoire, and thus by Lotharingia… This leaves out many potential candidates. One house stands out as not being part of Zupten, and that is the House von Wittelsbach.”
”Even there, there is exception. For example, the Bavarian branch has a clear anti-Lotharingia agenda. It is amassing troops to attack some Lower Counties islands. This is, in many sense, far worse than what the Gelreans could do, as they have never tried to attack the domains of the Crown directly. This would be the first time Lotharingia has been attacked by a foreign house… ever.”
”But, on the other side of the scale, the Bohemian branch has not looked at Zupten. It understands the problem of imposing a ruler in Lotharingia. It is not surprising that we now see strong ties between most houses of the Empire and the Wittelsbachers, even as far as the Valois themselves… This is something to think about.”
”But the thing that will strike people the most, is that the Bohemian branch of the Wittelsbach is the only one that can say that it can make Lotharingia sign the Martial Bulle…”
”And I do not have to tell anyone the importance of such an event for the future of the Empire. This shows how integrated to all the houses of the Empire the Wittelsbachs are. Having the Martial Bulle signed means agreement with all of the families of the Directoire… not just the Berry… ALL OF THEM.”
”And you don’t unite the houses of the Directoire with piece of insults like Zupten… you do it by leadership, compromises, and being able to find the middle ground.”
”Your Lordships, perhaps it is time to consider the impact of what you are doing right now… You are electors, and thus have a duty to understand the impact of the decisions you will take. And I firmly believe that actions talk louder than words….”