HoI 4 - Polish puppet probably shouldn't cede half to USSR

[ProtoformX]

Description of issue
Unwinnable war and Polish puppet probably shouldn't cede half to USSR

Game Version
1.11.9.e52a (3f99)

Enabled DLC


Do you have mods enabled?
Yes

Description
Mods are achievement friendly and should be UI only.
This post probably isn't strictly proper, however I'm unable to decide where it should be posted.
After opposing Hitler and releasing poland as puppet.

I'm unable to end the civil war due to remaining at war with fascist east indies, with no short term way to end the war.
Poland puppet- poland gives up eastern half to USSR.

Steps to Reproduce
In this save playthrough, I've started as Germany,
Using Nazi Pp income,
Justifed on both dutch east indies and Poland.
Declared on both in same hour.
Annexed Nederlandt
Satellited dutch east indies
Annexed Poland
oppose hitler focus
release poland as puppet
Wanted to keep Danzig when releasing Poland.

Upload Attachment
File(s) attached

 

[SRhistory]

Hi,

Not sure but maybe you are new on the forum?
The bug section of the forum is for real bugs. Not for help with how to win the setup and walk through you did. My advise is ask this question in the main forum part and you will get some help with it.

Can’t help you with this Germany issue. Haven’t play opposite Hitler yet… mostly playing historical… but many people on the main forum should be abel to help. So pls open a thread over there

 

[ProtoformX]

Greetings and salmutations.
You can say I'm new to the forum. I agree that both listed problems are not a failling of the game engine or interactivity between game/OS.

However compared to the alternatives, I consider both problems to be closest to bugs.
What you describe as a "playthrough setup" isn't accurate here, as I'm not asking for help. I'm stating that the situation I'm in shouldn't happen in the first place.

If you know better where to post such things, please let me know.

Thank you for your time.

 

[SRhistory]

Greetings and salmutations.
You can say I'm new to the forum. I agree that both listed problems are not a failling of the game engine or interactivity between game/OS.

However compared to the alternatives, I consider both problems to be closest to bugs.
What you describe as a "playthrough setup" isn't accurate here, as I'm not asking for help. I'm stating that the situation I'm in shouldn't happen in the first place.

If you know better where to post such things, please let me know.

Thank you for your time.

like I said post this in the main forum part Heart of Iron IV. There you will get help an advise. Doesn't sound like a bug to me.

 

[ProtoformX]

like I said post this in the main forum part Heart of Iron IV. There you will get help an advise. Doesn't sound like a bug to me.

Just checking that we're on the same page, do you mean you've had playthroughs with puppets; and your puppets have handed over half their country to your enemy or someone your hostile with?
Do you mean this is a perfectly normal feature of the game?

 

[SRhistory]

Just checking that we're on the same page, do you mean you've had playthroughs with puppets; and your puppets have handed over half their country to your enemy or someone your hostile with?
Do you mean this is a perfectly normal feature of the game?

Answer is yes. With Poland, Romania and its perfectly normal based on history. But just before the land owner is moved you Will get a notification/choose…. If you are the owner… if its a puppet then the AI will get the choose and does what history always did.

Posted your questions in the main forum pls . I can’t explain it very well. Other are better with this.