Higher learning stat of chaplain results in lower success chance in 'improve relation'

[highsis]

All dlcs, no mods, version 2.8. sorry, didn't specify it in the title.

I had a vassal chaplain with 14 learning.

the chance of success for the 4th action improve relation was 14%, and failure chance was 14%.

When I appointed a new chaplain(landless) with 22 learning, the chance became 8% success and 16% failure.

 

[SchwarzKatze]

Maybe it's their traits? E.g. Diligent vs. Slothful.

 

[highsis]

Maybe it's their traits? E.g. Diligent vs. Slothful.

Do traits affect councilor action's chance of success? I don't believe they do.

 

[jruderman]

Traits don't matter in this event. Neither does learning skill above 13.

Most likely you were surprised by one or more of the following MTTH modifiers related to the location and the court chaplain's culture:

       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { culture_group = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { culture = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.5
           location = { religion_group = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_1 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.50
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_2 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.25
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_3 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 3.0
           location = { is_hard_to_convert = yes }
       }

See events/job_lord_spiritual.txt (first event) for the full thing.

 

[SchwarzKatze]

Traits don't matter in this event. Neither does learning skill above 13.

Most likely you were surprised by one or more of the following MTTH modifiers related to the location and the court chaplain's culture:

       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { culture_group = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { culture = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.5
           location = { religion_group = ROOT }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.75
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_1 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.50
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_2 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 0.25
           location = { has_province_modifier = depopulated_3 }
       }
       modifier = {
           factor = 3.0
           location = { is_hard_to_convert = yes }
       }

See events/job_lord_spiritual.txt (first event) for the full thing.

Wait, improve relations check if the province is depopulated?

 

[jruderman]

Sorry, I was looking at the "convert province" event. Ignore my previous comment.

For the "improve religious relations" job action, event 906 only checks learning skill (up to 13) and moral authority (20%, 40%, 60%, 80%). Did your replacement have the same religion as the previous office holder?

You mentioned a "4th action" so I thought you might be referring to the MNM offmap job action, but I think that's just hunting heretics and doesn't include improving relations.

 

[highsis]

Sorry, I was looking at the "convert province" event. Ignore my previous comment.

For the "improve religious relations" job action, event 906 only checks learning skill (up to 13) and moral authority (20%, 40%, 60%, 80%). Did your replacement have the same religion as the previous office holder?

You mentioned a "4th action" so I thought you might be referring to the MNM offmap job action, but I think that's just hunting heretics and doesn't include improving relations.

Yes, both Catholic. I was talking about improving relations.

It seems to be a bug, after all.

It's also weird how learning 14 has equal chance of success and failure. Other councilor actions have much higher chance of success with stat 14.