The biggest argument I saw though against the game was that some players brought too many "undesirable" players, mostly from places like the IAAR community, and made the game "poor of quality". Some people (like myself) who come from this area (The IAAR zone) resented it, leading to arguments over player quality.
Note however: 95% of this took place on IRC.
Shame that the game didn't last long, and I am sad to see it go.