Ok, my thoughts about the lot.
First of all: Venice is probably the worst off, but still playable. Don't forget that if Venice gets dropped, France loses an important ally and the fights for Italy will get truly ugly. England/Spain will grab the NA provinces and the Ottoman Empire the Venetian islands. In five years.
Secondly, I can somewhat agree with Btg that he thinks Venice isn't viable anymore as a nation, due to her badboy and inflation.
But still, if the French alliance beats the Habsburgs for good, Venice could reclaim a few provinces etc. I agree it's looking bad, but not that it is hopeless.
Anyway, he suggests to move to another country, which is all fine and good with me. But the problem is, he then wants that country to be beefed up enormously.
Why move from a non-viable country to another non-viable country, which you need to edit to greatness? You can as well edit Venice then (something for which I do
not advocate).
I can agree with the thesis that a country run by the AI for some years needs to get a few cookies, but the current proposals for Persia are totally out of order.
First of all, the edits should be no means larger then what a human player could accomplish.
Secondly, AI Persia hasn't lost a single province to the Ottoman Empire since they were AI. If you are going to edit Persia cookies now, you are assuming the human player could develop his country in all peace, which is hardly the case.
If there would be a human player in Persia all the time, he would have to fight with the Ottoman Empire every decade at least.
I don't think Persia would still have all his provinces, let alone that he could tech a bit
and build large fortresses.
Also, the Ottoman Empire hasn't build fortresses in the east,
assuming Persia would stay offlimits.
So, all in all, I think if you are going to make Persia finally human again, I can only agree on two conditions:
- The edits are mildly repairations what the AI has done
- If Blk, for whatever reason, drops again, Persia will stay inlimits this time.
I think the Mughals are far more preferable now. They're in quite good shape. I could hardly beat them in SP

and Spain had troubles with them enough in MP.
We also need a sub for Holland, since Rezag moves for a couple of weeks.