[size=+1]Chapter Six: Crusader Kings[/size]
Alfonso was not the first Iberian to go on a crusade. The Dukes of Catalonia had been carrying on an epic struggle against the Emirs of Sevilla and Toledo since the 1070’s – albeit a fruitless, ill-advised, and ultimately ill-fated one. His son, Domingo, took up the cross in the name of God in the spring of 1095, officially declaring his participation in the crusade to free Jerusalem, by then still in the hands of the Fatimids. Domingo, however, had neither the men nor the resources to mount an effective invasion of the Holy Land, and his armies did nothing but sit in their castles and camps for the next seven years. Alfonso thought this a stupid move, and informed his son of this in no uncertain terms, but Domingo’s response was lost to history – if, indeed, there was a response, as the son and father were not exactly on speaking terms by that point.
Although Queen Constanza stood by Alfonso throughout her life, she never embraced his heresy, a fact that Alfonso fully accepted. Their love was more powerful than their religious leanings, and if both were reconciled to the fact that they would not spend their afterlives together, they made the most of their lives on this earth. When the queen died, Alfonso conducted her funeral service with the utmost respect for her religious beliefs, granting her a full Christian ceremony free of the trappings of Alfonso’s heretical beliefs and presided over by an official from the Papacy. Pope Alexander II misunderstood Alfonso’s actions as an attempt to reconcile with the Church, and offered the emperor another opportunity to pledge obedience to the Pope and be absolved of his sins – for a generous charitable donation to the Church. Alfonso again turned the Pope down flat. It is said that Alexander II, when receiving Alfonso’s reply, was so overcome with rage that he suffered a massive stroke and died on the spot. His successor, Gregory VII, was no better at reconciliation – after offering Alfonso another opportunity to repent and being rejected, Gregory VII created a more potent form of excommunication entitled “double-secret excommunication” and applied it to Alfonso. The Pope and the Emperor were no longer on speaking terms.
Despite his bitterness toward the Church, Alfonso sincerely wished to regain some status with the crowned heads of Europe and, possibly, do God’s work in this world. Lacking any other direct way to improve his standing aside from tithes, Alfonso proclaimed a crusade against Sulayman al-Amiri, Sheik of Valencia in 1100. Immediately upon receiving Alfonso’s declaration of war, Sulayman appealed to his ally, Nizamaddin Duh’l-Nun, Emir of Toledo, for aid. Nizamaddin cheerfully mobilized his armies and marched on León as 4000 Spaniards under Alfonso’s leadership descended upon Valencia. Decades of war having drained southern Spain of manpower, Alfonso was met with limited resistance and invested the Sheik’s castle in Valencia. It seemed that Alfonso was destined for victory.
That is, until Domingo, King of Navarra and Alfonso’s only son, declared war on his father later that year in an attempt to wrest the throne from the old man. Immediately, 5000 men were rallied under Bishop Ramon Berenguer d’Empuires and marched on Domingo’s home castle in Viscaya. The army of Navarra, 1100 strong with King Domingo at its head, met the invading force on the field before the castle and was slaughtered. Domingo, having been captured, offered his entire fortune for peace. Acting on behalf of the king, Bishop Ramon accepted.
Meanwhile, Valencia fell and Sulayman al-Amiri fled into exile in Toledo. Alfonso’s army marched on La Mancha and, finding it occupied by forces under the Emir of Sevilla, continued on to Calatrava. The castle and the county fell halfway into 1101, and Alfonso disbanded his army in an attempt to coerce the Emir’s forces out of hiding, so they could liberate La Mancha and give the king the opportunity to take it back.
The ploy worked, but was almost a disaster for the Emperor’s cause. An army 3000 strong led by the Emir’s marshal and one of the greatest military minds of the century, Abdul-Haleem Ali, the Fist of Allah, invested the castle in Caltrava and, when that fell, liberated La Mancha from the Emir of Sevilla in 1102. When his army moved to leave the county, Alfonso marched back in at the head of 4000 fresh troops. He met Abdul-Haleem’s force of 3000 outside the castle in La Mancha. Abdul-Haleem fought with characteristic skill and bravery, outflanking Alfonso’s numerically-superior force and driving them back with heavy casualties. Alfonso retreated to higher ground, where he made his stand with the surviving half of his army. The engagement that followed was long, drawn out, and brutal, and lasted three days. Despite his superiority as a general, the Fist of Allah could not break through the Demon King’s lines, and withdrew west, into Calatrava, with the remnants of his army. Alfonso invested the castle in La Mancha with his 1,500 remaining troops. After a quick engagement with the now-deposed Sulayman al-Amiri, now a general for the Emir of Toledo at the head of 800 troops, La Mancha fell to Alfonso. Sulayman al-Amiri received a horrific injury during this battle, and died a few months later, having been captured and placed under house arrest in his old castle in Valencia.
With the breaking of the Emir’s army at La Mancha on June 4, 1102, Nizamaddin could not maintain an effective resistance against Alfonso’s army. With the fall of Calatrava late in 1102, all of the Emir’s lands which were contiguous with the Empire of Hispania had fallen. Alfonso, himself drained of manpower and not wishing to march through the Emir of Sevilla’s territory to besiege the last of Nizamaddin’s lands on the extreme southern coast of Spain, agreed to peace with the Emir. Alfonso’s Crusade was over by Christmas, 1102.
Alfonso spent the rest of his years in blessed relaxation, rousing only to slaughter the occasional peasant army threatening to tear down the very fabric of the medieval social system. He continued to support the idea of crusade despite his heretical stance on the central beliefs of the Catholic Church. In 1104, for example, he granted Froilán Ponce de Leon, the seven year old Count of Faro and Silves, the gold necessary to declare himself Duke of Alagarve, solidifying his hold over Muslim lands recently conquered from the Emirate of Sevilla. However, despite his full treasury and ideological support of crusade in the Holy Land, Alfonso steadfastly refused to participate in the liberation of Jerusalem. Such a quest was, in his eyes, both foolish and wasteful, and he let everybody who asked know this. This was characteristic of Alfonso’s character – pragmatic to a fault, he refused to follow in the Church’s footsteps even if it were to repair his stature in the eyes of the world and, possibly, of God.
On November 29, 1104, Alfonso I, Emperor of Hispania, King of León and Castille, Duke of Asturias, Galicia, Salamanca, and Castilla, Count of Leon, Burgos, Valencia, Asturias de Santillana, Asturias de Oviedo, Molina, La Mancha, El Bierzo, Castellon, Compostela, Cuenca, Valladolid, Zamora, Santiago, Soria, Calatrava, and Salamanca died. Even though he was a heretic in the eyes of the Church, he was highly respected as a military leader – despite his utter lack of finesse on the battlefield – and as a ruler. Since his sins made an official Church burial impossible, his corpse was burned and the ashes scattered to the wind over the ramparts of his castle in León. Popular opinion of the time was so strongly against him that his image was stricken from every mosaic, painting, and sculpture in the realm and his name all but struck out of the official chronicles of the time. Only his family history, kept by his loyal chronicler and bishop Ramon Berenguer d’Empuires, survived the destruction, hidden in a secret vault in a shrine in Burgos. It is thanks to this chronicle that the details of Emperor Alfonso I’s life and deeds survives to this day to counterbalance the vicious propaganda promulgated after his death.
In the end, we must ask ourselves, was Emperor Alfonso I truly the Demon King of legend? He slaughtered thousands, possibly millions, in the pursuit of an abstract and ultimately unattainable ideal of personal security. His attempts to control the hierarchy of the church, including his assumption of the title of Pope of the Iberian Catholic Church, fly in the face of every medieval convention of his day. His intrigues and the assassination of his sister would have made the Renaissance princes of Italy uncomfortable. And yet, underlying the moral corruption was a very basic, very vital human spirit. Alfonso was driven by perfectly reasonable motivations – he merely wanted respect, possibly even the love of those who were closest to him. His relationship with Empress Constanza is a manifestation of this, as is his early family life and his ultimate loyalty to his father’s wishes. Therefore, we cannot judge the Emperor only by the number of people who died by his hand, but by the content of his character. Only then can we realize that Alfonso was totally, and possibly fatally, human, and worthy of our respect, if not our admiration. In the end, Alfonso could have been any one of us.