Originally posted by Ebusitanus
Ok...big diference, Pirate and Privateer...A Privateer is basically a privately operated vessel who is allowed to keep the spoils from attaking the enemies of the nation who gave him is letter of marque and no other. Since Spain and England weren't at war that makes Drake a pirate, a lawless individual who once captured is sent to the gallows directly. That the English crown agreed in letting him do his hobby during the oficial peace time wouldn't say much of the moral temper of such a Queen/King, the fact that not only that but that Drake and Hawkins were repeatly provided with weapons and vessels from the Royal Navy plus some monetary help just makes that Queen by all standards little better than them. Its you who say that there was some "higher" goal behind looting colonies and ships as a (lol) efective way to check Spain's growth or equalitze resources...lol..(Oh, man)..sorry but this is just so funny...
Why don't you just call it for what it is/was...they craved Spain's riches and tried to bottom feed upon them by assaulting where she was the weakest, its colonies and un convoyed vessels.
You really believe Elisabeth sat down with her counselors and they agreed this way was the best to defeat Spain?...Oh C'mon
Pirates or privateers are there for their own benefit, being any beneficial side result purely accidental.
On a practical sense the filibusters who assaulted the South American shores were some knid of mixture between the semi legal privateer and the "free for all" pirate...actually kind of the worst from both camps. Pirates they were without doubt since they had no letter of marque provided by any nation at war with Spain. But on the other hand they were never discouraged (to say the least) by certain European powers, oficially at peace, nevertheless opposed to the Spanish monarchy. Those Elisabethian expeditions were little more than organized looting trips set up as shareholding businesses where the biggest nobles including the own Queen had their interest in.
Too bad Spain never fought (discounting some very limited exceptions) back with the same weapons of privateering since Ferdinand "the Catholic" had made them completely illegal at 1489 since he considered such practices as inmoral.
I personally love this instance were during Spain's fourt French war 1542-44 were this French privateer called Jean Alphonse de Saintonge won fame by assaulting and looting the por of La Luz in the Canary Islands. So selfconfident was this guy that when the war was over he kept of assaulting vessels which he took to his home base at La Rochelle. But this time even up there he was followed by the Great Pedro Menendez de Aviles who went straight after him into the harbor and once he got all five of the pirate's preys he assaulted himself the pirate's ensign Le Marie killing Saintonge and most of his crew. To bad the wind was against him and he wasn't able to leave port inmediatly and got thus hailed by the Governor to surrender or face the guns of the fortress. But the Spaniard argued that his victim had been a pirate and not a privateer since both nations were at peace. He could leave finally the port with all his prey back to Spain.
This is the same man who dispached quickly with the French Hugenot base in Florida with so much bloodshed.
It is very simple - if privateers didn't hinder Spain in some way, Elizabeth WOULD have had the arrested. She would not have wanted to aggravate a much more powerful Spain unless there was some serious advantage. This seems pretty obvious.
While war wasn't declared that doesn't mean an under the covers war didn't exist. For example, the USA hasn't declared war on Afghanistan yet, however people in the USA constantly talk about being in "a state of war".
As for Spain not using similar tactics, don't think for a second it is because they wouldn't - it is because England was no where near as vulnerable to it as Spain was. You can hardly claim any moral high ground for a nation that plundered and enslaved the natives of virtually an entire continent. Certainly England was no saint, but neither was Spain.