Thats exactly what he did with his blue blob video xD Or are you ironic?Does it matter? It's not like they're going to claim some sort of world record.
- 4
- 1
- 1
Thats exactly what he did with his blue blob video xD Or are you ironic?Does it matter? It's not like they're going to claim some sort of world record.
I think it depends on the goal of the video. If it’s just for entertainment, then it shouldn’t matter. If it’s a guide for a specific tag, then it definitely matters. A guide with hidden cheats can be very frustrating for players who follow it. It can be very frustrating for newer players who don’t have a strong grasp of the mechanics.Does it matter? It's not like they're going to claim some sort of world record.
there are ways to use console in iron man tbh. His skill made also a huge jump forward, he is now better than me ( I have 4000 hours most achvievments 90% or so), where before he was way worse. If florry did something like that it would be plausable, but he savcescumms, restarst until he has the result, he doesnt show how he made it, which makes it hard to believe him. For beginners I recommentd radio res, he has good guides to understand. For advanced players budget monk, especially his hre, poland, hungarian and byzantium runs. People also save scu, I do it too, when I get attacked because my alliances had 4000 in debts, or the 6 6 6 heir dies stuff like that not all the time but otherwise u can loose 40 Years of build up witch would just suck.Yes that’s probably it. It’s not console cheating as you can clearly see achievements are enabled.
Although it’s also edited so he could be copy/paste save scumming. Only he can know. I do like his videos though and he is a good player.
OP is right though in that he does talk like what he’s doing is straight forward and anyone can do it but it’s extremely RNG dependent.
From what I've seen so far, restarting over and over again and save scumming is exactly what's "normal" for Ironman, so I don't see the issue.it matters if what's being shown doesn't represent 'normal' gameplay. if that's the case it should be made explicit so as not to mislead people
You’re not wrongFrom what I've seen so far, restarting over and over again and save scumming is exactly what's "normal" for Ironman, so I don't see the issue.
(not talking about console commands obviously)
He literally makes money off his videos.Does it matter? It's not like they're going to claim some sort of world record.
I'm not sure which thing astonishes me more:
1) That there are people willing to devote the time and effort to fabricate EU4 videos for youtube.
2) That there are people willing to devote the time and effort to sniff out and expose fabricated EU4 videos on youtube.
I followed some of his starts and they're clearly not unreasonable or unrealistic if you push the boundaries of AE/mercing up. Like, not at all. And just looking at the way he plays I realize he's playing more meticulously/skillfully than I did in some of my runs.
I see these videos less as guides to follow and more as inspiration for people that has above-average tier of gameplay already, and entertainment for the rest of us.
You can literally enable the achievement button through the console these days. In addition multiple mods and editing software that could do the same.
Regarding Ludi it's almost assured that he's cheating. Too many inconsistencies in his videos (there's a yt video out there explaining one case, but there are many other cases that seemed very odd).
In addition while he's a solid player he's not good enough to do everything he does without cheats, you can see a fairly clear differences between him and some of the 'best' wc/sp players when you compare their gameplay.
Speak for yourself. I detest “entertaining” YouTube videos that are trying to convey any info at all. Much rather have some autist with a spreadsheet tell me what I need to know then watch actually funny content creators rather than pastiched crap being repeated - Ludi makes me cringeI enjoy Ludi's videos and find them helpful.
Overall, I think the most important thing to keep in mind is that a good EU4 Youtube guide video has to be both informative and entertaining.
I have seen some very entertaining videos that are not particularly helpful. They are intended to be pure entertainment and while you could get some tips or inspiration, that's not really why you watch them. An example of this would be many of the videos of the "Social Streamers." I like their videos a lot, btw. One I saw recently was essentially a rant about why Enrique Trastamara is a trash simulated human being.
On the other end of the spectrum you have the purely informative videos, while these are extremely informative -- and often give you click-by-click guidance -- they are not always very entertaining. There is a guy who has a channel called "Vicktor Vildras" that has really, really solid strategy guides. I also like his videos, but they are not maximum entertainment. He had a really good Byzantium Opener based on the Budget Monk strategy.
Ludi's videos are trying for that sweet spot -- good entertainment value and good information. Other really good EU4 youtubers are: Habibbi (mostly MP), Red Hawk (Openers), BudgetMonk (Grand Streams) and Reman (Mechanics, but I'm not sure he makes videos anymore, at least not on youtube).
Back to Ludi.
He's pretty open about editing and jumping forward in time. I suspect that in the specific example of the Manchu campaign is that he put two different campaigns together in his video. This could have been on purpose to be deceptive, but why?
He wasn't submitting the save-file for some kind of speed run record. I took the video for just showing off what one could do as Manchu. Personally, I think it is more likely that he made a mistake when editing together the many Manchu save files he has.
I could be wrong, but I don't think that even the people who raised some issues with Ludi's videos are saying that what he did is flat out necessarily impossible without console commands, but instead saying that what he did is impossible given where one clip ended and a what later clip showed. Specifically, he ended a war and took some specific provinces, but in a later clip it appeared like he annexed the entire nation.
Let he who hath not save-scummed, click the dislike button....
The guy is legitimately a good player -- much better than I am. He's also more entertaining that a lot of his competition. Just take his videos for what they are: He makes jokes about your lack of girlfriends while playing EU4 in a fake Scottish accent while saying fake German phrases like "Stacken-Wipen." You also get some good tips, strategy ideas and sometimes an explanation of mechanics.
It’s not console cheating as you can clearly see achievements are enabled.
He is already. He clearly states it's his opinion...Speak for yourself. I detest “entertaining” YouTube videos that are trying to convey any info at all. Much rather have some autist with a spreadsheet tell me what I need to know then watch actually funny content creators rather than pastiched crap being repeated - Ludi makes me cringe
He is already. He clearly states it's his opinion...
To add a dose of reality, in case anyone was thinking about dropping out of school:For many, it is their sole income which can generate five figure incomes PER MONTH for the very successful.