One line summary of your issue
In agnatic gavelkind, sons of dead and only dead sisters can inherit
Game Version
2.8.1
What expansions do you have installed?
All of the above
Do you have mods enabled?
No
Please explain your issue is in as much detail as possible.
Under agnatic gavelkind, sons of dead sisters are the heirs if the character has no sons, but sons of living sisters are not. This is the exact opposite of agnatic-cognatic gavelkind where sons of dead daughters are ineligible if there are still living daughters. This s not historical in any way, and is probably the result of someone mistakenly reversed the same criterion from the agnatic-cognatic version of the law.
Also, the succession order displayed in this case is bugged. While the first-in-line is correct, the rest are actually heirs of the heir once he inherits, not the actual succession order if the current heir were to die. While it works for primogeniture, it shows the wrong information for gavelkind.
Screenshots here:
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...-quick-answers.586872/page-1247#post-23608481
Sons of the dead sister are the heirs even if there are uncles and a older but living sister with sons.
And notice that how all six in the succession order are the male relatives of the dead sister's sons, but actually only the two sons of her are eligible; and how the uncles and sons of uncles fills the #2-#6 spots after a son is born, but they're actually not eligible if he was to die before he inherits.
Also c.f. a reddit thread titled "Primogeniture and gavelkind in ck2 explained" since a direct link is not allowed
Steps to reproduce the issue.
Upload Attachment
In agnatic gavelkind, sons of dead and only dead sisters can inherit
Game Version
2.8.1
What expansions do you have installed?
All of the above
Do you have mods enabled?
No
Please explain your issue is in as much detail as possible.
Under agnatic gavelkind, sons of dead sisters are the heirs if the character has no sons, but sons of living sisters are not. This is the exact opposite of agnatic-cognatic gavelkind where sons of dead daughters are ineligible if there are still living daughters. This s not historical in any way, and is probably the result of someone mistakenly reversed the same criterion from the agnatic-cognatic version of the law.
Also, the succession order displayed in this case is bugged. While the first-in-line is correct, the rest are actually heirs of the heir once he inherits, not the actual succession order if the current heir were to die. While it works for primogeniture, it shows the wrong information for gavelkind.
Screenshots here:
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...-quick-answers.586872/page-1247#post-23608481
Sons of the dead sister are the heirs even if there are uncles and a older but living sister with sons.
And notice that how all six in the succession order are the male relatives of the dead sister's sons, but actually only the two sons of her are eligible; and how the uncles and sons of uncles fills the #2-#6 spots after a son is born, but they're actually not eligible if he was to die before he inherits.
Also c.f. a reddit thread titled "Primogeniture and gavelkind in ck2 explained" since a direct link is not allowed
Steps to reproduce the issue.
Upload Attachment
Upvote
0
