Brandenburg/Anhalt Culture are wrong!

[Vharzul]

For some reason the culture is Western Slavic for both of Brandenburg and Anhalt, iirc they were mostly German tribes with only minor Slavs so why arnt they German culture then? also dosnt this hinder the Cultureal conversion for at least some province as this is an example.

Will the province convert from Western Slavic to German with German Realm leader?

But anyhow the issue is should Brandenburg and Anhalt be both German and not Western Slavic, iirc they were Germanic's mostly.

 

[Ciçatrix]

For some reason the culture is Western Slavic for both of Brandenburg and Anhalt, iirc they were mostly German tribes with only minor Slavs so why arnt they German culture then? also dosnt this hinder the Cultureal conversion for at least some province as this is an example.

But anyhow the issue is should Brandenburg and Anhalt be both German and not Western Slavic, iirc they were Germanic's mostly.

Documentation please.

Will the province convert from Western Slavic to German with German Realm leader?

Yes, after some time.

Anyway, a scenario freeze has been implemented, so these prorpsed changes won't make it to patch 1.05.

 

[Veldmaarschalk]

First of all a new culture set up will not be changed and may not be discussed in the public beta forum.

And secondly you are incorrect. Between the Elbe and Oder the tribes were Slavic

Check this site on the history of Brandenburg

EDIT
Plus see this map of around 1050

 

[unmerged(24328)]

Brandenburg/Anhalt Culture was wrong in 1.04a, now is correct

 

[unmerged(21937)]

You can bring the issue up after 1.5 if you like, with proper documentation to support the case.

 

[Vharzul]

Im no good at finding documentation, but from what i read in those two things Veld linked, i saw nothing to substnciat major Slawvic culture in those regions, it dosnt give any sort of number's it could mean to me that the Slaws were only a minority in those area's and not a majority, then again i could be wrong, so on a baised they should still be not Slaws but German for both provinces.

But its only my opinion.

Also this here Its only Rügen and not all of it!

I onlky see Ranian's Culture i.e. Slavic for Rügen and not the whole of the Veletian or Obodrite Union's and not the whole of the area!

Although the opther link does show diffrantly, but its s sort of 50 to 50 suject on what culture to give imo.

 

[Veldmaarschalk]

The Obodrites and Veleti are slavic tribes, not German tribes.

No offence, but you don't make a really strong point in convincing people that you are right. If you want to convince Paradox you will have to come up with sources.

About the slavic people in Brandenburg
http://www.genealogie-mittelalter.de/heveller_fuersten/heveller.html

About the slavic people between Elbe and Oder
http://home.student.uva.nl/kacper.vandenheuvel/slavs4.html

EDIT


Edited, removed the last link. First have to see what kind of a forum I have linked to, looks a bit awkward

EDIT
Another map