-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Found something in the AGCEEP Crimean event file, event 152050 allows the Crimea to inherit the GH after 1500, but it is triggered by either event 287002 or 287003 for the Golden Horde, which both require the Crimea to control the Golden Horde's capital. Also their are several additional triggers, for 287002 Kazan and Astrahkan need to exist and for 287003 Kazan and Astrahkan must not exitst and the GH has to be smaller then 10 provinces.
From the AGCEEP games I have played to so far I can say that that neither of these of conditions is ever met. Kazan usually gets annexed by Russia before 1500 and the GH tends to survive with more then 10 provinces making either event an impossibility. To solve this I would suggest merging the two events for the GH and removing all the triggers, with perhaps only keeping the following trigger: control = { province = 458 data = CRI }.
From the AGCEEP games I have played to so far I can say that that neither of these of conditions is ever met. Kazan usually gets annexed by Russia before 1500 and the GH tends to survive with more then 10 provinces making either event an impossibility. To solve this I would suggest merging the two events for the GH and removing all the triggers, with perhaps only keeping the following trigger: control = { province = 458 data = CRI }.
Alkar said:
The reason the events are setup this way is to avoid the possibility of a giant Crimea, as it is a bit off to have Crimea inherit all the Golden Horde's lands. So while this sequence isn't really working, I'm not sure what you've suggested is a great alternative.
Perhaps, as has long been suggested the trigger for the Russian Claim on the Steppes event should be changed? Work should also be done to make sure that the khanates that pop up are antagonistic to the Golden Horde.
Create an event to destroy the GH if it still exists at a certain point. I'm not sure how you'd go about that though. Maybe instead have Sibir annex it after it releases any vassals it might have and sheds a few provs.
Actually, I think the current sequence is OK, it just needs some tweaking. From what I've seen they always have 1 or more provinces east of Orenburg lingering on. Without these straggelers it would be fairly easy for Muscowy and the like to gobble them up. Of course, making the succesors a little more antagonistic wouldn't hurt either.
chegitz guevara said:
Should such an event also give Crimea Turkish culture? The reason I am asking this, is because in the later scenarios, 1492 and 1520, Crimea starts out with Turkish culture as well.
Garbon said:
The current existing events for the GH release both Kazan and Astrahkan plus secede a bunch of provinces to them and Russia. If the GH manages to hold onto provinces east of Astrahkan seceding those to Sibir would prevent Crimea from getting to powerful.
Removing some of the provinces for the triggering of the Russian claims on the Steppes, especially province 458, the Golden Horde's capital, would help Russia getting the event and their eastern expansion.
An idea perhaps to make the khanates antagonistic to the GH would be giving them a cb via an event either a temporary one or a cb-shield on the GH's capital and event triggering a war.
Why do they get Turkish? Did they start to be Ottomanized enough to justify an extra culture for them?
While googling around, I found this site on the Crimea.
Pretty interesting stuff really and it does contain some nice possibilities for events.
As to the case with Turkish culture there seems to be a point in giving it to them.
Pretty interesting stuff really and it does contain some nice possibilities for events.
As to the case with Turkish culture there seems to be a point in giving it to them.
The following might be an idea on how to have the Ottoman vassalization of the Crimea happening in the game:
I don't know what to use as triggers for the first event, should there be a war going on between the OE and Crimea and or should the OE own or control some of the northern Black Sea provinces, Kaffa, Kerch and Crimea?
Code:
[COLOR=White]
#Crimea becomes an Ottoman vassal#
event = {
id = ?
trigger = ?
random = NO
country = CRI
name = "Crimea becomes an Ottoman Vassal"
desc = "In 1475 the Ottoman Turkey invaded the Crimea. The Turks conquered Gothia and Genoese colonies and turned them into a Turkish possession. Also Ottomans captured Meсli Geray (a son and successor of Haci Geray) and brought him to Istanbul. Sultan Mehmed II allowed the khan to return to the Crimean throne after he had forced Meсli Geray to recognize Turkish suzerainty over the khanate.The Turkish suzerainty had a wholesome effect in the cultural development of the Crimean state, but often it extremely unfavorably influenced the political situation of the khanate. The khans were obliged to send large Crimean troops to sultans’ military campaigns. That duty much weakened the Crimean khanate, which wasted its forces far outside its borders (in Persia and Hungary). Another source of conflicts was Turkish interference to dynastical affairs of the Gerays. The monarch of the Crimea could not hold the throne without the appointment by the sultan and could be removed from the throne in every moment by the will of the Turkish sovereign."
style = 1
date = { day = 1 month = January year = 1475 }
offset = 30
deathdate = ?
action_a = {
name = "We accept Turkish suzerainity"
command = { type = add_countryculture which = turkish }
command = { type = relation which = TUR value = 200 }
command = { type = dynastic which = TUR }
command = { type = DIP which = 2 value = 60 }
command = { type = MIL which = -2 value = 60 }
command = { type = manpower value = -10 }
command = { type = desertion which = -1 value = -10000 }
command = { type = trigger which = ? }
}
action_b = {
name = "We will never surrender to the Turks!"
command = { type = breakdynastic which = TUR }
command = { type = relation which = TUR value = -200 }
command = { type = DIP which = -2 value = 60 }
command = { type = MIL which = 2 value = 60 }
}
}
event = { #triggered by "Crimea becomes an Ottoman vassal" event#
id = ?
random = NO
country = TUR
name = "Crimea becomes an Ottoman vassal"
desc = "In 1475 the Ottoman Turkey invaded the Crimea. The Turks conquered Gothia and Genoese colonies and turned them into a Turkish possession. Also Ottomans captured Meсli Geray (a son and successor of Haci Geray) and brought him to Istanbul. Sultan Mehmed II allowed the khan to return to the Crimean throne after he had forced Meсli Geray to recognize Turkish suzerainty over the khanate.The Turkish suzerainty had a wholesome effect in the cultural development of the Crimean state, but often it extremely unfavorably influenced the political situation of the khanate. The khans were obliged to send large Crimean troops to sultans’ military campaigns. That duty much weakened the Crimean khanate, which wasted its forces far outside its borders (in Persia and Hungary). Another source of conflicts was Turkish interference to dynastical affairs of the Gerays. The monarch of the Crimea could not hold the throne without the appointment by the sultan and could be removed from the throne in every moment by the will of the Turkish sovereign."
style = 1
action_a = {
name = "Great"
command = { type = vassal which = CRI }
command = { type = alliance which = CRI }
command = { type = manpower value = -10 }
command = { type = CAV which = ? value = 10000 }
}
}
[/COLOR]Since, AFAIK, you still can't force peace via event, war would be a bad idea for a trigger. In fact, the event shouldn't fire if at war, since if they accept vassalization, it will immediately be broken (cuz of the war) causing severe stability problems.
I would say check to see of the OE owns Kerch OR Kaffa.
I would say check to see of the OE owns Kerch OR Kaffa.
Got the ownership of either Kaffa OR Kerch by TUR set as triggers, also when Crimea picks option B, they go to war with TUR. I checked for errors using the online event parser and it came up with the following error:
* Integer -10000 out of range (0 to inf)
* Syntax error in object Event, state <action_command>, at line 30 char 14, with buffer 'type = desertion which = -1 value = -10000 } command'
I cannot figure out what I am doing wrong.
The event as it is follows below:
* Integer -10000 out of range (0 to inf)
* Syntax error in object Event, state <action_command>, at line 30 char 14, with buffer 'type = desertion which = -1 value = -10000 } command'
I cannot figure out what I am doing wrong.
The event as it is follows below:
Code:
[COLOR=White]
#Crimea becomes an Ottoman vassal#
event = {
id = 1
trigger = {
OR = {
owned = { province = 464 data = TUR } #Kaffa
owned = { province = 465 data = TUR } #Kerch
}
}
random = NO
country = CRI
name = "Crimea becomes an Ottoman Vassal"
desc = "In 1475 the Ottoman Turkey invaded the Crimea. The Turks conquered Gothia and Genoese colonies and turned them into a Turkish possession. Also Ottomans captured Meсli Geray (a son and successor of Haci Geray) and brought him to Istanbul. Sultan Mehmed II allowed the khan to return to the Crimean throne after he had forced Meсli Geray to recognize Turkish suzerainty over the khanate.The Turkish suzerainty had a wholesome effect in the cultural development of the Crimean state, but often it extremely unfavorably influenced the political situation of the khanate. The khans were obliged to send large Crimean troops to sultans’ military campaigns. That duty much weakened the Crimean khanate, which wasted its forces far outside its borders (in Persia and Hungary). Another source of conflicts was Turkish interference to dynastical affairs of the Gerays. The monarch of the Crimea could not hold the throne without the appointment by the sultan and could be removed from the throne in every moment by the will of the Turkish sovereign."
style = 1
date = { day = 1 month = January year = 1475 }
offset = 30
deathdate = { day = 30 month = December year = 1819 }
action_a = {
name = "We accept Turkish suzerainity"
command = { type = add_countryculture which = turkish }
command = { type = relation which = TUR value = 200 }
command = { type = dynastic which = TUR }
command = { type = DIP which = 2 value = 60 }
command = { type = MIL which = -2 value = 60 }
command = { type = manpower value = -10 }
command = { type = desertion which = -1 value = -10000 }
command = { type = trigger which = 2 }
}
action_b = {
name = "We will never surrender to the Turks!"
command = { type = breakdynastic which = TUR }
command = { type = relation which = TUR value = -200 }
command = { type = DIP which = -2 value = 60 }
command = { type = MIL which = 2 value = 60 }
command = { type = war which = TUR }
}
}
[/COLOR]The events for the formation of the Khanates of Crimea and Astrakhan are missing, I just realized. Were they intentionally removed? Why? If Kazan gets an auto-breakaway, why can't the others? Besides, the current way, Crimea forms Kalmuk and dies, and Astrakhan never gets created at all.
Archaalen said:
Makes sense to include Astrakhan and Crimean independence as well. The Crimean independence event description says the following:
For Crimea you could use the "Flight of Ulugh Muhammad" event, just add an independence command for Crimea in event 40058.
There is also a seperate file for forming Astrakhan: AGCEEP_Global_Astrakhan.eue though the events in the file do not happen for the Golden Horde only for everybody else. This last one makes me wonder though, should Russia also face these problems with the Astrakhan Khanate?
Archaalen said:
The only formation of Crimea and Astrakhan events that ever existed, were ones that gave them troops after they successfully revolted. I'm not so sure about scripting their revolts, as I never like the scripted Kazan sequence either. Its quite a bit artificial. And although Astrakhan has some difficulty forming, I almost always see and eventual lasting presence by Crimea.
Alkar said:
Desertion needs to be a positive number. Your event should read value = 10000, not value = -10000.
They weren't in AGCEEP as far as I know at all, but they were in EEP, I believe. The Astrakhan event had a b choice where you kept them, but got some bad revolts there for a while. Golden Horde actually turned into Crimea in the version I'm thinking of. They weren't stellar events, but they were events nonetheless.
Archaalen said:
These two events were lost when Crook's additions were removed. I didn't have the time to replace them for the initial release and haven't done any work in the area since.