Mettermrck said:
I think we're trying to simulate a unification of the German elements of the Empire, as embodied in the Kingdom of Germany. Of course if you look at maps of the Holy Roman Empire, such as
this one from 1360, it looks like Germany means everything outside of Italy. I guess we're doing a minimalist approach here, leaving out Bohemia, Moravia, Luxembourg, the Low Countries, Lorraine, etc.
I note that your link uses "Kingdom of Romany", not Germany.
Technically the Holy Roman Empire included several diffferent Kingdoms.
The Kingdom of Burgundy included much of Switzerland, Franche Comte, Provence, Savoy, and parts of Piedmont.
The Kingdom of Italy included all of Italy north of the Papal States except Venice, with disputes with the Pope over places like Parma and Modena.
The Kingdom of Lotharingia included Lorraine, Alssce, all of the Rhineland from the Palatinate down, and most of the Low Countries.
The Kingdom of Bohemia included Bohemia and Moravia.
I'm not sure how well the Kingdom of Germany was technically defined, but as I understand it, it excluded all of the previous Kingdoms.
The German Confederation is a complete anachronism, and I have no idea why it should be the basis for a Germany formed before (say) 1750. I don't see why Bohemia and Moravia should be included when Franche Comte, and Brabant are not. Each was just as much a part of 'Germany' in 1500.
I think we agree that shields over the entire Empire make little sense. I don't think that the Kingdom of Germany as constituted in 1419 or 1600 makes much sense as a basis for this replacement Germany. Twoflower believes otherwise
The Kingdom of Germany should logically have cores on all the Kingdom of Germany, i.e. as well on the Hapsburgs' 1419 provinces (even including Krain) and the Dutch provinces except Friesland, Flandern and Artois.
(and I'll note that I disagree with the exclusion of Artois. If Brabant is in Artois should be too.
Areas open to interpretation (all in the Empire) include
1)Modern Austrian/Slovenian lands
2)Kingdom of Burgundy (Franche Comte-Savoy-Schwyz-Bern)
3)Rhineland (Alsace-Lorraine)
4)Low Countries (with or without Friesland)
5)Kingdom of Bohemia (basically BOH in 1419)
6)trans-Oder Germany (Neumark, Further Pommerania)
I include the last because these were not part of the Kingdom of Germany in 1419, although they were part of the Empire.
I personnally would include 1) and 3) and exclude the rest.