• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
1-6/1936

SgtGranite

Updates will arrive, albeit SLOWLY
28 Badges
Nov 10, 2014
47
33
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Steel Division: Normandy 44 -  Back to Hell
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Steel Division: Normandy 44
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Together for Victory
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Victoria 2
  • Steel Division: Normand 44 - Second Wave
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Hearts of Iron IV: La Resistance
  • Battle for Bosporus
  • Hearts of Iron IV: By Blood Alone
  • Hearts of Iron IV: No Step Back
  • Hearts of Iron 4: Arms Against Tyranny
  • Darkest Hour
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Semper Fi
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • For the Motherland
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
Watch out, the current AAR in 2023 starts at post 21!

1936 would've been an interesting year for one Theodore Hoffmann. Not only did he receive his long-awaited promotion to Captain in the Heer, was also given his first assignment to a regular army unit, the 23rd regiment of General Von Niebelschutz's 11th Division. Hoffmann's letters clearly evoke a mild excitement at being assigned to the same grounds as his famous Uncle when he helped humiliate the Russians in 1914.

VMxeIDQ.png


Hoffmann's own father flew with the squadron of a certain Goering, but the man himself was never comfortable flying and chose to join the rapidly-expanding Heer. As an officer, he would hear of more than just common knowledge regarding new factories from Krupp, Henschel, and others in the large-scale program of expanding the army, or the government's favor of long-term investments for the year and how they might inevitably circle back to aiding rearmament.
Rumors came that the Berghof in the Alps was being renovated, now with bomb-proof chambers and flak emplacements. More noteworthy were claims that the government had completely overhauled it's foreign agenda. They were reaching out covertly to similar parties in Europe; Belgium, Holland, even Norway was supposedly under consideration. If not the coming elections, than the ones afterwards would surely be impacted.
Meanwhile, the Luffwaffe was undergoing it's first major expanasion of administrative personnel around the same time as the SturmAbteilung underwent a shake-up of it's own. Of the Brownshirts, Hoffmann had mentioned little, aside from the doubt he expressed at their potential combat effectiveness for so much manpower involved.
As for the German government, there was some minor drama over news that the cabinet was being altered with Rudolf Diehls and Carl Schubert being brought in to handle Security and Intelligence respectively. Diels was put to work rooting out "dissidents" and Schubert helped refine the general R&D program of the Reich.

k4KtwQX.png

Hoffmann's family would've gotten the news of this change on radios like this.

A former athlete in school, Hoffmann devoured news of the Olympic games that year, between observing with curiosity that the economic cooperation program with Chiang-Kai Shek's China had been cancelled. Knowing how tensions were growing in the region, there was only one other nation that might take China's place for partnership, and it's possession of a proper navy did seem to be one factor in it's favor.

zLjtNlY.png


Later on, the government vocally shot down the idea of funding a revanchist group called the "Reichskolonialbund". The money instead went to the sprawling Reichslufthartministerium.

N0nSQHP.png

THL3ySM.png

(Cropped this image upon noticing the partially obscured Swastika making up the logo for the RRG)




Overseas, odd reports were coming in from America of some rogue Catholic priest putting in a good word or two for Germany and Italy while scorning his own President. Hoffmann is known to have pondered how such a man's popularity might be "useful" insofar as keeping the US out of the next war-for one was certainly part of the plan.
FbG52Vw.png


More importantly relating to the matter of war, the German Army also commenced it's latest "Welle" program for mid-1936. The 25th, 26th, 33rd, and 34th infantry divisions were all called up. Plans were also made to overhaul the 3 half-motorized infantry divisions already present.

MG08_Ausbildung_1937_05.jpg

How the 10th division trained in the field. On it's own, photos like this might fool the observer into thinking it was from 1915.

Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-2008-0717-503%2C_Potsdam%2C_Rekrutenvereidigung_im_Lustgarten.jpg

Bundesarchiv_Bild_102-16108%2C_Vereidigung_von_Reichswehr-Soldaten_auf_Hitler.jpg

The Germany army of 1935/36 was not much of a leap from the Reichswehr.

Mz2jwp6.jpg


What comments can one offer in favor of the Panzer 1? It was certainly a good foundation to work off of after the Leichtraktor and Grossetraktor of the prior government. But with 3 divisions of Tanks all possessing 2 brigades each of this "foundation", German industry would be catching up with the Heer's armament needs for a long time.

Bundesarchiv_Bild_136-B3093%2C_Herbstman%C3%B6ver_des_IX._Armeekorps.2.jpg


Germany's primary recon armored car had a better main gun (20mm) than the panzer 1 and it's 7.92mm machine guns, a fine example of how the Heer was still flailing forward in 1936.


A/N: Finally got around to playing the BIce 10.33 campaign with all the submods like I'd planned. I chose Germany and decided to write an AAR for it. My Goal was not so much to win as to experience the full breadth of events offered in mods like TRE and GGA. How did that turn out? Well...
This will be partially based on events from the game with some changes to work around the more gamey aspects of Hoi3.
Thedore Hoffmann is of course not real, merely a representation of the PC unit's presence on various key fronts.
 
Last edited:
  • 3Like
  • 1
Reactions:
A BICE AAR - a rare treat. I’ll watch and try to pick up some of the different aspects of the mode which (like HPP) I haven’t played yet. Good luck!

That first graphic with the unit shot depicting ‘you’: what does that represent?

Cropped this image upon noticing the partially obscured Swastika making up the logo for the RRG
Well done.
 
Last edited:
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
A BICE AAR - a rare treat. I’ll watch and try to pick up some of the different aspects of the mode which (like HPP) I haven’t played yet. Good luck!

That first graphic with the unit shot depicting ‘you’: what does that represent?


Well done.
It represents that the "player" unit is an officer in the land forces and as such functions as a battle commander for ground units.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
It represents that the "player" unit is an officer in the land forces and as such functions as a battle commander for ground units.
Thanks. Does it give any advantage, or display more info or events related to that unit?
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
@Bullfilter, as I recall it basically functions as a Gary Stu self-insert into history as a commander.
 
  • 2Haha
  • 1Like
Reactions:
7/1936-1/1937
Aside from the Spanish Civil war kicking off, 1936 was a routine year. Militarily, Germany was really starting to hit it's stride production wise in the form of 3 new Battleships and 1 Heavy Cruiser as the most expensive examples. The Heer also mobilized another partially truck-borne infantry division and two escort brigades for a pair of planned Siege Cannons on top of another two Welles and the reorganization of the Ordnungpolizei.

v96M5Ua.png


Later that Year, Hoffman wrote fondly of Heinz Guderian's newly-published book on Trench warfare. A new strategic doctrine to make the most out of the Heer was just he wanted to see, wary as he was of dying in a repeat of the last war. On the other hand, there was clearly a wide gap in this idealized vision of warfare and the current Army. Someone in the higher ranks of the Heer must've thought so too because that month the 29th division was taken out of service and refit for motorized warfare.

Z85eJm6.png


The major internal controversy of the year occurred not over rearmament but some grand planned architectural escapade. Funnily enough the proposed "Deutsches Stadion" was described as "costing less than two Bismarcks", a shoddy attempt at reframing that was opposed by enough of the cabinet to shelve it. Hoffman was annoyed at the ensuing brouhaha. Expanding the army should've always taken priority over sports!

dICvvmy.png

On the other side of the Polish corridor a large series of maneuvers were held. Subsequently, motorization schemes for the Heer were accelerated.

Tzifu4D.gif
 
Last edited:
  • 3Like
  • 1
Reactions:
@Bullfilter, as I recall it basically functions as a Gary Stu self-insert into history as a commander.
Takes one to know one. ;)

This AAR seems interesting and to be honest better in execution than most BICE AARs that tend to start with joy and exuberance and then die out before 2 January 1936 comes around. With BICE there is always a struggle to avoid getting buried in the details of manifold events and mechanics, which can make it difficult to maintain the narrative, but I think this character focus will be a very positive aid in that regard.
 
  • 3Like
  • 2Haha
  • 1
Reactions:
There is a lot of events, that’s for sure. I take it part of that is because it’s Germany and with some additions from the sub-mod(s). Do they tend to over-boost Germany, or are there snakes and ladders with the choices made?

Just one small thing, a swastika managed to slip through on the TN eagle
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
1938
(My save files are acting weird, but this is why I took so many screenshots as a record.)
1938 was a key year for Germany. Right at the start, Germany succesfully absorbed Austria following a pro-unity referendum. The German Army happily absorbed Austria's Army and officer Corps. This gave the Heer two mountaineer division, one undersized light tank division, 3 infantry divisions, and another garrison brigade. A key exception to this incorporation was the Austrian air force-it's biplanes were sold to Hungary.
In the ensuing months, there was a sudden uptick in activity by the so-called "self defense forces" of German residents in Outer Czechoslovakia AKA the "sudetenland". As the Czechoslovak army was forced to take a more active role, British PM Chamberlain visited Hitler at his Bavarian residence with several other heads of state. Instead of standing with the Czechs against an army that was built more on boasts than material in March of 1938, the Western Democracies choose to let Hitler have the Sudetenland.


KMh0NBD.png

This gave the Germans a not insubstantial paramilitary force to incorporate into the Heer that consisted of two regiments. One regiment would be supplied with Czech trucks and guns shortly after Germany absorbed all of the Czech lands half a year later. The other was given to the rapidly-expanding SS.

In September of 1938 came the news that the Spanish Republican government had capitulated to the Nationalists. As a result, the German Condor legion returned to Germany with several dozen airplanes and a cadre of proto-mechanized ground troops and trainers lead by Wilhelm Von Thoma. They were sent to East Prussia near the 11th Divisions staging grounds and joined a specialized motorized Corp.

In October the tottering Czech government was dismantled by a peaceful German occupation. Without their extensive border forts, the army had no chance to resist. One odd consequence of this was that many Czech divisions had their equipment transferred to the German's puppet Slovak state, giving them a substantial army.
In return they assembled a division of grateful Slovaks and German volksdeutche officers to be put under Heer control.
vJBTI2S.png


What about the rest of the Czech army? Their artillery and trucks were railed over to Jena, which would server as Germany's go-to dumping ground for looted weaponry in the coming years.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Things now seem to be progressing in a pretty typical OTL way - for now, anyway.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Great to see some new work on the HOI3 sub-forum. I've looked into some mods, and the complexity of Black Ice is almost frightening. I'm impressed that you're managing to keep things relatively concise without leaving out anything of note. The in-game character is also a nice touch, and something that will surely help tell the story when the war starts going.

Up to now, it seems the only significant deviation from our timeline is the construction of 3 Bismarcks instead of 2. I'm looking forward to learning more about Black Ice, and to the twists and turns of this alternate reality.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
"The Slovaks have thrown of the joke of Czechoslovakia and now enjoy the freedom to oppress each other!"

- free from memory after EUIII :)
 
  • 1Haha
  • 1Like
Reactions:
It's fine! There's a certain air of leisure here on the HoI3 boards: no update is ever late, take your time, and we love updates whenever they come along.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
1/1939-8/1939
By 1939 the military was undergoing heavy expansion. Multiple divisions now existed on paper and in the form of HQs, along with several Marine divisions and Airbase divisions.
WcEA43H.png

83Ntdy9.png

The Sudeten brigade receives its equipment. They later received a Sturmpioneer Battalion.

This was also when the rather slapdash Heer started organizing for an invasion of Poland in earnest.
XiWzzo5.png

There would be a major charge from East Prussia to Warsaw, and an armored push to encircle the Ponzan army. To free up troops for this encirclement, SS Totenkopf brigades would hold the flanks of the pocket. The revolutionary utilization of an all-airborne attack by the 7th Flieger division on Torun was also added later on with the goal of cutting off the corridor. To the South, another armored push would take Lodz. Securing territory further South was the responsibility of Germany's growing Mountain infantry force and SA troops.
The plan held more than a few risks. The SS goons might break if the Polish had enough proper divisions to charge them. East Prussia's defenses consisted of Orpo battalions, SA goons, the Konigsberg Garrison, Air force base defense troops and a neglected Cavalry division to ensure that the push on Warsaw had the maximum amount of divisions. As for the Aerial attack, it was the first of it's kind and has numerous assumptions. But the German's had one important Ace up their sleeve for this showdown...
 
  • 4Like
Reactions:
There would be a major charge from East Prussia to Warsaw
I don't know if I've ever seen anyone launch the main spearhead from East Prussia, so this should be interesting!
The SS goons might break if the Polish had enough proper divisions to charge them. East Prussia's defenses consisted of Orpo battalions, SA goons, the Konigsberg Garrison, Air force base defense troops and a neglected Cavalry division to ensure that the push on Warsaw had the maximum amount of divisions.
I know one of the selling points of BICE is the more detailed unit composition, but could you give a brief overview of what your divisions are made up of? I had a hard time telling from the screenshots.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I don't know if I've ever seen anyone launch the main spearhead from East Prussia, so this should be interesting!

I know one of the selling points of BICE is the more detailed unit composition, but could you give a brief overview of what your divisions are made up of? I had a hard time telling from the screenshots.
Everything is just copying the OOB for the most part sans a few unique units.
Infantry: Division HQ, x1 Infantry brigade (Bice has one brigade represent the whole enchilada with brigade size upgrades, Art. x1, AT. x1, ENG x1, Recon Cavalry x1, horse transport battalion x1. The lone Cavalry division that arrives via events had the same support units. Can't add anything without the superior firepower tech. Swap out regular infantry and other gear for their semi-motorized and motorized equivalents. Gebergsjaeger divisions has pack artillery. After 1940 I was building infantry divisions with Rocket artillery instead of regular artillery. Jager divisions had light infantry and elite light infantry battalions.
Armor: Divison HQ, Light armor X2, Motorized infantry battalion x1, Armored car X1, artillery x1, motorized engineer x1, truck transport battalion.
SA: one or two brigade or battalion sized units spawned by the OOB and a few SA recon cavalry units that are company-sized.
SS Totenkopf standarte: SS Garrison x1 SS police x1 as spawned in events.
SS VT: three of them with one unique brigade each representing a future division (LSSAH which has Dietrich as a battle commander, Wiking, Das Reich) and a motorcycle recon battalion.
Leichte Division: Division HQ, Light Armor Battalion x1, Motorized Battalion x1, Artillery x1, Motorized engineer x1, Motorcycle recon x1, motorized transport.
Railway Artillery: Division hq, infantry x1, heavy aa x1, railway gun x1, engineer x1, truck transport.
Orpo: 3 Ordunpolizei battalions (they get really high soft attack with upgrades, police units can even recieve the Assault rifle tech).
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Thanks for explaining how the units work! I can see how this would be very satisfying to create a historical OOB.

One final question; how do the railway artillery units work/are used? Are they some sort of siege/urban assault unit?
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Thanks for explaining how the units work! I can see how this would be very satisfying to create a historical OOB.

One final question; how do the railway artillery units work/are used? Are they some sort of siege/urban assault unit?
Recalling what Gamer_1745 said once, they grant a large bonus (200% and 150%) to fort attack and urban attack. So yes, a Fort destroyer.
 
  • 3
Reactions:
Thanks for explaining how the units work! I can see how this would be very satisfying to create a historical OOB.

One final question; how do the railway artillery units work/are used? Are they some sort of siege/urban assault unit?
If you click on the artillery brigade, there opens an additional window, showing the stats of the artillery I can see that my "Siegfried" artillery currently has +290 fort attack, 210 Urban attack, -500 amphibious attack. So Rail artillery is good at fort and city attack, but the landing crafts are not the ideal position to attack from as you need a rail ferry to transport it.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions: