About the Autonomy faction.

[icegr80]

So here my story.

I control a female ruler (thus I used the seduce focus to have some of my dukes as lovers -they must really love my dwarf queen). Now my every adult vassal is member of the autonomy faction (even those who have 100 opinion of me - there really should be another faction for them to join) and while no other vassal has a negative opinion of me (at worst at 0) there is a notable exception the leader of the faction who hates me (-100 opinion who's a pretender and my uncle and the most powerful of my Dukes with 2 duchies).

So on their next meeting they decide they want more (the same happened their last 2 meetings that I accepted) so I say no and they decide to rebel against me (even my 4 duke lovers - all 100 opinions) only a imprisoned duke and 2 under-aged dukes remain in my side.

Other than that They also raise a super army of 70k (when even at my best I had 50k) against my petty 20k army (broken in parts) plus a loan paid mercenary force so I naturally lost the war.

I really think they should decide individually whether they'll revolt or not and not automatically as a whole faction (as was historically accurate).

 

[HandicapdHippo]

(even those who have 100 opinion of me - there really should be another faction for them to join)

That would kind of defeat the point of the faction, without the people who like you to counterbalance the vote it would end up revolting against you much more and almost never helping you.

I really think they should decide individually whether they'll revolt or not and not automatically as a whole faction (as was historically accurate).

Pretty sure this already happens, if the faction votes to revolt then those who voted no have the option to leave the faction at the cost of pissing off the rest of the faction.