• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

phargle

Field Marshal
57 Badges
Apr 14, 2005
2.565
150
  • Stellaris: Synthetic Dawn
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Europa Universalis IV: Third Rome
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Age of Wonders III
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Crusader Kings II: Jade Dragon
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Stellaris: Apocalypse
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Stellaris: Distant Stars
  • Europa Universalis IV: Dharma
  • Stellaris: Megacorp
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Fury
  • Europa Universalis IV: Golden Century
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • 500k Club
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Cities: Skylines Deluxe Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
Hello, and welcome to the revised AARland Choice AwAARds! Please read carefully, because there are some changes to the way this is being conducted.

. . . the changes! (bum bum bum)

1. There are four categories per game: Narrative, History-Book, Comedy, and Gameplay.

2. There are five games: EU, Rome, HoI, CK, and Vicky. Yes, that means EU1/2 and EU3 are merged. Sorry, fellahs.

3. An AAR updated at any point in 2009 is eligible for the entire year.

4. Instead of Q1, Q2, Q3, etc, we'll have four rounds of voting throughout the year. It works the same as quarterly voting, but the difference is more than semantic. Read on:

5. Once an AAR wins a category, it's designated as one of the year's winners - and then it's out of the running for the rest of the year. That way, we get four unique winners for each of the four categories per year.

And a few more thoughts. . .

1. I hope I've run the ACA in a way that convinces people of my commitment to doing it ethically . . . but for my own peace of mind and happiness, any AARs I write while I'm running the ACA are ineligible for competition, and also unsuitable for small children, people with heart conditions, or anyone who can read above the third-grade level. Ta.

2. That said, I invite everyone else to vote, compete, and get into the spirit of things. The ACA works best when we all pull together as a community. Y'all rock, so rock on.

3. Actively campaigning for AARs isn't really in the spirit of AARland. It poisons the process and threatens the ACA. It's cool (very cool) to remind people about the ACA. It's cool to ask them to consider your AAR in a public post in your AAR, and it's cool to say what category you hope to win. Beyond that, it kinda stops being cool. Let's all be cool, like a forum of little Fonzies here.

4. Rome's kinda on thin ice. I'm just sayin'.

5. Try to avoid one-vote posts. There are a lot of terrific AARs out there deserving of attention. The ACA should be here to help build the community of writers and readers, and spreading out the love helps make that happen.

Without further ado, the sample ballot:

- - - - -

Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky

- - - - -

Voting closes on May 1st, 2009. Thank you all, and happy voting!
 
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome For Rome's Honour, comma
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome Petius Nieblus, kurt
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome Petius Nieblus, kurt
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome The Ilergetan Republic, lofman

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU Mandate of Heaven (An MEIOU JV AAR), treizev
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU Alfred packers crovan empire aar
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU Paris ne vaut pas une messe! - A Huguenot IN AAR, milites
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU Prawnstars The Audacity of Hope - An Iroquois IN AAR

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI French Mod 1914 Alternate History AAR (1897- ?) Les Flammes des Ténèbres by gaiasabre
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI French Mod 1914 Alternate History AAR (1897- ?) Les Flammes des Ténèbres by gaiasabre
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI German Freedom and German Greatness: The Legacy of Gustav Stresemann by faeelin
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI Defense of the Ancient: Rebirth of Greater Tibet! by thundergate

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK Piety of the North Star, saithis
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK Lo Llibre dels Feyts - The Book of Deeds, kurt
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK The Siwards - A Family Story, tudor
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK Homelands: Tales of the Anglo-Prussians, mr. capitalist

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky Saints and Angels, volksmarshall
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky Oh Those Japanese!, fallen morgan
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky peru-aar by asd(insertrandomdigitshere)
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky The real purpose of war: an alternate WWI gameplay AAR, qwerkus
 
Last edited:
Reserved.

A very bad April fools joke. :eek:o:mad:


. . . an unfortunate and amusing twist on the way the quarterly system works is that we often begin voting on April 1st. :) No, this isn't an April Fool's Joke. This is a legitimate and carefully-considered revision of the system that I think will result in a better ACA.

If you have some thoughts on the changes, I'd love to hear them - drop me a PM. Thanks.
 
1st Ballot = :cool:
1st Complete Ballot = Double :cool:

Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome - Darthvegeta800 - Sparta: Return to Glory?
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome - Kurt_Steiner - Petius Nieblus, The First Dog in Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome - RossN - The Games Gods Play
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome - Ablamor - Armenia Aar

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU - coz1 - The Longest Night
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU - Duke of Wellington - Kanem Bornu
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU - Babington-Smyth - Scotland the Brave (but a wee bit cowardly)
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU - PrawnStar - The Audacity of Hope

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - The Yogi - The III Reich in World War III
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI - C'est Moi - Would you like Fry with that?
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - demokratickid - Ireland, Ascend!
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - Remble - The Setting Sun

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK - timetogetaway - The Mann on the Island
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK - It's Amazing - The Prince of Pronsk
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK - Vesimir - The Life and Deeds of Richard the Lionhearted
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK - kadvael56 - The tale of CanAARias

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky - Hardraade - An Irishman's Story
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky - FallenMorgan - Oh Those Japanese!
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky - asd21593 - We Are Free, May We Always Be So
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky - qwerkus - The real purpose of war
 
Last edited:
Reserved, should be able to find a few good AARs here. ;)


Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI Reuniting the Motherland - A Fatherland Experience. by Hatuke
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI "What happened to the good old comedy AARs?" :confused:
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI Democracy's Last Legs: A US - UK DAIM AAR by {LD}Firestorm and Cools

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky
 
Last edited:
What happened to the categories "favorite new writer" and "best graphics"?

April's fools joke or..? ;)
 
No, it is not a april fools.

And Phargle, you could also mention in the top post, that everyone allowed to use signatures should use them for advertising this thread, to gain as many new voters as possible forum wide. ;)
The more adverts, the more voters, the more votes which leads to more happy aarlanders. :p
*I will destroy this message with time...*
 
What happened to the categories "favorite new writer" and "best graphics"?

April's fools joke or..? ;)

Heh, I should've done my usual start-this-thing-a-day-late trick. :) No, this is a serious revision. Since the ACA is now revised to better handle new writers, the need for a category exclusively for new writers went away. Best graphics is also really a sub-set of the other four -- although if there's sufficient interest, it might be worth adding a Best Graphics category for each of the individual games. Personally, I think having a Best Graphics weekly award is the way to go there.

Note that the overall favorite in each category is also gone - it was seldom more than a "you get to win another award" award for whoever won narrative, which really made it an unnecessary award-pile-on, or a way for people to sort of strategically vote. And a big part of this revision is to remove that aspect of the ACA. Now, people ought to be able to vote their convictions in the categories, because there are more cycles throughout the year when they can vote for other AARs without feeling like they are voting against previous winners.

We'll have to check with the mods to see what sort of discussion or analysis they want on the ACA. It may be that there needs to be a thread (separate from this one) where we discuss the logic of it all.
 
Favorite Narrative AAR, EU - N/A
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU - Kanem Bornu - Out of the Sahara by Duke of Wellington
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU - Paris ne vaut pas une messe! - A Huguenot IN AAR by Milites
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU - The Audacity of Hope - An Iroquois IN AAR by PrawnStar

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - Democracy's Last Legs: A US - UK DAIM AAR by {LD}Firestorm
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI - N/A
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - China's AARight to be Hostile - A different way for the Guomindang by Porkman
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - Democracy's Last Legs: A US - UK DAIM AAR by {LD}Firestorm

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK - Rome AARisen - a Byzantine AAR by General_BT
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK - The Bagratuni's - A GeorgiAAR by Valhalla's Call
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK - N/A
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK - The tale of CanAARias by kadvael56
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome: [thread=388852]Sparta: Return to Glory?[/thread] - Darthvegeta800
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome: [thread=390085]Petius Nieblus, The First Dog in Rome[/thread] - Kurt_Steiner
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome [thread=394137]The Ilergetan Republic[/thread] - Lofman
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome: [thread=387292]There can be only one[/thread] - vandalay222

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU: [thread=385134]The Longest Night[/thread] - coz1
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU: [thread=384892]Kanem Bornu[/thread] - Duke of Wellington
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU: [thread=343076]Scotland the Brave (....but a wee bit cowardly sometimes....)[/thread] - Babington-Smyth
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU: [thread=341855]BohemiAAR: An Alternate History[/thread] - Qorten

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI: [thread=397356]Timelines: What if Stauffenberg had failed to save the World?[/thread] - Kurt Steiner
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI: [thread=387869]Ab Urbe Condita (HOI DD) [/thread] - Kurt_Steiner
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI: [thread=399705]The Z-aar Plan. A German Naval Rearmament 1936 AAR[/thread] - Simon1397

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky: [thread=363851]Carefully Applied Force: A Prussian AAR[/thread] - robou
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky
 
Last edited:
Reserved

Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - The Channel Pact - A tale of two empires by TRP
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI - For the MotAARland (Soviet WIF AAR) by Storm501
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - Ireland, Ascend! by demokratickid
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - "Das war ein Befehl!" A German Götterdammerung '44 AAR by DvD-IT

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK 1066 and all that: an England aar by gja102
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK The Republic of Genoa. A community AAR by Grauuu
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky Oh Those Japanese! by FallenMorgan
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky Carefully Applied Force: A Prussian AAR by robou
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky How do you solve a problem like Krakow? - A VIC 1.04 AAR by wargames
 
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU - The Longest Night, by coz1
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU - Adventures of the Crovan Clan 2: The World is Way Too Much, by Alfred Packer
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU - Paris ne vaut pas une messe! by Milites
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU -The Last Greek Empire by Junuxx

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - Red Star over Blue Seas, by th3freakie
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK - Piety of the North Star by Saithis
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK - He's the Prince of Pronsk, and He's Finally Made it, by It's Amazing
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky

Unfortunately I haven't read around that much these last couple months, so my voting is going to be scanty... :(
 
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - KiMaSa - Forging Destiny: Sunrise of a new world
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI - Cascadia - For the Emperor?!
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - Striker475 - Past Decisions: Documents from the United States archives 1967-84 and onwards
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - Iwo Jima - Pravda vítězí - Strategy Czech AAR

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky
 
Reserving? Bah! DoD reserves for NO MAN!

Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome - crusaderknight - Regnum Iudaeorum - The Lost Ten Tribes Of Israel
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome - Kurt_Steiner - Petius Nieblus, The First Dog in Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU - Duke of Wellington - Kanem Bornu
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU - aldriq - The Shortest Road to Damascus

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - Kurt_Steiner - Timelines: What if Stauffenberg had failed to save the World?
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - El Pip - The Butterfly Effect: A British AAR
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - Sir Keisari - Screw the commies and the Japs, Chiang has the right ideas!

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK - Jestor - Ten Years After: The Lost Girl and the History Book
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky
 
Last edited:
DONE! YAY! :D

Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome - comagoosie - For Rome's Honor
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome - Kurt_Steiner - Petius Nieblus, The First Dog in Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome - RossN - The Games Gods Play
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome - Lofman - The Ilergetan Republic

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU - coz1 - The Longest Night
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU - Brandenburg III - I’m Gonna Be IN PictAARs
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU - Salik - Gesta Danorum- Deeds of the Danes
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU - PrawnStar - The Audacity of Hope

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI - Kurt_Steiner - Ab Urbe Condita
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI - Cascadia - For the Emperor?!
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI - El Pip - The Butterfly Effect
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI - Tommy4ever- Defenders of Freedom and Democracy

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK - Saithis - Piety of the North Star
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK - It's Amazing - He's the Prince of the Pronsk, and he's finally made it!
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK - tudor - The Siwards
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK - kadvael56 - The tale of CanAARias

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky - Director - A Special Providence
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky - FallenMorgan - Oh Those Japanese!
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky - asd21593 - We Are Free, May We Always Be So
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky - andrergsanchez - The Belgium Africa Company
 
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome: For Rome's Honor by comagoosie
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome:
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome:
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome:

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU: The Longest Night by coz1
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU:
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU:
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU:

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI: The Last Mission by TheExecuter
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI:
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI: Ireland, Ascend! by demokratickid
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI: The Setting Sun - Gotterdammerung, Japan 1944 by Remble

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK:
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK:
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK:
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK:

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky: A Special Providence by Director
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky:
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky: The Harp and the Crown: An Irish AAR by RossN
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky: The Roof of the World: A Tibetean AAR by Eärendil
 
Last edited:
Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU The Adventures of the Crovan Clan 2: The World Is Way Too Much by Alfred Pecker
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI New Zealand: Land of the Long Red Cloud by Raaritsgozilla
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI For the Emperor?! by Cascadia
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI game! GMT Saturday Multi - 10 player MP by lots of people and Storm501

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK Rome AARisen - a Byzantine AAR by General_BT
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK Rome AARisen - a Byzantine AAR by General_BT
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky Oh Those Japanese! by FallenMorgan
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky The Revenge of the Bear! A BeAARhug just for you! by Mishgan
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky
 
Favorite Narrative AAR, Rome
Favorite Comedy AAR, Rome
Favorite History-Book AAR, Rome
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Rome

Favorite Narrative AAR, EU
Favorite Comedy AAR, EU
Favorite History-Book AAR, EU
Favorite Gameplay AAR, EU Mantua Redux: Improved WC

Favorite Narrative AAR, HOI Habsburga la vista, baby! - A 1914 Austro-Hungarian AAR
Favorite Comedy AAR, HOI Habsburga la vista, baby! - A 1914 Austro-Hungarian AAR
Favorite History-Book AAR, HOI Habsburga la vista, baby! - A 1914 Austro-Hungarian AAR
Favorite Gameplay AAR, HOI Democracy's Last Legs: A US - UK DAIM AAR

Favorite Narrative AAR, CK
Favorite Comedy AAR, CK
Favorite History-Book AAR, CK
Favorite Gameplay AAR, CK

Favorite Narrative AAR, Vicky
Favorite Comedy AAR, Vicky
Favorite History-Book AAR, Vicky
Favorite Gameplay AAR, Vicky

*One day, Dualism will rise again... *
 
Last edited: