A-history suggestions

[Akaki]

Not really. Maybe for Poland and Lithuania but beyond that it wasn't. Pilsudski was far too ambitious when making the plan.

Not the right place to discuss this, but with some luck and few different decisions (without obstruction from Dmowski and his pals) there was a chance to create an ukrainian state. Not to mention that during the peace talks Soviets offered Poland almost all of Belorussia (with Minsk)...
Ironically, Lithuania would be the hardest to sway to join some kind of union of federation. The status of Wilno and fear of polish influence were the main obstacles...

Back to ideas - I'd love to see some events about German-Russian talks before 1941. When Molotov demanded Bulgaria, Finnland while Hitler offered him acces to tripartite pact and british India...

 

[Cybvep]

Pre-emptive war in 1934 would be an interesting solution, especially considering the fact that the western countries weren't too keen on starting the war so soon. There are plenty of possibilities in case of WWI-style trench warfare between Poland and Germany (blitzkrieg was not likely) - Soviet intervention, dissent in the west in case of eruption of hostilities etc.

Not the right place to discuss this, but with some luck and few different decisions (without obstruction from Dmowski and his pals) there was a chance to create an ukrainian state

Right... Not after 1921 .

 

[Dutchemperor]

Not to mention that during the peace talks Soviets offered Poland almost all of Belorussia (with Minsk)...

why did they not accepted then!?


EDIT: two Polish above my post are talking but one of them is using a wrong avatar. one uses the indonesian flag and the other the polish.

 

[Akaki]

Well, we've won the war but lost the peace . Dmowski's National Democracy dominated the delegation to Riga. They were against Pilsudski's federation conception, insisted on incorporation and polonisation instead. They didn't want too many Belorussians in Poland and that's why we've rejected Minsk...

 

[Porkman]

why did they not accepted then!?


EDIT: two Polish above my post are talking but one of them is using a wrong avatar. one uses the indonesian flag and the other the polish.

I always feel bad for Indonesia and Poland. Seriously, you can't put a coat of arms or something? A bicolor? Not even a tricolor? And Red and White? The two most common colors on all national flags. Congrats guys on being different without being original. :rofl:

 

[Dutchemperor]

I always feel bad for Indonesia and Poland. Seriously, you can't put a coat of arms or something? A bicolor? Not even a tricolor? And Red and White? The two most common colors on all national flags. Congrats guys on being different without being original. :rofl:

yes, i want a flag with purple, orange and grey. that is something new.

 

[JRHINDO]

I always feel bad for Indonesia and Poland. Seriously, you can't put a coat of arms or something? A bicolor? Not even a tricolor? And Red and White? The two most common colors on all national flags. Congrats guys on being different without being original. :rofl:

Polishs copied the Indonesia Flag obviously

 

[tuore]

Polishs copied the Indonesia Flag obviously

Don't forget Monaco and Sharjah.
This goes a bit OT, but IMO Armenias flag is quite different from all the other three-coloured flags.

 

[Cybvep]

Polish people love their flag. The problem is that PI forums got Indonesian and Polish flags wrong. My flag is labelled as "Indonesian", even though it's really Polish by law and vice versa.

 

[unmerged(191057)]

I have a suggestion for an A-History scenario, "The British Civil War"

It starts in the 1930's with a financial crisis greater than OTL, causing a massive rise in radicalism among unemployed and also increases the determination of scotish and welsh seperatists, and in 1936, King George V dies, with Edward VIII being heavily influenced by Oswald Mosley and his facists, communists rise up declaring the "People's Republic of Britannia" and the seperatists make their move aswell.

 

[Porkman]

Polish people love their flag. The problem is that PI forums got Indonesian and Polish flags wrong. My flag is labelled as "Indonesian", even though it's really Polish by law and vice versa.

You're right judging by the American one I have, the only way to get the stars in the upper left corner when it's hanging vertically is to flip the entire flag over and rotate it ninety degree.

 

[Beleg32]

Polishs copied the Indonesia Flag obviously

Heretic

 

[seattle]

1945 - Alpenfestung

Scenario starts in spring 1945. German troops dug-in in the fortified Alps (fortress and AA-level through the roof). Some rocket research and nuclear reactors, too. Plus, Germany gets tech advantage in form of secret weapons.

You basically got three factions: Allies, Comintern and tiny yet technologically advanced Axis. Since relations between Allies and Comintern are fragile, the Germans can try to ally with either side or just hold out until Allies and Comintern go at it (event chains).

This could be the most fun scenario ever, especially when playing Germany. You get rocket interceptors, experimental helicoptors and even secret arctic bases with modern submarines.

 

[Ithron]

Possibility to change the dying and revive the Legue of Nations and the concept of collective security, disarment, economic sanctions, etc., thus for example at least delaying the Nazi war to 42-43.

 

[LordInsane]

Unification of Scandinavia!

Hm. Rather unlikely. Unification of Norden, on the other hand...

 

[Fulmen]

Hm. Rather unlikely. Unification of Norden, on the other hand...

If by that you mean the unification of all of the Nordic countries, then that'd be even more unrealistic than the already immensely unrealistic unification of Scandinavia.

 

[unmerged(63881)]

If by that you mean the unification of all of the Nordic countries, then that'd be even more unrealistic than the already immensely unrealistic unification of Scandinavia.

Well, actually this is the A-Historic suggestions Thread, isn't?

 

[Fulmen]

Well, actually this is the A-Historic suggestions Thread, isn't?

I don't know about you, but I want my ahistorical outcomes plausible.

 

[Ovg]

I say adding Socialist revolution in United Kingdom following the 1926 general strike would be good to have. Socialist Britain could then befriend USSR or go their own way.

 

[LordInsane]

If by that you mean the unification of all of the Nordic countries, then that'd be even more unrealistic than the already immensely unrealistic unification of Scandinavia.

I disagree about the order of unrealisticness, but agree that both are immensely unrealistic. Cooperation, yes. Actual, full-blown unification? Implausible in the period covered (theoretically, it could be merely unlikely - but as there is no Grand 1914-1964 Campaign, and as playing as a state for 4 years of that period wouldn't be all that fun for all the effort anyhow...).

I don't know about you, but I want my ahistorical outcomes plausible.

I agree. Unless it is a scenario, I'd also like them to be alternative outcomes, not alternative events (that is, no 'Hitler dies in random car-crash, yes or no' but perhaps 'Car-crash that nearly killed Hitler in OTL kills him, no or yes').