[2.4.3 vanilla]I pillage and the minor clan revolt!

[abcdgh]

I just pillaged for the nomad to graze
and when i pillaged the land till all the holdings destroyed, the province will become my religion and culture
but! the revolt risk raised by pillaged still exists, so that there will be no other revolt types but just minor clan revolt for the khaghan, even though i have already reach the clan limit
in my opinion, pillage will just make the peasant or citizen angry, but nomad doesn't even care a bit, so when i pillage a province to none holding, all the modifier caused by pillaged should be clear
hope u guys can fix this, thx

 

[Dracko81]

Nothing wrong here, you are obviously over the maximum amount of land that other clans want you to have. Failure to do so leads to these revolts.

Don't want it to happen, hand out land.

 

[abcdgh]

Nothing wrong here, you are obviously over the maximum amount of land that other clans want you to have. Failure to do so leads to these revolts.

Don't want it to happen, hand out land.

the revolt risk are not because i got too many land(i recoganize i got too many land and i don't care), it's all about i pillaged this land

 

[Dracko81]

Yes and combined revolt risk increases the chance that any revolt will occur.

 

[Dracko81]

There would of been a 4% chance of revolt because of over maximum land count. The province could have 200% revolt risk from anything else, but that 4% chance still exists for the province. You got the revolt because you were over land limit.

 

[abcdgh]

Yes and combined revolt risk increases the chance that any revolt will occur.

nope, not any revolt, a province with the same religion and culture as its holder, there will be nothing else but just peasant revolt(which doesn't exist for nomad) and minor clan revolt
so that there will be just minor clan revolt

 

[abcdgh]

There would of been a 4% chance of revolt because of over maximum land count. The province could have 200% revolt risk from anything else, but that 4% chance still exists for the province. You got the revolt because you were over land limit.

if you don't believe me, check this pic

 

[Dracko81]

You see that recent uprising? End of Story.

 

[abcdgh]

You see that recent uprising? End of Story.

recent uprising caused by the minor clan revolt
i dont know what is the story, all i meant is this revolt risk did NOT caused by too much land or too little clan, it's all because i pillaged this land, and the minor clan revolt should NOT occur just because i pillage the land for the nomad themselves

 

[Dracko81]

The flags are cleared on the 1st. How about a screenshot from the day before? The risk was there, you ran the risk of it happening, and it did.

 

[abcdgh]

The flags are cleared on the 1st. How about a screenshot from the day before? The risk was there, you ran the risk of it happening, and it did.

here you are
and you can see the whole persian empire has no revolt risk at all, this means i don't get any revolt risk debuff for i got too much land or too few clan
all the red-alerted provinces are either pillaged or herectic

 

[Dracko81]

That is a year after. Just stop embarrassing yourself.

 

[abcdgh]

That is a year after. Just stop embarrassing yourself.

the time is not important
i reload it for i dont want to handle a 360K minor clan revolt ok?

 

[abcdgh]

That is a year after. Just stop embarrassing yourself.

i just play it in ironman, and i wouldn't copy a save file per year, especially i can't even forecast when it will revolt
here is my savefile which give a QA for another bug: http://1drv.ms/1LUmUAZ
i dont know if u can load a ironman save
if u can, try it, and pillage Orsha or Murom, then wait for a great minor clan revolt