A condensed history of the OE 1622 - 1635:
April 1622 Status Quo peace with Russia and Austria, as previously agreed.
Nov 16 1624: DoW Nubia (with Aden) (with CB, from allowing province of Nile to defect in previous months, despite presence of over 20k in adjacent province to retake it). (+1BB)
Sep 10 1627: Peace with Nubia giving 100d, Nile (core province), Bisharin, Nubia and Batn al Hajar to OE. (Offensive war) (+6BB)
May 18 1629: DoW Hedjaz (no CB) (+4BB)
Aug 16 1629: Force annex Hedjaz (same religion) (+6BB)
PJL points out OE now over BB limit. BGW says "oops". Other players explain that this will produce civil wars.
Sep 18 1630: Peace with Aden, giving Arabia, Medina, Hadramaut and Aden to OE. (+8BB)
Oct 5 1630: Released 1-province Hedjaz, thus meaning that all the new provinces from Aden supply no manpower and are subject to the overseas income penalty. (-1BB)
Nov 5 1630: Released 1-province Iraq, one of the richest provinces and highest manpower provinces in the Empire. (-1BB)
Dec 1 1631: Civil war in OE
Oct 1 1632: Civil war in OE
Oct 1 1633: Civil war in OE
Aug 1 1635: Dulkadir declares independence from OE (-1BB)
Net +22 BB
Currently the OE has 49.1/44 Badboy, after starting the session at 29.6. Including the gradual BB reduction, it has still gone up almost 20 BB, and in return the OE has gained seven mainly poor provinces, but Iraq and Dulkadir are now independent and 19 provinces are currently rebel-held. It seems likely more of them will declare independence before I can recapture them, and further civil wars are likely before that much BB can be removed.
Trade 4 was achieved during the session though.
What was the Sultan's intention? The OE was supposed to gain trade 4, then gain stability, all the while being ready to attack to force Austria to sign a white peace with Burgundy if they attacked them. Meanwhile, a slow stream of diplomats would attempt to diplovassalise some of Persia, Nubia, Aden, Mughals and Gujurat. With badboy at historically low levels at the start of the session, this would have allowed expansion into central Asia, India and East Africa. Such expansion will now be impossible for about another century if BB is to remain below the BB limit.
Link to Kurtbrian's Badboy FAQ. I plead with everyone to read this document. There are several important things learn, but the most important are:
1. Attacking without a CB hurts a lot. (+4 BB)
2. Forceannexing a nation of the same religion hurts a huge amount (+6BB)
Either are acceptable when you are very small and needing rapid growth, but only then.
Ho hum.