• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

TheRemQc

French Canadian Imperialist
45 Badges
Aug 3, 2014
575
218
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Stellaris: Synthetic Dawn
  • Europa Universalis IV: Third Rome
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Darkest Hour
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Steel Division: Normandy 44
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Cities: Skylines - Mass Transit
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Steel Division: Normand 44 Sign-up
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Together for Victory
  • Cities: Skylines - Green Cities
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Europa Universalis IV: Dharma
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Cities: Skylines - Campus
  • Hearts of Iron IV: La Resistance
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Victoria 2
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Stellaris
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Cities: Skylines - Natural Disasters
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
Prologue:
Tsar Alexander University, Petrograd, Russia, 1940

Vasily was listening to the speaker very carefully. As the words came out of his mouth, he couldn't hold back his thought. What a statesman this man would have made in other circumstances! The speech had started slowly, with some words almost inaudible and some expressions dating from the Victorian area, a time the 66 years old man would, without doubts, gladly return. Now, he was raising his voice, adding short but hard hitting words. Vasily caught himself hanging at every sentences falling from the old man's lips, he took a look around him, everybody in the room was silent. Not a word could be heard and the audience stood here, at breathless attention. Yes, what a statesman Sir Winston Churchill would have made! Exiled in Canada, Churchill was travelling the world trying to gain support for the only cause he now defended, the liberation of the British Isles from the Totalist oppression. The recent defeat of Germany under the combined armies of the French Commune and Imperial Russia had brought him to Petrograd and the Chairman of Tsar Alexander University had seized his chance to invite the Britton to give a speech. Obviously, Churchill was enjoying this unexpected opportunity.

Daring anybody in the crowd to challenge him, Churchill unleashed the essence of his prose with thunderous words:

"From Alta in the Arctic to Syracuse in the Mediterranean an iron curtain has descended across the Continent. Behind that line lie all the capitals of the ancient states of Central and Western Europe. London, Paris, Rome, Oslo, Madrid, Lisbon, Brussels and Essen, all these famous cities and the populations around them lie in what I must call the Syndicalist sphere, and all are subject in one form or another, not only to Syndicalist influence but to a very high and, in some cases, increasing measure of control from Paris. The French-dominated West-German government has been encouraged to make enormous and wrongful inroads upon its own citizens, and mass expulsions of thousands of undesirables on a scale grievous and undreamed-of are now taking place. The Left Wing radicals and Syndicalist parties, which were very small in all these Western States of Europe, have been raised to pre-eminence and power far beyond their numbers and are seeking everywhere to obtain total control. Police governments are prevailing in nearly every case, and so far, there is no true democracy."

The audience gave Churchill a warm round of applause. Standing on his feet, Vasily like everybody else, was flabbergasted by the power of the speech he just listened to. He had stopped taking notes and had no idea with what he was going to fill his column but at the moment it didn't mattered, all others attending journalists were in the same position he was. Overwhelmed by the man. Overwhelmed by the consequences of the speech. Overwhelmed by the truth. “An Iron Curtain, this might be actually true…”

Indeed, relations between Russia and France had deteriorated following the fall of Berlin. The decision of Russia to keep post-war Germany politically intact had mattered a lot in the decision of Paris to cease the negotiations in order to unite Germany under a single flag and to set up its own government in the west. Subsequent Russian demands for free elections in French occupied territory were all unanswered, as well were the French demands of self-determination for the former eastern German client-states. Only time will tell how this new kind of ideological war, a “cold” war in opposition to the recent “hot” conflict, will end…


===

VXLlwIz.png


===
Welcome to my second attempt at an AAR on this forum. My first attempt, Mexicans at the cry of war is on hiatus as I'm not personally satisfied with the result and that anyway I don't have time to work on two AARs while I'm developing a mod. At the same time, I was missing writing and really wanted to start something new, so here I am!
I'm playing with Kaiserreich but be aware that at this point in the game, there's not much left in terms of events so I'll be making new ones to make things a little more interesting and realistic.
Expect updates every two weeks, I'm not writing that fast and I have a lot of real-life stuff in addition to the mod!

I hope you will enjoy! :)

===

Table of Content

Prologue
Introduction - Part One Part Two
Chapter I - Part One Part Two
Chapter II - Part One

 
Last edited:
So the International and Russia has Imperial Germany, the worlds only superpower at the start of a regular game of Kaiserreich, all defeated and split up by 1940???
While I do love the Idea of a Kaiserreich Cold war, and the mod is desperately in need of something/anything to do after WWII I find this to be extremely unlikely.
Also, Imperial Russia cooperating with the Communards? How? Why? The French would never do that, Imperial Russia is everything they hate. You got some explaining to do me thinks.

Basically Russia brought this situation on itself.
 
One of the classic Kaiserreich Cold War situations! (Democratic because mentions of demands for free elections? Pro-Entente because of Churchill?) Imperial Russia and her network of puppets and reconquered lands dividing the common foe of the superpower German Empire in the Second World War, in a deal with the devil, with the Third Internationale before entering a cold war with a divided syndicalist West Germany and pro-Russian East Germany. I look forward to this AAR.
 
Eagerly waiting with anticipation!

Fantastic opening, I'm very interested to see where this will go.

Great opening.:)
Thank you all for the good comments!

A kaiserreich cold war is a very interesting tipe of AAR. I hope it didn‘t end like Mexicans at the cry of war.
I have a lot more stuff in the back of my head for this one don't worry ;). Also to be honest, loosing all my pictures I had for Mexicans at the cry of war was the the straw that breaks the camel's back, after this I really ran out of motivation.

So the International and Russia has Imperial Germany, the worlds only superpower at the start of a regular game of Kaiserreich, all defeated and split up by 1940???
While I do love the Idea of a Kaiserreich Cold war, and the mod is desperately in need of something/anything to do after WWII I find this to be extremely unlikely.
Also, Imperial Russia cooperating with the Communards? How? Why? The French would never do that, Imperial Russia is everything they hate. You got some explaining to do me thinks.

One of the classic Kaiserreich Cold War situations! (Democratic because mentions of demands for free elections? Pro-Entente because of Churchill?) Imperial Russia and her network of puppets and reconquered lands dividing the common foe of the superpower German Empire in the Second World War, in a deal with the devil, with the Third Internationale before entering a cold war with a divided syndicalist West Germany and pro-Russian East Germany. I look forward to this AAR.

Can't wait to see the map and your exposition!

I don't want to spoil too much but maybe this will help answer some of your questions:

D9Bwqjk.png
 
Does that dark yellow on Poland, baltics and Finland mean that they're semi-autonomous or what? I'd like to know
These are Congress Poland, the Baltic Governorates and Grand Duchy of Finland (as well as the Kingdom of Armenia in the Caucasus is you look closely). Clarification about their status will come soon, but if you make a quick research on google you might found a hint or two about their status.;)

You planning on custom flags? I can help if you need and don't know how to art.
Is it okay if I send you a private message about that?

God save the Tsar. God damn the Syndie scum! Looking forwards to this.
Amen! Thanks for the support!
 
Ah Poland, the Baltic states, and Finland are autonomous parts of the Russian Empire once more. Are they really democratically self-ruling parts of the Empire or unofficially directly ruled from the Russian capital and subject to Russification policies like in the original empire?
 
Ah Poland, the Baltic states, and Finland are autonomous parts of the Russian Empire once more. Are they really democratically self-ruling parts of the Empire or unofficially directly ruled from the Russian capital and subject to Russification policies like in the original empire?
So much questions... so few answers...;)
Don't worry I'll clarify the situation very soon!
 
Introduction:
The birth of a superpower


Part I - Dimitri

ZMXE7Lp.jpg

His Excellency Dimitri Pavlovich Romanov 2nd President of the Russian Republic

The first half of the 20th century was for Russia, a special one. First humiliated by Japan in 1905, the country was rocked by revolution and Tsar Nicholas II forced to transform the country into a constitutional monarchy, in name if not in facts. For the next decade, the Russian bear went healing its wounds and re-arming for the next round against Japan. On July 12th 1914 however, Russia’s destiny was changed forever. After the assassination of the Crown Prince of the Austro-Hungarian Imperial throne, Russia found herself, in an unexpected turn of events, at war against Germany and Austria, soon to be joined by Turkey. During the following years, Russia's backwardness and military incapacity was exposed in plain sight as the country, with an Army 12 million strong, was unable to defeat its foes. As the dead were piling high, the morale on the home front was reaching all-time lows and in February 1917 the country went through its second revolution in less than a lifetime. Forced to abdicate, the Tsar went in exile in Siberia and Russia became, for the first time in its long history, a republic. This first democratic Russia was however short-lived. Eight months after the Tsar left Petrograd, a coup by Bolshevik revolutionaries transformed Russia into a proletarian dictatorship. The Bolsheviks first move was to make peace with Germany, thus ending Russia’s participation in the Weltkrieg. The ensuing treaty was another bitter humiliation for Russia: Poland, Lithuania, the Baltic provinces, the Ukraine, Crimea and others are all lost to the Central Powers. The Bolshevik government of Vladimir Lenin then proceeded to consolidate its power over Russia but was soon met with resistance, first in Finland where Germany was already helping the Finns against the Red Guards, then all across Russia as the announcement of Lenin recent assassination spread and boosted the morale of the White forces. In July 1919, the Volga campaign came to an end when the two largest counter-revolutionary forces, the Siberian Whites and Wrangel’s Army, met at Samara along the Volga. In conference in Ufa, the leaders of the two groups decided to unite under a single force and to cut ties with the Entente. The fall of Petrograd to General Nikolai Yudenich then gave to the Whites the opportunity to proclaim a provisional All-Russian Government. The final nails in the Bolshevik’s coffin came during the winter of 1919-1920 when on January 22nd the Whites took Moscow after two months of siege and formally ended the Russian Civil War.

0y3YCw1.jpg

Alexander Fyodorovich Kerensky the strongman of Russia during the interwar

It was now time to rebuild the country. This uneasy task would fell on President Alexander Kerensky who would be known as one of the most controversial man in Russia’s history. When faced with a plot led by Alexander Kolchak to coup the government, Kerensky successfully outmanoeuvred him and defeated the pretender. But at the same time, Kerensky was unable to prevent Kolchak to set up his own republic across the Amur River and to retain the Cossacks within the Russian state. For the next fifteen years Kerensky –increasingly unpopular– would nevertheless hang on to power. Using his influence to maintain a weak coalition of the two main parties in the Duma, the Kadets and the Socialist Revolutionaries, Kerensky saw a lot of Premiers passing by but with the lack of a serious opposition and with the help of much electoral manipulations, he himself remained in the Presidential office until his assassination on January 6th 1936. Much like the shot that killed Franz Ferdinand in 1914, the killing of Kerensky would have worldwide aftereffects, although it would take time for them to be noticed.

a5gCHyu.jpg

The transition of power after the President death went smootly but was
a critical moment when a lot of things could have went wrong


The immediate effect of the President’s death was to put an end to the SR-Kadets coalition, creating a power vacuum across the country. In order to assure a smooth transition and to avoid violence, someone was to take the oath of President as fast as possible. While the Duma was still in chaos, the Senate took the matter in its own hands and elected Dimitri Pavlovich Romanov as provisional President. Dimitri’s first action, the nomination of Pavel Milyukov as his Prime Minister, surprised more than one in the political society of Russia. The Grand Duke was known to be a life-long reactionary and it was expected that his friend and landowner Vladimir Purishkevich –with whom he had assassinated Rasputin in 1916– would inherit the head of the government. Unexpected as it was, Milyukov nomination contributed to bring back a semblance of order in the mess that was now the Duma. Dimitri’s next move was to sell some of his personal estates as well as some other Grand Dukes in a program called Money for the Motherland. Even if it contributed to add to his growing popularity, the move was in reality nothing more than smoke and mirrors as these estates had already been returned to the possession of the State before. Dimitri’s third action was however of a much greater importance. In collaboration with Milyukov’s Kadets and the Duma, President Romanov proceeded to rewrite the Russian criminal and civil codes. The presidency of Alexander Kerensky, although it lasted two decades, hadn’t introduced a lot of new legislations and Russian laws were now composed of a mix of old imperial and provisional laws instituted by the president. With this bill, Dimitri –and the Romanovs– truly won the hearts of the Russian people. Voted almost at the unanimity by the Duma the bill almost failed in the Senate where the reactionary Senators opposed it. But then again, Dimitri surprised everyone by forcing the hands of the Senators and asking them to pass the bill, which they did. Finalizing his charm operation, Dimitri Pavlovich Romanov signed a Presidential decree which, against all odds, started a land reform in collaboration with the newly reformed Zemstvo (local governments), now working along a revised system of suffrage. Under President Romanov, Russia had undergone more changes in six months then in the last ten years.

2XSZkPz.jpg

Prime Minister Pavel Nikolayevich Milyukov, the man with whom Dimitri Romanov
would collaborate the most in the Duma and, ironically, at the same time the architect
of the resistance against the President


Today, with hindsight and access to Dimitri’s memoirs it’s easier to understand why the Grand Duke was acting in such ways. But in 1937, the Russian political class was stunned. Dimitri had never been a democrat and had always supported Nicholas II in his absolute and autocratic manners. He was a staunch critic of the Duma and in the years preceding the Weltkrieg had opposed to every reforms proposed by the deputies. For the aristocratic Senators who gave him the presidency, it was a monumental betrayal. Or so it seemed. Although it would be hard to compare Grand Duke Dimitri to a great statesman like Bismarck, a resemblance between their approaches towards reforms can be found. Much like the German Chancellor had done in the 19th century, granting the German people calculated social reforms in order to keep the dissent low, Dimitri was reforming the Russian political system in a way that would make the Russian people feel like their conditions were improving. While it can’t be denied that their living standard were effectively on the rise and that with Dimitri’s reforms their political power was increasing, what most of the Russian people didn’t knew was that the Grand Duke was manipulating them. A year after he had been sworn President, Dimitri Pavlovich Romanov had reached a level of popularity that most Tsars would have envy. And he knew it.


The Grand Duke popularity was however viewed with suspicion in at least one sphere of the Russian society, the Duma. Even though he had actively worked with the assembly, the members of the chamber suspected that this impromptu collaboration was to serve another cause. Even the new party founded by Felix Yusupov to serve the needs of Dimitri, Indivisible Russia, was beginning to ask questions about the intentions of the President. But when in April 1937, the President publicly announced that he was leaving the capital for an undetermined length to confer with Grand Duke Kirill Vladimirovich Romanov at his residence, everybody in Petrograd –and across the country– understood. Grand Duke Kirill was, ever since the slaughter of the Imperial family by the Bolsheviks, the head of the Romanov dynasty, and heir to the Imperial Throne of Russia.

McPMTC3.jpg

Grand Duke Kirill (left) with Grand Duke Dimitri

Grand Duke Kirill Vladimirovich Romanov was a controversial figure. At the time of the February revolution, he had sworn allegiance to the Provisional Government and authorized the flying of a red banner over his Palace. During the years following the civil war, there was a dispute among the monarchists about whom of Kirill or Grand Duke Nicholas should be the leader of the Romanov dynasty, a dispute that was only settled by the death of Nicholas in 1929. Aged of 60 at the spring of 1937 when Dimitri went on his journey to meet him, the Grand Duke had become desperate to regain what he claimed to be his throne and thus accepted much of the conditions imposed on him to be allowed to integrate the Winter Palace. Kirill’s old-school outlook on politics and internal relations would later spark tensions between him and the government but what is today generally acknowledged by historians about his reign is that he was nothing more than a puppet of Dimitri, who was still running the show.

The restoration bill was submitted to the Duma at the beginning of March and was subject to amendments and modifications not well-received by the President. Among these, were the necessity for the Tsar to authorize the Tauride Palace to start work on a new Constitution within a year of his coronation and in the meantime agree to nominate the head of the leading party in the Duma his Prime Minister. Despite being reluctant to those modifications, President Romanov accepted the bill in its modified version and presented it to a disgusted Kirill the same day it was adopted. The old man complained that he would be a Tsar without power and the first Russian head of State unable to effectively govern Russia. Nevertheless, on May 1st 1937 (although he officially accepted the crown on March 18th), the new Tsar-to-be entered Moscow on horseback welcomed by hundreds of thousands of Russians. Security was tight and General Anton Denikin’s personal division had been mobilized for the event. The highly religious ceremony reached its climax when in the Cathedral of the Dormition –beating heart of the Third Rome– the new monarch was sacred Emperor of All the Russias.

4Mg5p9T.jpg

For better and worst: the coronation of His Imperial Majesty Kirill I

It was a milestone of Russian modern history. A lot of people in Russia were relieved of the Tsar’s return, republicanism had too obviously failed Russia. It had thrown the country in civil war, humiliated it in a peace with its enemies and removed the little prestige the country still had on the international stage. The Romanov restoration was in many ways a fragile compromise. The aristocratic and reactionary part of the society was satisfied of the return of the Imperial family, and would now fight to increase the power of the monarch, while their liberal opposition would fight to reduce it. Between them, Grand Duke Dimitri –now the Tsar’s principal advisor– was weaving his web. The first step was to put in check the Duma. It was hoped that the upcoming general elections would see the triumph of Yusupov’s puppet party, Indivisible Russia. This would give the Tsar –and the Grand Duke– a blank check to write a constitution that would be automatically accepted by the Duma (under control of Indivisible Russia) and the Imperial counterpart of the Senate, the State Council.

The outcome of the 1937 elections was however very different from what the ex-President expected. At the last minute, Milyukov’s Kadets formed a coalition with the Liberals and, against all odds, succeeded in beating Indivisible Russia in spite of all the “help” granted to Felix Yusupov by the Grand Duke’s money. Dimitri Pavlovich asked the Tsar to make Yusupov his Prime Minister in spite of the result but in yet another unexpected turn of events, the old Tsar felt that he owned the Duma for his accession to power and granted Pavel Milyukov the office –although declining the Duma’s calls for resignation of Dimitri–. Not all hopes were lost for the Grand Duke though, he could still write his constitution and try to rig the vote within the Duma once the time comes. The important thing was just to stay in good terms with the Tsar, an easy task. During 18 months, the Grand Duke worked hard to prepare the ground for the vote in the Duma and in the end, it looked like it might very well work. But on October 12th 1938 –the exact date of his birthday– Tsar Kirill I peacefully passed away. For Dimitri Pavlovich Romanov, it was truly the end, but for Russia, it was only the beginning...

HkSnEuw.jpg
 
Unless another set of unlikely events occur, Russia's future is as a somewhat conservative democratic constitutional monarchy. Will the new Tsar Vladimir try to reclaim more power or remain a popular figurehead? We will see if the fragile democracy survives in the harsh and infertile lands of Russia. If it does, I believe that Russian democrats will mockingly hail Grand Duke Dimitri Romanov as the "Russian Washington", the man who made Russian democracy possible. Russia will apparently ascend to superpower status and undo the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in only two years after Tsar Kirill's death if the prologue's dates are right.
The Tsar, Duma, and Prime Minister will restore Mother Russia to glory! God save the Tsar!
 
A very well written chapter, with a wonderful cliffhanger.:)
 
Very much enjoying the history.