(( private: @ThaHoward ))
Mon Capitaine,
it seems inevitable to me that your League shall be banned. Even if the Chamber were to revolt, the King would do in an ordinance. Better that we control the manner . That is why my friends have been supporting the motion to ban both the League and those treacherous green banner gangs of toughs that the Ultras use to commit crimes in broad daylight. But I do not write you to convince you to support the Militia Act.
Instead I propose that you transform your League into something greater. As a Deputy, you are at this point, the subject of Royal intervention, the most prominent man of an open and liberal mind in the Doctrinaire grouping; at a time when Decazes is demanding absolute loyalty from a party that has never been a single faction. And I suspect you have sympathies for your fellow retired soldier, General Lamarque; even if Greggoire wouldn't be the hill you would choose to die on yourself. And his defense of the bishop has made him the most important Independent Liberal at this moment. Men who wait for instruction from Benjamin Constant are going to be lost in this time of turbulence. And said men make a suitable republican bogeyman, representing the far left of the Chamber.
I say that you lead an open revolt of the Deputies, that is to say a political revolt against party leadership, in the Chamber. Split the left of the Doctrinaires and take them to the center of the Chamber and ask Lamarque and his liberal allies to do the same. Let them see the strength of sentiment patriotic Frenchmen command. The deflation of the government's majority in the Chamber will lead to a new election and the chance for your likely modest at first breakaway group to return stronger than the conservative Doctrinaires. After all, you have said before you would rather work with moderate Ultras. Removing an out of touch leadership from power and forcing a two-party government of moderate members of the Left and the Ultra-Royalists would be a boon for France.
- Duval
((Private letter.))
Friend,
I thank you for your advise it is well recieved. For the rebellion that is exactly what I have done. I've been loyal to Decazes and even wrote several essays where I encouraged Doctrinaires, Liberals and moderate-Ultras to unite behind him. Now he is out to get me as he percieve me as illoyal. And for what? For giving the Council the authority to depose of Gregoire or not. To calm the voices. Unfortunately he see this as a hostile act. I see him then as a proto-tyrant. And where I sacrifised personal beliefs for the unity of the Doctrinaires I see now no action but to sacrifice that unity to lead Decazes back to the Center or let the Left take over.
Now while I see that you mean well, I percieve the militia bill of your deputy as dangerous. On the simple ground that it go against the Charter. Veterans are specifically allowed to keep use of their uniform and rank. If the petition is passed the Charter who are meant to keep the government in place from abusing the people will be overruled by the said government. That lead to a dangerous path where the will of the governmemt trump the Charter. In my opinion we should move toward a liberal society where rule of law is central and not the arbritation of the government.
Lastly it is also dangerous as it create the possibility to repress and deny public meetings. We should again, if we are to move to a liberal society, increase these rights and not take them away!
Based upon these observations I advise you to make your friend retract that petition and instead stand behind me. I have also issued a compromise to Decazes and hopefully he will accept it. But if not, it would be of great help if your deputy and likeminded ones supported me and prevented the Doctrinaire from being just a petite-Ultra faction.
-Lothaire Lécuyer.