• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
1969 - With a Bang, Not a Whimper (Part 2)

It is not wrong to describe the New Year Speech by Prime Minister Satō Eisaku, where among other things he announced that he would not be standing for another term as leader of the Rikken Seiyūkai, as a seminal moment in Japanese politics. Observers and political commentators were absolutely baffled by this move as everything that they had come to rely upon for guessing when a certain Prime Minister would resign, had failed them, as it had suggested that there was no reason that Satō would not be leading the party and the nation deep into the new decade. The PM was well liked, polled well in the ratings, despite or perhaps because of the ongoing student protests, he had not been found out to be related to a major corruption case, the war in China was going as well as could be hoped and most importantly the Prime Minister had not made some unexpected visits to hospital. The final point had not occurred to many politicians before Ikeda's resignation. Whilst journalists mostly chalked it down to a fluke and the manic obsessives took to scouring any and all possible sources for even a shred of data - the 'Atami Accords' that stood as the true reason behind this move would evade public record for decades to come. The January leadership race, as it has come to be known among the politically interested, that followed Satō's announcement would be a fairly close run affair. This was not just due to the primary system that Satō had helped put in place, but also due to the fact that the two men that were meant to succeed Satō, Maeo Shigesaburō and Ōhira Masayoshi, had failed to reach an agreement on which of them would have that honour. Although Ōhira coveted the seat for himself, Maeo seemingly set his sight on the future generations of the party and had more interest in denying that seat to Ōhira than standing himself. He figured that someone younger and more vigorous like Suzuki Zenkō or Itō Masayoshi would be better fit to lead the party into the future than an old man like himself or Ōhira. Maeo is also noted to have considered bringing back Tanaka Kakuei at one point, but burying that idea due to worries about the revival of the Black Veil incident and reigniting internal struggles. He would eventually also fail to choose a single candidate and, due to the primary system, unofficially throw his weight behind both Suzuki and Itō. The fact that Ōhira refused to step back and continued to insist that he take part in this race, this fact let Satō avoid endorsing any candidate on an official or unofficial level. Miki Takeo, Fujiyama Aiichirō and Nadao Hirokichi join the three liberals in the leadership race, raising the number of candidates to six.

xp79ZWE.jpg

The candidates in the 1969 February Rikken Seiyūkai leadership race from left to right - Nadao, Ōhira, Miki, Itō, Fujiyama and Suzuki.

A relatively short campaign trail saw both Suzuki and Itō withdraw from the race, as it fairly quickly became obvious that the two young men lacked the name recognition that could carry them to lead the party. This was a fact that no amount of fundraising or ringing endorsements from liberal heavyweights standing against Ōhira could help about. The rather wooden Miki would be carried to safety and to head the pack by his continued insistence of coming to terms with the Chinese and ending the Japanese support for the Qing dynasty, making him a lightning rod for pacifist voters in the leadership race. Things were not much more united in the conservative caucus, which stood almost as divided as the liberal one. Although the 'big business' Fujiyama had managed to weld together a big group of conservatives around him, it only amounted to a small plurality within the conservative ranks. Seeing this the rest had fallen in lockstep behind the more traditional Nadao, who had served as education minister during the majority of the protests in 1968 and become familiar to the public for his rather authoritarian statements for dealing with the protests as a threat to the Kokutai. The results of the primaries on the 25th of January saw Miki emerge slightly ahead with Ōhira, Nadao and Fujiyama in hot pursuit. The likelihood of four candidates making it through the primaries had not necessarily been considered, leaving the party in a rather difficult situation as there were no written rules for determining a winner between the four. Eventually. following a emergency meeting of the party leadership, it was decided that if no candidate earned a simple majority in the first round, where the factions voted, that run-off elections would be held, between the factions, with the two winning candidates from the previous round. The likelihood of a candidate with such a majority emerging was thought as highly unlikely and this was proven shortly afterwards, as on the 31st of January no such candidate emerged. The faction vote saw a reversal of fortunes with Miki pushed to the back, given that his faction was dwarfed by all of his competitors. Fujiyama had managed to take third place, only slightly losing to Ōhira. Surprising everyone it was Nadao that had taken the lead, this was primarily due to the fact that most had thought that the liberals would unite behind Ōhira, despite the growing antipathies between him and Maeo. The latter however enjoyed something of a friendship with Nadao and had pushed his supporters to support the conservative over his more liberal rival.

dLcdrgS.jpg

Prime Minister Satō bantering with parliamentarians during the leadership election.

The beginning resurgence of the student protests and the unclear public reaction to the events at Yasuda Hall would however mean that Diet members that made up the party factions were rather unsure about the prospects of what Nadao's victory would mean for their chances at the ballot boxes. This, along with a well observed tradition in Rikken Seiyūkai leadership races of candidates at the back uniting against the one at the front, is why in the second round of voting Ōhira not Nadao came out ahead and took control of the party. The victory was hollow in many ways, as liberal unity had been broken and the new party leader was tasked with not only pleasing those two very different groups that had backed him for victory, but also making sure that those that had lost would be willing to accept defeat as well. Besides their nigh pacifist views towards the conflict in China, the 'centrist' group around Miki was also known for their rather odd views in relation to the rest of the party. The group called for widespread political reform as well as holding an idealist stance that argued that politics should move away from centring on money and porkbarrel politics. The alleged Anglophilia of the faction had also brought them close to officials from Australia and New Zealand with Miki spending much of his time not spent on lobbying withdrawal for China and clean politics, on arguing for an equalisation of relations between Japan and the last remnants of the once mighty British Empire. Miki had also been one of the suspected backers of the Konoe Incident, much to the dismay of Ōhira. The situation was not helped that the big business conservatives around Fujiyama, who in addition to arguing for weakening government intervention in business, almost openly argued that money as well as the zaibatsu should play an even greater and more direct role in politics than they had thus far. Reconciling these views with the 'one nation conservatism' that had been party policy for decades now and the internal clashes that it caused, dominated the few weeks of the Ōhira leadership in the lead-up to the 1969 elections and would have a rather negative effect on the party and its electoral chances. While its victory was still in many ways assured assured, especially thanks to the hits that that the Taishūtō had taken due to their suspected affiliation with the Zenkyōtō, many were seriously suspecting whether the party would need to enter into a coalition. Even though these concerns eventually proved misplaced, the party would emerge from the 1969 elections with naught but remains of its previous dominance.

YaxO9iv.png

The mixed messaging, consolidation of left-wing votes following the banning of the Communists as well as
surprisingly good showing by both the Komeitō and the Nihon Shintō are often blamed for the thin majority.

Given that the victory at the ballot box in reality represented a resounding defeat for the party, at least that is how the politicial landscape in Japan saw it, infighting once again surged to the front. Ōhira would eventually convinced to resign after rumours surfaced that his former rivals might vote against him at a vote of no confidence organised by the opposition in early April. Reluctantly, he announced that he would tender his resignation on the 14th of March. Whilst most had expected another bombastic primary, which did indeed occur, an unexpected event also happened. The Miki faction had been one of the few groups to actually manage to be not negatively affected by the disastrous 1969 elections, having gained a single additional member. Now sure that reform to the political system could not emerge from inside the Seiyūkai, Miki began to put out feelers towards all of the opposition parties during the internal struggles that followed the results of the elections and preceded Ōhira's resignation. Even though this should have set off some alarm bells, his role as secretary-general meant that contact with the opposition was determined a vital function. Through these contacts he determined that there was indeed enough support for an anti-Rikken coalition despite the internal issues present in Taishūtō and the other parties, as the leaderships of the opposition parties were reluctant to miss a shot at actually getting into power. Following a considerable amount of backroom dealing a basic agreement was put into place and thus on the 15th of March, when the media was still in a state of hangover and preparing for the next leadership race, the Miki faction announced that they were unanimously withdrawing from the party and through it stripping the Seiyūkai of its majority. The anti-Rikken coalition now dropped its masks and banded together for official talks, where minutia such as cabinet postings and actual policy proposals began to be hammered out. The group would emerge from their talks about a week later announcing that they had come to an agreement and would be forming a coalition government headed by Konoe Fumitaka. In truth there was little that the coalition had actually agreed upon during that week and public arguments between coalition members about the policy that they had supposedly championed when toppling the RSK became the norm. There was indeed only one policy proposal that all of them could agree upon and it was that the fact that the rule of the Rikken Seiyūkai had to come to an end. Topics such as electoral reform as well as peace on the Mainland, were left ambiguous for a reason and were to be filled in at a later date once a sufficient middle-ground was found.

VfW0Wah.png

Regardless of the chaotic nature, the parliamentary coup or the 3-15 Incident as some would nickname it, heralded
the end of an era in Japanese politics and the transition heading to the 1970s marked a plunge into the unknown.

-----------------------------------------
Does the student movement have any leaders? You didn't give any names, so it comes across as quite an amorphous, nebulous, incomprehensible phenomenon that will only be remembered for the disruption to people's lives and and damage to buildings that it caused. (Which is certainly a lot, but buildings can be repainted, while favorable impressions of charismatic individuals can stay in people's minds for a long time)

But surely there were prominent individuals with leadership roles in the movement? Individuals whose statements, attitudes and defiance inspired some, put off others, and left a mark in history? It's so hard to follow the events and understand what they mean, when otherwise it's really quite without high or low points, and no perceivable "progress" towards its mostly academic specific goals.

And what did the student activists really want to happen, in wider society? It was mentioned early on, that there wasn't much resistance against the ongoing draft, which struck me as odd since the one thing that's guaranteed to turn young adults into fighters for their own interests, is to tell them the state will shear their hair, stuff them into uniforms, and order them to become fighters for other people's interests in a far away land. Japan is still embroiled in a quagmire in China, trying to prop up a vicious and half collapsed regime against a genuinely popular republican resistance that likely has world wide support. Wouldn't that rile up students too? Are there any outrageous solidarity demonstrations of Japanese students cheering for the Chinese Guomindang? Famous TV and cinema stars, visiting Guangdong and shaking hands with Madam Sun, to the outrage of the patriotic Japanese press?

The thing to consider with the student movements both in OTL and TTL is that, while there might be certain individuals that kick things off there is very rarely a clear leader of sorts. It is in many ways... somewhat anonymous, much like the society around it. Danny the Red, that I mentioned earlier, and Paris '68 of OTL is a fairly good example in this regard. He and his group of would be revolutionaries, that had been pivotal in writing the 22 March Manifesto ended up rather quickly marginalised by names that are far less known and the majority of the movement would take place without as much of their intervention as others took their place. The student movements in the late 60s represented in many ways everything to a very wide group of people and something resembling rule by committee, rather than by a Lenin or a Bonaparte strikes much closer to what happened. Both of these things however inevitably make it an amorphous, nebulous and incomprehensible mess as well as at the same time pulling in quite a few disgruntled people, even those that would in normal circumstances loath to even breathe the same air as the other. In this regard, the student protests represent a turn of phrase that I would like to call - few remember a failed revolutionary, but many more remember a failed revolution.

But to actually answer your question, yes there were prominent individuals. However I deemed them okay to cut to not flood people with too much throwaway information, in many ways there is a lot of it in this AAR, but for some reason I could not bring myself to include these names. As although a man might unknowingly sow the seeds of revolution, the role of an individual decreases fairly quickly in the face of the act itself. It is this act, which as you yourself said that becomes a formative event for a future generation of potential community leaders, business executives and why not military officials. I do agree, that the amorphous blob makes for a really bad storytelling, but it is this amorphous feeling an unclear movement that described the movement and thus I thought it important to maintain it. It is not Petrograd in 1917 after all and the students are not revolutionary sailors on the Aurora. Concessions were already maintained to cut down on other potential unnecessary points as well. I will however concede that a better writer could have moulded this into a much better narrative.

The meaning of the protests or what the students wanted to happen depends a lot on who you ask, this is where the amorphous unguided nature of the movement once again comes into it. The whole thing can in many ways be summed up as grab bag, since it is in reality a large mass of students becoming politically active and experimenting with different facets of ideology that they find fascinating. As mentioned, there was the occasional - manifesto declaring that the "Universities are the Devil and should be Crushed" as well as a slogan or declaration calling to "Tear down the Imperial System", but in truth it was a rather eclectic mix of youth, experiencing and pushing various anti-consumerist, at most times anti-imperialism and of course anti-authoritarianism rhetoric and ideas. The latter of course includes opposition to the draft. In regards to opposition to the draft, I do think that I mentioned that there haven't been draft riots not that the public has kept its head down. Before we got to 1968, I used to sprinkle in the occasional anti-draft demonstration or two or three into a few years. Granted they were in the "Wikipedia" part, where the eyes of reader start to gloss over, but they were there. In regards to 1968 itself, the first Kanda Quartier Latin during the long summer stemmed from an anti-war and anti-imperialist show of colours and was only beaten apart once students pushed their luck too far. This is also to say that I find the likelihood of some students showing their admiration and support towards the Kuomintang rather likely. Same with a visit or two by a celebrity or two, perhaps only those that are either capable of sustaining themselves independent of agencies, as well as the ability to perform at number of venues, or those that are "big in China" and can survive there without performing in the Home Islands. The point about support for the KMT comes back to the point that I was trying to make earlier, the protests are very much a rather mixed bag. Also, without full posts on them, I am not sure that I could have stretched them out into a full post. It was already fairly difficult to make it clear that this was happening across the country and not just at Tokyo Imperial University and Nihon University, somewhat naturally. A better writer would likely have found a way, but I'm afraid that if I had covered them then I would have likely lost any chance at maintaining something resembling a through line.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
1969 - With a Bang, Not a Whimper (Part 3)

Whereas 1968 had seen the political right in power and something resembling the political left in the opposition, the 'parliamentary coup' organised in March to push the Seiyūkai out of power saw the tables turned and the Japanese right, or at least its institutional form for over three decades at this point, pushed into the opposition for the first time ever since the 1937 constitutional reforms came to force. Many journalists hailed it at the time as an end to the one and a half party system, whilst the former party of government grumbled and rumbled rather loudly, predicting that their opponents would throw the state into chaos due to their lack of experience. Due to the events of the year, 1969 has since been often touted as one of the most important trials for Japanese democracy. Although there had been a changes in government and governing parties beforehand the handover in 1969 represented the first test of what the iron triangle, or pyramid depending on interpretations, that formed the basis for the long term rule of the Seiyūkai would do when put under threat. Many politologists and journalists feared and theorised, even though few would openly suggest this outright, that the nation might enter into a period of rapid collapse and pandemonium given that bureaucrats, zaibatsu and the military were thrust into the unknown and robbed of their stable partners. Others feared, while even fewer deemed it right to state it, that the elections might mark an end for Japanese democracy altogether ostensibly fearing that the Empire might once again return to a period of government by assassination like in the the '30s. There was a general sense that the other sides of the geometric shape were not willing to tolerate socialists, religious fundamentalists or most dangerously reformists, in government at least without someone to balance them out. The fact that they had not only lost to the Seiyūkai at the polls and then overthrown it through "underhandedness and treachery" was seen as a point of contention by many. This would indeed become a relatively important fact, especially in regards to Seimeitō, the former Miki faction, as the legend of betrayal painted the largest targets on their backs. This would eventually lead to an incident, where a nationalist punched Miki in the face during a public meeting in May and causing quite a kerfuffle, when it came to police security details offered to politicians. This event also served to feed the paranoia of the Konoe cabinet, as members that had entered office in hopes of reforming the Empire now and without a care in the world found themselves potentially facing down a life or death situation.

4pVX40m.jpg

The Miki Incident prompted the creation of a special group of law enforcement
tasked with protecting parliamentarians and government ministers.

Even though the student movement had spent much time in the public eye for the last few years, the public generally only associated the student movements with the Zenkyōtō, the poltiical left of the student movement. In contrast, right-wing students had largely escaped media coverage, only appearing rarely and more often than not just being folded into the general 'loyalist' crowds that university staff used for cracking heads in lieu of riot police and eventually with keeping guard over their less trustworthy compatriots on the left. The Japanese student right would however be no less active than the student left, forming political clubs and printing newsletters and mirroring their left-wing counterparts in many ways. The topics they discussed also overlapped frequently, although the right would often reach different conclusions and solutions to the problems being discussed. The reason for their lack of appearance is the fact that as mentioned previously, they largely fell into line with official institutions such as the government and universities. There were of course exceptions, perhaps most infamous being the Waseda based right-wing that was formed around the Ronsō Zasshi (Controversy Magazine), founded in January of 1967. Similar to most student produced literature, the paper was rather obscure and would likely have faded from public memory had it not come to the attention of one Hiraoka Kimitake, known across the Japanese Empire by his pen name Mishima Yukio. Over the decades, the observations of the changes to the 'Japanese Spirit' had left the writer somewhat depressed and pushed him increasingly to the fringe of right-wing politics, as he thought the Empire to be on the same straight path that had lead the Anglo powers to fall to Syndicalism. Attempts to recruit him into day to day politics by more right-wing Seiyūkai officials had failed, as he saw the party of government at fault for their role in putting Japan on this path. Instead Mishima would attempt to make his mark on the Japanese political world through other methods, such as the students at Ronsō. After having become the de facto patron of the journal, the writer began to guide the group towards increasingly radical purposes especially after confirming loyalty through a blood oath on the 26th of February 1968, which marked the 32nd anniversary of the February 26 Incident. Those that swore the oath, had reportedly promised to die, if necessary, to prevent the outbreak of a Syndicalist revolution in Japan and to protect the Emperor and the Imperial System with their lives. Like many others on the right, Mishima was shocked by the riots and occupation taken by radical university students at campuses across Japan and would begin laying the foundations for a private militia to fulfil that oath, if necessary. The Tatenokai (Shield Society) would be formed on the 5th of October and through employing students that had finished their military training, Mishima began to whip his counter-'revolutionary' core in to shape.

8q9GV2g.jpg

The focus in the Tatenokai was not just put on physical fitness and martial training,
but also the cultural much to the surprise of some former conscripts.

It is both impossible and unnecessary to explain how the leadership of the Tatenokai reacted to the 3-15 Incident and the formation of an ostensibly left-wing government exercising control over the Empire. While the government spent hours publicly arguing over which specific electoral reforms would be best to deny the return of the Rikken Seiyūkai to power in the elections to come, leading some to suggest the possibility of a government collapse, the Tatenokai kept on conduction their preparations. Barring a brief debate between the writer and members of the Zenkyōtō, all of its members seemed to disappear from the face of the earth. Summer would turn into autumn and with winter fast approaching, on the day after the first men to grace the lunar surface had returned to the Earth, the Tatenokai struck. On the 25th of November, Mishima and four of his most trusted loyalists - Morita Masakatsu, Ogawa Masahiro, Koga Masayoshi and Koga Hiroyasu used the pretext of visiting Mashita Kanetoshi, the commandant of the Imperial Japanese Army Officer Prepatory School located in Ichigaya, to gain access to an Army facility. After gaining entry, two of his loyalists barricaded the office and tied the commandant to his chair, whilst Mishima stepped out onto the balcony with his two remaining comrades. The two that came with him carried a banner that was thrown over the rail, which detailed their demands in order to ensure that the soldiers that had gathered below would be sure to hear and understand their call. It is likely that the message was meant to inspire the troops present there to start another period of gekokujō, so as to bring about a reversal of what Mishima had berated as the destruction of the samurai spirit by the material world. In reality, few soldiers were interested in the speech and the rant against consumerism appeared to many as little more than the rambling of a rather wealthy individual against the massive improvements in living standards that the Empire had seen, serving only to irritate the soldiers gathered below. This was especially true among large numbers of veterans from the China War that had good understanding of the difference between life on the continent and in the Home Islands. Thus instead of praise, the writer turned revolutionary was met with heckling and jeers as well as a passing helicopter drowing out parts of his speech. Morita and Ogawa would also scatter written copies of their masters speech, as the latter retreated back into the office after three cries of "Tennō Heika Banzai!" Once back in the office, Mishima proceeded to apologise to the commandant, claiming to have seen no other way to push Japan out of this path and then proceeded to commit seppuku. Even though originally all four of his attendants had planned to follow their, all but Morita had been convinced to abandon the idea in order to carry on their solemn duty.

QnF8Yg9.jpg

Photograph taken in the immediate aftermath of the Mishima Incident, the putch
members have already retreated inside and their banner is still flailing about.

The reaction to the incident was rather visceral, with a number of media houses now openly appearing to suggest that the responsibility for the putsch fell squarely on the shoulders of the current coalition government. A number of Rikken Seiyūkai members would also blame their rivals for dragging Japan back three decades. Knowing what we know now, it seems to be quite an overreaction as well as a bit silly, yet as hindsight is 20-20 the reaction at the time, given the knowledge they had, was not an unexpected one. The trial of the three surviving Tatenokai turned into a massive media circus, thanks to the fact that Mishima had generously provided for the legal defence of his disciples. The testimony of the confined commandant, who was subsquently forced into retirement, would also aid to limit their sentences. Mashita would claim that he harboured no ill will towards the five, given that their actions were taken with pure hearts and with their country in mind. Due in part to these two reasons, as well as significant pressure from the public after the justice minister was forced to resign for trying to influence the judge in question to come down on the side of the death penalty, all three survivors would only be imprisoned for four years for activities. The results of this case convinced even the most stubborn in the coalition that extensive reform was needed given the extent to which the Seiyūkai had established itself in the Japanese government. More interestingly, the putsch also put the Seiyūkai into a fairly difficult spot, as many senior party members had been close to Mishima and these relations as well as their knowledge of the Tatenokai and allegedly of its intentions were revealed at the trial. Although most of their supporters would dismiss it as a witch hunt, quite a few were surprised by the close relations that high ranking officials seemed to have with this supposedly anti-government militia, leading some theories to rise about the involvement of the party or at least parts of its leadership. The Mishima Incident has since caused a lot of other questions as well, the most often discussed topic being the reasoning for the date. The most prevalent theory thus far has been that the coup attempt was only a pretext for a ritual suicide that the writer had been preparing for since quite a while ago. This seems to be supported by the fact that the 25th of November marks the date that, he had begun writing Confessions of a Mask, which Mishima often called his resurrection from the 'Realm of Death'. Other theories suggest that Yoshida Shōin, whom Mishima admired, had been executed on the same day. Some have since called him the Yoshida Shōin of the Shōwa era. Some also suggest that the date was simply set based on a period of bardo, 49 days, so that Mishima would be reincarnated on his birthday, the 14th of January. Whatever the reason, the Mishima Incident would have a profound reason on Japanese politics for decades to come.

ZvWTmnv.jpg

Mishima in the front with his 4 disciples at the back. Morita, Koga H., Ogawa and Koga M. in the back row from left to right.
-----------------------------------------

It is done, I do hope you enjoyed at least parts of it. I also am aware that this clashes a lot with what I just said recently in regards to the student protests, but unlike the former this is a very centralised event with a very centralised leadership. On another note, I slightly miscalculated the amount of posts I had to make, however you shouldn't have to suffer due to my poor arithmetic. Therefore, I give you the map. Just as a note, this is the world in 2001 or H13.
D5gO3tt.png

I'll be back with something actually resembling a conclusion maybe, if you have anywhere else beyond Japan that you'd like to know about please do let me know through comments, as I mentioned before.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Action causes reaction, so it seems. The political right is pushed from power, and new left thinking pushes its way into society as a result of social and economic changes - so, political thought on the right is energized into trying to find answers. Although maybe the answers that this militia was trying to give, aren't so much new as rather old ideas, rehashed and made more shrill so that they sound like something new...

Thank you for this insight into Japan at the dawn of the new era in Japanese and world politics. It seems that Japan and its empire are pretty well set up to coast into the last quarter of the 20th century. Internal conflict seems pretty loud beef very civilized, what with a bit of arson and a fist to the face and two ritual suicides taking center stage. Mishima was a writer of Nō threatre, right? Maybe Japanese culture actually internalized this civilized style so much, they can do with hints and gestures where actors (political and performing arts likewise) in other stages cultures must communicate with stomping and screaming and on stage physical fighting. The Japanese, masters of the minimal.

Whose astronauts are on the moon during those last months of the narrative?? Japanese, German, American? I'd think they were Japanese, there were hints in the earlier chapter, but I'm too much of a western brute to be able to read subtle hints, let alone remember them ;)

The world map looks intriguing!

It's scary to think that the American red empire is still intact at the turn of the 21st century. Must be a surveillance state like OTL PRC, to withstand the centrifugal forces in this unholy dystopia.

The Arab world appears very united. I don't remember if this was already so in earlier maps? Makes me think that the time of German dominion over parts of Africa, really must be over, if the Arab nations in Germany's former sphere unite in such a way, and confront the global north with one voice.

Vietnam looks like it's now no longer the same color as the Japanese empire. Did they manage to break off, and restore their independence?

China, all republican turquoise... Ah well... The empire, long divided, must unite, and all that. Must be difficult for the Japanese to come to terms with this neighbor. What form of government are they running in China?

Lastly, the observation of Korea in the yellow of the Japanese empire, hmm, I must say I didn't expect that. Especially with China united and likely not friendly with China. Did the Japanese reform their empire into a not-empire, a union of equals? I'd think that with Japan as of 1970 set on a course towards social liberalization, there should be a moment when the Koreans just stand up and demand equal rights, or they'll just walk out of the door. Or did the social liberalization not last, and the hot heads of the Tatenokai actually succeed in turning opinion around, and bring back iron fisted repression against all divergences in the outer parts of the Japanese empire?
 
Last edited:
Conclusion - A Lesson, 2001

L5dIY9g.jpg

"... did you see Kōhaku, Sachiko?"
"Not really, my dad was channel surfing and for most of the night we were watching the TBS 21st Century Project thingy."
"Seriously, Sada Masashi was..."

"bing-bong, bang-bong"

The door swung open and in stepped Mr. Tanaka the History teacher, a jovial, slightly balding man in his late 40s. He arrived at the podium and gestured for the class representative to do her thing.
The call to "Attention", was followed by the mass of students rising from their seats with a degree of energy, the subsequent "Bow," brought along a less energetic look at the floor and the "Be seated," was followed by the 36 students of class 8-3 returning to the same place that they had started this small routine in.
"Right class, first of all I would like to wish you a happy new year. I hope all of you had a good break and had time to finish your homework. Pass it to the front. I will be taking attendance in the meanwhile."
The class was soon filled with the sound of papers being shuffled and passed to the front, as well as names being answered by calls of present. After Tanaka was sure that the students were all present and the papers had reached his podium he put the classbook away.
"Now, given that it is the start of a new term I thought we would take it somewhat easily and I would give you a brief recap of what we are going to talk about for the next three months. Although I would be overjoyed to take this slowly, I know that this term will be last time I meet a number of you in a classroom setting. Therefore let us tie things up so none of you would need to be embarrassed in your adult lives about not knowing your past. Now where did we leave off... Katō?
"Teacher, Katō is a sleep."
"Well wake him up then."
The sleeping Katō was silently nudged from all four directions by history textbooks and jumped awake.
"What..."
"Now that you've rejoined the class Katō would you mind telling us, what topic we finished on last term."
"Ah, yes.... The... The.."
"Mishima incident," a voice whispered from behind him.
"The Mishima incident"
"Right you are Katō, try to stay awake. Just because the intro won't be on the test doesn't mean that you ought to sleep through it."

"Now, where were we. Ah right, the Mishima Incident, which we discussed last year, represented something of a shock for both the general public and the political establishment of the Japanese Empire. The anti-Seiyūkai coalition that had been formed by Taishūtō, Komeitō, Nihon Shintō, Seimeitō, the remains of Rikken Minseitō and some independents put aside their internal squabbling for the time being and was overcome with a spirit of compromise. Under this newly found uniting light, the coalition pushed through, what is now known as the Three Irreversible Changes. These were - the rapid and permanent withdrawal of all Japanese troops from Northern China to their positions in Manchuria, the Legation Cities and the Home Islands as well as the demobilisation of newly called up units; the expansion of suffrage to women; and finally weakening control and oversight over religious and trade organisations. This reform package represented a lot of concessions from a lot of different members and was formulated so as to pass in a single vote so that coalition partners could not pick and choose. It was indeed a mixed bag of things similar to, but different from what each coalition partner had truly lobbied for in the sweeping reforms. Some, like the socialists and the political arm of the Buddhist sect got off better, as the loose wording in the reform allowed their support organisations to assert their independence from central oversight and the long arm of the Home Ministry. Others got of worse with the grand plans of the reformists in regards to campaign finance law and altering the sizes of districts being reduced to a mere expansion of suffrage to women. The anti-war/pro-Chinese faction within the coalition perhaps drew the shortest straw of all, as the Empire remained fully lodged in continental affairs and although its direct conflict with the Chinese would be over, it would still remain in a long standstill with the Russians. The reforms left no one political force in the coalition particularly pleased, not to even mention the reactions on the right, and thus the spirit of compromise that the Mishima Incident had caused began to rise between the different parties began to wane, leading to what... Kobayashi?"


vJznP1F.jpg

"The Grand Coalition and the Revolving Door Premierships?"

"Correct, you are Kobayashi. Right in March of 1971, just a month after the reforms had passed Prime Minister Konoe resigned and announced the withdrawal of his party from the anti-Seiyūkai coalition citing internal issues within the coalition, which were at the time largely thought to be the result of an unwillingness to proceed with restructuring the campaign finance laws. This prompted the once united coalition into a race to see who could remain in power as a partner of the Seiyūkai, as the country was left largely adrift and in the control of bureaucracy. In the fighting, the Taishūtō emerged victorious with Prime Minister Eda being crowned interim Prime Minister and leading the Grand Coalition government to snap elections. It is thought that their willingness for elections is what saw the socialists win out over Komeitō, as Minseitō with its three Diet members was found lacking and the rest of the former coalition partners were never really in the running. The snap elections of 1971 saw the election of the first female parliamentarians to the Japanese Diet and the restoration of a narrow Seiyūkai majority through a number of massive electoral defeats for the Seimeitō, whose remaining membership would subsequently merge into the Nihon Shintō. The aforementioned Shintō and the Taishūtō, whose more left-wing membership were now in full revolt after the death of Asanuma Inejiro, would also see minor defeats. Despite the victory, 1971-73 would see four different prime ministers, after Konoe, as factions within the Seiyūkai fought defensive and offensive battles in regards to the Three Irreversible Changes, but by summer of 1973 stability began to set in as it had become clear that these changes were here to stay. The collapse of the Qing government, following rapid efforts to withdraw Imperial troops, marked the end of the China War. The Republican leaders would not have long to rest on their laurels as Double Ten Day in 1973 marked an end for Chinese Democracy, at least for some time, as military officials seized control of the state. The Chinese military regime would subsequently get into conflict with most of its neighbours over various issues, including its previous allies the Mongolian State after they intervened to protect Han civilians being terrorised by the Mongolians. After tensions began to grow on the Sino-Manchurian border, as well as hints that the Chinese government was considering seizing Japanese property within their borders, Prime Minister Fukuda saw the need to avoid another costly war on the mainland as the most important issue of his premiership. Following negotiations lead by former prime minister Tanaka Kakuei, the Port Arthur Accords were signed in 1974. The Japanese government wished for amiable relations with Republican China in order to avoid their drift into the Russian sphere as well as assurances to its economic holdings. In exchange for confirming these requests, the Chinese wanted aid, the gradual return of Manchuria as well as acceptance into the Legations Council as equals, thereby beginning the restoration of control over the coastal cities of China... Someone wake up Nakamura."


yjYnFEG.jpg

"I'm awake teacher."
"Not you, your brother."
"Nakamura, why did the Chinese Republicans agree to the Port Arthur Accords?"
"... Because they were foolish?"

"No, the Chinese government agreed to the treaty not because they were foolish, but because they were a military dictatorship with less regard to the opinions of the general public and because they were engaged in conflict with most of their neighbours. The gradual cession of control over Manchuria and through it the introduction of the Chinese into the conflict concluding in the handover ceremony in 1980, helped to finally bring an end to the stalemate that the Japanese had reached with the Russians. Primarily through handing the conflict off to the Chinese to solve. The subsequent Russian withdrawal from Manchuria is largely seen as the reasoning behind the collapse of the gerontocratic and by now deeply unpopular Russian Junta, leading to the formation of a democratic government under the Czar. The Port Arthur Accords, although deemed necessary, would prove quite unpopular among politicians back home leading to the end to the short period of stability that had the Japanese political scene had enjoyed under Fukuda, who was toppled after the Seiyūkai only maintained its rule only after finally absorbing the remains of the Minseito. 1974-75 would see a different prime minister elected each year, until finally in 1976 a longer period of stability returned following the election of Prime Minister Nakasone. The Prime Minister charted a more liberal course for the economy, one that was well received as growth had failed to live up to the heights of the Shōwa Golden Era. Nakasone, a former high-ranking bureaucrat, had long since attacked the massive role that the Japanese state played in the economy and campaigned heavily on privatisation as well as deregulation. The beginning of the the Nakasone period is often also called the beginning of the end for the vice-like grip that the bureaucracy had held over the Japanese economy, central control which has often been called the bedrock of the Shōwa Democracy or Japanese one-nation conservatism, as our friends down under have called it. These efforts also saw the recognition of Korea and some of the South-Sea Regions as naichi and opened to industrial investment, actions which lead to a great deal of economic growth for the Empire through the influx of workers with lower wages into the labour market. During this time political decisions in Europe also saw the region loosen its export restrictions, allowing for Japanese exports to reach an unprecedented period of dominance on the global market. The investments into the colonies also worked well to bind the previously restive natives ever closer to the Imperial whole. The Nakasone reforms were of course not all positive, as they also put a large amount of strain on the economic well being of less educated residents of the Home Islands with a considerable amounts of them finding themselves laid off and thrown into the increasingly competitive labour market at a late period in their lives. This would however do little to stop the reforms, as snap elections held in 1977 to push through widely debated reforms seeking to further weaken the control of the bureaucracy over the country through strengthening and democratising local government, confirmed that the people of the Empire stood behind Nakasone and not his backbench. The 1977 elections would also mark the last election that the Nihon Shintō would compete in, as the Seiyūkai under Nakasone had campaigned for much the same policies and the party found itself outflanked and outgunned. The party would later return as the Nihon Jiyūtō. Murayama, what do you think happened next?"


KXT3Nty.jpg

"The Aleutian Crisis?"
"Yes, but what I meant was closer to the period we discussed, not that much after. Shimada, can you help Murayama out?"
"The Second Black Veil Scandal?"

"Correct, you are Shimada. The economic growth caused by the deregulatory policies and other attacks on bureaucratic control meant that by the 1980s different consultant organisations had begun to play an ever larger role in politics as the bureaucratic side of the iron triangle weakened due to political pressure. These organisations were usually staffed by former big wigs from the business world, retired politicians and even people whose previous employer had been the bureaucracy. The rise of these consultancy firms only served to thin the once again increasingly close relationship between government and big business. The years following the resignation of Prime Minister Nakasone in 1981, would be mired in an ever increasing number of corruption cases. These cases took a toll on public trust, as they would often incriminate rather high-ranking politicians and the sums of yen in question would put the First Black Veil Scandal era to shame. These issues within the party also brought about another period of revolving door premierships as the party began to desperately find clean politicians with weak internal support to shuffle into power. Attempts by these politicians to reverse course or probe deeper would be met with them ending up deposed. This period of internal strife would eventually culminate in the Seiyūkai once again losing unilateral control of the Diet in the 1989 snap elections, held following the death of the Shōwa Emperor and to mark the beginning of the beginning of the Hofū era. The splintering of the Taishūtō in the 70s following the death of Asanuma, into left and right wing factions, meant that the opposition was far too deeply split for an anti-Seiyūkai coalition to be formed. This meant that Seiyūkai rule continued with support from the right-wing socialists in exchange for halting and reversing some of the less than popular decisions that the party had taken during the Nakasone era. These elections marked the end of the Shōwa era and thus the end of our curriculum. The Aleutian crisis that Murayama mentioned is currently considered too recent an event to be covered in history class, even though it is often cited as an important representation of the rebirth of Red America. The same is true of our cold relations with the Chinese after the collapse of their military government, although the downturn in relations had already begun after their unilateral invasion of Brunei."


2jfrqMc.jpg

"bing-bong, bang-bong"
"Well seems like that is all the time we have for today. See you all on Thursday, I hope you'll have a wonderful year. Class rep."
"Attention, bow, dismissed."

-----------------------------------------


Action causes reaction, so it seems. The political right is pushed from power, and new left thinking pushes its way into society as a result of social and economic changes - so, political thought on the right is energized into trying to find answers. Although maybe the answers that this militia was trying to give, aren't so much new as rather old ideas, rehashed and made more shrill so that they sound like something new...

Thank you for this insight into Japan at the dawn of the new era in Japanese and world politics. It seems that Japan and its empire are pretty well set up to coast into the last quarter of the 20th century. Internal conflict seems pretty loud beef very civilized, what with a bit of arson and a fist to the face and two ritual suicides taking center stage. Mishima was a writer of Nō threatre, right? Maybe Japanese culture actually internalized this civilized style so much, they can do with hints and gestures where actors (political and performing arts likewise) in other stages cultures must communicate with stomping and screaming and on stage physical fighting. The Japanese, masters of the minimal.

Whose astronauts are on the moon during those last months of the narrative?? Japanese, German, American? I'd think they were Japanese, there were hints in the earlier chapter, but I'm too much of a western brute to be able to read subtle hints, let alone remember them ;)

The world map looks intriguing!

It's scary to think that the American red empire is still intact at the turn of the 21st century. Must be a surveillance state like OTL PRC, to withstand the centrifugal forces in this unholy dystopia.

The Arab world appears very united. I don't remember if this was already so in earlier maps? Makes me think that the time of German dominion over parts of Africa, really must be over, if the Arab nations in Germany's former sphere unite in such a way, and confront the global north with one voice.

Vietnam looks like it's now no longer the same color as the Japanese empire. Did they manage to break off, and restore their independence?

China, all republican turquoise... Ah well... The empire, long divided, must unite, and all that. Must be difficult for the Japanese to come to terms with this neighbor. What form of government are they running in China?

Lastly, the observation of Korea in the yellow of the Japanese empire, hmm, I must say I didn't expect that. Especially with China united and likely not friendly with China. Did the Japanese reform their empire into a not-empire, a union of equals? I'd think that with Japan as of 1970 set on a course towards social liberalization, there should be a moment when the Koreans just stand up and demand equal rights, or they'll just walk out of the door. Or did the social liberalization not last, and the hot heads of the Tatenokai actually succeed in turning opinion around, and bring back iron fisted repression against all divergences in the outer parts of the Japanese empire?

He did indeed write Nō and Kabuki plays or well it is among those are among the things that he wrote. Perhaps you are right and the theatrics did indeed have some influence on him and his actions. You are quite welcome, I started this project off because I wanted to write something and the real reason that I started posting it was so as to not be able to back down and trash it. Glad to see that someone enjoyed it as well.

Well, considering that one of these nations was in total pandemonium at the time, another had only just conducted their first spacewalk and the final one was at one time described as "racing itself into space", which of these do you think is most likely to be the one? :p I kid of course, it is indeed Germany. I did at one point have a plan to write a chapter about the moon landings, it was one of those things that I was really sure that I wanted to cover. However when I eventually got to it, I was already sure that this was ending and I was somewhat unsure how to write it, so I ended up trashing the chapter without having written much.

The AUSS is a rather friendly state, provided of course that you are not a dissident within it or don't get in the way of some important people some way, I'll gladly tell you that much. At the very least that is how the general public sees it, given that many still remember the Cultural Revolution, which lasted way past the forever nap of Chairman Browder and well into the 1980s. It is currently becoming more of a strong police state, largely due to the fact that it has recently emerge from the Third Great South American War, where it tried to bring the rest of the Americas under its sway. The war only stopped due to massive casualties costing tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of American lives... I kid of course, it did cost those lives, but the real reason it stopped was due to extensive threats from Europe and Asia, particularly Japan due to the fairly large role that Argentina and its food exports play. In the end, the war saw the La Platan bloc collapse, Brazil reassert its independence under a rather Anglophile ie pro-American popular front government and saw the Caribbean become an internal sea of the Pan-American Council through the establishment of the Bolivarian Republic of New Granada as well as the integration of the UPCA into Centroamerica. The large amounts of casualties can largely be put down both due to extensive damage caused by the Cultural Revolution, but America has begun its period of reinvention much to the concern of every other power. Washington is sending the message of over there, over there that the Yanks are coming over there.

I think I hinted to the Arab situation before. The Arab states themselves were never 100% in the German sphere, more orbiting it due to necessity while trying to undermine the Ottomans - the real German ally in the region. The Caliphate, or as it is officially known the Arab Federation, is the by product of botched coup, which left Arabia leaderless after the military knocked off a very large portion of the Hashemites, necessitating an intervention by the Egyptians given their long term cold war with the Iranians. The temporary solution fairly quickly turned into permanent one with the King of Egypt being proclaimed the Caliph and leading to the establishment of a united Arab state. Note this is not to say that it is a stable creation, but it has been stable enough and its fairly massive control over oil exports means that nobody has really tried to meddle there aggressively enough thus far. This fact was also the reason that helped them blackmail the Germans into retreating from the Suez, a fact which massively boosted the popularity of the state. No humiliations at the hand of an "Outremer" state on a number of separate occasions and the presence of the Turkish and Iranian threats also helped quite a bit. Although no side has gained the upper hand over the other in the Arab-Iranian debacle, the Arabs did give the Turks a bloody nose during the Turkish-Greek war in the 1980s ending in the Greeks taking the Turkish held Aegean islands.

However yes, as the increased number of states in Africa suggests, German direct dominion over Africa is more or less over. The brunt of that effort has fallen on the South African bloc, ie South Africa, Namibia, North Rhodesia and Mozambique, which... Need I say more? Most of the settlers that did not want to return home or stay in the collapsed remains of the Syndicalist-aligned African states moved there. Some also moved to the German Indian Ocean territories, which also includes Zanzibar and is there because it has proven to be the cheapest way to maintain a pretence of power projection in the region and because nobody.

Vietnam has always been independent or well, as far as this AAR is concerned. It just used to be called Indochina, you can freely add the words Red or Independent to it if you so wish. The Syndicalist Indochinese state however became a bit of an eyesore for the regional powers, ie India, Japan and China, and following a series of mind games and support for nationalist groups it was dismantled. The Indians kicked the whole thing off by supporting the independence of the Laotians, which destabilised the Indochinese Federation. The Japanese were next with the Chinese acting soon after. Japanese action was prompted by increasing instability in the region after the death of Uncle Ho, which spread to their allied state of Thailand particularly the parts of Thailand inhabited by the Khmer. The Japanese solution to this issue was to sponsor the creation of an independent Khmer state, standing of course under Thai supervision, which only lead to more instability in Indochina, particularly the regions inhabited by the Khmer that wanted to join this state. These Khmer would break off soon afterwards, as the Chinese Junta invaded to protect the rights of ethnic Chinese in Vietnam and to "protect" the rump state from the Indians. The invasion unsurprisingly resulted in the installation of a less radical government in Vietnam. One that is deeply unpopular, but has managed to stay in power as the Chinese democrats have thus far seen the region as too important.

China has once again come to resemble something along the lines of a democracy, at least as far as this world is concerned. I mentioned that thee Republican Army took a more direct approach to governance for much of the 1970s-80s. The toppling of the Qing was quite popular, don't get me wrong, but the coup was triggered by displeasure in the Army about some of the rather unpopular decisions that the Kuomintang had taken in this conflict. Decisions such as giving up large chunks of "rightful Chinese territory" to the Mongolians, which had seriously shaken public trust in the government. Also, not responding to the "humiliation" that the Indians, who also occupied "rightful Chinese territory", had caused to the Chinese public by spitting in the face of "Chinese friendship" and not sharing their plans on how to produce nuclear weapons. In the end the junta was brought down by cronyism, which lead to economic mismanagement, as well as a rather unpopular foreign adventures, khm Brunei. Also, the continued cooperation with the Japanese that sort of screwed China royally in the past century, still hold a fairly important position in the economy and are really the only force still standing in the true reunification of China - the Legations and the Liaodong concession.

Onto Korea then. The previously warm relations between the Japanese and the Junta in China sort of meant that Korea was a bit of a none issue between the two nations, at least geopolitically speaking. On the domestic front, as RV-Ye put it rather effectively, the Korean independence group were more or less "beheaded" for a considerable period and the idea was reduced to a niche one for a bit. By the point that Korean nationalism recovers from this debacle, we've already reached the Nakasone era and the rapid rise in Korean living standards after being recognised as a naichi. An overwhelmingly Japanese mass media and education system that is geared towards turning the kids Japanese, as well as other methods in the approximately 2 decades of passive and 4 of active Japanification have allegedly turned the province Japanese enough to trust it, or at least that is what the government claimed. Industrial concerns flood in to take advantage of the cheaper labour, as well as shorter supply chains due to the closer proximity of resources kickstarting an aggressive rise in living conditions for the up until this point fairly agrarian Korean peninsula. This is not to say that all is fine and dandy and that some Imperial institutions or citizens still don't discriminate against Koreans or that a certain percentage of the public aren't still mad at losing at their jobs to the peninsula nor that a certain percentage of Koreans aren't trying to lobby for independence, just that for the moment the issue of Korean independence is a non-issue. Given that most of the around 50 million or so Koreans are currently enjoying living standards that their ancestors could never have even imagined in their wildest dreams, at least the ones that weren't nobility or whose families didn't return from whatever labour migration pitch Imperial officials sold about Australia or whatever other god forsaken place needed extra hands. Once the effect of that economic boom wears off... Well that's another story for another time is it not. The Empire may have socially liberalised to a degree, but it is still an empire. Once the people get too rowdy and start disturbing "public order", the velvet glove of economic incentive can come off to reveal an iron fist. A state will inevitably defend itself from those that seek to undermine it, don't our liberal democracies do the same? So to answer your question, the Koreans got something resembling equal rights and are now treated as equals on the peninsula and the Home Islands. That is if they don't start actively pushing for those "wild theories" on how the Korean people deserve independence and how Korean is not just a historical curiosity, but the language that should be used officially across the peninsula.


edit; 404 seems like a good point to end it... :p Anyway, this AAR is done then, if anyone has any more questions they're free to ask them. Just that the periods that I answer them in might get a bit more... Erratic as I'm once again trying to wean myself off the forums.
 
Last edited:
  • 2Love
Reactions:
D5gO3tt.png

I'll be back with something actually resembling a conclusion maybe, if you have anywhere else beyond Japan that you'd like to know about please do let me know through comments, as I mentioned before.

NGL, digesting this is going to take me a while. Medium sized Russia hurts my One and Indivisible configured brain though!
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
Woah, gotta say this has been such a fascinating and interesting run. (Sheesh, university really kept me away from plenty of updates, spent the last days doing my last projects and rushed to read the updates I missed here and on One and Indivisible :p )

1) Student Movement: I must admit that was so interesting to read, from my part I have never been too interested on student movements and protests (despite being quite important in hindsight!) and I must say it was so amazing to learn the situation for the average Japanese student in this timeline and the way it all went. I got angered when the government meddled into the already agreed negotiations, so annoying! But it was impressive and it was surprising the way it also developed a counter by itself depicted with Yukio Mishima. I must admit I was rooting for Yukio here haha, I kinda wanted to see this Japan fall back into militarism, just to see what could happen. But the way it all went was surprising and fascinating to read!

2) Argentina and 1968 Olympics: I'm not sure if it inspired you or if it was just something that happened to be similar (which I don't believe :p) but I found plenty of similarities betwwen La Plata and OTL Mexico, especially due to the year of the Olympic Games and the heavy response by the government against the students. With all this focus on student movements you reminded me about 2020, before the pandemic arrived to my country there was a strong movement where I live, we took the "University City" and lmao, I got so sick after spending one night keeping guard at an entrance without any blanket nor warm clothing. So, by the next morning I sadly had to leave since I got really sick, and with news of COVID spreading... yeah, didn't want to risk anything.

3) Other thoughts: -wild screeches- Sad to see Korea being kept as a colony BUT, at least the life has improved despite still being under the Japanese thumb. Though all in all, with Japan liberalizing I believe it will eventually be easier for the Koreans to live in the Empire. I must say I'm sad to see Red America hasn't collapsed, I had hope that they would have a new civil war and maybe Mexico would recover the independence. Which btw, leads me to wonder, how is Mexico treated by 2001? How is the situation at the "country"? I was also wondering, I'm not too versed on the musical developments in Japan and the Korean Peninsula (well, the southern part) but it seems that through the decades both countries borrowed words/genres/techniques from American music genres and that way it developed into their own distinct things while still being heavily influenced by the West (for example, City Pop in Japan by the 70s-80s if I'm not mistaken); but, with Japan having never being occupied in this TL... how do you imagine their music would be? (I bet this is a tough challenge, though just guessing would be great haha) I assume Korea will follow the Japanese way whatever it is. (Though now that I think of it... Australia having formed part of the Empire and with it possibly creating a loose connection to the Anglo-Sphere and culture... who knows...) :p

Anyways, I love this AAR and it has been one of the most interesting ones I've gotten to read. :) It always felt so well researched regarding the subjects of the updates, it has been so enjoyable and I hope to get to read a new project of yours eventually. ^^
NGL, digesting this is going to take me a while. Medium sized Russia hurts my One and Indivisible configured brain though!
Haha, at least Russia exists in the AAR! ;)
 
Woah, gotta say this has been such a fascinating and interesting run. (Sheesh, university really kept me away from plenty of updates, spent the last days doing my last projects and rushed to read the updates I missed here and on One and Indivisible :p )

1) Student Movement: I must admit that was so interesting to read, from my part I have never been too interested on student movements and protests (despite being quite important in hindsight!) and I must say it was so amazing to learn the situation for the average Japanese student in this timeline and the way it all went. I got angered when the government meddled into the already agreed negotiations, so annoying! But it was impressive and it was surprising the way it also developed a counter by itself depicted with Yukio Mishima. I must admit I was rooting for Yukio here haha, I kinda wanted to see this Japan fall back into militarism, just to see what could happen. But the way it all went was surprising and fascinating to read!

2) Argentina and 1968 Olympics: I'm not sure if it inspired you or if it was just something that happened to be similar (which I don't believe :p) but I found plenty of similarities betwwen La Plata and OTL Mexico, especially due to the year of the Olympic Games and the heavy response by the government against the students. With all this focus on student movements you reminded me about 2020, before the pandemic arrived to my country there was a strong movement where I live, we took the "University City" and lmao, I got so sick after spending one night keeping guard at an entrance without any blanket nor warm clothing. So, by the next morning I sadly had to leave since I got really sick, and with news of COVID spreading... yeah, didn't want to risk anything.

3) Other thoughts: -wild screeches- Sad to see Korea being kept as a colony BUT, at least the life has improved despite still being under the Japanese thumb. Though all in all, with Japan liberalizing I believe it will eventually be easier for the Koreans to live in the Empire. I must say I'm sad to see Red America hasn't collapsed, I had hope that they would have a new civil war and maybe Mexico would recover the independence. Which btw, leads me to wonder, how is Mexico treated by 2001? How is the situation at the "country"? I was also wondering, I'm not too versed on the musical developments in Japan and the Korean Peninsula (well, the southern part) but it seems that through the decades both countries borrowed words/genres/techniques from American music genres and that way it developed into their own distinct things while still being heavily influenced by the West (for example, City Pop in Japan by the 70s-80s if I'm not mistaken); but, with Japan having never being occupied in this TL... how do you imagine their music would be? (I bet this is a tough challenge, though just guessing would be great haha) I assume Korea will follow the Japanese way whatever it is. (Though now that I think of it... Australia having formed part of the Empire and with it possibly creating a loose connection to the Anglo-Sphere and culture... who knows...) :p

Anyways, I love this AAR and it has been one of the most interesting ones I've gotten to read. :) It always felt so well researched regarding the subjects of the updates, it has been so enjoyable and I hope to get to read a new project of yours eventually. ^^​


Hope you did well on those assignments, university does take precedence after all.

I do have to admit, a slide into blatant militarism was appealing to me as well for some time, as it would allow to hand wave away a number of... things. However, I eventually found the fabled quote from the Eighteenth Brumaire as a better solution to this whole thing. Because boy, if 2-26 and the preceding list of abortive coups was a tragedy, then 11-25 and the student rebellion that preceded it takes on a rather rather farcical nature. This was probably helped by a text I read, probably from the recently released notes from audiences with the Showa Emperor after the war, but I can't exactly recall... Either way, there the comparison was made, and it wasn't inherently a negative one, that the student rebels of the 1950-60s in many ways represented the new generation of the junior officers of the 1920-30s. Young, hot-blooded and their heads filled with all sorts of ideological solutions to the problems that the nation faces. Yet different, as the country has moved on to a different age and whilst a uniform is still likely to see the opposite sex fawn over you in the end what matters is the dosh you bring home.

Oh yeah, I made no attempt at hiding it. After all I mentioned the institutionalisation of a formerly "radical" party. :p The events in Mexico City in 1968 provided a great creative spark for me, especially given how people outside of Mexico largely seem to "forget" about it in lieu of the other things that happened at those games. It proved an interesting way to contrast the "fawning" over the Olympics that I had done previously, even the Japanese one only saw really hidden suggestions that everything might not be all glitz and glamour. The Rosariazo and the other 1969 Argentinian "scuffles" were also good sources of info to try and flesh it out a bit more and to make it feel a bit more correct. The oddity that is KR South America aside of course.

Eventually? Yeah, probably. I would say that life has improved drastically compared to the agrarian period as I stated before though that doesn't mean that life is good-good as industrialisation comes with its own share of problems. Red America has even grown... I went through some of the earlier comments and I discovered that I had made a commitment to not allow America to just break apart, like it did at the end of Crown Atomic. This wasn't the reason that it stayed together, but I keep my word. :p A Civil war was of course an option, but then again the chaos of the American Cultural Revolution can be called a civil war of sorts. As to Mexico.... Things are better by which I mean that by 2001 the region has surpassed the living standards during the independence period. The war and the cultural revolution did a number on the country. English is the official language of "interethnic communication", but Spanish, or well Mexican Spanish, enjoys co-equal status there are a lot of them after all and they need to be kept peaceful somehow. There's also the fact that Chairman Henry Winston confirmed a rather wide range of minority rights after Gus Hall, the man that took over from Browder and continued his movement, mysteriously died, of diabetes, putting an end to the Cultural Revolution. Chairman Winston would not be long for this world, but his alliance with the military managed to secure that a more "moderate" candidate succeeded that carried on the legacy and went about rebuilding the AUSS into a world power. This would eventually culminate in that recently ended Third Great South American War, but that is that. Like I mentioned though, the security state is pushing its tendrils out further and this will inevitably culminate in minority rights being eroded to a degree.

Oh most definitely, but the borrowing was heavy even before the war and even without the occupation. There's this often cited point that Jazz proved too popular for the Japanese Empire to really suppress during the war, despite it being "enemy music". It took on a more... Patriotic tone and continued to be played just under a different name. Music is a rather fluid thing after all and fairly open to borrowing. In this sense I do still imagine that there would be Western influences from Australia as you mentioned, but also from say Europe and even America to a degree. I would imagine that Enka and Trot would be a bit more alive, I did however hint that the "enemy music" still broke through and that rock and roll appeals to boomers across timelines. The Americans may have had a slight stumble down the stairs, but their short period of music exports lit a flame.

Thanks, I'll take this time to say that I rather enjoy your project as well. Looking forward to seeing what turns it takes.

NGL, digesting this is going to take me a while. Medium sized Russia hurts my One and Indivisible configured brain though!

Take your time Aussie. The 8 intervening decades without Ukraine have either given rise to a Russia that isn't bound to the Triune All-Russia concept. It's almost definitely still there, but lucrative trade between the nuclear armed Russian Empire and the nuclear armed European bloc has probably allowed the not nuclear armed Ukraine question to largely be put to bed.

Haha, at least Russia exists in the AAR!

This is true, at least it is a medium one and not a balkanized or even a non-existent one. Then again on some occasions it is perhaps better to not exist than to face the horrible reality.
 
  • 1Love
Reactions:
The History of American Film in the 20th Century

The dominance of the Mitteleuropan Babelsberg system across the wider civilised world has sometimes lead to the mistaken impression among the European public that this process was inevitable, given the extent of European control over global affairs during the 20th century, or indeed that there have been and are no rivals to what the domestic market offers. This could not be further from the case and indeed the characters and pieces that we find rather familiar are often seen as quite strange and even somewhat alien in the confines of Syndicalist America or 'free' Asia, just like their movies seem odd and bizarre to us. This had not always been the case however and had history played out somewhat differently, it is the opinion of this author, that the great continental cinema system that has entertained countless Europeans for the better part of 7 decades, named after the eponymous German studio and its national affiliates across the European continent, could have seen itself supplemented. Whilst it is unlikely that the levels of mass appeal achieved by the Babelsberg system could have been achieved by the Russians or the Japanese, given the capital shortages and the ideological through lines in the works of those two countries, there is an often recounted saying among students of film history. The saying goes that if ever more than two representatives of that hallowed profession are put into a room, then a considerable argument will develop about the potential future that might have followed had the rise of the once vibrant Hollywood film scene of the former United States of America not been cut off by the outbreak of the Second American Civil War.

A7qPX5m.jpg

Photo from overlooking the Hollywood sign, originally just meant as an advertisement for a real-estate
development, the sign would be burned into the public consciousness by the short but grand Hollywood period.

Considering the current state of Hollywood, now the district of Sinclair in the city of Foster, it is easy to understand how what something that seems like the antithesis, given its closed nature owing to the large naval presence, to the pluralistic and vibrant towns that make up the centres of the Babelsberg system could have once rivalled the continental film industry. However what is important to consider is that Hollywood itself is irrelevant and little but a mere symbol in the grand scheme of things, given the migratory nature of American film industry up to that point. What is important is to understand the depth of talent that said symbol represented that first the Federalists could call upon to surge past the continental system even during its long decline into the civil war during the interbellum period. Whilst much of said talent was lost to the Syndicalists, a lot of it remained or was later reacquired and Pennywood, the ironic nickname for the centre of the 'red' American film industry, seems to largely adhere to what we understand that a film industry ought to have. Indeed in the Old World, there seems to be an almost unquenchable thirst for stories from the frontiers held by our transatlantic brethren. This fascination that Europe has seemed to have resulted in American films being greeted by throngs of visitors, whenever they have eventually returned to screens of European theatres during various warm periods of international relations. This has been despite numerous campaigns by more conservative forces, often backed by domestic film industry, to ban these films as Syndicalist filth meant to rile up the masses of crypto-Syndicalists and fellow travellers supposedly hidden within our ranks. Although, much of the success of the films can largely be put down to large viewership numbers among the working classes, it must be said that the numbers are not unlike those of their Babelsberg counterparts. Additionally similarly 'red' productions from the Union of Britain, prior their "quiet revolution", such as the 1958 war film 'Run Silent, Run Deep' or the numerous lesser known films featuring British secret agent James Bond, often called an inferior rip-off of the Polish film series about Hauptmann Kloss, have managed nowhere near as much success as their counterparts and erstwhile rivals in the New World, even though the ideological colouring remained the same.

N4nBrk4.jpg

Still from the third Hauptmann Kloss movie -
"On his Imperial Majesty's Secret Service"

The early history of film in America is rather closely tied together with the early history of commercial film itself and begins, unsurprisingly, on the East Coast of the former United States. Among his numerous other inventions, the American businessman Thomas Edison is also often credited with the creation of the first commercial film studio, the Black Maria, in his home state of New Jersey at the turn of the 19th century. Despite this seemingly early lead, the Americans proved unable to leverage this achievement into a real competitive position on the market. Indeed, beyond his role in creating or at least patenting the methods of film making, Edison seems to have played a primarily antagonistic role in the history of American film until his death in 1931. Pursuing litigious action from his own offices in New York in a nigh religious manner, the inventor would try to push himself as a beneficiary for all movies made and direct his lawyers to actively seize film making equipment that had been deemed to be produced illegally - ie not having paid Edison. The desire to get as far away from Edison as possible would take some time to truly find begin to bear fruit and the centre of American film industry would largely remain on the East Coast until the 1920s. This period has later been nicknamed the Fort Lee period among scholars of American film after the name of the town that held the development of the majority of American films. However even during its heyday in the 1910s Fort Lee was not unchallenged, primarily due to the Edison issue, and during the latter half of the First Weltkrieg Fort Lee would begin to lose ground to its rival on the West Coast that would go onto to name the next period of American film history - Hollywood. The West Coast based location allowed as much distance as possible from Edison and his army of lawyers the result of which was that most companies would largely evade his litigative attempts. The austere war years in Europe also meant that America had lost its greatest rival and saw its productions sweep across the globe. Given that this was the era of silent film, localisation proved easy and the visions of a better life and adventure out West offered by American films proved quite comforting to the shelled continent and beyond. The subsequent Syndicalists revolutions that swept across much of Western Europe, although disastrous for the American economy, saw the New World consolidate its grip on the film markets it now held given the fall from grace of the once dominant European film companies.

ymE8aNz.jpg

Movies from vaudeville comedians such as the Marx Brothers and Charlie Chaplin were among
some of the most highly sought after American movies during its Weltkrieg era boom.

The slow burning economic collapse of the United States that followed the defeat of and revolution in the Entente powers also saw American film industry consolidate quite viscously. Although smaller studios would end up closing shop or being merged into bigger conglomerates, as was the case with Vitagraph Studios, a prolific short silent film maker, the increasing size of the production companies allowed for increased economies of scale leading to the industry seeming strangely untouched by the ongoing decline of America around it. The Gilded Age of Hollywood would thus go on even as the state itself stumbled from crisis to crisis. The relatively cheap cost of movies, topping off at around 10 cents even after the decline of the nickelodeons, following the rise of the feature film after the now partially lost 1915 silent film the Birth of a Nation, provided plentiful entertainment for the increasingly strained budgets of the American populace. The rising revenues allowed for more consolidation in the industry as well as vertical integration leading to the development of the studio system, which would lead to approximately 5 studios controlling the entire market, would become the by word for the Hollywood era. The studio system would prove an important innovation and the basis for the film industry long outlasting the studios and the state that had pioneered it. Such was also the case with other American innovations, which would provide inspiration for the resurgent European film industry now lead not by the French, despite heavy investments by the Syndicalist government, but by the Mitteleuropan Babelsberg and its captive market. The fleeing American talent would often end up in Babelsberg and end up providing great use to the golden age of the Babelsberg system after the during and after Syndicalist War. Even though in some cases the innovations pushed by the American industry would end up harming it in the short term, such as through the adoption of the 'talkies', through which a number of American films were deprived from a great number of foreign markets as they proved unable to understand the plots, even in the case of other English speaking states, in general the innovations being pushed, particularly colour film, as well as the stunning camera work and gripping plots saw American films, and thus American soft-power rise, even as the rising German juggernaut was pushing it further inwards.

786jHcw.jpg

Collection of the five big studios that dominated the Golden Hollywood era of American film industry of these MGM,
20th Century Fox and Paramount Pictures would try to make a resurgence in Europe with little to no success.

The outbreak of the Second American Civil War on the 19th of February in 1937 would mark an end to Hollywood era and thus American film on a global scale, for a considerable amount of time with the last Hollywood movie, "The Last of Mrs. Cheyney", being released on the day that war broke out and even that only to limited screenings in the Pacific States of America and New England then still under Canadian occupation. Although the American Second Civil War would eventually conclude in late 1939, the continental United States would find itself divided by the Mexican invasion of the Pacific States and their annexation into the United States of Mexico in the second half of 1940 would mark a long term division of the continent and deprive the young Syndicalist America from the majority of its film industry. Thus even though the Combined Syndicates of America had nationalised the property of the former 5 studios and brought them under control of the American State Syndicate for Cinematography, referred to from now on Synfilm, the nationalisation had resulted in the Americans gaining relatively little. Instead the majority of their holdings were now under the control of the Mexicans. The iron fisted rule of Pancho Villa and his ruthless solution to the Anglo problem would see Hollywood bled dry of what had remained there during the invasion with the majority of its equipment, capital and even talent syphoned off south to support the flourishing Mexican film industry that would maintain a dominant position over Latin America until the outbreak of the Second Mexican-American War. The fresh start accorded to the Syndicalists saw American film move back to the East Coast, more specifically to Allentown in Pennsylvania. The apparent 'cheapness' of the films, caused by a noticeable drop in quality due to the loss of Hollywood, as well as the price of admission being pegged to 1 cent or a penny earned it the derisive name Pennywood. The industry would later discretely adopt it although in official American histories of the its film industry the Penny part is stated to be a shorthand for Pennsylvania. The new American cinema would initially be put to ideological work, as the Browder-Foster diarchy at the head of the Combined Syndicates relying on Syndicalists orthodoxy saw film as a potent propaganda tool and thus an important part of consolidating the rule of the new state over the hearts and minds of the American populace.

oYfLw2b.png

The Pennywood logo would allegedly adorn every American
production after the middle part of the 1950s
.

In its role as a propaganda tool Synfilm would remain under the almost direct supervision of Chairman Browder, who saw it as his mission to keep the internationalists under Foster from infecting the American public with the failed values of the European syndicalist powers. In his role as guardian of the American film industry, Browder would initially allow directors a great deal of freedom to explore film as a medium without any real constraints to budgets, provided that it maintained a correct ideological approach and adhered to Browder's vision of Syndicalism as 20th century Americanism. Although newsreels would initially dominate the immediate postwar period of the 1940s, they would slowly but surely be replaced by increasing amounts of feature films as the directors sought to surpass the glitz and glamour of the decadent capitalist Hollywood. During this initial period the American cinema would be dominated by war epics such as "Marching On!" by James J. Edwards releasing to great domestic accolades in 1943. The film was seen by many as the physical incarnation of the unspoken compact between the Syndicalist government and the Black community to not allow the failure of the Reconstruction period to be repeated as the film explores the post-war life of a black soldier that had fled from a plantation farm to join the Union Army and liberate his brethren only to see Reconstruction fail and fall into destitution as a share cropper following the institution of Jim Crow laws. "Home of the Brave" by Herbert Bibermann would also make its debut during this initial experimental period and cement the writer as one of the premier American directors. Ironically enough the movie would be one of the few internationalist films that Foster managed to push Browder to produce primarily due to its anti-British tone that appealed to the Chairman, despite it also hyping up the public for the eventual American intervention in the Entente-Internationale War. Centring on the War of 1812, the movie released in 1946 inspired a whole subgenre of anti-British/royalists films in the American industry that had thus far primarily focused on attacking the former American elites. The film had a different reception in Canada however and is argued by some to have contributed to the start of the failed peace talks with the European Syndicalists after the withdrawal of the Indians from the Entente and thus the war.

GeHrPEV.jpg

During the Golden Age of Pennywood period many outside observers would try to glean American foreign policy
and ongoing trends in the state by looking at what the message American movies were trying to get across.

Although the American intervention and the destruction of the Entente would not be received well abroad, the threat of the Americas was somewhat overshadowed by the racial panic caused by the Japanese invasion of Australasia and more importantly its nuclear attack on Sydney. In light of this as well as the SPD coalition government leading Germany, as well as its ascension into the Internationale the American film industry would begin to make its first slow forays abroad. Despite proving unsuccessful at any push into Latin America, it would see some success in Europe as well as the United Kingdom. Its primary success coming through Westerns, which had become the main fascination of the industry after the fall of the Canadians. The 'red' Westerns as they became known provided as many hits as they did misses on the international market. This was primarily due to the more traditional frontier setting being often replaced with the antebellum South, such as in the case of "Django" released in 1950 by former comedy writer Spencer Williams Jr. and being praised for melding comedy as well as social realism, or the Second Civil War era, "Red Moon Rising" also released in 1950 by Dalton Trumbo. The European audiences found it difficult to adopt the new settings, given that they had little experience with them beforehand, and the rather heavy political subtext lead to many movies being banned outright. The more traditional Westerns, now often featuring the Natives as the heroes such as the Winnetou movies, would fare much better among European and particularly German audiences that lead to a surge of European Westerns. The late 1940s would also see films honouring the 10th anniversaries of the revolution and the death of John Reed, the most notable of the latter being "February" released on the 19th of February 1947 and the former being seeing a series of biopics by various directors about the different stages of Reed's life all releasing in 1949. It would however take until 1955 and the release of the hit known as "12 Angry Men" for American movies to truly be taken seriously on an international level beyond just light entertainment. The movie would earn director Sydney Lumet, who had changed his name to coincide with the city to protest Japanese imperialism, a Golden Bear at the Berlin Film Festival and mark the return to form of American cinema.

mOdrbSp.jpg

Much like "Home of the Brave" the 'red' Western "Django" would be an internationalist film starring an exiled French
revolutionary
turned bountyhunter that ends up helping a freed slave incite a slave revolt in the antebellum south.

This return to form would however would not be allowed to last for long. Although worries about the increasing influence that Syndicalist media held in Europe had begun in the early 50s the return or rebranding of German conservatism into 'Christian Democracy' and the collapse of the SPD coalition governments over Ireland, Ukraine and various other domestic issues saw Mitteleuropa more or less bolt its doors to Mitteleuropa as the Syndicalist scare of the 1930s was replayed on a much more limited scale. Syndicalist films were subjected to strict censorship and any that still managed to pass these criteria were subjected to massive excises so as to make all but the most diehard Americana fans abandon them. The latter were subsequently put under careful watch to see whether their appreciation of Anglo media was just an aesthetic or a cover for Syndicalist loyalties. Additionally, the Babelsberg system would finally develop into the predecessor of its modern form at this point. Film colleges were established across the Eastern parts of Mitteleuropa and local subsidiaries of the major German studios were formed across most states. German companies would also continue to buy stakes into existing companies, such as those resurging in France, creating the "son" and "brother" difference that is often seen when discussing the Babelsberg system. The loss of European markets would have relatively little effect on the Americans, despite the loss in extremely desired foreign capital, who would instead focus their foreign efforts on Africa and the less developed parts of the world. Trade links with India at this point relatively aligned with the Internationale helped lay the groundwork for Indian cinema now known more commonly as Bollywood, despite that name would only appear later long after American influence had vanished. Links between the two major Anglo film industries would also reach their peak during this period with British auteur director Stanley Kubrick 'borrowing' Pennywood resources to produce pieces that would have proven impossible in the Union of Britain. The most noteworthy of which proving "Under Capricorn" released in 1957 and featuring a murder mystery with the Japanese invasion of Australasia, or at least a propagandised version of it, used as a backdrop.

c5F1PTr.jpg

The unwillingness to invest abroad would lead to the juggernaut of UFA losing its lead as
head of the Babelsberg system to smaller rivals such as Terra and Bavaria-Film.

The lead up and the subsequent outbreak of the Second Mexican-American War would however put an end to even those few international relations as the American film industry turned almost fully inwards. Whilst the 1950s had seen about 30 'red' Westerns a year produced by Pennywood across all mediums in the aftermath of the death of General-Secretary Foster those numbers had jumped to 100 in 1961 alone with the war years seeing the numbers reach even greater heights with the attentions largely shifting away from the antebellum South back to the Western frontier and with primarily Mexican, Catholic and British villains. The period would also see an increasing crackdown on the freedom of artists as Browder began his long purge of the internationalists and other assorted perceived enemies of the revolution from within the ranks of the American power structure. This would lead to the exodus of a number of talented American artists, such as Stanley Kubrick that would renounce his American citizenship and be handed a British one by the Mosley government. Although he would be caught up in the round up of Americans from the British society that followed the assassination attempt on Mosley, the Chairman would personally intervene to release him as the the ageing dictator had taken a liking for the young director. In the newly formed American Union of Syndicalists States the 'red' Western would subsequently continue to dominate the period between the conflict with Mexico and the subsequent beginning of the Great American Cultural Revolution with most other fiction and particularly what little science-fiction had developed taking a general backseat as many of the authors involved in writing the pieces were swept up by the purges for 'anti-American' sentiments and associations.

iAXgd0Z.jpg

Photograph of Stanley Kubrick, thus far only half of the photo has been found thus there are a number of
theories of who is standing to the right of the director. Many theorise it to be Oswald Mosley himself.

Just like the Second American Civil War that had come before the Great American Cultural Revolution marked an end for American cinema on the world stage for a considerable period of time particularly, when it came to the realm of 'feature films'. Whereas the 1950s-60s had seen around 100 films produced by Pennywood each year peaking at 111 in 1963, the purges that followed had brought that number down to around 50 by 1968. The Cultural Revolution saw the banning of all films that had come before it, something that even the CSA had not practised for old Federalist era films, the reassignment of most film industry workers to 'more productive labour' and most devastatingly the destruction of the vast majority of any negatives of films produced before the period by student protesters. Although Browder shielded some of his favourites, the American film industry was fundamentally gutted by these actions and would never recover the glitz that had passed to it from the golden age of Hollywood. During this period the AUSS leadership, primarily in the form of the Hallites, would assume very stringent control over any films produced leading to further drops in the number of productions with Pennywood producing a grand total of 2 feature films between 1970-76. What little was produced by the American film industry at this point largely abandoned the previous genre that had been pursued during the Golden Age of Pennywood and focused heavily on musical pieces, something that had been helped by the fact that the various operas as well as artists of the AUSS were largely left alone. The death of the Eternal Chairman, as Browder became known during the subsequent Hallite period, would lead to a slight easing of the Cultural Revolution for the general public, but also mark a beginning of the terror for those that Browder had protected, but who didn't initially align themselves with the Hallites. Thus upcoming 40th anniversary of the Revolution would be celebrated by large scale musical pieces such as 'America the Beautiful' released and involving, primarily, the cast of the First New York Opera Theatre.

kw4aiei.jpg

The realities of the Hallite and late Browderite era caused a shift in the American
film industry towards a higher amount of musical features.

'Normalisation' would finally reach Pennywood at around the same time as the rest of the AUSS, in April of 1985. The mysterious disappearance of the majority of the Hallite leadership, including Gus Hall himself, over the Rocky Mountains in northern Columbia has subsequently lead to a number of conspiracy theories suggesting that a cabal of Army officers, centred on Marshal of the Army Benjamin O. Davis Jr. had them assassinated. The theory has been proven a tricky one to prove, particularly after the harsh downturn in relations after the Third Great South-American War, also known as the A-ABC war. Regardless the de facto junta officially declared an end to the Great American Cultural Revolution and returning the American Union of Syndicalist States from the chaos of the Hallite era back to 'Reedist orthodoxy'. The junta restored the 3 year plans and made the transition back to a party rule one of the primary goals of the first 3 year plan. Other factors included the restoration of the American economy, in ruins after decades of purges, de facto non-existent educational facilities and the bizarre goals of the Hallites. In the restored American economy Pennywood also had its role, since the junta leadership understood the importance of American soft-power in convincing the rest of the world in their legitimacy and desire for good relations, for the time being, the new generation of directors that had grown during the Hallite era were given a rather early Browderite era deal in producing movies. The American film industry subsequently began an unprecedented boom and although the nu-Americana, as it became labelled in the 1990s, provided to be a strange and uneasy viewing experience it still broke records as European audiences seemed over the moon about the return of their transatlantic brethren. A lot of the oddities can largely be put down to the different meanings that the symbols of old Americana had acquired as a result of the Cultural Revolution that had not yet reached Europe, as well as the borderline esoteric symbology that the new generation of American auteurs had developed so as to hide their real meanings from government scrutiny during the Hallite era. Even though the American films would end up leaving Europe once again at the turn of the 20th century as a result of the breakdown in the détente following the German intervention to protect the collapsing Southern Cone governments from falling fully under American domination, the products of Pennywood have once again just changed focus onto other markets.

5cr2ayU.jpg

Films produced during the 'normalisation' were at times openly dissenting against the ruling regime,
but the layers upon layers of subtext as well as different methods of hiding criticism kept them largely uncensored.

The history of cinematography in America has largely been one of innovation and constant needs to begin again. In this way the fate of the film industry has been constantly tied to that of the country itself being at the control of the whims of the zeitgeist, the American film industry has been unable to escape from the chaos that has gripped the continent for the entirety of the 20th century. Despite all these problems, the American dream factories have never collapsed into irrelevance as one might expect from the chaos and terror that they've been subjected to. Instead every fall has been a chance to rise again and produce products that enrapture audiences around the world and pushed the other film industries around the world to innovate, adapt and rise to the challenge. Perhaps much of this is all just a rose-tinted glasses or nostalgia for a period that the author has never truly experienced, but one that just resonates with him. Alternatively it could just be a deep rooted disappointment with the products churned out by the modern Babelsberg system that has managed to shrug off the recent challenge by Pennywood with little to no change, but if this author was to ever be addressed with a question about the viability of Hollywood or indeed simply American dominance had history played out differently, then it is the view of this author that the "Hollywoodites" are 100% correct. Although the majority of both the Hollywood and Pennywood catalogue is now sadly lost to the winds of history like much of the writings from ancient Rome, some of these products from the two American Golden eras of film have survived and discoveries, such as the negatives of the 1954 musical "Wizard of Oz" in the Indian National Film Archives, give hope to the public and historians alike that more of this world of the silver screen that we thought lost may still lie in the archives of various nations around the world. Perhaps one day we may experience more of this wondrous past that lies so close, but yet so far to us.

GtQ1KGW.jpg

"The Wizard of Oz", although revolutionary in many aspects, the movie itself apparently has very little to do with the original
writings by Baum and largely just shared names and some parts of the cast to tell a wholly different story.

An essay by J. Goldbergs in the student newspaper of the Fellin College of Film, a subsidiary of the State University of Dorpat
-----------------------------------------

Well now... Who would've thought that I would be returning to this? I certainly didn't when I finished the AAR in December of last year, nor did I think this was going to happen as late as the beginning of July. However the 2 week vacation that I'm currently enjoying as well as a number of planned ideas for said vacation, when I had to mark mine down at the end of the year means that we're now where we are and this short piece is the product.

Note this doesn't mean that the AAR is alive, it's still concluded. However provided that I get sufficiently bored again, the very fine Aussie still finds himself consumed with his Youtube based activities and my on again off again idea to write a detective story set in this slapped together universe that I have created runs into another wall there might be more of these. Maybe, I'm not sure at this point. The history of film in Red America seemed like a semi-interesting thing for me that required no need to touch Excel and just some deep thinking to run a few threads together. I've recently developed an allergy to that program so the less I see it the better.

Stuff like this without any real deadlines does seem rather fun to me and, if nothing else it will give those of us that compulsively feel the need to visit this forum to check if somebody, anybody is writing something at least something to do. So if people like it then let me know, if nothing else I will know whether there'll be a desire to necro this AAR thread from time to time or whether I can just write these into a file and forget about them till I get a surge of creativity to do something more useful with this stuff.
 
  • 3Love
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The History of American Film in the 20th Century

The dominance of the Mitteleuropan Babelsberg system across the wider civilised world has sometimes lead to the mistaken impression among the European public that this process was inevitable, given the extent of European control over global affairs during the 20th century, or indeed that there have been and are no rivals to what the domestic market offers. This could not be further from the case and indeed the characters and pieces that we find rather familiar are often seen as quite strange and even somewhat alien in the confines of Syndicalist America or 'free' Asia, just like their movies seem odd and bizarre to us. This had not always been the case however and had history played out somewhat differently, it is the opinion of this author, that the great continental cinema system that has entertained countless Europeans for the better part of 7 decades, named after the eponymous German studio and its national affiliates across the European continent, could have seen itself supplemented. Whilst it is unlikely that the levels of mass appeal achieved by the Babelsberg system could have been achieved by the Russians or the Japanese, given the capital shortages and the ideological through lines in the works of those two countries, there is an often recounted saying among students of film history. The saying goes that if ever more than two representatives of that hallowed profession are put into a room, then a considerable argument will develop about the potential future that might have followed had the rise of the once vibrant Hollywood film scene of the former United States of America not been cut off by the outbreak of the Second American Civil War.

A7qPX5m.jpg

Photo from overlooking the Hollywood sign, originally just meant as an advertisement for a real-estate
development, the sign would be burned into the public consciousness by the short but grand Hollywood period.

Considering the current state of Hollywood, now the district of Sinclair in the city of Foster, it is easy to understand how what something that seems like the antithesis, given its closed nature owing to the large naval presence, to the pluralistic and vibrant towns that make up the centres of the Babelsberg system could have once rivalled the continental film industry. However what is important to consider is that Hollywood itself is irrelevant and little but a mere symbol in the grand scheme of things, given the migratory nature of American film industry up to that point. What is important is to understand the depth of talent that said symbol represented that first the Federalists could call upon to surge past the continental system even during its long decline into the civil war during the interbellum period. Whilst much of said talent was lost to the Syndicalists, a lot of it remained or was later reacquired and Pennywood, the ironic nickname for the centre of the 'red' American film industry, seems to largely adhere to what we understand that a film industry ought to have. Indeed in the Old World, there seems to be an almost unquenchable thirst for stories from the frontiers held by our transatlantic brethren. This fascination that Europe has seemed to have resulted in American films being greeted by throngs of visitors, whenever they have eventually returned to screens of European theatres during various warm periods of international relations. This has been despite numerous campaigns by more conservative forces, often backed by domestic film industry, to ban these films as Syndicalist filth meant to rile up the masses of crypto-Syndicalists and fellow travellers supposedly hidden within our ranks. Although, much of the success of the films can largely be put down to large viewership numbers among the working classes, it must be said that the numbers are not unlike those of their Babelsberg counterparts. Additionally similarly 'red' productions from the Union of Britain, prior their "quiet revolution", such as the 1958 war film 'Run Silent, Run Deep' or the numerous lesser known films featuring British secret agent James Bond, often called an inferior rip-off of the Polish film series about Hauptmann Kloss, have managed nowhere near as much success as their counterparts and erstwhile rivals in the New World, even though the ideological colouring remained the same.

N4nBrk4.jpg

Still from the third Hauptmann Kloss movie -
"On his Imperial Majesty's Secret Service"

The early history of film in America is rather closely tied together with the early history of commercial film itself and begins, unsurprisingly, on the East Coast of the former United States. Among his numerous other inventions, the American businessman Thomas Edison is also often credited with the creation of the first commercial film studio, the Black Maria, in his home state of New Jersey at the turn of the 19th century. Despite this seemingly early lead, the Americans proved unable to leverage this achievement into a real competitive position on the market. Indeed, beyond his role in creating or at least patenting the methods of film making, Edison seems to have played a primarily antagonistic role in the history of American film until his death in 1931. Pursuing litigious action from his own offices in New York in a nigh religious manner, the inventor would try to push himself as a beneficiary for all movies made and direct his lawyers to actively seize film making equipment that had been deemed to be produced illegally - ie not having paid Edison. The desire to get as far away from Edison as possible would take some time to truly find begin to bear fruit and the centre of American film industry would largely remain on the East Coast until the 1920s. This period has later been nicknamed the Fort Lee period among scholars of American film after the name of the town that held the development of the majority of American films. However even during its heyday in the 1910s Fort Lee was not unchallenged, primarily due to the Edison issue, and during the latter half of the First Weltkrieg Fort Lee would begin to lose ground to its rival on the West Coast that would go onto to name the next period of American film history - Hollywood. The West Coast based location allowed as much distance as possible from Edison and his army of lawyers the result of which was that most companies would largely evade his litigative attempts. The austere war years in Europe also meant that America had lost its greatest rival and saw its productions sweep across the globe. Given that this was the era of silent film, localisation proved easy and the visions of a better life and adventure out West offered by American films proved quite comforting to the shelled continent and beyond. The subsequent Syndicalists revolutions that swept across much of Western Europe, although disastrous for the American economy, saw the New World consolidate its grip on the film markets it now held given the fall from grace of the once dominant European film companies.

ymE8aNz.jpg

Movies from vaudeville comedians such as the Marx Brothers and Charlie Chaplin were among
some of the most highly sought after American movies during its Weltkrieg era boom.

The slow burning economic collapse of the United States that followed the defeat of and revolution in the Entente powers also saw American film industry consolidate quite viscously. Although smaller studios would end up closing shop or being merged into bigger conglomerates, as was the case with Vitagraph Studios, a prolific short silent film maker, the increasing size of the production companies allowed for increased economies of scale leading to the industry seeming strangely untouched by the ongoing decline of America around it. The Gilded Age of Hollywood would thus go on even as the state itself stumbled from crisis to crisis. The relatively cheap cost of movies, topping off at around 10 cents even after the decline of the nickelodeons, following the rise of the feature film after the now partially lost 1915 silent film the Birth of a Nation, provided plentiful entertainment for the increasingly strained budgets of the American populace. The rising revenues allowed for more consolidation in the industry as well as vertical integration leading to the development of the studio system, which would lead to approximately 5 studios controlling the entire market, would become the by word for the Hollywood era. The studio system would prove an important innovation and the basis for the film industry long outlasting the studios and the state that had pioneered it. Such was also the case with other American innovations, which would provide inspiration for the resurgent European film industry now lead not by the French, despite heavy investments by the Syndicalist government, but by the Mitteleuropan Babelsberg and its captive market. The fleeing American talent would often end up in Babelsberg and end up providing great use to the golden age of the Babelsberg system after the during and after Syndicalist War. Even though in some cases the innovations pushed by the American industry would end up harming it in the short term, such as through the adoption of the 'talkies', through which a number of American films were deprived from a great number of foreign markets as they proved unable to understand the plots, even in the case of other English speaking states, in general the innovations being pushed, particularly colour film, as well as the stunning camera work and gripping plots saw American films, and thus American soft-power rise, even as the rising German juggernaut was pushing it further inwards.

786jHcw.jpg

Collection of the five big studios that dominated the Golden Hollywood era of American film industry of these MGM,
20th Century Fox and Paramount Pictures would try to make a resurgence in Europe with little to no success.

The outbreak of the Second American Civil War on the 19th of February in 1937 would mark an end to Hollywood era and thus American film on a global scale, for a considerable amount of time with the last Hollywood movie, "The Last of Mrs. Cheyney", being released on the day that war broke out and even that only to limited screenings in the Pacific States of America and New England then still under Canadian occupation. Although the American Second Civil War would eventually conclude in late 1939, the continental United States would find itself divided by the Mexican invasion of the Pacific States and their annexation into the United States of Mexico in the second half of 1940 would mark a long term division of the continent and deprive the young Syndicalist America from the majority of its film industry. Thus even though the Combined Syndicates of America had nationalised the property of the former 5 studios and brought them under control of the American State Syndicate for Cinematography, referred to from now on Synfilm, the nationalisation had resulted in the Americans gaining relatively little. Instead the majority of their holdings were now under the control of the Mexicans. The iron fisted rule of Pancho Villa and his ruthless solution to the Anglo problem would see Hollywood bled dry of what had remained there during the invasion with the majority of its equipment, capital and even talent syphoned off south to support the flourishing Mexican film industry that would maintain a dominant position over Latin America until the outbreak of the Second Mexican-American War. The fresh start accorded to the Syndicalists saw American film move back to the East Coast, more specifically to Allentown in Pennsylvania. The apparent 'cheapness' of the films, caused by a noticeable drop in quality due to the loss of Hollywood, as well as the price of admission being pegged to 1 cent or a penny earned it the derisive name Pennywood. The industry would later discretely adopt it although in official American histories of the its film industry the Penny part is stated to be a shorthand for Pennsylvania. The new American cinema would initially be put to ideological work, as the Browder-Foster diarchy at the head of the Combined Syndicates relying on Syndicalists orthodoxy saw film as a potent propaganda tool and thus an important part of consolidating the rule of the new state over the hearts and minds of the American populace.

oYfLw2b.png

The Pennywood logo would allegedly adorn every American
production after the middle part of the 1950s
.

In its role as a propaganda tool Synfilm would remain under the almost direct supervision of Chairman Browder, who saw it as his mission to keep the internationalists under Foster from infecting the American public with the failed values of the European syndicalist powers. In his role as guardian of the American film industry, Browder would initially allow directors a great deal of freedom to explore film as a medium without any real constraints to budgets, provided that it maintained a correct ideological approach and adhered to Browder's vision of Syndicalism as 20th century Americanism. Although newsreels would initially dominate the immediate postwar period of the 1940s, they would slowly but surely be replaced by increasing amounts of feature films as the directors sought to surpass the glitz and glamour of the decadent capitalist Hollywood. During this initial period the American cinema would be dominated by war epics such as "Marching On!" by James J. Edwards releasing to great domestic accolades in 1943. The film was seen by many as the physical incarnation of the unspoken compact between the Syndicalist government and the Black community to not allow the failure of the Reconstruction period to be repeated as the film explores the post-war life of a black soldier that had fled from a plantation farm to join the Union Army and liberate his brethren only to see Reconstruction fail and fall into destitution as a share cropper following the institution of Jim Crow laws. "Home of the Brave" by Herbert Bibermann would also make its debut during this initial experimental period and cement the writer as one of the premier American directors. Ironically enough the movie would be one of the few internationalist films that Foster managed to push Browder to produce primarily due to its anti-British tone that appealed to the Chairman, despite it also hyping up the public for the eventual American intervention in the Entente-Internationale War. Centring on the War of 1812, the movie released in 1946 inspired a whole subgenre of anti-British/royalists films in the American industry that had thus far primarily focused on attacking the former American elites. The film had a different reception in Canada however and is argued by some to have contributed to the start of the failed peace talks with the European Syndicalists after the withdrawal of the Indians from the Entente and thus the war.

GeHrPEV.jpg

During the Golden Age of Pennywood period many outside observers would try to glean American foreign policy
and ongoing trends in the state by looking at what the message American movies were trying to get across.

Although the American intervention and the destruction of the Entente would not be received well abroad, the threat of the Americas was somewhat overshadowed by the racial panic caused by the Japanese invasion of Australasia and more importantly its nuclear attack on Sydney. In light of this as well as the SPD coalition government leading Germany, as well as its ascension into the Internationale the American film industry would begin to make its first slow forays abroad. Despite proving unsuccessful at any push into Latin America, it would see some success in Europe as well as the United Kingdom. Its primary success coming through Westerns, which had become the main fascination of the industry after the fall of the Canadians. The 'red' Westerns as they became known provided as many hits as they did misses on the international market. This was primarily due to the more traditional frontier setting being often replaced with the antebellum South, such as in the case of "Django" released in 1950 by former comedy writer Spencer Williams Jr. and being praised for melding comedy as well as social realism, or the Second Civil War era, "Red Moon Rising" also released in 1950 by Dalton Trumbo. The European audiences found it difficult to adopt the new settings, given that they had little experience with them beforehand, and the rather heavy political subtext lead to many movies being banned outright. The more traditional Westerns, now often featuring the Natives as the heroes such as the Winnetou movies, would fare much better among European and particularly German audiences that lead to a surge of European Westerns. The late 1940s would also see films honouring the 10th anniversaries of the revolution and the death of John Reed, the most notable of the latter being "February" released on the 19th of February 1947 and the former being seeing a series of biopics by various directors about the different stages of Reed's life all releasing in 1949. It would however take until 1955 and the release of the hit known as "12 Angry Men" for American movies to truly be taken seriously on an international level beyond just light entertainment. The movie would earn director Sydney Lumet, who had changed his name to coincide with the city to protest Japanese imperialism, a Golden Bear at the Berlin Film Festival and mark the return to form of American cinema.

mOdrbSp.jpg

Much like "Home of the Brave" the 'red' Western "Django" would be an internationalist film starring an exiled French
revolutionary
turned bountyhunter that ends up helping a freed slave incite a slave revolt in the antebellum south.

This return to form would however would not be allowed to last for long. Although worries about the increasing influence that Syndicalist media held in Europe had begun in the early 50s the return or rebranding of German conservatism into 'Christian Democracy' and the collapse of the SPD coalition governments over Ireland, Ukraine and various other domestic issues saw Mitteleuropa more or less bolt its doors to Mitteleuropa as the Syndicalist scare of the 1930s was replayed on a much more limited scale. Syndicalist films were subjected to strict censorship and any that still managed to pass these criteria were subjected to massive excises so as to make all but the most diehard Americana fans abandon them. The latter were subsequently put under careful watch to see whether their appreciation of Anglo media was just an aesthetic or a cover for Syndicalist loyalties. Additionally, the Babelsberg system would finally develop into the predecessor of its modern form at this point. Film colleges were established across the Eastern parts of Mitteleuropa and local subsidiaries of the major German studios were formed across most states. German companies would also continue to buy stakes into existing companies, such as those resurging in France, creating the "son" and "brother" difference that is often seen when discussing the Babelsberg system. The loss of European markets would have relatively little effect on the Americans, despite the loss in extremely desired foreign capital, who would instead focus their foreign efforts on Africa and the less developed parts of the world. Trade links with India at this point relatively aligned with the Internationale helped lay the groundwork for Indian cinema now known more commonly as Bollywood, despite that name would only appear later long after American influence had vanished. Links between the two major Anglo film industries would also reach their peak during this period with British auteur director Stanley Kubrick 'borrowing' Pennywood resources to produce pieces that would have proven impossible in the Union of Britain. The most noteworthy of which proving "Under Capricorn" released in 1957 and featuring a murder mystery with the Japanese invasion of Australasia, or at least a propagandised version of it, used as a backdrop.

c5F1PTr.jpg

The unwillingness to invest abroad would lead to the juggernaut of UFA losing its lead as
head of the Babelsberg system to smaller rivals such as Terra and Bavaria-Film.

The lead up and the subsequent outbreak of the Second Mexican-American War would however put an end to even those few international relations as the American film industry turned almost fully inwards. Whilst the 1950s had seen about 30 'red' Westerns a year produced by Pennywood across all mediums in the aftermath of the death of General-Secretary Foster those numbers had jumped to 100 in 1961 alone with the war years seeing the numbers reach even greater heights with the attentions largely shifting away from the antebellum South back to the Western frontier and with primarily Mexican, Catholic and British villains. The period would also see an increasing crackdown on the freedom of artists as Browder began his long purge of the internationalists and other assorted perceived enemies of the revolution from within the ranks of the American power structure. This would lead to the exodus of a number of talented American artists, such as Stanley Kubrick that would renounce his American citizenship and be handed a British one by the Mosley government. Although he would be caught up in the round up of Americans from the British society that followed the assassination attempt on Mosley, the Chairman would personally intervene to release him as the the ageing dictator had taken a liking for the young director. In the newly formed American Union of Syndicalists States the 'red' Western would subsequently continue to dominate the period between the conflict with Mexico and the subsequent beginning of the Great American Cultural Revolution with most other fiction and particularly what little science-fiction had developed taking a general backseat as many of the authors involved in writing the pieces were swept up by the purges for 'anti-American' sentiments and associations.

iAXgd0Z.jpg

Photograph of Stanley Kubrick, thus far only half of the photo has been found thus there are a number of
theories of who is standing to the right of the director. Many theorise it to be Oswald Mosley himself.

Just like the Second American Civil War that had come before the Great American Cultural Revolution marked an end for American cinema on the world stage for a considerable period of time particularly, when it came to the realm of 'feature films'. Whereas the 1950s-60s had seen around 100 films produced by Pennywood each year peaking at 111 in 1963, the purges that followed had brought that number down to around 50 by 1968. The Cultural Revolution saw the banning of all films that had come before it, something that even the CSA had not practised for old Federalist era films, the reassignment of most film industry workers to 'more productive labour' and most devastatingly the destruction of the vast majority of any negatives of films produced before the period by student protesters. Although Browder shielded some of his favourites, the American film industry was fundamentally gutted by these actions and would never recover the glitz that had passed to it from the golden age of Hollywood. During this period the AUSS leadership, primarily in the form of the Hallites, would assume very stringent control over any films produced leading to further drops in the number of productions with Pennywood producing a grand total of 2 feature films between 1970-76. What little was produced by the American film industry at this point largely abandoned the previous genre that had been pursued during the Golden Age of Pennywood and focused heavily on musical pieces, something that had been helped by the fact that the various operas as well as artists of the AUSS were largely left alone. The death of the Eternal Chairman, as Browder became known during the subsequent Hallite period, would lead to a slight easing of the Cultural Revolution for the general public, but also mark a beginning of the terror for those that Browder had protected, but who didn't initially align themselves with the Hallites. Thus upcoming 40th anniversary of the Revolution would be celebrated by large scale musical pieces such as 'America the Beautiful' released and involving, primarily, the cast of the First New York Opera Theatre.

kw4aiei.jpg

The realities of the Hallite and late Browderite era caused a shift in the American
film industry towards a higher amount of musical features.

'Normalisation' would finally reach Pennywood at around the same time as the rest of the AUSS, in April of 1985. The mysterious disappearance of the majority of the Hallite leadership, including Gus Hall himself, over the Rocky Mountains in northern Columbia has subsequently lead to a number of conspiracy theories suggesting that a cabal of Army officers, centred on Marshal of the Army Benjamin O. Davis Jr. had them assassinated. The theory has been proven a tricky one to prove, particularly after the harsh downturn in relations after the Third Great South-American War, also known as the A-ABC war. Regardless the de facto junta officially declared an end to the Great American Cultural Revolution and returning the American Union of Syndicalist States from the chaos of the Hallite era back to 'Reedist orthodoxy'. The junta restored the 3 year plans and made the transition back to a party rule one of the primary goals of the first 3 year plan. Other factors included the restoration of the American economy, in ruins after decades of purges, de facto non-existent educational facilities and the bizarre goals of the Hallites. In the restored American economy Pennywood also had its role, since the junta leadership understood the importance of American soft-power in convincing the rest of the world in their legitimacy and desire for good relations, for the time being, the new generation of directors that had grown during the Hallite era were given a rather early Browderite era deal in producing movies. The American film industry subsequently began an unprecedented boom and although the nu-Americana, as it became labelled in the 1990s, provided to be a strange and uneasy viewing experience it still broke records as European audiences seemed over the moon about the return of their transatlantic brethren. A lot of the oddities can largely be put down to the different meanings that the symbols of old Americana had acquired as a result of the Cultural Revolution that had not yet reached Europe, as well as the borderline esoteric symbology that the new generation of American auteurs had developed so as to hide their real meanings from government scrutiny during the Hallite era. Even though the American films would end up leaving Europe once again at the turn of the 20th century as a result of the breakdown in the détente following the German intervention to protect the collapsing Southern Cone governments from falling fully under American domination, the products of Pennywood have once again just changed focus onto other markets.

5cr2ayU.jpg

Films produced during the 'normalisation' were at times openly dissenting against the ruling regime,
but the layers upon layers of subtext as well as different methods of hiding criticism kept them largely uncensored.

The history of cinematography in America has largely been one of innovation and constant needs to begin again. In this way the fate of the film industry has been constantly tied to that of the country itself being at the control of the whims of the zeitgeist, the American film industry has been unable to escape from the chaos that has gripped the continent for the entirety of the 20th century. Despite all these problems, the American dream factories have never collapsed into irrelevance as one might expect from the chaos and terror that they've been subjected to. Instead every fall has been a chance to rise again and produce products that enrapture audiences around the world and pushed the other film industries around the world to innovate, adapt and rise to the challenge. Perhaps much of this is all just a rose-tinted glasses or nostalgia for a period that the author has never truly experienced, but one that just resonates with him. Alternatively it could just be a deep rooted disappointment with the products churned out by the modern Babelsberg system that has managed to shrug off the recent challenge by Pennywood with little to no change, but if this author was to ever be addressed with a question about the viability of Hollywood or indeed simply American dominance had history played out differently, then it is the view of this author that the "Hollywoodites" are 100% correct. Although the majority of both the Hollywood and Pennywood catalogue is now sadly lost to the winds of history like much of the writings from ancient Rome, some of these products from the two American Golden eras of film have survived and discoveries, such as the negatives of the 1954 musical "Wizard of Oz" in the Indian National Film Archives, give hope to the public and historians alike that more of this world of the silver screen that we thought lost may still lie in the archives of various nations around the world. Perhaps one day we may experience more of this wondrous past that lies so close, but yet so far to us.

GtQ1KGW.jpg

"The Wizard of Oz", although revolutionary in many aspects, the movie itself apparently has very little to do with the original
writings by Baum and largely just shared names and some parts of the cast to tell a wholly different story.

An essay by J. Goldbergs in the student newspaper of the Fellin College of Film, a subsidiary of the State University of Dorpat
-----------------------------------------

Well now... Who would've thought that I would be returning to this? I certainly didn't when I finished the AAR in December of last year, nor did I think this was going to happen as late as the beginning of July. However the 2 week vacation that I'm currently enjoying as well as a number of planned ideas for said vacation, when I had to mark mine down at the end of the year means that we're now where we are and this short piece is the product.

Note this doesn't mean that the AAR is alive, it's still concluded. However provided that I get sufficiently bored again, the very fine Aussie still finds himself consumed with his Youtube based activities and my on again off again idea to write a detective story set in this slapped together universe that I have created runs into another wall there might be more of these. Maybe, I'm not sure at this point. The history of film in Red America seemed like a semi-interesting thing for me that required no need to touch Excel and just some deep thinking to run a few threads together. I've recently developed an allergy to that program so the less I see it the better.

Stuff like this without any real deadlines does seem rather fun to me and, if nothing else it will give those of us that compulsively feel the need to visit this forum to check if somebody, anybody is writing something at least something to do. So if people like it then let me know, if nothing else I will know whether there'll be a desire to necro this AAR thread from time to time or whether I can just write these into a file and forget about them till I get a surge of creativity to do something more useful with this stuff.
That was an eerily beautiful look into the world you created! Haunting, but fascinating. The snippets about post-cultural-revolutionary America, about Gus Hall's fate, are entrancing. The allusions to old American cinema being lost like the works of antiquity, and modern n American cinema being strange and unfamiliar, haunting.

I love the world you created and would love to read more about it, whenever you find it in yourself to write and post some :)
 
Being a massive film buff, I really appreciated this chapter, Health :) Don't really have the energy for a proper critique at this time; suffice to say that if I needed any more reasons to hate Browder in this timeline, he just gave me the perfect one by effectively murdering the Golden Age of American Film.
 
That was an eerily beautiful look into the world you created! Haunting, but fascinating. The snippets about post-cultural-revolutionary America, about Gus Hall's fate, are entrancing. The allusions to old American cinema being lost like the works of antiquity, and modern n American cinema being strange and unfamiliar, haunting.

I love the world you created and would love to read more about it, whenever you find it in yourself to write and post some :)

Thanks! Haunting was sort of what I was trying to go for, glad to have at least partially stuck the landing. I got a surge of inspiration for this after rereading some tidbit or another that the vast majority of silent films, as well as other pieces of early cinema, are now gone. Some of those have been rediscovered of course from the depths of archives as in the case of this story the rediscovery of the Wizard of Oz in India or in real life the discovery of pieces cut from Metropolis in Argentina and New Zealand.

As to more writings... It's rather possible as from time to time I've been finding myself coming back to this as I delve deeper into, relatively, obscure tidbits about primarily interwar Japan but also the more generic Cold War stuff. It wasn't until rather recently that I came to the conclusion that I should probably write some of it down in a more comprehensible and less stream of consciousness kind of way. I can fairly easily track most of the stuff down again, primarily due to the fact that I rambled about it to online acquaintances.

The easiest to do it, ie the least amount of sanity damage from looking at data, would probably be the educational system of the Japanese Empire. The multiple branch system and what it could eventually end up as seemed rather interesting to me considering the prevalence of the "single path" systems in East Asia. Similarly when I've finally managed to fortify my brain against Excel, or lost enough sanity that it stops having an effect on me - I've been considering taking a stab at trying to rationalise how the Japanese economy was actually capable of doing what I claimed it was in the story or how I've rationalised the what was it approximately 2 million, correct me if I'm misremembering, total Imperial Japanese Armed Forces personnel in the 1960s. Pilfering Northern China only gets you so far you still need to exchange it for stuff. I've had other ideas as well but those two/three are the furthest to nearing having something resembling bones that I can add flesh onto.

Being a massive film buff, I really appreciated this chapter, Health :) Don't really have the energy for a proper critique at this time; suffice to say that if I needed any more reasons to hate Browder in this timeline, he just gave me the perfect one by effectively murdering the Golden Age of American Film.

You're very welcome and if you ever do get the energy to cut through that piece then I'll be glad to discuss it at length.

As to Browder, I wouldn't necessarily call him the villain in this scenario at least not as clearly as I or well that "UBD university student" is painting the Hallites. He would indeed end the Second Golden Age of American Cinema through his purges and crackdowns on "rootless internationalists threatening America" and inadvertently set into motion the final deathblow to the Red, White and Blue, that he was sort of trying to resurrect, and see its true transition into the Red White and Black. On the flip side, would the American film industry had risen from the ashes like it did had it not been for him and more importantly with the carry over from Hollywood? Perhaps Foster would have had other priorities and American film would've been relegated to flounder with minimal budgets producing little of note or mass appeal on the foreign market for decades.
 
PLUq0c4.png

Many have struggled to understand how the backwards reactionary forces that made up the leadership of the Japanese Empire could ever lead the nation to the position that they now occupy. It is a simple fact that behind all successful imperialist states lies an almost vulture like behaviour to detect rotting organisations to benefit off of as well as a lack of any real social consciousness. Despite their apparent abhorrence of the working man's ideology the Japanese leadership seems to have taken this concept to heart such as during their most recent decision to abandon the Manchu lead pretender government of China, as well as the tyrannical warlords and religious fanatics that they had relied upon, to their fate at the hands of the Chinese public. Upon closer refection however, it can be revealed that these actions are less the result of an underlying causes of Imperialism as stated clearly by the Great Chairman Mosley and more of an almost genetic memory to conduct such actions. For you see, this is not the first time that the Japanese have tried to claim dominion over China. In this case, I'm referring not to the outrageous demands made by the Japanese to the revolutionary Chinese government during the Great War, but indeed to something that dates back centuries to the closing era of the feudal conflicts in Japan between petty warlords that saw a full-blown imperialist incursion into Korea as well as China to establish Japanese dominion over these territories and give the murderous barbarians that had been terrorising the peasantry for more than a century at this point. Indeed it seems that those, whose veins carry the blood of this accursed people are forever doomed to repeat their mistakes and commit atrocity upon atrocity towards their neighbours across the Far East. It does however worth noting that as the headline of this piece suggests, the Chinese would not be the lone targets of this vulture like tendency of the Japanese in pursuit of whatever bourgeoisie petty imperialist desires they held in their hearts. Indeed during the conflicts that would define the latter half of the 20th century - the Second Great War, the exiled reactionaries across the former British Empire would also fall into the trap laid by these honey-tongued Asiatics.

XeotpRi.jpg

Further steps must be taken to liberate those toiling in the shackles of Japanese imperialism.
This story, like many in the era, begins with the outbreak of the Second American Civil War. Due to decades of misguidance the American people under the leadership of the revolutionary hero Jack Reed finally threw off the shackles of the corrupt federal government and were in exchange treated as all revolutionaries are - violent suppression. The conflict would then quickly expand, as other vultures descended to pick apart the American carcass with the reactionary racialists in the South and even the Pacific States, lead by the effete bourgeoisie Republican Party, joining the conflict against the Federal Government, under the control of the equally Southern Democrats. For the purposes of this narrative, the following conflict is important for one reason and one reason only, the fate of the American gold. Even though the United States had been in economic decline, having backed the wrong horse during the Great War and seen its parasitic loans and trade deals that threatened to bleed us dry declared null following the glorious revolutions that first brought Syndicalism to power in France and later within our unbreakable Union, the state had continued to remain safe haven for capitalist oppressors to hide their wealth - something akin to the Swiss but on a much larger scale. The efforts by these reactionaries and capitalists, which would also see us denied a considerable amount of our national gold reserves, as well as their continued hard-headed adherence to the gold standard contributed to a period of American history called 'starving with gold coins in our mouths'. Although the working class that were subjected to the massive unemployment and ever worsening poverty rates had no benefit from it, the national gold reserves would continued blooming. The Americans had initially held their gold primarily in major coastal cities such as San Francisco, Philadelphia and New York, but the growing concerns about the loyalty of the urban proletariat here as well as the threat of potential incursion by foreign powers had contributed to the creation of plans to hide the gold away in more safe, and the Federalists hoped, loyal inland regions. By the outbreak of the civil war, the gold that had been in San Francisco had already been evacuated to Denver, but the removal of the East Coast gold had yet to be completed. A facility had been built, somewhere in Kentucky, but the start to the transfers had been delayed due to security concerns despite initial plans to begin them in 1937. This meant that by the outbreak of war, most of the American gold had not been moved further inland and this would play an important role in what was to come.

D6z7h5Q.jpg

Capitalist greed meant that those working were denied the right to the products of their labour
that was then used to invest in unnecessary gold rather than the good of the working classes.

It is at this point that the exiled reactionaries enter the story, initially through their direct incursion into the conflict through the occupation of New England, this remaining the closest they would come to reclaiming any piece of England. Following the recapture of both Philadelphia and New York by the Federal government, diplomats from Canada would approach the Federalists and offer them a deal. The Royalist government knew that it needed a considerable amount of gold to even begin to approach the possibility of trying to break the backs of the workers defending Mother Britannia and that the Americans were indeed in control of a lot of gold, had little ways to spend it and were realistically in no real position to bargain. This was particularly the case after Canadian meddling and the severing of contact lines with the East Coast had seen 'Field Marshal' MacArthur assume direct control over all American forces in Middle America as well as seize the gold in Denver for its 'protection'. The reactionaries would offer safe passage for all types of military equipment, volunteers as well as refuge for those that were of little use in the ongoing conflict for a price - the American gold. This deal would see Federalists hand over lump sums of gold for every 100 people and every tonne of materiel that moved across the border between Canadian and Federal territory as well as, given their tendencies towards usury, a percentage fee for every piece of war materials that moved across the border in the increasingly desperate attempts by the Federal snakes to secure weapons against the working man's revolution. The Canadians would also directly arm the Americans in exchange for gold and offer similar deals to the the Pacific States, after the latter seized Denver, greatly depleted by the retreating forces of MacArthur which had struck a similar with their Royalist puppet masters to supply equipment for his 'Free American Army', a high-flying name for what amounted little more to a bandit force lead by a jumped up would-be Bonaparte, in exchange for guns. Much of this gold would be used to fund the massive expansions of Canadian industry, that the exiled reactionaries use to persecute their war that turned Englishmen against Englishmen during the dark days of the Second Great War. It is thought that this gold even played a role in sponsoring the only successful naval invasion of this fair island since 1066. Granted the action was not taken by the Canadians themselves and instead by reactionary elements within the fleeing French forces during their exodus across the Channel. Even though control over the city of Dover that they had claimed was soon restored by arriving Popular Militia units, the fact that they held the city for nearly 2 weeks caused many defeatists to think that the end was at hand. This was particularly because the Royals would attempt landings at Edinburgh and Glasgow at nearly the same time. Our brave fighting men in Scotland would however hold their ground and the traitorous French would be dealt with as befitting of traitors to the cause.

StzCtz1.jpg

Our brave Popular Militia troops examining retaken positions following the destruction of French forces.
Whereas the Republican Navy had been humbled off Iceland by a treacherous Canadian raid and off Dogger Bank by the Germans, both victories had largely been pyrrhic and the lessons learned from these battles applied quickly. The Canadians however would refuse to learn even after losing much of the old surface fleet major combatants that had carried them away from revolutionary justice as well as what little they had been able to cobble together in that period of 'exile'. The Germans in the mean while would realise that an invasion of our fair island was something that was beyond their abilities, even given our difficult situation and decided to sue for peace. The failure of its naval invasions and the departure of the German imperialists from the war through the Peace with 'Honour', that would ultimately lead to the rise of the ever wise Chairman Mosley, would see Canadian successes begin to wane as our fighting men begin to retake the initiative of the war. Eventually by the time that the revisionists in America were finally beginning to consider joining the conflict to conduct the international duty of all working men, at least in whatever heterodox way they understood it our forces were already on the doorstep of the revisionists. During the Atlantic Campaign, by our Republican Navy in the latter half of the Second Great War, the Canadians had found themselves increasingly pressed for resources, particularly as our brave submariners ensured that whatever regions would still provide them with resources would quickly become unwilling to do so. It is at this period that the American gold began to flow out of Canada at an ever increasing pace. Thus much of their active trade would operate through the Pacific, beyond the reach of our watchful naval forces. Here we would see the return of the Japanese into the picture who, due to cordial diplomatic links with the royalist government of Britain prior to the revolution as well as an inherent revulsion for Syndicalism and a desire to weaken German hegemony over Asia, saw the Canadians as if not an ally then at least a cash cow. Despite protests from the racialists and petty bourgeoisie playing at Socialism in Australasia, the Canadians would strike deals with the Japanese that would see the latter provide all types of war materials to fund the ongoing war effort of the reactionaries. The Japanese, like the Canadians before them had done for the Americans, would only accept payments in gold, primarily since they did not trust the stability of the Imperial Dollar on the global market to fund their own ongoing industrialisation process. Many historians have identified this deal as one of the root causes of the continued Canadian resistance until the intervention by the revisionist Americans. However, as our efforts finally began to bear fruit the increasing rumbling from America would also see efforts to ship what remained of the gold reserves of the reactionary government shipped off to Australasia, a process which was still in progress when American forces seized Vancouver in 1947. Although myths would quickly develop that the Royalists had buried much of the gold or drowned it lakes in the Deep North, later records would show that apart from the gold reserves recovered by the Americans in Vancouver, amounting to approximately one-fifth of what the old United States had held prior to the civil war, nearly all the rest of it had been shipped off over the Pacific.

8PXhbs1.jpg

Estimated gold supplies based on work of our intelligence officers and estimates by the British NatBank.
This is at least how the story has been told to us thus far, primarily due to needs of state security. More recently however on the urges of the wise Chairman Mosley those that served to keep us safe, both inside and outside the country during the Second Great War as well as its immediate aftermath, have been allowed to step forth and publish stories about of some of their actions during the war. These stories have thus far been accompanied by files from the archives about the agencies in question to confirm their truthfulness, following some controls to avoid risk to the security of our republics. These efforts have also helped bring to justice some reactionaries and revisionists that have been hidden in plain sight for decades, waiting to strike a blow at Mother Britannia. Among these books is a rather recent piece that has attracted mass attention due to its ties to the movie "Thunderball". Named "The Real Thunderball - the Canadian Bomb Effort from Someone That Was There" has been written by an agent that due to professional reasons has remained anonymous. He claims to be one of many agents that were tasked in the late 30s with infiltrating the atomic programs of threatening states across the world, following the French refusal to proceed with the Damocles Project in 1937. This was partially to keep a track on how the reactionaries were fairing as well as to cheapen the cost of the program for Britain, if possible by send back highly perspective information, and increasing the cost of the program for the reactionaries, primarily by leading the scientists and engineers on wild goose-chases. In his preface, and thus far the only comments we have of him, the author would claim that he had not planned to write this story, but following the release of the movie "Thunderball" the past came surging back to him. So due to a desire to tell his son what really happened and cut away at the exaggerated amounts of drinking, femme fatales and gun fights that Comrade Fleming had decided to add, he decided to force himself to face his past write his experiences down. Even though the book confirmed what we already knew about the Canadian program, that it failed thus putting to bed the wild stories about an atomic bomb detonation to delay American access to Vancouver, at least on this side of the pond. It did reveal some shocking facts that had thus far remained outside public knowledge.

kXfgHdi.jpg

Photo of the atomic facilities used by the reactionaries in Canada.

Despite the fact that many, particularly among the younger generations, have begun to take the peaceful British atom as a fact of life, a sizeable portion of the public still remembers the time before this was the case - the time before the unprovoked and brutal Japanese terror bombing of Sydney, one of their many crimes in that conflict against the working men of Australasia. The general consensus among scientists at this point in time was that no state could actually produce a weapon from the atomic processes tested or indeed a create energy for public usage, at least not without an amount of resources that would approach obscene. This would of course be proven wrong by the Japanese on the 3rd of November in 1950 to massive public outcry. The more recent shocking claims put forth by this book have however revolved around the origin of the uranium used by the Japanese to make their horrific bomb and use it to murder thousands of brainwashed working men fighting for the royalists at Sydney. Indeed the book seems to suggest that the resources used to build the weapon used against by the royalists would come from the royalists themselves. Intelligence reports, primarily consisting of post-war studies on Canadian achievements, released just a few days ago seem to confirm the claims of the book put as well as even suggesting that some key Canadian scientists and documents had been whisked away by the Japanese during chaos of the Royalist evacuation of Canada, unbeknownst to the reactionaries themselves who thought the men dead or captured by the advancing American revisionists. The book has left many wondering about how this cruel twist of fate could happen. Why would the Canadians supply the Japanese with Uranium, especially when we consider the fact that the Royalist government had banned the export of that mineral as well as anything else they considered important in the creation of a bomb following the start of their own program in 1940. The truth of the matter is that the inbred Royals have since time immemorial cared little for things that the rest of us British hold highly - such as rule of law. Their disregard for the law is perhaps most clear from the recent statements by the Antipodean 'Virgin' Queen promising to restore order, if she and her harem of 'close friends and advisors' were to take back control of our fair land. Her order of course caring little for the law of the land and would likely subject the working classes of Britain to a terror unseen since the Harrying of the North and which would even make her ancestor Bloody Mary blush.

WWYclTM.jpg

The Saxe-Coburg and Gotha pretender surrounded by her ridiculous 'guards' and 'advisors'.
Thus given their inherent disregard for laws, the Royalist government, at that point deeply corrupt and increasingly prone to suppressions of dissent by excessive use of force, decided to export uranium to the Japanese anyway despite their own ban forbidding it. This was due to the fact that on balance unlike the gold that they had pilfered from the working men of America and the rest of the world, the illegal export of some uranium was seen as a marginal concern. After much negotiations, the Japanese would agree to accept shipments of uranium ore in place of the gold that they had been initially promised, although in much larger quantities. The Japanese would however not forget this, which they have allegedly deemed yet another Western betrayal and would later claim this deal for the justification for the gold that they seized in their brutal campaign across Australasia. The constant supply of fissile material thus secured, the Japanese would thus get to work. Sourcing more from other foreign sources when necessary. The book and intelligence reports also seem to disprove the long time theory of the most likely point of uranium for the Japanese bomb being the German colonial regimes in Africa. Many have seen the former 'Mittelafrika' as the most likely source given the inability of the German central government to actually control what goes into and what comes out of these states. Indeed it is now more likely that most of it, at least until the defeat of the reactionaries at the hands of the American revisionists, would instead come from Canada. Despite the initially optimistic expectations by the Royalists, the uranium trade with the Japanese would doom their own atomic bomb program and with it any real chance of successfully resisting our forces. Whilst resource shortages have often been cited in published interviews with captured Royalist atomic scientists as the main cause for the failure of their bomb program, it has not been clear who or what was truly responsible for these shortages, until now. The Japanese, now armed with gold and uranium would go onto complete their terror weapon at some point before 1950, most likely in 1949.

uM5Uh4r.jpg

The German 'hands-off' approach to Africa has more recently been documented by visiting Swedish journalists, whose research
confirms what the public in the Syndicalist world has known for decades about exploitation of the Africans under German control.

Beyond their genetic tendency towards imperialism, the Japanese have over years proven that they are unable of progressing beyond copying the ideas of Western thinkers as can still be seen from their armed forces to this day. Combined with the published intelligence reports suggesting that the Japanese whisked away certain key scientists as well as data pertaining to more promising processes, it is rather clear that the Royalists would not only provide the Japanese with the funds, the resources but also the know how for building the horrific weapon that they would then turn on the Australasians in 1950. Some of our brethren in Australia have already become aware of this and have begun action against their dysfunctional corrupt puppet regime - a state that hates them and against the Japanese that pull the strings behind the curtains. They have begun to rise up against the slave shackles that the Japanese have thrust upon them and act against the efforts by their government to force millions of other Asiatics upon the continent in hopes of pleasing their Japanese masters and affirming the stranglehold of the latter over the Pacific Ocean. It is up to us in the British Islands, one of the few places, where the fires of revolution have yet to be extinguished by the wind of revisionism or the vacuum of reactionarism, to help guide our fellow working men to revolution. Only when the 'Windsors' have shared the fate of the Qing have in China wrought on them by the bourgeoisie revolutionaries of the Chinese Nationalists can the world be at peace. Unlike the Chinese however, our revolution will not deal in half measures and if necessary will bring these cowards and their sympathisers to justice even if we have to track them to the ends of the Earth. Their crimes against the people of Britain, humanity and the Earth itself must not be allowed to stand. We must put our trust in Comrade Mosley to lead us to this promised land, for it is only thanks to him that the British state survives sovereign and free from the reaches of imperialists, reactionaries and revisionists.

An article from the Daily Star on the 1st of May 1972, entitled "Shining Rocks - the Fate of the North American Gold Reserves and the Role of the British Exiles in the Japanese Atomic Bomb Project"
-----------------------------------------


Since it is now Monday in the wonderful land of Oz, I've decided to post another one of the things that I wrote. Hopefully since it is still the weekend we'll still see something new from Aussie/Teivel. In the meanwhile - I hope you enjoyed me slagging off the House of Windsor. This will probably be the last of these posts for some time, not for the fact that I will have to go into hiding to escape a mob of pro-Windsor hitmen but because my vacation is over and I'm going back to work. I do have some monstrous piece I wrote about Japanese educational reform... But I'll actually need to go through it to make it semi-coherent. So provided that Aussie returns to updating expect that when another lull happens. Just banter, love your work both here and on YT, Teivel.

One of the biggest regrets that I've subsequently had with the AAR was the fact that I really only featured "the Japanese perspective". I did do pieces overseas but they were from "me the Japan player" rather than "me the AAR writer with a wider lense". I hope this rant posing as a newspaper article helps create a somewhat better presentation of the view that I had of Japan from the perspective of the states that aren't aligned to it and the public in those states - in this specific case it comes from a British Syndicalist. Note - this like everything else thus far, this too tries to carry a degree of bias from the person that is the author of this piece inside the world, rather than from myself. I've tried to tone down the yellow peril aspect, but I felt it as a topic something too important to sanitize completely.

On another topic of a regret, I didn't really cover what happened in WK2, primarily since I as Japan had no part in it. My trade agreements with the Canadians, since I had relatively decent relations with them and they were willing trade with me despite my unwillingness to pay in cash or trade oil, is the basis for the majority of this narrative. Particularly the about uranium since the gold I could easily say was just "acquired" from a bunch of men at work that had pulled it there across the Pacific, but where the Japanese sourced the uranium for the bomb has always been a bit of an explanation problem for me. I obviously couldn't get it from Australasia since they wouldn't trade with me and indeed really hated my guts as far as AI go, China was an option that I alluded to a few times but problems there as well. The Russians definitely weren't going to sell to me, the Germans also probably not. Mittelafrika was always an option "covert stuff" wise - since although the Germans did their decision to break Mittelafrika apart they never got rid of Goering and his lackeys.

However continuing on the topic of WK2, I've been going over the files somewhat recently both to see whether I have the backing for some neat stories should the need arise and also for nostalgia. The conflict at times really was a massive comedy of errors. Take the Dover landing I referred to in the text, the British are totally surrounded with the Germans and the Canadians and even the French conducting a united blockade. The French take a port and then the AI completely flubs holding the beachhead, there are a grand total of 4 French divisions there and nothing else when it falls. Meanwhile when the French are getting knocked out of the only beachhead the Entente would manage, the Canadians attempt some bonkers landing in Scotland. Then the Germans beat a British naval force taking equal damage and then they decide to just peace out. The more that I looked through the files at the mass incompetence slap fight - the 7 separate naval invasions of Bermuda, whatever the hell allowed the SRItalians to hold on, the pandemonium in Morocco, losing their continental French lands on the one side and losing Iceland on the other, the more I became convinced that I did the merciful thing and let the AI fumble their way into the events to have America invade.
 
  • 2Love
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Oh what a wonderful insight into the zany world of Kaiserreich :)

The uranium story actually sounds like one of the more reasonable things to take place in the zany setting of USA falling apart and Canada trying to become a great power :D

As for the course of the Weltkrieg - AI on AI wars always need a ton of explanation to have a believable narrative spun from them. Just remember what Teivel had to come up with to explain why the French communards left the door to Internationale Europe so completely open prior to his Russian Empire's epic home run from the Elbe to the Portuguese Atlantic coast. :)
 
The Educational Reform of the Japanese Empire in the 16th Year of the Shōwa Era (1941)

The System as it Was
NvgjykH.jpg

The changes enacted to the educational system of the Japanese Empire as a result of the reforms of the 16th year of the Shōwa era can for better or for worse still be felt today. However to truly understand the revolutionary effects that these changes had and how they turned the Japanese Empire from a regional power of the post-Weltkrieg environment into the great power that it is today, we first have to take a short peak at the foundation laid in the eras that directly preceded it - those being the Meiji (1868-1912) and the Taishō (1912-26). During its rapid modernisation efforts in the Meiji era, the Japanese Empire had adopted a modern education system based, as with a number of other Japanese systems, largely on the Prussian model. The "Elementary Schools Law", passed in 1886, laid the foundation for the transition to a compulsory system of education, lasting at that time for the length of the elementary school course - then 4 years. The length of compulsory education would later be increased to 6 years in 1907, through changes to the curricula of elementary schools which lengthened the school program, and would remain at this length, despite numerous debates to lengthen it further, until the 1941 reforms. This system as well as its relatively zealous enforcement by both national and local officials, whether due to cultural values and/or the perceived economic benefits thought to stem from an educated populace, meant that by the end of the Taishō era the elementary schools henceforth referred to as primary education, enrolled nearly 100% of appropriately aged children within the Home Islands. Due to different standards, such as the lack of compulsory education, the colonial territories of Taiwan and Korea lagged behind the internal prefectures, although the attendance rate gulf was much smaller with Taiwan than Korea. The last year of the Taishō era saw the state also legally clarify the position of pre-school education, leading to a true blooming of kindergartens from 1931, once the worst effects of the 'Hoover crash' that lead to the American meltdown had passed. The increasing number of kindergartens would in turn lead to a considerable amount of women liberated, at least nominally, from childcare with a number of those women in turn finding employment at the aforementioned institutions. This liberation would lead to an increasing amount of women entering the labour market as well as creating a demand for a considerable number of women educated in childcare, as every institution needed a kindergarten teacher per 40 children, to a maximum of 3. Whilst was more a happy accident than a result of any actual planning, as little official attention was still given to the need for women to gain higher education, the pressure to provide education for women would help to begin the narrowing of what was a considerable education gap.

Although primary education in the Japanese Empire, at the end of the Taishō era, stood shoulder to shoulder with its contemporaries across the world having achieved stellar results given how short its existence had been compared to its counterparts, and had indeed even slightly pushed the envelope when it came to a child centric education, the same could not be said for its secondary education. Here the German model began to show its relative weakness in providing a uniformly well-educated populace as the Japanese lagged behind its contemporaries with less elitist systems. The best as well as the most extreme example of that being the educational system of the United States, where secondary school attendance rates would reach 50% of the appropriate age group in 1930, a feat unmatched by the rest of the world. Even the European Syndicalist powers would only achieve such rates in post-war age cohorts, despite still beating the Japanese who were by then hot on their heels. Even Germany on whom the Japanese had modelled their system stood ahead of them, if for no other reason than simply the fact that the imperial dominion that Germany had achieved over much of the world had allowed her middle class to expand at an unprecedented rate. This granted the new and much wider middle-class access to the quite academically rigorous and elitist world of German secondary schools. Due to differing systems however it has to be noted that the data on this topic is not directly comparable for two major reasons - those reasons being differing thinking when it came to mixed-sex as well as multi-track education. Whilst today most of the world, barring a few pockets, has adopted multi-track education, be it under the guidance of the 'Japanese', 'German' or the 'Syndicalist' model, at this point the old United States and a number of English speaking countries and nations inspired by them still clung onto to the single track model. Thus the entire United States attendance rate is based on academic education, whereas data on the aforementioned multi-track models varies greatly due to differing opinions on whether to include data from vocational schools when presenting numbers on secondary school attendance. It should also be noted that due to historic reasons a lot of data on the old United States is either lost or otherwise unavailable to us and thus the majority of the conclusions drawn about the Americans are based on either newspaper reports or documents smuggled out by those that fled. Irregardless the lead held by the United States is staggering and has lead some to suggest that the high percentage of people with an academic education, combined with economic difficulties or just a lack of jobs for them, helped spread the contrasting and combative radical ideologies that contributed to the collapse of the old federal state. The other often cited example is Romania, which too adopted a rather extremist position largely on the backs of peasants and university graduates. Additionally as mentioned before it also merits noting that differences in thinking about single-sex vs mixed-sex education, as well as whether there was much point in educating women at all as this line of thinking often went hand in hand with the single vs mixed debate, contributes to overall lower secondary school attendance rates in those states pursuing the single-sex model.

This 'educational gap' was not unknown to the Japanese officials working at the Ministry of Education at the time. Indeed during the entirety of the Taishō era there had been heated debates, which technically had kicked off during the the very late Meiji era, on whether there was a need to lengthen the period of compulsory education to at least to 8 years, if not more. Methods on achieving this varied from simply lengthening of the 'volksschule' period of primary education, as had been done during 1907, or through making parts of secondary education compulsory. The choice in method in these cases largely came down to how many years the specific bureaucrat in question wanted to keep children in schools. Unfortunately the ongoing demands of booming export economy from the Weltkrieg lead to no real action being taken as many figured that increased wealth would naturally lead to more secondary school attendance. The debates themselves however continued to rage and contrary to these expectations plans began to be drafted, but the economic crash following the defeat of the Entente as well as the naval build-up that followed would lead to further delays, as would the 'Hoover crash' during the early Shōwa years. Eventually reflationary policies, supported by increased resource extraction in Manchuria, lead to the Japanese economy stabilising and as budgets began to grow once more, the subject of education reform once again bubbled to the surface. The debate would largely take place as a part of the 'course alternations' undertaken by the Mitsuchi cabinet in the aftermath of the 1937 Constitutional Reform. Unlike the intervening decades, where economic realities of the state or the desire to not overburden guardians had won out, there was for now a clear cut desire and need to increase the amount of both upper and lower secondary school graduates. The pressure was felt particularly greatly from the newly formed MITI, which saw the lack of educated industrial labour as the prime bottleneck for the grandiose expansion plans that it had dreamt up for the Japanese economy. Although by 1935 Japanese secondary school attendance rates had risen to 20.4% for boys and 16.5% for girls, they still lagged behind their European counterparts. Whilst annual data likely exists for this period, information available to the public on this subject has sadly only been provided at five year intervals as almost a footnote in the Imperial Statistical Yearbooks. What we can glean seems to show that the majority of secondary school attendees leaned towards the academic or the academic-vocational track rather than the purely vocational track, much to the dismay of MITI that only grew louder in its demands for better trained vocational graduates. Thus the first action of what we now know as the 1941 reforms would end up taking place in 1939 and consisted of announcement by the Japanese government that tuition fees on all types of vocational schools would be abolished. MITI wasted no time in lobbying the Ministry of Education and sponsoring efforts by local governments to create new vocational schools as well as 'encouraging' the zaibatsu, smaller economic conglomerates and even government monopolies to form partnerships with existing and new trade schools to ensure that students were taught modern methods and to provide more direct routes to employment for new graduates.


The Japanese Multi-Track System Prior to The Reforms
uREiEoi.jpg

Given how the Japanese educational system was almost completely turned on its head with the 1941 education reform, it is perhaps best to first explain how the multi-track educational system in Japan looked prior to the reform efforts. Much like a railway, after which the system is in truth named, even though the terminus of the multi-track educational system is different, the point of origin for all Japanese education, with one small exception, was and still is the same. Modelled as mentioned before on the German model, the general elementary school was the Japanese equivalent of the 'volksschule'. Unlike any of the subsequent steps primary education in the Japanese Empire was, to an extent, multi-sex and would become even more so over time. Unlike its German counterpart lasted 6 years, starting at the age of 6. Despite the recent confirmation of kindergartens as the official pre-school educational facilities - the reformers did not see the need to stick a compulsory step before the start of compulsory education, as the benefits of pre-school education had still yet to be brought to light. They were also encouraged by the rapid growth of the amount as well as attendance of kindergartens in their decision to leave them as they had been following the passing of the 1926 "Kindergarten Law". The first branch off the Japanese education system, at this point, would be the schools for the blind as well as the deaf-mutes. Expanding largely as a result of the push towards a more child centric education, on the whole the establishment of special needs schools was still largely in its infancy. Even the aforementioned schools were at this point rather limited in number, located primarily in urban areas or as a subsidiary to a teachers college, also located mostly in urban centres. These schools would in general accept children after 3 to 4 years of elementary school, or in most cases home schooling, and depending on the needs of the child as well as the economic and other capabilities of the family take care of schooling these kids until a rather wide age range from 13 to 18. The reforms would largely fully separate special needs children onto their own path, similar to the only other way not into a general elementary school at this point, outside of home schooling - Peers Schools. Although technically not limited to just descendents of peers, at least until tertiary education, the Peers Schools are perhaps the best example of the elitist nature of the system accepting all sons and daughters of peers without exams but very rarely letting in commoners and even then only the very wealthy.

Barring the branch off for kids of the very wealthy or those with other special needs, the Japanese education would only truly begin to branch after the conclusion of primary schooling with the students were in theory presented with 4 major paths for their future. These paths were in turn themselves subdivided into smaller paths, creating a number of potential educational dead-ends that continued to exist regardless of the ire they drew. First, and technically peerless in prestige, barring the aforementioned Peers Schools, stood the extremely rigorous 7 year 'higher schools' sharing little in common with the single-track high schools that they are often confused for by the public. Indeed as one would expect from the high amounts of German influence, they were most similar to the gymnasiums on which they were modelled - although lasting longer than their German counterparts just as with elementary schools. In this role they were little more than highly prestigious and long term preparatory schools linked for the most part with their local universities, both imperial and medical. Before the reforms of 1941 these schools numbered, 25 and were further split into 8 'numbered' schools and 17 'named' schools, the latter taking their name after the prefecture they were located. Entry into these schools was seen as an almost guaranteed straight path to the aforementioned medical and imperial universities, at least for those that could manage to graduate. The relatively limited amount of imperial and medical university spots, as well as the prestige tied to those degrees at that time, meant that these schools could and would be extremely picky with who they would accept. Due to this pickiness as well as their quite high tuition fees they would over time become almost as dynastic institutions as the Peers Schools, although unlike the latter they were technically meant to accept the general public. Due to this transition into somewhat dynastic institutions the role of these schools in the overall mass of secondary school graduates would become increasingly marginal, despite these schools continuing to be founded in every prefecture and still bleeding off many of the best students, as the amount of secondary students increased rapidly following the 1941 reforms. Their continued existence can mostly be ascribed to the considerable backing that these institutions enjoy within Japanese bureaucracy, as this remained a place where graduates of higher schools still outnumber graduates of less elitist schools, this is particularly true of bureaucrats in more senior ranks. According to most recent data although technically meritocratic, the entire senior leadership of the Japanese bureaucracy is still made up of alumni of these schools and the universities, which they feed with high achieving students.

Following the 'higher schools' in prestige and offering the other potential academic track were the 5 year 'middle schools', which were once again unsurprisingly modelled on their German counterparts although offering a full secondary education. They proved slightly less elitist nature, accepting a 'whopping' 8% of secondary school attendees in 1935. Despite this they still levied rather high tuition fees much like their more prestigious alternatives, which made entry into them practically impossible for working class families and still quite difficult for the less well off parts of the middle class. The simple fact that they were more open to the public would however prove to be the downfall for their role as elitist institutions with the educational reform painting a proverbial target on their back. Many in the ministry felt that in addition to the increase in vocational secondary graduates, there would also be an equivalent increase to the amount of graduates with an academic education. This would see the eventual transition of middle schools into the academic school of choice for finishing or indeed gaining a complete secondary education in the years that followed the 1941 reforms. The fact that these schools offered the widest set of choices to secondary school students also appealed greatly to the bureaucrats in charge of the reforms that wanted to take the number of dead ends to an absolute minimum. The most attractive of these paths was the possibility for the more capable students to transfer to the much more prestigious 'higher schools' following 4 years of middle school, a change made to ensure an ample supply of replacements for those that had proved promising at first, but had subsequently failed to make the cut. Alternatively students of middle schools could complete their 5 years of secondary education and choose from a wide range of tertiary school choices - ranging from 2 year teachers seminaries, down from the usual 4, to become certified as educators on the primary level, 4 year teachers colleges to become teachers at a secondary school level, attending the less prestigious but still rather rigorous preparatory schools separate from the 'higher schools' system to gain access to universities or take a more vocational path and attend the numerous special colleges that taught everything from agriculture to dentistry and everything in between. The latter route would prove perhaps the most popular and provide much of the actual trained working professionals of the Empire for decades to come. Whilst not necessarily a major path for students at middle schools, the Army cadets schools would initially largely recruit from 13 to 15 year old middle school students, but a number would also originate from other sources.

Thirdly and offering the vocational branch in this multi-track system were the various vocational schools, split into agricultural, agricultural and forestry, commerce as well as manufacturing schools. These vocational institutions were additionally split into first rates, lasting a 3 years preceded by a 2 year additional preparatory education for a total of 5 years, or second rates, lasting simply 3 years. The first rates were intended to produce both mid-ranking technical and commercial specialists as well as true leaders in their fields, who after graduation would pass into the hands of the 'polytechnics' which taught everything that the special colleges didn't and more where the two overlapped. In contrast the second rate schools were intended to produce blue-collar workers that could quickly be pushed into their labour force at the ripe old age of 14 to 15. The pressing needs and ever louder statements of those needs by MITI for more highly trained and qualified technical workers would see the merging of these two different vocational branches during the 1941 reforms. This was done also due to a desire to decrease, the number of potential dead-ends and partially as there was a general belief that more modern working methods would take more time and require better skills to master. Overall these schools would enrol somewhere close 20% of of the age cohort for secondary school students in Japan by the 1960s, as well as going forward. They were however already on the way out as the dominant secondary school, as their peak would arrive during the late 40s and early 50s, when the effects of the 1941 reforms on the academic track had yet to truly take effect and the influence by the abolition of the tuition fees from vocational schools was felt the most. The reputation of vocational schools would vary greatly in the Japanese Empire, although as the access to academic schools was eased all would gain a slightly negative tint and begin to be seen as the road for those not smart enough to make it in a white-collar school the schools focused on manufacturing and agriculture were looked at with a degree of suspicion from the start.

Even though technically not counted providing a secondary education, due to providing only what is now understood as lower secondary level education, the advanced elementary schools made up the fourth and final choice in the secondary school level. In 1936, they enrolled the majority of the 66% of students that continued on studying after graduating elementary school. This reason would see merging of the advanced and general elementary schools into the national or general schools, depending on translation, during the 1941 reforms. During its heyday the advanced elementary schools were often seen as a stepping stone onto other secondary education routes, whilst only half of its graduates would actually continue on studying. Thus their attendees would be quite varied in their purpose for attending these schools, ranging rōnin students that had ended up there after failing the extremely demanding entrance exams into higher or middle schools to those with plans of attending the first rate vocational schools or cadet schools to those simply desiring to improve their status by enrolling in a teachers seminary to become primary school teachers or simply those wanting to study more before finding a job. Due to this very varied group of students, the length of attendance for advanced elementary schools would fluctuate wildly from 1 to 3 years. Functioning as the last and only bastion of multi-sex education in Japanese secondary education, the shortest attendees of these institutions would be the rōnin students that managed to prove that the second shot was all that they needed. This would also include girls that had failed the rigorous entrance exams to the only academic path forward for women at the time - girls higher schools. Given the single-sex nature it is worth noting that these institutions provided a thus far unmentioned 5 path, largely functioning as middle schools, but for girls. These schools would also provide the only truly open path for women to gain a tertiary education at the time - teachers colleges, of course gender separated, as well as the few special colleges and private universities that accepted women producing some of the very few female postgraduates of the period. Those leaving after 2 years would include more of the aforementioned rōnin that proved the third time to be the charm as well as those boys going into cadet schools and those boys and girls going into first rate vocational schools, although now as mentioned in single-sex environments. Finally those that would complete 3 years of education only really had one path open to them, for continuing education, which was also the only path to gain a secondary education without paying for tuition outside of the military prior to the 1939 changes - 4 year teacher seminaries. These were, as mentioned before, separated by sex and provided its graduates the qualification of primary school teachers, much like the shorter 2 year seminaries offered to graduates of middle schools and girls higher schools.


The Reforms
sz3Vu2I.jpg

The 1941 reforms would greatly simplify the system with the most visible change enacted being the decision to raise the length of compulsory education to 9 years. For the general public at this point, the change would mean that compulsory schooling would be extended until what had formerly been advanced elementary schools, which were as a result of the reform folded into the existing elementary schools to create the general or national schools. A notional degree of difference between the two stages would be maintained with examinations retained between the transition from one rank to another, primarily to ensure a continued flow of students to the more prestigious higher and middle schools. Although less visible, the decision to freeze all tuition fees at their current levels in all public secondary schools would perhaps prove to have the biggest influence on the Japanese educational system on a whole. The decision to freeze instead of abolishing the fees outright had come mostly due to pressure from MITI, whose bureaucrats were afraid of losing out on a large potential amount of graduates on the vocational track. Thus unlike the abolition of tuition in vocational education, which would see the attendance in those institutions surge rapidly, the tuition freeze would have a more long standing effect that allowed for the academic path to grow and expand at a slower rate. This came due to fears of overwhelming the existing facilities and staff as well as continued elitist concerns about what a rapid increase of lower class students entering the higher and middle schools would mean for the spread of radical ideologies among the student body. Given that the freeze had been designed to eventually allow them to enter, this change would slowly give rise to a previously non-existent school - the 2 year middle school. These would over time crowd out the 5 year middle schools and make up the majority of upper secondary schooling for boys. Local authorities would even at times force some of the less prestigious 5 year schools to adapt to changing realities and transition to 2 year programs. A similar process would be repeated in girls higher schools, although less due to pressure by local officials and more as a result of the 1941 reform itself, which had brought the school leaving ages for girls higher schools to parity with their male counterparts - the middle schools. These changes would see these schools also transition into institutions mostly offering 2 year program. Some examples, particularly in the private sector, would however continue to adhere onto the 5 year model. In exchange for MITI getting its way in regards to tuition fees for academic institutions, they would in return have to accept the increase of compulsory education to 9 years instead of the 8 that they had tried to push the Ministry of Education into. Whilst they would lose out on 1 year of extra labour from graduates of vocational schools, later internal memos would rate this additional year of education highly in aiding along the Imperial economy.

The result of these changes are perhaps best visible when looking at attendance rates, although pure numbers of schools, teachers and students jumped noticeably they are less easily comparable than percentages. Thus where as in 1940 only 28% of boys and 22% of girls attended upper secondary education, whereas in 1945 that number had reached 46.9% for boys and 43.6% for girls. Even though these numbers only reflect attendance and not actual graduation, there is a reason to suggest a large amount of these students graduated, as an increasingly larger portion continued onto tertiary education. This is reflected by a similar jump in attendance rates for tertiary schools with 10% of the male age cohort attending some variety of the above mentioned institution in 1945, up from only 5.6% in 1935 and 6.5% in 1940. The effect is also visible among women with 1.7% of the female age cohort attending tertiary education, up from merely 0.6% in 1935 and 0.8% in 1940. Whilst the attendance rates for women in higher education would still continue to lag behind greatly compared to their male counterparts, likely thanks to in no little part by many bureaucrats questioning what value could be gained from women gaining more education, coupled with societal pressures during the boom eras of the Golden Shōwa for women to take a more domestic role, the 1941 reforms would for the first time begin to see the educational gap between men and women, that had thus far only grown, begin to narrow across the board. Additionally, the 1941 reforms would be responsible for truly throwing open the doors of tertiary education to the masses more so than any other decision subsequently. Whilst this would have its side-effects, as proven by the increasing disorder in universities, colleges and other places of tertiary education during the 60s as well as lead to the gargantuan private institutions that would in part cause most of the aforementioned problems and which continue to dominate tertiary education Japan to the modern-day, it is largely seen as a positive step for the future of the Japanese Empire.


Effects of the Reform in the Colonies
rmZWF6c.jpg

The 1941 educational reform would also have an effect across the colonial possession of the Japanese Empire, primarily to a more direct intervention by the central government in what had thus been fully the purview of the colonial government. This intervention would see Japanese possessions transition almost full cloth over to the system employed in the Home Islands. Due to the nature of Japanese holdings at the time, only Taiwan and Korea had actually maintained their own education systems which were in broad strokes similar to one another and indeed the one in use on the Home Islands. The main difference of course being the lack of compulsory education with others stemming from ideological reasons, such as the desire to prevent the spread of dangerous ideas among the colonial subjects, but also more mundane ones such as the natives limited command of Japanese. Whereas the lack of compulsory education is often focused on, it was this last factor that formed the basis for the different approach to populations within their own territories. Those that were deemed to speak Japanese at an acceptable level, almost always just Japanese colonists or in extreme cases also Japanified locals, would attend schools that were run under the same rules and regulations as their counterparts in the Home Islands. Those that couldn't, making up a very large part of the locals, were sent to schools that operated under local rules and curricula, being called public schools in Taiwan and normal schools in Korea. This is where the common-part between the colonial systems begins to run out, as for example in Taiwan both Japanese and Taiwanese children would both attend the same schools starting from secondary education, a change adopted in 1922. Whilst this would mean little in the short term, as few Taiwanese reached secondary schools, in the long term, particularly after the 1941 reforms, this would help better facilitate the increased Japanification of the local elites of the following generation as the change was seen as less drastic. In contrast the colonial government in Korea would maintain separate schooling based on language skill, in reality ethnicity, until being forced to unify the systems as a result of the 1941 reforms. Between 1911 and 1937 the Korean colonial government had also maintained Korean and through it the teaching of Hangul as a subject in the normal schools. Even though previous separatist problems with the Koreans had raised questions about potentially dropping the policy, most bureaucrats saw ending it as the cause of more problems than solutions. This would change after the '3 Days in March' uprising in 1937 with the colonial government using it as an excuse to end the teaching of Korean and the Hangul alphabet, contributing to slight problems in regards to literacy. The central government would use this chance to pay back the German government for its role in these actions, leading to the now famous 'education programs' to China and German Indochina by army officers disgraced after the putsch attempt.

The colonial government would also use the uprising as an excuse to begin a crackdown on Seodangs - a network of traditional Confucian private schools that had long frustrated the efforts of the Japanese in establishing a modern school network in Korea and which many suggested had been training networks of nationalist agitators. In pursuit of this the colonial government would greatly expand the school network across the nation and began efforts to reach every child, regardless of background. Many have seen this effort as the bureaucrats staffing the colonial government of Korea finally beginning to take offence at the less than kind comparisons being made with to their co-workers in Taiwan. Many Ministry of Education bureaucrats had begun to see a posting in Korea as a personal insult and an affront against their honour. Due to a result of these efforts the school attendance rates would rise to a more respectable 36.9% in 1940 from just 21.7% primary school attendance rates among locals in 1935, even before the 1941 reforms came to force. In comparison to Taiwan however, Korea still continued to lag behind greatly with the island posting a 41.5% primary school attendance rate in 1935 and continuing to steam ahead at 57.6% by 1940. Many outside of Japan have seen the low school attendance rates as a campaign of civil resistance against the colonising power, particularly when making the point that compulsory education had been enforced in these territories, where as others have seen it as a direct effort by the Japanese to keep the Koreans down the reality likely lies somewhere in between. Whilst it is true that the colonial government in Korea didn't necessarily seem that interested in massively educating the native populace, given the agricultural nature of the colony at least as long as pressure from above remained low, demonstrated by the relatively limited investments in normal schools compared to the elementary schools attended by Japanese youth as well as the lack of compulsory education, the same was, relatively speaking, true for Taiwan which always showed higher school attendance rates compared to Korea. The question of dialect cards for those heard speaking anything beyond standard Japanese at schools has also been raised in regards to attendance rates, as a potential reason for the lower school attendance rates in Korea. Given that these would only really make their debut after the abolition of Korean as a subject and in a period which saw a rapid surge in school attendance among the Korean public unprecedented until that point, it is more than likely that it is a post-facto explanation for a policy which many saw as unpopular after the general public entered these schools.

Regardless of what had been before, the reform now fully mixed between all ethnic groups into one school system both in the colonies like the case had been at home. The compulsory system and the increased funding that followed from being brought under the aegis of the Ministry of Education would see Taiwan climb to a 74.7% compulsory schooling attendance rate by 1945 and achieve parity with the Home Islands in 1951, shortly before its appeal to Tokyo for its territories to be raised to equivalent position with the Home Islands. These educational achievements combined with the, according to government statistics, nigh universal understanding and use of Japanese at this point across the island contributed greatly to the decision to accept the appeal by the central government. In Korea however things continued to differ, given that the region continued to be plagued with internal issues as well as the simple fact that it began the transition from a lower starting position compared Taiwan, but by around 1944 it too had finally crossed the 50% mark and had reached about 51.5% of those targeted by the 9 years of compulsory education. As mentioned internal issues as well as resistance by parents and guardians, through their continued patronage of the Seodangs, would continue to plague the colonial government. This manifested in the fact that a disproportional amount of the admittedly small living standard increases enjoyed by the Korean public at the time, compared to those in the Home Islands, being direct primarily on these private schools rather than consumer goods as the central government hoped. In a more long term view it did somewhat seem that government efforts had begun to bear fruit, as the number of these Confucian schools had steadily declined from around 20 thousand in 1910 to just 3 thousand in 1945 as had their attendance and it was hoped that the Koreans could be weaned off their perceived dependency on these schools through increasing Japanification, but others remained pessimistic in their expectations. Their pessimism at the time seemed to be based on little more than fears as public comprehension of Japanese was also growing at a steady pace reaching reaching 24% by 1945. Illiteracy among the general public still remained something of an issue, largely due to the large mix of writing systems that had been advocated by the colonial government over the 20th century, but was increasingly becoming limited to the older generations that had not had the fortune of being born in the Korean nobility.


Towards a Global Position
ZxJuupR.jpg

Besides its colonies, the Empire would attempt to propagate its educational model across the territories that it saw within its sphere of influence. The rates of success varied rather greatly, for example attempts to export it to Qing China largely failed in the interior, but proved somewhat successful in the coastal cities, where the strength of the warlords was the weakest and Japanese influence greatest. The similarly German inspired system of the Republican Chinese would later find the transition of these schools and their own students to their own model quite simple and the curricula rather applicable. Despite intense pressure from the Japanese, particularly during the Marcos era, the one track system established by the Americans during their rule of the Philippines proved difficult to shift and proved the most embarrassing example of the failure of Japanese soft-power to propagate the system. Similar problems would be faced during the Japanese 'guidance' in reforming here in what remained of former Australasia with the system only adopted partially. First applying only to Japanese subjects, primarily children of soldiers and sailors stationed across the two states, and eventually all Asians, once the population grew large enough due to the demographic transition in the north of the country. There had been plans initially to expand the system to both Australia and New Zealand, but many in their governments saw the multi-track system as the potential cause for racial and cultural tensions as well as seeing vocational schools as potential hotbeds for further Syndicalist indoctrination of the lower classes, so reasons and excuses were found for how the occupation era officials saw that the idea stood in conflict with the Japanese guideline of liberalisation. Due to this reason, seeing long term stability as preferable to simply pushing its model onto a system that could provide unwilling to adopt it, the Japanese decided largely leave the working out of the Australian or New Zealand educational system to the nations themselves, that is the centralised Ministries of Education that they still pushed through. Over time Transamur would also adopt the Japanese model, as its Tsarist era multi-track model had long since become out of date and many seeing it as not fit for purpose. The Federated States of Oceania would prove to be the only state not officially aligned with the Japanese bloc to adopt the model, although as German influence waned the islands largely came under the economic and cultural domination of the Japanese.

In contrast to its largest failure, the Philippines, South-East Asia would also see the greatest success of the Japanese model in its application in the former Dutch East Indies. The colony, ruled in entirety by the Japanese between 1942-1956 and later split between the Japanese aligned majority Muslim Indonesia and the more varied Groote-Ost which remains under Japanese control to this day, would see the model applied rather early in Japanese rule with the bureaucrats deployed there seeing the transition quickly produce stunning success. Although initially not a target of Japanification efforts, this would change in the territories that remain under Japanese control after the Dutch revolt of 1948 bringing. Up until that point the de jure codominium with the Dutch had largely lulled the Japanese into a state of trust towards the Europeans that had made up the former colonial elite as well as the Christians that they saw as their allies. The persecutions that followed have often been compared to that of the Tokugawa Shogunate, primarily by more radical members of the Japanese Federation of Churches (JFC), and by other Christian organisations across the globe as pure barbarism. Whilst these comparisons would change little and indeed usually harmed the attempts at clamping down on the more outrageous policies, the JFC would largely succeed in influencing similarly minded politicians into holding bureaucrats responsible and stopping most of the persecutions by 1959, when Crown Princess Michiko joined the Imperial Family. Many sources have since claimed the transition to the Japanese educational system as one of the prime reasons behind the attempt by the Europeans living in the region to reassert their rule and throw the Japanese out. The stunning successes that the Japanese were looking at rubbed a lot of the Europeans the wrong way with many seeing it as a plan to replace them with the much more numerous locals and a number of Dutch veterans that survived the war and the expulsions citing mixed-ethnic schools as their main reason for fighting. Following the independence of Indonesia, under the leadership of Sukarno, the Indonesians would attempt to pursue domestic reform to the educational system but little of note would be changed over the years.

In this way they mirrored the Japanese themselves, as the the system although far from perfect and since recently target of increasing amounts of scrutiny, has thus far been unchanged. Indeed many officials have privately cited a lack of political or bureaucratic will for another empire wide reform of the system established 60 years ago. Despite this debates are once again increasingly ranging about topics such as raising the age of compulsory education up to 11 years, the conclusion of secondary education, as well as a search for a solution to the increasing mental strain that students find themselves under due to the intense pressure put on them to succeed. The Ministry of Education has thus far decided to stay out of the debate on an official level, whilst it has been documented that these same things are the subject of intense discussion in Kasumigaseki as they are in the outside world. More recently they have however come down as somewhat siding with reformist ideas by approving a number of pilots projects, on prefectural levels, to test the difference a 5 day school week has on students compared to the existing 6 day model. Similarly the ministry has organised a number of mergers between secondary schools in populations suffering from population drain that has even lead to the establishment of mixed-sex education on the secondary school. This goes to show that at least to a degree the Japanese educational system isn't glued to the 1940s, the system has also seen other discrete change within the boundaries established by the 1941 reforms through changes of the curricula. Examples of this are best provided by the decision to drop English as a mandatory foreign language in lower secondary education in national schools in 1949, following the fall of Canada to the Syndicalists as well as the backdrop of the increasingly tense relations between the Japanese and what remained of the exiles here in Australasia. This change brought these schools in line with the programs of the 5 year middle schools and girls higher schools, where students could a foreign language of the students choice that the school could provide, helping to streamline and standardise the system. Most students would still continue to learn English for the time being, as the resources of the schools following the reform favoured English purely due to the fact that the teachers were there. This is also how extracurricular activities, such as sports and cultural clubs as well as school festivals and sports days were officially established in 1953 - despite or perhaps because they were more or less the norm in most schools already. Even though forced attendance of clubs as well as the increased workload it puts on teachers is something that the Ministry has recently been coming under fire, the concept itself was quite revolutionary in the global sense. In many ways that can be said for the entire system on its 60th anniversary.

A collection of articles by Head Teacher Ariel Han Hong from the East Darwin Municipal Middle School for the Darwin Educators Weekly on the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the Japanese educational reform.
-----------------------------------------


A very merry Knowledge Day to you all. It seems our friend down under has once again been drawn to more important tasks. My time to shine I guess... Most of the things leading up to the reforms are based on the Japanese education system of the 1920s/30s and the reforms themselves are to an extent inspired by the actual reforms conducted by the Japanese government during the War. Of course with an actual focus on education and the fostering of a civilian economy that would fund the expansion of the Empire rather than just keeping boys in schools to keep them out of trouble and train their bodies and minds.

Next post will be no sooner than next month, but probably not I got work and I'm not at all pleased with the two ideas I've got thought up - those being the influence of Mitteleuropa on the German population in Eastern Europe and a piece on the final battles of the Royal Navy in the 'Ditch' after their attempt to flee from the "unfortunate incident" that hit the city of Sydney in 1950.

I've also tried less pictures in this post, if someone seems a shortage of them as a problem let me know and I'll add them in. Once my own eyes started glazing over, during rewriting this monstrosity I just thought that adding in pictures would just make people's eyes gloss over quicker. Also, if anyone wants links to the stuff I used for the more factual parts of this piece let me know.

Oh what a wonderful insight into the zany world of Kaiserreich :)

The uranium story actually sounds like one of the more reasonable things to take place in the zany setting of USA falling apart and Canada trying to become a great power :D

As for the course of the Weltkrieg - AI on AI wars always need a ton of explanation to have a believable narrative spun from them. Just remember what Teivel had to come up with to explain why the French communards left the door to Internationale Europe so completely open prior to his Russian Empire's epic home run from the Elbe to the Portuguese Atlantic coast. :)

Glad to see that you liked it. Even though it did just develop into a slap fight in the end, the Canucks put up a hell of a fight, certainly more so than was to be expected from the capacity of the country capital wise. Thus tying the American gold into it seemed like a smart idea, but since they'd probably see trading uranium which is at this point largely just a shiny deadly curiosity as less harmful than direct gold trades I would imagine that they'd try to pull off such a trade. Why the Japanese took it is of course another question, but eh slightly handwaving it away.

No doubt there, the almost decade long deadlock in Italy from my own AAR also comes to mind in this regard. What the Syndicalist Italians were fighting with in the end or what they were eating is beyond me, but somehow they held on.
 
Last edited:
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Still alive and kicking? I love it!
 
Still alive and kicking? I love it!
I would say less alive and kicking and more... Infirm and occasionally kicking someone once it gets bored enough. This isn't really an AAR at this point, more of something that I can throw huge walls of text at and give the nagging feeling in my head that I didn't waste the time I did looking somewhat into a topic. The school system one is very much that.

Speaking of which, probably no new post this month, maybe. As I mentioned before I've got something on the Royal Navy and the influence that MItteleuropa would've had on the German population of Eastern Europe still in the works. However the latter has changed from Mitteleuropa to just the UBD, for the most part, and since the schools thing seems to have employed a "reader reduction strategy" primarily since it's more akin to a rant or a short pamphlet then something I'd expect anyone to want to read on their screen I'm trying to keep it from spiralling out of control.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I would say less alive and kicking and more... Infirm and occasionally kicking someone once it gets bored enough. This isn't really an AAR at this point, more of something that I can throw huge walls of text at and give the nagging feeling in my head that I didn't waste the time I did looking somewhat into a topic. The school system one is very much that.

Speaking of which, probably no new post this month, maybe. As I mentioned before I've got something on the Royal Navy and the influence that MItteleuropa would've had on the German population of Eastern Europe still in the works. However the latter has changed from Mitteleuropa to just the UBD, for the most part, and since the schools thing seems to have employed a "reader reduction strategy" primarily since it's more akin to a rant or a short pamphlet then something I'd expect anyone to want to read on their screen I'm trying to keep it from spiralling out of control.
Oh, I love everything KR about post WK Mitteleuropa! Please do not feel the need to appease any particular hesitance against longer pieces on this topic. :)
 
The Great German Migration

It should not come as a surprise to anyone that the creation of Empire is always accompanied by the movement of the populace. These migrations do tend to vary by time and by country as well as in scope and direction, but they are always a present factor even if often overshadowed by the discussion of the main purpose of all colonial ventures - the exploitation of resources for the benefit of the metropole. Prior to the industrial era, and to a degree even after it, this exploitation is something that more often than not required a much more substantial population of loyal subjects to oversee these processes, which is seen by some as one of the main driving factors of settler colonialism. Thus in places where the native workforce was found lacking in number to provide the necessary rate of exploitation, or where simply the metropole had a need to do away with a certain portion of its metropolitan populace be it due to land or prison shortages, settler colonialism has followed. This type is perhaps best exemplified in the European conquest of the New World, or to turn to a more recent example the efforts of the Japanese to secure Australasia for itself through settling it with an ostensibly loyal Asian population, an offer that many here in India have taken them up on with open arms. The process of settler colonialism as we know it today can be traced back to antiquity - be it the Romans from whom English and many other Western languages draw their term for colonisation, the various city states of Mesopotamia or indeed the military-frontier policy of the Chinese Empires. This in a way stands out compared to the expansion of our Indosphere during that era, which many scholars argue had little if any movements of people. Thus settler colonialism is often categorised as the 'old model' of economic imperialism and subsequently many that seek to revitalise it choose ascribe to it the romantic ideals of the civilising mission, particularly when contrasting it with the 'new model'.

Discussion of the 'new model', as with most current things and events, is rather divisive and many both in and outside the academia choose to divide it into at least two independent parts with the former being the much more widely known examples of neoimperialism in the 19th and 20th centuries and the latter neocolonialism, a less widely known method of explaining continued domination of colonies by former imperial powers as well as something into which Social Imperialism is often cast. This is despite the fact that as more recent scholars have begun to point out that the only real major difference between those two and indeed the settler model is simply that, as technology has advanced, primarily in the fields of communications and weaponry, the amount of people, whose loyalties lie to the metropoles, that are required to maintain dominion over the natives has rapidly decreased. Given European dominance over global affairs from around the 1850s up until about the 1980s, it should thus not come as a surprise that unlike the 'old model', which is more an idealised form of many older traditions through the ages, this newer type of colonialism can rather firmly be placed at the feet of the Europeans. However arguments over as to whether various foreign dependencies from straight up vassals to client kingdoms and even indeed the Chinese tributary system can be seen as an earlier manifestation of the newer model have begun to shake this attribution, but that is best left for another discussion. This neoimperialism as many have begun to call it largely maintained the lip service of aiding the native population that it had inherited from settler colonialism. Except that instead of just bringing them the light of God, and through it salvation and civilisation, these new conquerors primarily brought with them the changed understanding of civilisation brought on by modernity. This method of colonialism would in reality differ relatively little from the settler colonialism that had preceded it, as experience in fair India shows best give the long period of European rule over parts of the subcontinent as well as the Muslim conquests, because as mentioned previously improvements into the fields of communication and weaponry meant that instead of relying on a vast amounts of loyal settlers, as well as natives that had been bought over as was also true with the older model, this form of colonialism would instead rely on a much narrower circle of people drawn from the bureaucratic as well as capitalist classes. The successful implementations of this method would instead largely co-opt local power structures in order to leave as small a footprint as possible to ensure that the anger of the natives was directed at their local rulers rather than the imperial power. Beyond India a similar pattern is seen repeatedly across European, American and later Japanese control over the majority of the rest of Asia, Oceania and Africa. Additionally, although separation into newer and older would imply that the new type has come to fully replace settler colonialism in truth as suggested before the system is not really something new and both examples still continue to be practised by the various imperialist and indeed social imperialist powers of the world.

7kzSORT.jpg

Whilst based on different principle the white man's burden was in many ways a continuation of the old
justifications that had spurred settler colonialism.

However, among more or less all examples historic and modern, the German Empire following the Weltkrieg in many ways truly stands apart as a colonial power. Not for its rule being particularly brutal or really anything else, but simply for the aforementioned migrations. This article is not meant to discuss the transfers of people under the Hindenburg Programme or its spiritual successor that was instituted following Black Monday and developed into an unprecedented nigh-command economy, which would both help and hinder the German Empire during the Syndicalist War as many more enterprising Germans had left the country for other European nations to escape the restrictions during that program. Germany would maintain this programme until rather ironically the demobilisation efforts by Schumacher, a social-democrat, brought an end to the crippling manpower shortages that the Empire had increasingly fallen into and allowed for a relaxation of which businesses were and were not vital for the continued functioning of the state. Although both programmes, as well as the 'guest workers program' that was introduced by the German conservatives to try and solve the increasing manpower shortages during the sheer paranoia of the *Watchful Peace' of the immediate post-war era have played an undeniable part in shaping the demography of the German Empire as it is today, it is not the subject of this piece. No, instead this article focuses on the trends visible in the movement of the German public as a whole in the German imperial sphere, more specifically it focuses on the trends in the United Baltic Duchy. Because despite the fact that the Germans were a rather late arrival on the world stage as a unified power, the German people were no strangers to colonialism or indeed imperialism. Most clearly of course this is visible within the Danubian Federation, dominated for much of its history by the Austrian Germans, but this story goes much deeper. Indeed much of what we now understand as Germany, particularly along the coastline of the Baltic Sea, was gained through these methods from its numerous original inhabitants belonging to the West-Slavic and Baltic peoples, the remnants of the latter we will return to later when discussing the UBD. In their divided state various Germans would also play a rather distinctive role in facilitating other nations conquests in the New World, the Russian conquest of Siberia and later even the neoimperialist efforts by various states in Asia and Africa. In general it can be said, that where ever any colonial power went you could always find Germans facilitating their efforts. Thus it cannot be said that the Germans were short on theoretical knowledge on the subjects of imperialism or colonialism, even if it can be argued that there was a shortage of practical knowledge in Germany itself as whilst Germany would find a colonial empire thrust upon it shortly after its unification, few of those in the colonies of other powers, as the long 19th century proved surprisingly tolerant in this regard, would return. The only real change in this regard would take place with the conclusion of the Weltkrieg.

1CDpMC0.jpg

British propaganda caricature from the Weltkrieg era about the forced deportations conducted by the Germans to secure labourers for the Hindenburg programme. These resettlement efforts would return in a different sense during the response to Black Monday.
The Great War saw any previous German officials in the other colonial powers at best forced out of office and at worst subjected to imprisonment or even execution. In the grand scheme of the war this would matter little as its victory in the war earned Germany not only its place in the sun, but many of these administrators would make their way to the Kaiserreich to aid in its imperial efforts to come. Following the confirmation, or as some argue the affirmation, of the German position as supreme global power following its acquisition of British territories ostensibly for safe-keeping, after the British Revolution of 1925, these people would prove invaluable in staffing the by now very very short staffed German colonial office. The peace conducted at Brest-Litovsk and later at Versailles had truly thrust upon Germany a magnificent continental empire that not only rivalled but surpassed that of Napoleon - Mitteleuropa, and the Peace with Honour not only ensured the survival of its existing overseas Empire across much of Africa and Asia, but also would lay the groundwork for its later expansion. In more ways than one the German Empire of the interwar era began to increasingly resemble a combination of Russia and Britain, just lacking the established institutional experience of either in how to deal with the respective types of Empire, despite ironically drawing from their former officials that had experience serving under both powers. Although unmistakably a great boon for the resource strapped German economy after the end of the Weltkrieg, the efforts to establish control over these regions would result in the German Empire massively overstretching its established resources of established manpower - something that rapid reforms could not fix. This meant that realistically speaking the Empire struggled to really actively control the bureaucratic apparatuses of the parts of Africa or Asia that it had gained from the British, Belgians or the French meaning that previously existing bureaucratic instances were largely kept in place. This was also true to a lesser extent in the colonial holdings of the German Empire that it regained after the Weltkrieg, as its rule had been severely weakened as a result of the Entente occupation. This lack of central control as well as a degree of distrust that the Germans held for the colonial elites in the territories that it held would hinder communication between the two sides and subsequently contribute greatly to the chaos experienced during the Chinese and Indochinese campaigns. Whilst the Kaiserbund policy of 1943 is largely seen as an attempt to remedy this situation, by introducing more loyal natives into positions of control, these failures as well as the policy itself are largely seen as the reason that we see the Asian periphery of the German Empire begin to crumble in the years and decades after the Syndicalist War, including a number of cases where the Germans are alleged to have forced independence on their colonies at gunpoint.

2H60Zye.jpg

Lost to the Entente nations in 1916, the German administration of Kamerun was quite decimated after the war.
Even though the planter class returned quickly finding new government officials proved hard in many cases contributing
to the development of the Göring era feudalism.

In contrast to a rather laissez faire policy, the Kaiserreich would maintain a rather harsh grip over Europe, given that most of these territories had been taken through active military conquest and maintained sizeable garrisons by Imperial Army forces even after the war on the continent ostensibly ended. Yet German control over these regions would not be remarkably more resilient. Whilst few would actively challenge the might of the Deutsches Heer, its controlled over the hearts and minds of the public remained strained. Perhaps the most extreme of these examples is that of White Ruthenia, where when the outbreak of the Syndicalist war saw all eyes turned West, the pro-German leadership proved so weak and incapable of a response not reliant on intervention by Berlin that it quickly found itself overthrown by pro-Russian factions that quickly sought protection under the aegis of the Russian State. Even though some states, like the restored Commonwealth, would benefit greatly from German rule in general even this restoration proved a source of brewing internal tension. Due to this the Mitteleuropa of the interwar era was often described as 'at best a rather muddled order that left few pleased, but even fewer ready to do anything' by a number of British exiles, most notably Winston Churchill. This situation only really began to breakdown in the decades that followed the Syndicalist War, much like in Asia not through a creation of real order but by a deepening of the crisis and increasing pressure from the natives to be treated as equals in their own countries. There is nowhere that better exemplifies both the ordered chaos and the breakdown than the United Baltic Duchy. Formed during the Weltkrieg out of the three former Baltic sea provinces/duchies of the Russian Empire - the United Baltic Duchy was never necessarily meant to be an independent state. Whilst some German officials would try and make an argument of working together with the native population of Esthonians and Letts, the general sentiment among the German leadership, drawn from the sizeable local German population, was that the locals were incapable of self-rule having been incapable of creating a state of their own during the last 700 years and were at best fit fodder for Germanization. The problem was of course how to achieve said Germanization as the decades that had seen Russification come to force in the region had seen the native intelligentsia that proved unwilling to Germanize deftly use the Imperial government as a cudgel to weaken the grip that their former landlords and masters held over the common man in the previous decades. This alliance would only be broken by the failed 1905 Russian Revolution, which saw the Czarist forces reform their alliance with the local gentry against the native peasantry and proletariat.

o8vp1kI.jpg

Punitive troops arresting peasants following the failed Russian revolution in 1905. The troops were often made up of government forces bolstered by local units drawn from the nobility that had become the main target of the revolution in the Baltic sea provinces.
Regardless of this, the damage to the German position had already been done and many Germans were unwilling to trust the Russians to not change their mind once more, which would occur with the outbreak of the Weltkrieg. This distrust lead to many Baltic Germans that had thus far been a staple of the Russian court, military and bureaucracy even during the period of Russification to emigrate from the Russian territories to the Americas as well as back to the Kaiserreich or the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Although Germans had made up around 5 to 6% of the population on the Eastern coast of the Baltic sea in the late 19th century, their proportion to the native population would begin to take a massive nosedive eventually approximately halving by the outbreak of the Weltkrieg. Even though at first one would suspect increasing native population numbers through a population boom as the main culprit, the truth is far from that. During this period the fertility rates of the Baltic were more similar to that of post-Napoleonic France than the rest of Europe. Instead this occurrence, which was of course not be limited to just the UBD but it was here that it was first noticed and described, had to do with Germans returning back to their ancestral home countries. Thus even as German officials back in Berlin dreamed of Germanizing the provinces the plan was already being undermined by the feet of the German public. First hopes were quite grandiose with plans drawn up to introduce approximately 2 million German settlers into the region in 1919 alone and settle them primarily as a sort of farmer-soldiers reminiscent of an idealised Roman colonist rather than in the cities that had historically held the absolute majority of the local German population. Initially it seemed that the both the Imperial and Ducal governments seemed to be making serious efforts to realise this colonial adventure to strengthen their foothold in what had been deemed the Eastern bulwark of the Kaiserreich, but cracks began to show quickly. The government of the UBD relied heavily on the Baltic German gentry for support and was indeed largely made up by them as well, the latter unsurprisingly proved quite unwilling to part with their lands - at least without fair compensation, the rates of which were going to be defined by them of course as the local officials tasked with such decisions were also Baltic German. Whilst some land could and would be reappropriated from disloyal Esthonians and Letts, many of those that had actively opposed the Germans were urban in nature and those from the rural areas were primarily either smallholders or tenant farmers, which made the land reappropriation efforts rather worthless for benefiting the settlement of a large population of Germans. Given that the landlords owned nearly all of the woodlands and approximately 60% of the farmland, the Ducal government soon found itself between a rock and a hard place, unwilling to threaten its only real domestic pillar of support.
4TrzyGU.png

An illustration of the lands belonging to the Siklecht manor. Whilst peasant landownership had become more
common since the end of serfdom, especially in Northern Livonia, most peasants were still crofters.

This is however where the aforementioned movement of people comes into effect. Even the most optimistic of suggestions state that between 1919 and 1936 only about 10 thousand Germans would arrive in the Duchy, a number which most can note is much much smaller than 2 million. Most of the returnees were primarily members of the gentry or petite bourgeoisie that had departed, rather than the farmers that Berlin or Riga had hoped to see take the front stage. In contrast around 30 thousand additional Baltic Germans would leave to the Kaiserreich or to the wider world with a secret census conducted in 1936 suggesting that the population of Germans in the United Baltic Duchy had dipped dipping below 100 thousand. Thus by 1936 the process, described quite succinctly in German as Umsiedlung had reached a position that can at best be described as an abject failure. In addition to the difficulties in drumming up land for the colonists, the failure is also thought to stem from the fact that settlement in the Baltic seemed a rather dull and meagre existence for the post-Weltkrieg German soldier. In contrast many saw the colonies in Asia and Africa as a more thrilling and rewarding experience, even before the rise of Hermann Göring as Statthalter and the potential of even a man of rather modest background rising to rule over a small fiefdom, if he knew who to suck up to and how to grease the wheels. The issues in the Baltics were compounded by the fact that many of the landlords, became increasingly removed from the day to day affairs of ruling over the lands that they owned often delegating rule to more trustworthy natives, or worthy sons, and instead preferring to live in the more 'civilised' portions of Europe. A number would take increasing gambles in investments in the then seemingly limitless expansion of German industry, which would pay dividends for those that managed to bet right at least until Black Monday. All in all, this sharp decline in the number of Germans combined with the rather muddled approach to education by the ducal government meant that the growth of the native intelligentsia began to rapidly outstrip the rate of Germanization, largely ongoing through mass media and higher education, at an alarming rate. Due to their largely rural backgrounds, the collective attention, and often anger, of these native elites was rather quickly turned back towards their increasingly absentee landlords, who controlled more land on average due to having continued to dwindle in numbers despite the growth in native land ownership. Although most of the loudest troublemakers would be rounded up as Syndicalists during the 'isolated incidents' that took place during that the interwar era, primarily subjected to deportation in the many overseas territories that Germany had, and another large proportion being rounded up at the outbreak of the Syndicalist War, mostly meeting the same fate, quite a few would persist and remain a perennial problem for the German leadership in Riga as well as in Berlin. The genie was now truly out of the bottle and their voices would only continue to grow louder and more problematic over time as the German population in the Duchy continued to contract, in spite the ever so slight surge that followed the evacuation from the Rhineland and 'labour management' efforts during the Syndicalist War. Consequently the natives of the Duchy would continue to gain more rights as the German leadership tried to somewhat unsuccessfully pursue a policy of divide and conquer through policies intended to aid the creation of the so-called "Juniper" or "Hut" Germans. Whilst the latter group would help to slow the decay of Germanization by the end of the 20th century the upper classes of the Duchy had increasingly 'gone native'.

We can see similar trends also begin to unfold at later times in the rest of Mitteleuropa with the Auslandsdeutche increasingly leaving their homes and travelling to the Imperial centre. The staggered timing of this can largely be attributed to the fact that unlike in the other parts of Europe that held significant German diaspora, the one in the United Baltic Duchy was very heavily tilted towards the upper class. Due to better career opportunities most of these Germans would begin to leave following the arrival of Mitteleuropa, spelling an end to the diaspora. In contrast to this the populations in other parts of Mitteleuropa such as the Germans of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, Ukraine and White Ruthenia were much more equally spread out through out the classes. These groups had formed full, if parallel, communities and proved quite a bit harder to budge, but particularly in even they would begin to move after conflicts based on ethnicity began to break out at an increasingly alarming rate following the Sevastopol massacre, the Kiev bloodbath, the events of the Slavic Spring. The same was true of the German settlers in and across the Russian state, where increasing Russification efforts by the Russian junta were putting quite a bit of pressure on them despite appeals to Berlin for aid. Most of those that left would choose the safety of the German cities and urbanize, but a notable proportion would move to Africa, where their expertise was put to rather 'good use'. This stood in sharp contrast to the overwhelmingly Mennonite Germans from Russia, who wanted little to do with the militarised urban living offered by the Kaiserreich or indeed much less with the aggressive and bloody conquest of Africa perpetrated by Göring and his lackeys with the majority of them instead heading to South America. This migration would go onto have a significant influence on modern global affairs as unlike in Russia the emotional appeals by the descendents of German Mennonites to their brothers over the sea would push the Kaiserreich into intervening to put a stop to the A-ABC War, alongside a wide range of other economic and geopolitical reasons.


9Pz8cHI.jpg

German marines in their intervention in the A-ABC War capturing the Islas Malvinas from the invading AUSS troops
that had seized the islands as a naval base and a launching off point for an attack on Buenos Aires.

Considering what has been mentioned earlier it is also probably not surprising that in contrast to any of the other German colonial holdings, the population of Germans in Africa would surge massively with the most estimates suggesting that by the mysterious death of the Staathalter Göring in 1943 after a decade of rule and the subsequent division of Mittelafrika that around 1 million 'Germans' lived on the Dark Continent. Much has been said about Görings methods both the coercive, such as the short period in the 1930s where the German government had approved the exile of criminals that Göring considered loyal to Mittelafrika, as well as the non-coercive, such as the considerable financial boons he offered to settlers. The first cooling of spirits would only really be felt after the fall of the French Empire and the establishment of the Syndicalist states along the northern border of the 'successor states', but the migration would only really begin to dry up following the Sierra Leone crisis, which saw the Germans lose control of a region with practically no white settlers as well as the start of the Afrikan Bush War in the 1970s. The Bush War, much like the German intervention in the Americas, is another fine example of the massive geopolitical influence that migration brings with it. The conflict would last nearly a decade leaving the Kaiserreich exhausted and eventually pushed from most of its African holdings barring the Southern Cone of Africa, or Apartheidia as the region is now often referred. The efforts to save the Cone would only really be accomplished thanks to nigh titanic efforts by the South Africans that saw the rolling tide of Syndicalist advance as a threat to the stability of their own regime and would thus prop up Namibia, the Central African Federation and the Independent Lusitanian Republic of Moçambique as buffer states. These states would absorb what was left of the European and even some loyalist African populations that managed to flee retribution by pro-independence factions following the collapse of the post-Mittelafrikan states. Germany itself would only maintain direct control over the islands of the Zanzibar Archipelago, which had played a pivotal role in the evacuation of Europeans during the final chords of the Bush War, and Djibouti up until its independence at the turn of the millennium. Many have seen the migration of the Germans back to the Kaiserreich as a kind of brain drain occurring to deal with the large amounts of over-extension that Germany suffered as a result of its frankly stunning and surprising victory in the Weltkrieg. Others also point to quickly increasing living standards in the metropole that lead to few to want to risk their life on the frontiers of civilisation, unless the rewards were overwhelming such as was the case for German settlers in Africa. In this dash to the metropole, the Germans would often be accompanied with Africans, Asians and indeed other Europeans. Many of them would last three arrive as guest workers, hoping to fill the needs of the ever hungry German industrial machine for labourers, whilst others would arrive as students, spouses and other dependents. All of them would inevitably contribute greatly to the varied and colourful ethnic make-up of the German Empire of the modern day introducing a number of their traditions that have since been adopted as inherently German.

KNwBPTv.jpg

The German Schutztruppe were more often than not supported by 3 or more Askari in their helicopter based raids during the Bush War. Whilst the German government would make an effort to save some Askari during their evacuation to Zanzibar, many were lost, particularly those fleeing to Apartheidia, causing quite a deal of outrage in the domestic press.

Giulia Garzonio, professor of Eastern European studies University of Bombay
-----------------------------------------

Oh, I love everything KR about post WK Mitteleuropa! Please do not feel the need to appease any particular hesitance against longer pieces on this topic. :)

Well it's your funeral. :D Just kidding this one isn't nearly as long as the last one. About half the characters last time I checked.
 
  • 1Love
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The Ditch Splat a Rat

It is probably fair to state that we all see ourselves as the heroes of our own story. This statement seems to ring true both for individuals as it does for the organisations that they make up. For better or for worse, history provides us with numerous examples of such behaviour, but given that the general public finds the more recent past much more exciting than the lives of those faded into the sands of time the discussion on this subject always returns to that of the British exiles. Following the Revolution of 1925 and intensifying at an increasing pace in the mid to late 30s in the lead up to the Syndicalist War the British Exiles began to to portray themselves as nigh Arthurian figures with an equally difficult struggle laying ahead of them. Their Syndicalist foes, who stood in the way of what they believed to be their destiny and birthright - the liberation Britain from the grips of the usurpers, thus increasingly began to be slightly schizophrenically caricatured as both pushovers, the Picts and Saxons of Arthurian lore, and as towering villains or traitors like Mordred. This latter category would be the role of that the British leadership, dominated at later dates almost exclusively by Oswald Mosley and his inner circle after their rise to power following the Second Peace with Honour. Due to this mentality of superiority over their insular rivals, as the Mordred comparisons would only really become official policy after Mosley took the reigns well into this nigh decade long conflict, an almost foolhardy certainty in the inevitability of their victory over their Syndicalist rivals would thoroughly infect every organisation that the Exiles controlled during the years leading up to that fateful intervention in 1940. Sadly for the fate of the British Empire, and the organisation itself in question, this mentality would become almost mandatory in the previously quite balanced Royal Navy, due to its high reliance on the Exile officers, meaning that in the conflict the Royal Navy would prove incapable of delivering the knock-out blow and relegated to little more than a few Phyrric victories. The mercy that the British would seemingly provide their rivals as they limped off the coast of Iceland at the start of the war would later come back to haunt them as it is then that many brought up in the Arthurian indoctrination would once again learn that there is big gap between reality and fairy tales. The fact that they were not the hero in this story had by 1950 become clear to all but the most indoctrinated officials and the associated mono-myth about British exceptionalism that had been cultivated for decades had begun to crumble. In that year it seemed as if the broadcasts by the IBC from Down Under got more and more venomous by the hour as further reports filtered through the censors about the state that the Entente and its armed forces now found themselves.

JwIwPW7.jpg

Whilst a lot of the broadcast time would be spent on attacks on the Republic of India, labelling it a nation of Iscariots,
a considerable amount of time would also be spent going back and forth between pleading intervention from other foreign
powers and lashing out at them, as well as internal rivals, for abandoning them to this current predicament.

The attacks conducted at internal rivals were largely tied to the failed peace summit with the Syndicalists in 1947. The talks had cost the then ruling Exile 'Liberal' clique in Canada a lot of political capital and their subsequent failure had caused them to fall from grace with the infighting that followed not only after the talks, but also during the talks themselves by both the representatives of the various dominions as well as the 'Tory' and *Imperialist' cliques that intended to sabotage the talks at all costs has been cited by many notable scholars of the 'British Civil War' as one of the primary reasons for the surprisingly rapid collapse of Canada against what many have deemed a mismanaged and incoherent American advance. Irregardless of what had lead them to this moment, it was clear to many that 1950 would likely mark the final chords of the war and through it the British Empire. The Boer victory in the South African Civil War had cost the Empire Africa and many loyal subjects, now either in exile or in the ground in shallow graves across the Cape. What ANZAC and Exiles forces had managed to break their way out of Canada, or indeed Italy, through the Syndicalist blockades had been thrown into the meat-grinder in the Françafrique against a seemingly unending tide of Syndicalist manpower and ordnance as well as betrayal and reprisals by locals with seemingly no way out. What naval assets remained of the Entente Mediterranean Command, now a command more in name rather than in function or size, were now locked in various ports in Algeria and Tunisia strapped for fuel, ammo and subject to occasional shelling and air raids by the increasingly bored crews of the British Republican and American People's Navy ships waiting for them just beyond the reach of their guns. Whilst the situation was dire in Africa, it was even worse in what remained of the Caribbean Federation. Following the seizure of the islands deemed useful or important, the Americans seemed willing to wait out the collapse of the Royalist government on the islands, a process they hoped to speed up through famine and revolution. Both actions were enacted by the same American ships with the ones enforcing a hard blockade of the remaining Federation islands also actively 'losing' crates of old materiel off the beaches of the islands, which would then surprisingly quickly find their way into the hands of various guerilla groups across the islands. Things were somewhat better in Australasia its territory as of yet untouched by the war, but it seemed to many that even the indomitable ANZAC sprit was seriously being eroded by defeat after defeat as wit increasingly fell by the wayside to be replaced by cynicism.

KnzdpK7.jpg

More recently American televisions like the 'Adventures of Captain Morgan' have begun to shed some light,
propagandistic as it might be, into to role of American secret agents in the West Indies.

Despite the horrific circumstances that it found itself in the Royal Navy would deliver one last ray of hope for the beleaguered Entente defenders giving hope to some that the war was not yet truly lost, although ironically this would come through loss of so many during a retreat. In the early days of April 1950 what remained of the Mediterranean Command, at this point made up entirely of the light cruisers HMAS Colombo and Perth, the latter being much more modern than the former, and what remained of the 3rd, 4th and Kanimbla Transport Flotillas would stage dramatic escapes slipping from port under the cover of night and attempting to break through the American as well as British patrols to make it to neutral ports. Many historians with a pro-Royalist bias have often seen the mad dash as truly symbolizing the undying nature of the ANZAC spirit that had allowed the Empire to cling on for as long as it had until this point. Less favourable reviews of the encounter have cited it as a result of the aforementioned hero complex cultivated by the Exiles taken to the final extreme with dire consequences. Some sources, particularly Syndicalist ones, have also subsequently ridiculed the escape as a repeat of the mistakes of the Weltkrieg suggesting that these were the actions of insane officers willing to throw away the lives of their crews and men for some questionable chase for glory before the harrowing that was to come to them. True to their character however, the Syndicalists have quite successfully intermingled fact and fiction as from what sources we do have of those that took part in the break out, it seems that the officers, ratings and indeed even all the civilian evacuees that piled onto the troopships were made fully aware of the risks involved and yet still chose to take a gamble to escape nigh certain death in Africa. Many would perish as the sea and the Great Barbary Turkey Shoot, as it became known in later American sources, would claim not only lives but what remained of the Mediterranean fleet with only the HMAS Colombo limping it back to Australasia relatively intact. HMAS Perth would be sunk and go down with all hands on the 3rd of April by the French Syndicalist Exile Battleship Languedoc, which had managed to make it to Britain following the collapse of the Commune and eventually found itself press-ganged for duty with the Mediterranean Expeditionary Fleet as Mosley had little trust towards the French and wanted as many of them involved in the fight rather than garrisoning Britain proper. The 3rd, 4th and Kanimbla Transport Flotillas would be ravaged by air strikes launched by the American carrier CSS Overpass with only 2 out of the 15 ships eventually reaching the neutral port of Cartagena in Spain for internment on the 4th and 5th April, having saved who they could without risking their own lives.

The actions of the British and American fleets in the Mediterranean would be dominated by a story that would go down in naval legend rivalling the hunt for Graf von Spee during the Weltkrieg by the British squadron - the hunt for the HMAS Colombo. Its eventual escape into the wide open stretches of the Indian Ocean on the 8th of April would come mostly due to the pity that Franz Kress von Kressenstein, the German commander of the Suez Canal Zone, took on the battered Aussie vessel. However no small part would also be played by the unwillingness of the Syndicalist commanders to draw the ire and potential hostility of the still very militarised Germans by attempting to sink the ship during its transit through the canal, an action which would end up weighing like an anchor around the future careers of the captains that had let the Colombo escape their grasp before she made it to the Suez. Most British and American high-ranking officers involved in the chase would largely get away with slaps on the wrist or deferrals of promotions with the exception of the two American admirals that had been in charge of the blockade, that had also been deemed political liabilities, that were forced into retirement. In a similar vein the captain of the Languedoc would be recalled back to Britain and executed following a court martial, this had more to do with the captains' own continued tirades against the Breton Commune and attacks on the British for betraying their French Comrades rather than any active policy on behalf of Mosley of getting rid of senior Communard officials. The fact that the Colombo would eventually share the same fate as the rest of the Pacific Fleet mattered little in the here and now, where its escape would prove an invaluable propaganda victory, providing a much needed boost to Australasian morale, particularly as news about the sinking of the other ships involved in the escape were largely hushed up for some time. The public once again began to put their faith in the steel wall of the Pacific Fleet, which whilst significantly mauled as a result of the chaotic evacuation of Canada was still considered by many proponents of the large gun theory as a serious force to be reckoned with at least by the standards of 1950. Due to this very heavy reliance on the battle fleet to make up of the Pacific Fleet, it is worth noting once more that contrary to popular myths spun by various 'historians' that the Royal Navy was not ignorant to the power presented by naval aviation, having both pioneered the practice and having used it against its Republican rivals in the fierce aerial battles over the North Atlantic. The escape from Canada and the subsequently increasingly desperate fighting in the Atlantic and later within the Mediterranean itself had cost the Royal Navy 5 of its 7 fleet carriers and 23 of its 25 escort carriers by the second quarter of 1950. Out of the four Royal Navy carriers remaining only HMAS Kiwi was a true fleet carrier as we now understand it with HMAS Wellington being a light carrier and the remaining two being the escort carriers HMAS Albatross and Pegasus. Thus the fact that the Pacific Fleet was in many ways more reminiscent of the Grand Fleet during the late Weltkrieg - consisting as it did of 11 battleships, 6 battlecruisers, 5 heavy and 14 light cruisers, as well as the aforementioned 4 carriers - had not been a willing choice but the result of a rather harsh campaign by their foes to force them back into the past.


TZ6JH7n.jpg

The HMAS Colombo in port at Perth following its fearless escape.
Despite this boost in morale, the issues for the Empire or indeed the Royal Navy still remained largely the same. Although the majority of the ships still had their munitions and were capable of replacing them at a reasonable rate, thanks in no little part to large investments to create munitions plants in Australasia, the Pacific Fleet was severely hampered by mindbogglingly terrible fuel oil shortage, a problem that pre-war planners had noted but had been unable to solve to a satisfactory level, instead banking on a short conflict. The late war attempt by the Australasian officials to solve this short fall of the Royal Navy - the facilitation of the European uprising in Indonesia against the Japanese, had only succeed in costing the Australians valuable war materials, good men and seriously harming relations with the Japanese. The uprising had also turned the focus of Japanese attention away from Chinese sabre-rattling and increasingly into the South Pacific, as the lobbying efforts by more junior Navy officers and MITI officials about the threat that a hostile Australasia could present, especially under the Syndicalist aegis, and the resources that could be gained from it finally managed to over take the traditionally China focused Japanese foreign policy. Due to this many Australasian officials that managed to survive the war have stated that the only real thing that the Indonesian uprising succeeded in doing was painting a target square on the back of Australasia. Upon the failure of the attempt the Labor government, which had been heavily involved in drafting and approving the plan, decided to push the blame on the Royal Navy and hung them out to dry - cutting their resource allocations, particularly aerial assets and instead chose to back the Army and their new plan - a plan and force that it saw as decidedly loyal to itself unlike the Exile dominated Navy. These cut backs as well as distrust sowed in the minds of their political masters meant that the growing Japanese build up in the former Dutch East Indies went largely unnoticed by the increasingly infrequent Australasian patrols. Those reports that did catch wind of it and even managed to somehow make it to the desks of the people in charge mostly went unheeded with the political leadership more concerned about the growing Syndicalist threat, allegedly putting out feelers for renewed peace talks particularly as the French continued to collapse, and were under the impression that the Japanese were simply ramping up their anti-insurgency operations rather than preparing for any sort of invasion of the vast Southern Land. The Japanese themselves were eager to feed those opinions through the unofficial talks that were taking place in neutral Manila under the watchful gaze of the exiled American Federalists. The invasion that followed on the 24th of June thus genuinely shocked many senior Australasian cabinet members including the prime minister himself. Yet the shock did nothing to change reality, war had finally arrived on Australasian shores.

yK7Tvwg.jpg

Although a semi-regular guest before the Indonesian revolt, its aftermath as well as the period in the lead up to and following
the conquest of Australasia made the Imperial Marines regular guests and acquainted with the 'first island chain' that the Japanese planned to use to their advantage against any European intervention in their Pacific backyard.

Northern Australia would see the brunt of the fighting in these early days of the war. Unlike the conflict on the land and in the air, that was focused mostly in and around the city of Darwin, the naval aspect of these first days would be focused on the Torres Strait. Following the outbreak of war, the Pacific Fleet of the Royal Navy, located in Fleet Base East, set forth at full steam almost as soon as the order came down and crossed into the Gulf of Carpenteria on the 28th of June. What they did not know is that the day that they arrived in the Gulf was also the day that the Japanese forces on the ground relayed messages back to Tokyo announcing that they had firmly secured the beachhead. Whilst the Royal Navy forces were well aware that the situation in the city was presumed dire from the get-go, as the amount of defenders in Darwin had never been that great nor was the city at the time particularly big, none of them had expected that the Japanese could conduct an opposed landing operation and secure the territory that they had in less than 4 days. News about the fall were also delayed by the fact that the force had adopted a policy of strict radio silence, primarily in a rather foolhardy attempt of catching the Japanese as unaware as humanly possible. However even if the force had been kept aware of the ongoing news they would've likely still been unaware of the situation on the ground as the Royal Australasian Army still claimed to be contesting the control of Darwin. Many have wondered whether the Royal Navy might have turned back and caught the Japanese unaware at later date, had they known of the fall of Darwin, but it is more than likely that the plan would have stayed the same as the relatively narrow waters around Northern Australia were much more suitable for battleship engagements than the wide emptiness that favoured the carrier - such as in the Tasmanian Sea. The plan, drafted by Admiral Harold Farncomb, commander-in-chief of the Pacific Fleet, figured that if Japanese air patrols could be bypassed then the force could conduct a night battle against the Japanese carrier force and retreat before the Japanese could mount an adequate response. Unfortunately for the Australasian force the plan began to come to pieces before it could really even be put into action as the IJN Southern Command in Batavia had largely predicted that something like this would be tried and their guesses seemed to be confirmed after undercover operatives in Sydney reported the departure of the Pacific Fleet, despite the threat that it posed to their lives. Armed with this foreknowledge the Japanese 3rd Air Fleet already in position in the Gulf of Carpenteria to support the ongoing fighting in New Guinea had its bombing missions largely scrubbed and was put on high alert with the order to coordinate patrols with the 4th Fleet, currently conducting operations near Fiji and within the Solomon Islands, to locate the Pacific Fleet and render it a non-factor for the near future. Flying boats were dispatched to the most likely course of the fleet and and managed to eventually locate it steaming past Brisbane from which point onwards the 3rd Air Fleet would keep close track of their positions up until their entry into the Torres Strait on the 28th of June.

29qCprV.jpg

Although efforts had been made to develop ground based airbases, difficulties in the wide reaches of the Pacific as well as a
strong lobby for flying boats meant that the Kawanishi H8K4 still remained the main work horse of Japanese long range naval patrol.

The choice of the 3rd with its 3 carrier divisions has been often seen as an odd choice by historians as it was rather clearly the smaller of the two Japanese Air Fleets deployed for the operation. The 6 carriers of the force offered quite a bit more limited of a strike compliment compared to the 9 carriers of the 2nd Air Fleet, consisting of 4 divisions and the command carrier Unryū, however it is important to note that two of these 6 carriers were of the brand new Taihō-class, the sister ships Taihō and Tenhō, which were notable among other things for being the first Japanese carriers to employ steam catapults. Once it had been confirmed that the force was indeed entering the Torres Strait action stations were called and the carrier air group sent up. The Japanese belief in a pre-emptive strike had not lead the wrong before and it would not lead them astray now as decision was made to deal with the approaching Royal Navy force and deter it from pushing further into what the Japanese were increasingly determined to make part of their naval domain. Under the light of the fading sun a swarm of Japanese carrier planes took to the skies - D4Y dive bombers, B6N as well as B7A torpedo bombers and a large variety of A7Ms, although mostly just A7M2s. Little did the pilots of these planes know that whilst they were engaging in life and death battles over the South Pacific for the glory of the Empire that they would not only herald the swan song of the Royal Navy, but also of their own airframes, as not soon after the first carrier jet fighters and bombers would make their mark known. Not even a year of the battle in the Gulf of Carpenteria the first Japanese carrier air groups consisting of jet planes would demonstrate their skills to the cheers of an adoring public and even though total adoption of the jet engine would still take some time the relentless march of time would continue. Before it would consume the prop planes it would take the Royal Navy detachment, which soon found itself under intense aerial assault by the Japanese once distance had grown enough for the fleet to be discouraged from staging an easy retreat back to the relative defence of the Torres Strait Islands. It is unknown how exactly the Royal Navy were caught so off guard, particularly as the force contained 5 capital ships with air and surface radar, but it is thought that electrical issues prevailed in all of them and thus the Pacific Fleet only really noticed the Japanese once the small CAP on the HMAS Kiwi and Wellington had taken the first losses and the first ships began to meet the business end of Japanese torpedoes and bombs. Chief among the Japanese targets had been the aforementioned carriers HMAS Kiwi and HMAS Wellington and even though the air group of the Kairyū, a ship of the second generation of the Unryū-class carriers, would make a good attempt at it they would only capture one of the two this time, the one being HMAS Kiwi sinking the carrier in record time before the rest of the air group had really managed to take-off and join in the fight. Not long after a retreat had been called and the fleet had begun the dash for the safety of the Torres Strait Islands a considerable part of the carrier escort, primarily light cruisers and destroyers, joined the mêlée and began lobbing torpedoes into the water to make the escape all the more interesting. In total the Japanese would lose only some 30 planes shot down as well as see around twice as much damaged in exchange for the battleship HMAS Benbow, the battlecruiser HMAS Hood as well as the heavy cruisers HMAS Carnarvon, HMAS Canberra and HMAS Hawkins as well as the aforementioned carrier HMAS Kiwi. Their plans now dashed and under nigh constant torpedo assault from the Japanese from both in the air and at sea, the battered force of the Pacific Fleet decided to cede the seas and limped away back to Sydney - spending the remainder of the war at port licking their wounds and lacking oil.

HaVb4VA.jpg

Japanese illustration about the Battle of the Gulf of Carpenteria and the maiming of the British Pacific Fleet
Due to the defeat of its main rival the Japanese fleet would spend the remainder of the war without any real large battles and was primarily tasked with supporting the land-borne fighting as well as anything incidental that stemmed from it, such as the battle in Huon Gulf which saw HMAS Brisbane and the 4th Destroyer Flotilla, made up of C-Class destroyers, sent to the bottom and the blockade of Sydney harbour. Their tasks also expanded to include commerce raiding or in reality an enforcement of a blockade in order to prevent the departure of the British royal family like had happened in Canada, which lead to actions in the Timor as well as the Tasman Sea the latter known to the locals by the more informal name of 'Ditch'. It would however be during one of the actions supporting the land-borne fighting that the Royal Navy would see its greatest, and only, victory against the Japanese in this conflict. Following it stunning victory in the Gulf of Carpenteria and the blockade of Sydney the Imperial Navy seemed to succumb to hubris as it began to increasingly consider the Royal Navy as a not a threat and failed to properly secure their landing forces on more than one occasion. This had not gone unnoticed by the Royal Navy, but it had also been unable to really take advantage of the situation that is of course until Dunedin raid and the battle off Otago that accompanied it. Much has been said about the consequences of the Royal Navy victory, such as the very common myth propagated among Western sources that this defeat was one of the underlying reasons behind the Japanese decision to conduct an atomic strike at Fleet Base East, as a sort of punishment against the insolence of the British for resisting. Given that this has been contradicted by historians more at home on this subject and who have had the rare honour of accessing Japanese archives on this topic there is little real reason to repeat it. More of interest is the battle itself considering that the New Zealand squadron consisted of primarily Weltkrieg-era vessels - the HMAS Sydney, a Town-class cruiser, and the 10th Destroyer Flotilla that accompanied it, made up of S-class destroyers. The Japanese had not taken these 'museum pieces' seriously and found themselves humbled when the force managed not only evade detection, but also reach the transport ships through the lax Japanese picket whilst the former were unloading troops onto Dunedin harbour. The division of marines that had already made land fall ended up mostly intact, the other as well as 11 of the 15 transport ships employed for this operation would be torn to pieces by the spirited attack by the plucky ANZACs crewing these ships. Once the 1st Fleet, that was supposed to be guarding the landing efforts, finally noticed the interluders and blocked their departure the crews of the ships are reported to have taken their imminent demise in stride, cracking jokes and even attempting to ram the Japanese pickets, now doing their jobs, once their stocks of ammunition ran dry. Yet death came to them without a doubt and all 6 ships would go down with the Sydney itself succumbing to repeated torpedo strikes from the air group of the carrier Shokaku that had been detached from the 4th Fleet with an escort to aid the 1st Fleet in operations off New Zealand.

a6kvfgY.jpg

Much of the surviving crew, as little of it as there was, would be rescued from the waters by Japanese sailors as orders from above had declared it thus and a shared antipathy against the sea won out over the relatively strong antipathy felt towards the British colonials and their less favourable treatment of all Asians, including of course the Japanese themselves.
Unlike these battles in the South Pacific, the ones that had preceded them in the Atlantic and Mediterranean or indeed any of the many other battles in the history of the Royal Navy, be they victories or defeats, there is not a story more sombre than the final stand of the Royal Navy. Primarily as it really cannot be described as a battle of typical sorts nor really can the loss of its hulls then be described as having fallen in battle. The Navy that found itself obsessed for decades over Trafalgar found its end trapped in a siege rather than a Trafalgar of its as many had secretly hoped for with its losses more akin to attrition than a big battle. Although undoubtedly the Japanese air raids constituted attacks, the Royal Navy found itself being picked apart piece by piece and unable to sally forth to break the siege. Much of the Pacific Fleet was under repair, or if it could really be called repair at this point, and the crews of the parts that had not taken part in the disastrous encounter at Carpenteria were rather reluctant in stating that they would fight, but they would not commit suicide. Thus the crews of the ships were picked dry and sent to the frontlines with the guns that they could remove from the ship in order to ensure the continued resistance of the ever shrinking defensive fortifications around Sydney with only skeleton crews left on the ships to ensure that the Japanese could not commit a Medway or worse a Copenhagen on the anchored Royal Navy vessels. Thus the ships were rather badly prepared to fight against day after day of Japanese air raids from carriers operating just far enough that the remaining naval guns could not hit them, but just close enough to provide their winged companions the longest time for delivering their payloads. The first Japanese raids would do a number on the remaining Australasian carriers with the air group of Kairyū going after the one that got away and sinking HMAS Wellington on the first day of the raids. The escort carriers HMAS Pegasus and Albatross would also be claimed by 3rd Air Fleet, going to Karyū and Tenhō respectively. Others would follow in their wake with Sōryū of the 2nd Air Fleet claiming the once elusive HMAS Colombo, among others, and in the week leading up to the atomic strike on Sydney the majority of the still floating ships of the once pre-eminent Royal Navy would be sunk, leaving those still afloat after this storm of steel little more than burning wrecks or beached emplacements from which still resilient AA gunners tried in vain to turn back the maelstrom of violence. Yet the end for the Royal Navy laid before them, the war was lost and the atomic strike on Sydney only sealed the deal. On the 25th of November, the guns fell silent and the Australasian forces still defending the city largely surrendered to the Japanese, even though some urban guerillas would continue their fight the nearly decade long great struggle that had gripped the English-speaking world had come to an end and with it so had the British Empire. Whilst the post-war would eventually see the return of the Royal Navy it returned as a very different organisation compared to its pre-war self, more Asian as some have derisively and more bluntly described it. This started first in its hulls, old Japanese hand-me-downs, then slowly in the crew, as the Asian population began to boom, and finally in its traditions, much like Australia and New Zealand themselves. The age of Arthur had come to a close.

transcript from a video series "History of the British Royal Navy Volume 10 - Exile to Ditch (1925-50)" on MeinVideo by Wiefferink
-----------------------------------------

A great November to you all. This is going to be it for now. I've got an ever growing backlog of games to play as well as work to do. I cannot of course state that I shall not return, as I do still have things in my "I want to write this" backlog, but for the moment at least I'm tapped out of creativity thus achieving my goal of killing the voices in my head that said I should write a detective novel set in this universe.
 
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Awww! the end? Really? So sad!

It has been a marvelous journey though. Through a world of light... and darkness.... Enlightenment... and blindness. Horror, fascination and wonder.

The most persistent memories, to me, are those of your story parts set around the post war Australia, in the Britain of the 1960s, and the haunting parts about the dark turn of American socialism and all the cultural knock on effects that you so brilliantly told.

The story of the superpower of imperial Japan and its unstoppable rise, and the development of its first world economy and society were also fascinating, insightful, and thrilling. And I learned more about Japanese student protests, than I ever thought possible :D

Thank you so much for the memories!

At some point someone should compile all the greatest AARs from the Kaiserreich mod universe into a book. I would buy it!