• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Another to check out and a game I know 0% about. Excellent work Rusty! Though would you mind not adding to my list of really great AARs to read? I'm struggling to catch up as is x-x.
Thanks for commenting! Hopefully we can get you into HOI3 yet, although I'm sorry for your free time if so!

Probably no in game effect, but that kind of thing should really make for logistical chaos, some kind of penalty.
Agreed, that must have an amazing mess in real life. At least Iran is better than China where they even had different calibers for rifles, pistols, and machine guns!

Interesting, if I’d ever briefly known this I had forgotten it. Rather poignant at the moment.
That's what I thought too. It's nice to think things could have gone better twenty years ago, but I'm not sure one man could make that much of a difference in five years or so.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Further Military Development

The New Year brought a shakeup in the ruling cabinet. The old Foreign Minister had been blamed for the early failures in securing German weapons, especially since it was soon revealed he was a dedicated Anglophile. He was quickly ousted on trumped up charges of corruption and shuffled off to one of the Shah’s modern prisons. The previous Minister of Security and Chief of the Air Force were allowed to resign with their dignity intact and were soon replaced by Ali Mansour and Sadegh Khan Koopal.

KH2b54u.png

The international scene became much more tense as Germany made two major diplomatic plays. First, they peacefully annexed Austria at the end of February, unifying both Germanic nations. This was followed by a much more aggressive demand: the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia. Hitler claimed the Czechs were abusing the ethnic Germans within their borders and demanded the German-majority Sudetenland be allowed to secede. A conference was held in Munich, attended by Hitler, Chamberlain, Daladier, and Mussolini, wherein they decided the Czechs must accede to Hitler’s demands. Sold out by their allies, the Czechs gave in, sacrificing their most defensible terrain. However, Hitler promised this was the extent of his demands, and Chamberlain proclaimed that he had secured ‘peace in our time’. The Shah was uncertain what to make of this action, although it seemed the German star was rising even as the French and British lacked the stomach for war. Whether Hitler would remain true to his word was another question entirely.

On a more personal note, Reza Shah was deeply saddened to learn his friend, Ataturk, had died on November 12 after a long period of worsening health. One of the great men to emerge in the post-war era had passed on, reminding the Shah of his own mortality. It seemed a new era was coming, and the Crown Prince would need to be ready. Fortunately, he had done well in his military studies and graduated as a second lieutenant. Mohammad Reza was soon promoted to captain and appointed inspector of the army. As part of his duties, he was tasked with inspecting various civil and military installations, giving him a taste of a ruler’s duties.

haFgB02.jpg

Mohammad Reza (left) receiving his commission from his father (right) upon graduation from the Officer Cadet College.

The Iranian military made substantial improvements in its doctrine and training over the course of 1938. Work began on developing a coherent infiltration doctrine that could be taught to the troops, with the expectation that it would be complete by early 1939. Similarly, the initial grand battleplan doctrine was completed in November and was disseminated to the officers of the IIGF. This was followed by further improvement in basic infantry training and further work on officer training. The Iranians were a few years behind on infantry training but were catching up on officer training, largely thanks to a jumpstart provided by sending officers to foreign academies.

xpBbYKM.png

This was followed by further improvement in the equipment of the IIGF. Another batch of vz.24 rifle kits were completed (Note: 1934 small arms tech), and the remaining machinery to begin full-scale production within Iran had nearly all arrived (Note: Starting 1936 tech). Additionally, all the German support equipment finished its training and was deployed to the 2, 3, 4, and 5 Infantry Divisions in early January, mid-March, mid-June, and late August, respectively. With these regiments deployed, the Iranians now had a full corps of modern infantry with the supporting heavy equipment necessary for modern warfare. In addition to the cavalry corps and its tanks, the IIGF was quickly becoming a serious force in the region. Even more importantly, Reza Shah had no intentions of ending his build-up and ordered a mixture of small arms, helmets, light artillery, and much more from the Germans with the goal of equipping another two infantry divisions. The first of these would be deployed by late November, although they would have to wait for their heavier weapons. The Foreign Ministry secured Italian weapons to support these divisions, primarily modern mountain guns and 47mm anti-tank guns. The Italians had been persuaded to part with their modern weapons thanks to a generous shipment of oil (Note: I bought licenses but in OTL the Italians often gave modern equipment for raw materials). It would take some time for these weapons to enter service, but the Shah was very pleased by how smooth the negotiations had gone.

mrqVatz.png

Note: I replaced the 1936 small arms tech with the vz.24 for flavor purposes. It surprisingly didn’t appear in the tech tree, so I thought it was a nice addition.

lvxHBP3.jpg
Italian Cannone da 47/32 anti-tank gun, a license produced version of an Austrian design from Bohler. A relatively modern piece similar in performance to the British 2-pounder or German 37mm, although it also has an HE shell available, allowing it to act as a close support gun. The biggest complaint was the lack of a gun shield and inability to be towed by trucks. Unfortunately for Italy, this gun remained in service throughout the entire war, becoming increasingly outdated.

UiCOAUI.jpg

Italian Obice da 75/18 75mm howitzer. This artillery piece was designed in 1934 and had two versions. The mountain gun could be broken down into packs while the standard did not break down. In OTL it was sold to Portugal and various South American countries in exchange for raw materials Italy badly needed. Therefore, I thought it seemed somewhat realistic the Italians would do the same with Iran.


1938 was a significant year for the IIGF as it rapidly grew in size, experience, and equipment. More technical troops were now being trained to utilize modern equipment, something that had never been before happened in Iran. Much of this could be attributed to the introduction of conscription in 1925 finally beginning to bear fruit. This law required all able-bodied men over 21 to serve 2 years in the military and another 4 years in the reserves. These men were first conscripted from the peasantry, followed by the tribes, and finally the urban population.

As much as conscription provided the manpower and training to strengthen the regime, its most important effect was on the development of a true Iranian identity. Conscription allowed the introduction of birth certificates and mandatory family names, allowing the central government to keep track of much more of its citizens.
Part of conscription’s goal was to pull people out of traditional nomadic environments and expose them to a greater Iranian identity they would be trained to aspire to. This included paying respect to a common flag, the Shah, and interacting with other men from across the country. Two-thirds of all conscripts spent their first 6 months learning Persian in order to better integrate them. Through conscription, simple peasants and unruly tribesmen were turned into citizens of an Iranian nation, something larger than any had ever aspired to.

lWrpJqZ.jpg

Iranian military policemen arrest a deserter


Note: All of the information on Iranian conscription is historical, and it makes an interesting parallel to Japan in the late 1800s/early 1900s where they heavily pushed Japanese nationalism/superiority, worship of the emperor, and fanatical loyalty. They also had 'history lessons' intended to assert Japan's prime position and duty to conquer in the conscripts' minds. In this respect, Iran's conscription feels much less like brainwashing like the Japanese model, although the general goal and methods are very similar.
 
  • 5Like
  • 2Love
  • 1
Reactions:
An interesting look at Iran's army! Though time will tell if this modernization will be enough when the Brits and Soviets come knocking.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Conscription and education are eroding the power of the local power brokers (even the smallest pond has a head fish). Rural Iranian young adults are learning that they are a part of something larger than their local village/clan. Thank you for the update.

Like @Superstorm, I have no idea how to play HoI3. That you are entertaining us, shows your gift as a writer.
 
  • 3
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I love the fact that the minimum level of training of your armed forces would be linked to how advanced your doctrines are. Interesting bit on the non-agression treaty with Iran's neighbours, well except for the Soviets...

I wouldn't want to be a logistician for this Iranian army, with the number of different artillery pieces, rifles, machine-guns etc. It's sure to be a nightmare to keep everyone happy and supplied with the parts and ammo they need.
 
  • 7
Reactions:
The old Foreign Minister had been blamed for the early failures in securing German weapons, especially since it was soon revealed he was a dedicated Anglophile. He was quickly ousted on trumped up charges of corruption and shuffled off to one of the Shah’s modern prisons.

Sounds like he definitely needed to go... :)

The Shah was uncertain what to make of this action, although it seemed the German star was rising even as the French and British lacked the stomach for war.

This will probably reinforce the Shah's belief that aligning with Germany is a good idea, which may or may not be true. Time will tell!

The Iranian military made substantial improvements in its doctrine and training over the course of 1938. Work began on developing a coherent infiltration doctrine that could be taught to the troops, with the expectation that it would be complete by early 1939. Similarly, the initial grand battleplan doctrine was completed in November and was disseminated to the officers of the IIGF. This was followed by further improvement in basic infantry training and further work on officer training.

You seem to be pushing hard on the doctrines and the training, and creating a more professional army. I hope you also have time to get your basic equipment up to scratch as well? You're just about getting there with the small arms now, at least.

Additionally, all the German support equipment finished its training and was deployed to the 2, 3, 4, and 5 Infantry Divisions in early January, mid-March, mid-June, and late August, respectively. With these regiments deployed, the Iranians now had a full corps of modern infantry with the supporting heavy equipment necessary for modern warfare. In addition to the cavalry corps and its tanks, the IIGF was quickly becoming a serious force in the region.

This is certainly turning Iran into a regional power - and that's after about two-and-half years of investment? So, you've probably got about the same again before things start to get hot!
 
  • 4Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Sounds like he definitely needed to go... :)



This will probably reinforce the Shah's belief that aligning with Germany is a good idea, which may or may not be true. Time will tell!



You seem to be pushing hard on the doctrines and the training, and creating a more professional army. I hope you also have time to get your basic equipment up to scratch as well? You're just about getting there with the small arms now, at least.



This is certainly turning Iran into a regional power - and that's after about two-and-half years of investment? So, you've probably got about the same again before things start to get hot!

Well, remember the region is piss weak, so becoming the regional power isn't too hard. Being an historic area of interest for two great powers at the same time, however, is not good news for anyone. Esepcially if you border both of them.
 
  • 3
  • 1
Reactions:
Being an historic area of interest for two great powers at the same time, however, is not good news for anyone. Esepcially if you border both of them.

That is undoubtedly the big problem in this AAR. The Soviet Union has unlimited resources (relatively speaking) to throw against Iran and British India is plenty strong enough to pose a real threat as well. The Shah has to hope the Germans and the Japanese provide sufficient distraction, and that might work out with a healthy dose of luck.
 
  • 4
Reactions:
Though time will tell if this modernization will be enough when the Brits and Soviets come knocking.
Absolutely, and part of the problem is that Iran is modernizing a bit early. A lot of the AT guns won't be able to defeat modern tanks in 1941 which is going to be a problem, but I don't have the industry to wait until 1939/40 to start modernizing either.

Conscription and education are eroding the power of the local power brokers (even the smallest pond has a head fish). Rural Iranian young adults are learning that they are a part of something larger than their local village/clan. Thank you for the update.
Yep, it's an essential step in modernizing the country, and it's kind of surprising that it took this long for Iran to even start the process. Probably a big reason Turkey was able to modernize more successfully than Iran in OTL.

Like @Superstorm, I have no idea how to play HoI3. That you are entertaining us, shows your gift as a writer.
I'm glad you've been enjoying it!

I love the fact that the minimum level of training of your armed forces would be linked to how advanced your doctrines are.
That is a really nice touch, and it's such a simple thing

I wouldn't want to be a logistician for this Iranian army, with the number of different artillery pieces, rifles, machine-guns etc. It's sure to be a nightmare to keep everyone happy and supplied with the parts and ammo they need.
Oh it absolutely has to be a nightmare!

Sounds like he definitely needed to go... :)
Got to work the Shah's authoritarianism in there, even if this is the propaganda version of Iran

You seem to be pushing hard on the doctrines and the training, and creating a more professional army. I hope you also have time to get your basic equipment up to scratch as well? You're just about getting there with the small arms now, at least.
I figure I won't have a big enough army, so they'll at least have to be well trained. I think I can get two out of four relatively up to date. Small arms seems like an obvious priority, but I'm not sure what a good second one would be. Leaning towards defensive support weapons or AT weapons. What would you think?

This is certainly turning Iran into a regional power - and that's after about two-and-half years of investment? So, you've probably got about the same again before things start to get hot!
Well, remember the region is piss weak, so becoming the regional power isn't too hard. Being an historic area of interest for two great powers at the same time, however, is not good news for anyone. Esepcially if you border both of them.
That is undoubtedly the big problem in this AAR. The Soviet Union has unlimited resources (relatively speaking) to throw against Iran and British India is plenty strong enough to pose a real threat as well. The Shah has to hope the Germans and the Japanese provide sufficient distraction, and that might work out with a healthy dose of luck.
Very good points, Iran is developing quite quickly but still has a long, long way to go if it wants to compete with the global powers. A big factor is hoping Germany makes it relatively far to lighten the weight of the Soviets on me, and then hopefully surviving until Japan joins the war. From there, it seems like I might be able to help capture the Caucasus and/or Middle East. It's very reliant on the AI powers, but I'll do what I can to contribute.
 
  • 3Like
  • 1
Reactions:
The Iranian regime continues to devolve ever downwards. The Shah imprisoning anyone with dissenting views, rounding up peasants for indoctrination and then punishing the army by inflicting Italian weapons on them!

I would very much like the view of Reza Mizani on all this, just to see why he thinks Human Wave and mass combat is in anyway a good idea when potentially facing the Soviet Union. Then again he is a Naval Intelligence specialist, so his terrible grasp of land combat does make a certain amount of sense. Him being Chief of Staff, perhaps not so much.

Well, remember the region is piss weak, so becoming the regional power isn't too hard.
Well Iran's neighbours are British India, the British puppet of Iraq and the Soviet Union. Iran is arguably the only independent power in the region bar the Brits and Soviets, so the Shah could have two blunt sticks and a camel and still be the regional power.
 
  • 3Haha
  • 2Like
  • 2
Reactions:
Well Iran's neighbours are British India, the British puppet of Iraq and the Soviet Union. Iran is arguably the only independent power in the region bar the Brits and Soviets, so the Shah could have two blunt sticks and a camel and still be the regional power.

You are technically correct, the best kind of correct.

However, the point still stands either way that Iran is piss weak.
 
  • 4
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Leaning towards defensive support weapons or AT weapons. What would you think?
Does the HOI3 AI prioritize using its tanks against a bigger threat when fighting on two fronts (focusing on Germany when fighting Iran+Germany at the same time)? Or is the AI pretty random in where it assigns troops?

If no Soviet tanks show up in Iran (its also mountainous so maybe that helps) then my vote is for the general defensive weapons rather than AT.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The AI doesn't know how to differentiate it's units. That's why you get bone head plays of five HQs, a malformed tank division, two garrison divisions and one infantry brigade in an assault of Denmark or whatever.
 
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The AI doesn't know how to differentiate it's units. That's why you get bone head plays of five HQs, a malformed tank division, two garrison divisions and one infantry brigade in an assault of Denmark or whatever.
I thought it could tell them apart, but attached a fairly low weight to it.

So when looking a garrisoning an island the AI prefers to use garrison divisions, but if none were available right that instant it will send whatever is available even if that is a super-heavy armoured tank division. Same for an invasion, the AI prioritises launching the attack with what is available over waiting for the correct units, even if the available units are a mismatched horror show.

I can sort of see why, better to have the 'wrong' unit on garrison duty than leave things undefended. And I can see why they didn't want the overhead of the AI constantly shuffling units around, but that meant once a SH Arm division starts garrisoning Bermuda it is never going to leave.

Paradox regularly claimed that various patches or indeed DLCs 'fundamentally improved' the AI and to be fair I think the Eastern Front got a lot better and some of the more ridiculous exploits in Italy were sorted. But as has been said many times Paradox hates the sea and all things naval, so anything involving naval invasions, island garrisoning and similar never really worked well.
 
  • 3
  • 3
Reactions:
Note: I replaced the 1936 small arms tech with the vz.24 for flavor purposes. It surprisingly didn’t appear in the tech tree, so I thought it was a nice addition.
Yes, a nice touch.
1938 was a significant year for the IIGF as it rapidly grew in size, experience, and equipment.
All good, but the key force structure question is what the Shah intends to use it for: defence against whoever might attackit (ie UK or USSR) or to try to become Shahanshah? Or a bit of both?
Iranian military policemen arrest a deserter
I doubt he'll be going to one of the modern prisons. :eek:
I figure I won't have a big enough army, so they'll at least have to be well trained.
Hmm, a big enough army for what (per above)?
Leaning towards defensive support weapons or AT weapons. What would you think?
Ditto.
it seems like I might be able to help capture the Caucasus and/or Middle East. It's very reliant on the AI powers, but I'll do what I can to contribute.
Ah, so an emphasis (not necessarily exclusive) on offensive strength would be useful? Whatever helps to improve hard and soft attack, plus related attacking/offensive doctrines?
then punishing the army by inflicting Italian weapons on them!
:D Still, in the land of the blind, the one-eyed man in Shah! ;)
 
  • 5Like
Reactions:
Without being in your position and checking all the numbers? No idea. :)
Alright, it probably won't be the biggest deal, so I'll go with whatever catches my fancy!

The Shah imprisoning anyone with dissenting views, rounding up peasants for indoctrination and then punishing the army by inflicting Italian weapons on them!
At least he bought Italian artillery, the one thing they were competent at. If he really hated the army, he'd have bought Italian machine guns!

I would very much like the view of Reza Mizani on all this, just to see why he thinks Human Wave and mass combat is in anyway a good idea when potentially facing the Soviet Union. Then again he is a Naval Intelligence specialist, so his terrible grasp of land combat does make a certain amount of sense. Him being Chief of Staff, perhaps not so much.
I must chalk this up to the manpower bonus being very useful, at least during peace time, and nothing to do with the merits of it against the Soviets! I'm glad Paradox's typical quality of research was not wasted on Iran, it just wouldn't be HOI3 without it.

All good, but the key force structure question is what the Shah intends to use it for: defence against whoever might attackit (ie UK or USSR) or to try to become Shahanshah? Or a bit of both?
There are two options, and I haven't decided which way to go. Option 1 is join the Axis early and strike against the British, probably sometime after Italy enters the war, trying to lock down the Middle East and eliminate one flank.

Option 2 is to go historical and wait for the British/Soviets to divvy me up. Main advantage is it gives me an extra year or so to prepare, but it also means I'm fighting on effectively all of my borders at once.

It seems like each has their advantages and disadvantages, but I think helping the Italians wrap up the Middle East would be better since that would gain me reinforcements and a connection to the Axis again.
 
  • 4
  • 1Like
Reactions:
There are two options, and I haven't decided which way to go. Option 1 is join the Axis early and strike against the British, probably sometime after Italy enters the war, trying to lock down the Middle East and eliminate one flank.

Option 2 is to go historical and wait for the British/Soviets to divvy me up. Main advantage is it gives me an extra year or so to prepare, but it also means I'm fighting on effectively all of my borders at once.

It seems like each has their advantages and disadvantages, but I think helping the Italians wrap up the Middle East would be better since that would gain me reinforcements and a connection to the Axis again.
Not much of a choice there. You will lose if you go with OTL. And if you go for Axis, you might be able to have a limited war against the British and Allies, whilst avoiding fighting the USSR. Big maybe.

I suspect you joining will in any case break the Axis AI as they wonder whether to reinforce you or not, because you'll have to fight India and the Middle East and the Soviets (maybe) by yourself.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Not much of a choice there. You will lose if you go with OTL.
Not necessarily, I'll just be VERY dependent on Germany to do well in Russia and Italy to do well in Africa. That's a bit of a tall order, but HOI3 is biased toward the Axis a bit.

suspect you joining will in any case break the Axis AI as they wonder whether to reinforce you or not, because you'll have to fight India and the Middle East and the Soviets (maybe) by yourself.
I'm not sure about that since there'd be no contiguous border for quite a while.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
There is Option 3 of joining the Allies which would probably short-circuit any scripted war.
 
  • 3
  • 2Like
  • 1Haha
  • 1
Reactions: