I am having some problems with the defeat of France results. While playing as Italy I cannot get historical results. I am able to create a Vichy France if I choose "Puppet" while issuing the DoW. If I choose take provinces, Italy will get those, but Germany gets nothing-and France continues with a truce with the Axis. If I choose "conquer", then all of France that was not occupied by Germany, by the time of surrender, becomes part of Italy. The oddest outcome was brought on by creating a puppet; Vichy France was created and had a truce with the Axis, the remainder of France was French land and was now at war the the UK.
This is with the 1940 Attack on the West campaign. My check sum is FDAJ.
Has anyone else had such problems or do I have a funny install?
__________________
So, after another couple fast replays I got a normal Vichy-while taking Nice as chosen. So it is working, but no where near the same each time.