I wanted to see how far I could go with Granada. I play the game at hard/furious 1.07. But while starting the game I thought about writing a literary AAR about it (my first non game-oriented AAR), and soon realized that the history of Granada between 1333 and 1492 although fascinating, is not easily found.
The Nasrid emirs (princes) had a very complicated lineage, with the same emirs repeating at different times, indicating lots of political strife as was so common between the spanish arab rulers. At the same time for the text books nothing happened in Granada for 160 years.
But a careful research shed quite some light, despite the lack of historical sources from the arab side. In fact the Nasrid lineage is messed up slightly in the game.
I decided then to write the AAR in terms of the relationship between the different social and religious classes in muslim Spain.
On top were the arabs, that constituted the nobility and the ruler class. They were few and were the driving force of the first invasion.
Then the berbers, the majority of the invaders. They were the army and the middle classes. They came to the peninsula to improve their life conditions. In general they were more orthodox in their religious beliefs. The different berber invasions of the peninsula came from different populations and regions of north Africa.
The christians that kept their religion were called mozarabs, as with the jews they were mostly tolerated at the beginning. The berber invasions of the Murabits (almoravids) and later the Muwahhids (Almohads) brought widespread intolerance, massive conversions and even christian martyrdom during the Cordoban caliphate. The jewish population of Granada was completely exterminated in 1066 by the arabs, including the jewish vizier Joseph ibn Nagrela (there goes a myth on Al-Andalus tolerance), during the ruling of the pro-jewish berber Zirid dynasty, although jewish returned to Granada during the Nasrid rule. During the reconquista, christians were prosecuted more and more and many forced to flee to the christian kingdoms.
The christians that changed their religion were called muwallads, and they were despised by all, although their life was easier and they didn't have to pay the dimmihn, the religious tax. Nevertheless, the shari'ah was interpreted under the very rigorous Maliki jurisprudence, and allowed for many injustices, where muwallads and mozarabs were frequently arbitrarily depossessed or over-taxed.
Political strife between different arab clans (usually Syrio-Saudis against Yemenis), and berber clans (usually Sanhaja from Tunisia against Zenata from Algeria and Morocco) was mixed with continuous uprisings by muwallads and mozarabs, that supported different parties.
After reading a little bit, I decided that the AAR should direct the game, instead of the other way around. One of the first decisions was to end the arab dynasty with Mohammed XIII Boabdil as it did in history, and supplant it with a much better berber dynasty, consistent with the AAR and with average statistics of 7,7,7. Cheating or not, I could not continue having Boabdil until 1819, and since I was going to change him, I could as well improve him. After all, monarchs are basically rated by their nations historical achievements, and this Granada is going to achieve a lot (I hope). A distinction is made between Granada, the province and city, and Gharnata, the country.
Finally a note on historic accuracy. Most events related to the Nasrid dynasty between 1419 and 1491 are historical. In fact, they are more accurate than in the game, since the EU2 Granadan dynasty contains several mistakes and omissions, although is understandable since it was common that two or even three emirs fought each other at the same time, controlling different parts of the emirate. This is a case where reality goes further than fiction.
Obviously the battles refer to my game, since I was not playing to disappear in 1492. Some characters other than the emirs are also historic, although not many because history is sparse over that period.
The arab clans or families are historic, with one exception. The Cegríes of the christian chronicles, deadly enemies of the Abencerrajes (the tribe of the Banu Sarray, whose members where called ben al-Sarray, or sons of the saddler) don't show up in the arab stories or history research of the time by that name.
In fact many secondary families are known but not that main one (at least to me, but I am not an expert). In the history books the weight of the confrontation with the Abencerrajes was carried by the Banu Bannigas, that show in the christian chronicles as the Venegas.
So who were those mysterious Cegríes? Unlike most arab and berber tribesmen in the chronicles, they don't carry the appellate ben. I have developed the theory that they are in fact the Ziris, the descendants of the berber Ziri dynasty that founded Granada in 1012. In tenuous support of this wild theory is not only the congruent sound translated into Spanish, but also the fact that the last name Zerí is still found in Granada, while no other Cegrí or Zegrí is found. Moreover, most Ziris did not carry the ben-Ziri suffix in their name, and they were not named Banu Ziris since they claimed a different ancestry from arab Yemen, instead of berber Tunisia, due to the low consideration that berbers had in al-Andalus. Perhaps someone can shed light on this point.
As a reference, this are the historic rulers of Gharnata:
BANU ZIRI (berber dynasty from Tunisia)
1013-1019 Zawi ben Ziri. Founder of Gharnata
1019-1038 Habus ben Makasan
1038-1073 Badis ben Habus al-Muzaffar al-Nasir
1073-1090 Abd-Allah ben Buluggin ben Badis
1090-(between 1145 and 1172) BANU AL-MURABITS (berber conquerors of al-Andalus)
(between 1145 and 1172)-1172 Part of the Tai'fa kingdom of Murcia
1172-1237 BANU AL-MUWAHHIDS (berber conquerors of al-Andalus)
BANU NASR (arab dinasty)
1237-1273 Muhammad I ben al-Ahmar
1273-1302 Muhammad II al-Faqih
1302-1309 Muhammad III al-Maijlu
1309-1314 Nasr Abu al-Yuyus
1314-1325 Ismail I
1325-1333 Muhammad IV ben Ismail
1333-1354 Yusuf I Abu al-Hayyay
1354-1359 Muhammad V al-Gani (first time)
1359-1360 Ismail II ben Yusuf
1360-1362 Muhammad VI
1362-1391 Muhammad V al-Gani (second time)
1391-1392 Yusuf II ben Muhammad
1392-1408 Muhammad VII al-Mustain
1408-1417 Yusuf III ben Yusuf
1417-1419 Muhammad VIII al-Zaghil (first time)
1419-1427 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (first time)
1427-1429 Muhammad VIII al-Zaghil (second time)
1429-1432 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (second time)
1432 Yusuf IV al-Mawl
1432-1445 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (third time)
1445-1454 Civil war. Up to three emirs simultaneously in different parts of the kingdom. These are:
Muhammad X al-Ahnaf (1445-1447), Yusuf V ben Ismail (1445-1450, first time), Muhammad IX al-Aysar (1447-1454, fourth time), Muhammad XI "the tiny" (1451-1454) and Saad Abu Nasr (1454) winner of the civil war.
1454-1462 Saad Abu Nasr (first time) aka Ciriza
1462-1463 Yusuf V ben Ismail (second time)
1463-1465 Saad Abu Nasr (second time) aka Ciriza
1465-1482 Abu al-Hassan
1482 Muhammad XII al-Zagoibi aka Boabdil
1482-1487 Muhammad XIII al-Zaghall
1487-1492 Muhammad XII al-Zagoibi aka Boabdil
30 ruling periods in 250 years. No comments are necessary.
The Nasrid emirs (princes) had a very complicated lineage, with the same emirs repeating at different times, indicating lots of political strife as was so common between the spanish arab rulers. At the same time for the text books nothing happened in Granada for 160 years.
But a careful research shed quite some light, despite the lack of historical sources from the arab side. In fact the Nasrid lineage is messed up slightly in the game.
I decided then to write the AAR in terms of the relationship between the different social and religious classes in muslim Spain.
On top were the arabs, that constituted the nobility and the ruler class. They were few and were the driving force of the first invasion.
Then the berbers, the majority of the invaders. They were the army and the middle classes. They came to the peninsula to improve their life conditions. In general they were more orthodox in their religious beliefs. The different berber invasions of the peninsula came from different populations and regions of north Africa.
The christians that kept their religion were called mozarabs, as with the jews they were mostly tolerated at the beginning. The berber invasions of the Murabits (almoravids) and later the Muwahhids (Almohads) brought widespread intolerance, massive conversions and even christian martyrdom during the Cordoban caliphate. The jewish population of Granada was completely exterminated in 1066 by the arabs, including the jewish vizier Joseph ibn Nagrela (there goes a myth on Al-Andalus tolerance), during the ruling of the pro-jewish berber Zirid dynasty, although jewish returned to Granada during the Nasrid rule. During the reconquista, christians were prosecuted more and more and many forced to flee to the christian kingdoms.
The christians that changed their religion were called muwallads, and they were despised by all, although their life was easier and they didn't have to pay the dimmihn, the religious tax. Nevertheless, the shari'ah was interpreted under the very rigorous Maliki jurisprudence, and allowed for many injustices, where muwallads and mozarabs were frequently arbitrarily depossessed or over-taxed.
Political strife between different arab clans (usually Syrio-Saudis against Yemenis), and berber clans (usually Sanhaja from Tunisia against Zenata from Algeria and Morocco) was mixed with continuous uprisings by muwallads and mozarabs, that supported different parties.
After reading a little bit, I decided that the AAR should direct the game, instead of the other way around. One of the first decisions was to end the arab dynasty with Mohammed XIII Boabdil as it did in history, and supplant it with a much better berber dynasty, consistent with the AAR and with average statistics of 7,7,7. Cheating or not, I could not continue having Boabdil until 1819, and since I was going to change him, I could as well improve him. After all, monarchs are basically rated by their nations historical achievements, and this Granada is going to achieve a lot (I hope). A distinction is made between Granada, the province and city, and Gharnata, the country.
Finally a note on historic accuracy. Most events related to the Nasrid dynasty between 1419 and 1491 are historical. In fact, they are more accurate than in the game, since the EU2 Granadan dynasty contains several mistakes and omissions, although is understandable since it was common that two or even three emirs fought each other at the same time, controlling different parts of the emirate. This is a case where reality goes further than fiction.
Obviously the battles refer to my game, since I was not playing to disappear in 1492. Some characters other than the emirs are also historic, although not many because history is sparse over that period.
The arab clans or families are historic, with one exception. The Cegríes of the christian chronicles, deadly enemies of the Abencerrajes (the tribe of the Banu Sarray, whose members where called ben al-Sarray, or sons of the saddler) don't show up in the arab stories or history research of the time by that name.
In fact many secondary families are known but not that main one (at least to me, but I am not an expert). In the history books the weight of the confrontation with the Abencerrajes was carried by the Banu Bannigas, that show in the christian chronicles as the Venegas.
So who were those mysterious Cegríes? Unlike most arab and berber tribesmen in the chronicles, they don't carry the appellate ben. I have developed the theory that they are in fact the Ziris, the descendants of the berber Ziri dynasty that founded Granada in 1012. In tenuous support of this wild theory is not only the congruent sound translated into Spanish, but also the fact that the last name Zerí is still found in Granada, while no other Cegrí or Zegrí is found. Moreover, most Ziris did not carry the ben-Ziri suffix in their name, and they were not named Banu Ziris since they claimed a different ancestry from arab Yemen, instead of berber Tunisia, due to the low consideration that berbers had in al-Andalus. Perhaps someone can shed light on this point.
As a reference, this are the historic rulers of Gharnata:
BANU ZIRI (berber dynasty from Tunisia)
1013-1019 Zawi ben Ziri. Founder of Gharnata
1019-1038 Habus ben Makasan
1038-1073 Badis ben Habus al-Muzaffar al-Nasir
1073-1090 Abd-Allah ben Buluggin ben Badis
1090-(between 1145 and 1172) BANU AL-MURABITS (berber conquerors of al-Andalus)
(between 1145 and 1172)-1172 Part of the Tai'fa kingdom of Murcia
1172-1237 BANU AL-MUWAHHIDS (berber conquerors of al-Andalus)
BANU NASR (arab dinasty)
1237-1273 Muhammad I ben al-Ahmar
1273-1302 Muhammad II al-Faqih
1302-1309 Muhammad III al-Maijlu
1309-1314 Nasr Abu al-Yuyus
1314-1325 Ismail I
1325-1333 Muhammad IV ben Ismail
1333-1354 Yusuf I Abu al-Hayyay
1354-1359 Muhammad V al-Gani (first time)
1359-1360 Ismail II ben Yusuf
1360-1362 Muhammad VI
1362-1391 Muhammad V al-Gani (second time)
1391-1392 Yusuf II ben Muhammad
1392-1408 Muhammad VII al-Mustain
1408-1417 Yusuf III ben Yusuf
1417-1419 Muhammad VIII al-Zaghil (first time)
1419-1427 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (first time)
1427-1429 Muhammad VIII al-Zaghil (second time)
1429-1432 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (second time)
1432 Yusuf IV al-Mawl
1432-1445 Muhammad IX al-Aysar (third time)
1445-1454 Civil war. Up to three emirs simultaneously in different parts of the kingdom. These are:
Muhammad X al-Ahnaf (1445-1447), Yusuf V ben Ismail (1445-1450, first time), Muhammad IX al-Aysar (1447-1454, fourth time), Muhammad XI "the tiny" (1451-1454) and Saad Abu Nasr (1454) winner of the civil war.
1454-1462 Saad Abu Nasr (first time) aka Ciriza
1462-1463 Yusuf V ben Ismail (second time)
1463-1465 Saad Abu Nasr (second time) aka Ciriza
1465-1482 Abu al-Hassan
1482 Muhammad XII al-Zagoibi aka Boabdil
1482-1487 Muhammad XIII al-Zaghall
1487-1492 Muhammad XII al-Zagoibi aka Boabdil
30 ruling periods in 250 years. No comments are necessary.