• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Nyrael

Field Marshal
82 Badges
Jul 20, 2008
5.875
5.103
33
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Stellaris: Distant Stars
  • Victoria 2
  • Crusader Kings III
  • Europa Universalis 4: Emperor
  • Stellaris: Necroids
  • Warlock 2: The Exiled
  • 500k Club
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Pillars of Eternity
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Stellaris
  • Stellaris Sign-up
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Tyranny: Archon Edition
  • Tyranny: Archon Edition
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Europa Universalis IV: Dharma
  • Shadowrun: Dragonfall
  • Shadowrun: Hong Kong
  • Stellaris: Megacorp
  • Crusader Kings II: Holy Fury
  • Europa Universalis IV: Golden Century
  • Imperator: Rome Deluxe Edition
  • Imperator: Rome Sign Up
  • Stellaris: Ancient Relics
  • Stellaris: Lithoids
  • Stellaris: Federations
  • Imperator: Rome - Magna Graecia
  • Shadowrun Returns
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Tyranny - Bastards Wound
  • Age of Wonders III
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Stellaris: Apocalypse
The Alternative History AAR's

INTRODUCTION
After geting fed up with my first game (Croatian Empire; I'm not interested in World Conquest) and geting expansions, I asked myself with whom I would play next, in which timeline and what would my goals be. Clicking here and there on Selection Screen, I saw historical bookmarks and came up with an idea to play every of them and complete goals that they gave. Then I came up with another idea: „Play from the beginning to the end, changing factions every time the date is the same as one of the bookmarks.“ The idea seems to be a good one because I will not get fed up with playing the same faction for 500 years and I will even have the pleasure of seeing how the world changes because of my actions and how the factions that I controled act.

Castille, the Terror of Muslims (1399AD – 1453AD)
(it is not really detailed because most of things are from few saves and rememberment. In otherwords, if you think tht this is boring, it does not mean the next update shall be as boring)
-how did I choose it? By fliping coin
-special objectives:
*Destroy Granada
*Take over NW Africa and show them teh way of the True Faith

i108666_AAR1.bmp

So we started playing with Castille and before I could check the current situation, a Mission Screen appeared and I saw I need to finish the Reconquista.
So I immediately declared war to Granada, the only Muslim faction left in Iberia (yes, I know that I could have used the situation to attack Portugal or Aragon, but I felt that it was cheating so I left them be).
The war with Granad didn't last for too long so I managed to annex Almeria and Gibraltar from them.
My ally Portugal attacked Morroco and asked me from aid which I happily accepted. The war against them was easy because might of Aragon, Portugal, Castille and Fez was too much for them. We managed to occupy entire Morroco when the Portugesse idiots accepted... white peace. May they burn in hell...
During that war, I became Papal controler and declared a crusade against Morroco which shall last until Morroco finally falls.
So I waited for few years until my truce with Granada expires and once it was over, I invaded. They were allied with Morroco and Algiers so I was able to crush three bugs with one hit. Granada soon fell and reconquista was finished. After that, I invaded Morroco and Fez used the situation to re-declare war with them. However, I soon signed a peace treaty with Morroco because Algiers became a nasty little problem.


In year 1410 AD, Algiers was beaten:
i108667_AAR1.bmp

Aures, Biskra and Gafsa fell under my control. Immediately, I sent few missionaries in some lands I conquered.
Now, all that need to be done is waiting for the truce with Morroco to expire.

And once it expired, i invaded. It seems that Algiers and Morroco had some rough time because they were no longer allies (or Algiers rejected to support them?). However, they made some friends in Tripoli so I needed to protect my eastern border.
Portgal and Aragon honored our alliance (damn them!) so the War of Castillian Agression started. I was lucky so my allies declared white peace with Morroco once it was crushed so its lands were mine for taking.

In Year 1413 AD, Morroco was beaten and most of its land was annexed and with 31 provines under my control, I established Imperial Administration.
i108669_AAR1.bmp

Five years of peace passed when my truce with morroco expired (again). However, they were prepared for me so they allied with Fez, Algiers, Tunisia, Najd and Tripoli. It was obvious that this was won't be easy.
The war lasted for five years. During those five years, Morroco was annexed while Fez, Tunisia and Tripoli last all but one province. Algiers and Najd got away with White Peace (or payment in gold... who remembers?) Also, England took over my pope so I turned my attention towards a new victim: HRE.

i108670_AAR1.bmp

Also, during that time Croatia declared independence from Hungary (since I am a Croat, it took my interest and since my next gameplay will happen in area of Balkan, I shall include the events from there in this AAR).

i108671_AAR1.bmp

(If they had Slavonia, Croatia would look like it does today)​

In year 1431 AD, Croatia annexed Bosnia, showing me that even the
infamous Croatian Parliament can sometimes play with brains turned on.

Lets return to Castille for now. In year 1434, I declared war on Algiers and Fez in order to annex them. They certanly were prepared this time:

i108673_AAR1.bmp

The famous USM (United States of Muslims)​

War ended on year 1438 AD and a new one started on 1446 AD when the kingdom of Mamluks was filels with Tax Rebellions (especialy on their western border). I used the situation and invaded, also managing to annex Lybia (you take what you can once the rebellion ends).

During those eight years Croatia conquered Hum and Morea (why did take Morea??)
Geting full of themeselves, they invaded Ottoman Empire only to get beaten up and forced to release Ragusa. Still ,they found a way to restore their prestige. In alliance with Bohemia and Austria, they invaded their former master and...

i108675_AAR1.bmp

...somehow managed to annex them even if they had more then one province​

Nothing interesting happened until 29th May 1453. Besides the fact that many provinces were converted, that is:

i108678_AAR1.bmp

This shall be important in future that is to come!​

Epilogue
And so this boring AAR ends. The next one however, the one where I play with Croatia and fight an much bigger army in lands filled with rebellions might be more interesting..
 
Last edited:
I like the way you are picking the countries, it'll certainly be interesting to see how the world develops because of your actions
 
Throne said:
Finally a Catholic North Africa.

In 3rd AAR, a lot of interesting things shall happen there, conected with religions. And nothing was my blame...
 
Throne said:
Finally a Catholic North Africa.
I conquered North Africa in a game as France and converted all of the people to Protestantism. :D
 
So what will you do with Croatia?

Conquer the Balkans from the Ottomans?
 
So what will you do with Croatia?

Conquer the Balkans from the Ottomans?

Conquer and liberate nations that didn't annoy me with freakin rebellions, try to take over the HRE crown which I took over with Castille (most electors had over 180 relationship with Castille) and survive Poland (which became dangerous, as you will see later).
Ah yes, and become the nation #1. In other words, beat my own nation.
 
Croatia, Rise of the Balkan Empire (29th May 1453 AD – 2nd December 1492 AD)

-why did I choose Croatia? Because the 2nd Bookmark in Selection Screen is centered on Balkan after zhe fall of Byzantine Empire. Since the Empire fell in my game, I needed to choose one of Balkan nations that would be able to beat the Ottomans. The choices were Transylvania and Croatia. I choose the 2nd because of obvious reasons

-Objectives:
*In order to beat the Ottoman empire, we need manpower. To get manpower, we need the HRE crown
*Create a powerful alliance with countries that are bordering the Ottoman Empire in order to attack them from all sides (FAILED)
*Free the Balkan from Ottoman presence (without Thrace, naturaly)

STATE OF THE WORLD IN YEAR 1453

Croatia and neighbourhood
i109532_AAr2.bmp

They control Croatiam Damatia, Istria, Bosnia, Hum, Pecs and Szolnok. Ah yes, and they annexed Morea

Denmark certanly knows how to handle royal ties
i109533_AAr2.bmp


As does Poland
i109535_AAr2.bmp


England has some problems (before few years, 75% of the island was under rebellion control)
i109536_AAr2.bmp


It seems that Japan is going through a golden age
i109538_AAr2.bmp

Gameplay
Lets check the current situation:

i109539_AAr2.bmp

-Despotic Monarchy? We ain't really advanced, are we?
-Prestige 0 and Rand #34. Well, it could have been worse
-Honorabke Reputation? They annexed Bosnia, Hungary and Mora and they still have honorable reputation? I have been beaten by Croatian Parliament... oh my God..
-only 4,116 manpower? This is gonna be rough...

Now, lets check the Court:
i109540_AAr2.bmp

Seems that our Helena II is Croatia's Elisabeth II. Her skills are appreciated.
And she even knew that wasting slots on useless advisors is NOT a good idea? Wow...
But... why do we have a Muslim spy in our court?

Now lets visit the treasurer:
i109541_AAr2.bmp

-3.4 ducats a month? How am I supposed to conquer the Ottoman Empire with that?! Forget teh investments for now, we need more money!

Now lets check the national ideas... Battlefield Commisions? Time to hire that artist and change the idea to Military Drill. 47.50% of Land Tradition should give us many good generals. However, I am glad that they had that decision before I showed up.
Now lets check the army. 11k in Croatia, another 1k in Mora and another regiment is being recruited in Istria. Nice, but lets recruit 4000 more while the inflatation is still small.
Also, to accomplish the first goal, we will need to have good relations with the HRE nations. And whats the better way to improve our relations then to join the HRE? So, all my provinces are now part of HRE. Also, it would be a good idea to improve my relations with Pope before I am excomunicated.
Next, we need... no, we don't need Morea. I gave them independence before rebells could rise and crush my 1000 soldiers into 1000x1000 pieces.

Few months later Castille decided that another war with USM would be nice so they attacked Mamluks and called me for aid. Since they are no treat to me and I don't need good relations with them, I accepted and later declared White Peace.

A year passed and I managed to enter a military alliance with Ragusa, who are also allied with the Ottoman Empire. Whom will they choose in future war? Theit Muslim liberators or their brethren? Future will show.

1st August 1454: Transylvania, with support from Aquilea invaded Moldavia. Since Croatia guaranteed Moldavia's independence, they called me for aid and I accepted their offer. Novgorod, Muscovy and Poland also sided with Moldavia. However, for some reason they fought that I should lead the war. Those were great news because I won't need to worry about when to accept a peace offer.

At beginning of year 1455, Serbians used the situation and declared independence from Transylvania. This event shall be very important in future (they shall screw up all of my plans). About the same time, Moldavia accepted peace with Transylvania. However, the Ottomans used the situation and invaded. Nobody asked me for help, tough. God knows why.

2nd April 1455: Aquilea accepted peace and ceded Gorz, a province filled with gold mines. I don't need to mention that I profited from that, do I?

16th april 1455: Transylvania ceded Banat and became my vasal. This should stop them from starting unwinable wars again.

22nd December 156: Ragusa finally showed where their loyalty lies. They accepted me as their sovereign state and became my vassals.

4th november 1457: After Serbia started a war with Montenegro (they dreamt about Great Serbia again <_<) and lost it, Ottoman empire once again used the situation and invaded Serbia. Serbians asked me to honour our alliance (which we signed after their war with montenegro) and help them in their war with Ottoman Empire.
I tought I was ready for minor war so I accepted... and forgot that we will be alone because my allies are not included in this war.
Naturaly, I became the war leader against OE, Golden horde, Naxos, Zaporozhie and the Golden horde.

After few years Serbia fell and was annexed and I was left alone to fight thiese enemies who woudn't accept peace for nothing! I was attacked by Ottomans from south and by Zaporozhie from sea.

And so we continued our war for a long, long time. Rather then explaining iin detail this long war, I'll just say how I won it.

Not long after the war began, I realized that my 18,000 soldiers were to small to fight an army that is 3x that size. Not to mention that I needed to leave few troops to protect the coast from Zaporozhie and few more to protect my lands from growing rebellions.
At first, it looked like I will lose. The Ottomans had powerful armies guarding their most important provinces and attrition didn't help me. Not to mention the annoying Byzantine, Serbian and Bulgarian rebels that seemed to favour attacking me rather then Ottomans.
But my worst enemy was attrition. It was annoying how it destroyed my numbers and my armie morale. However, then I remembered something: „Turning your enemy into your ally is your greatest enemy!“. If I suffer from attrition, won't those giant armies also suffer from it if they end up in „right“ provinces? So I devised a cunning plan: buy few mercenary regiments and make Ottomans chase them. While my small regiments run around, Ottoman armies will suffer from entering attrition, as well as from monthly attrition.
Very soon, their big army suffered. Their numbers didn't change a lot, but their morale was a different story. No matter how big they are, my army boosted with max maintance, Military Drill and Crusade were worth three times their numbers.

After my armies have beaten the crap out of their regiments, Turks realised that my army is superior so they retreated to protect their capital, continuing to decay from attrition.
After Serbia and Bulgaria fell, I understood their plan. They waited for me to move far enough for them to attack, liberate and retreat the occupied regions. In other words, I needed to choose my next province carefuly or the Ottomans will strike swiftly and take back what I took from there and perhaps even attack my own lands.

i109542_AAr2.bmp

I chose Edirne as my next target. That way, I split their kingdom into two parts and, since Edirne and Burgas are near one another, Turks coudn't use the situation and invade unprotected lands with their main armies. Once my secondary regiments (and some rebells) destroyed their army in Greece, I hired few mercenaries to attack other cities in order to speed up the war. Since rebellion risk increased, I used spies to Bribe Defenders of some cities and took a loan to buy mercenaries which would fight th rebells. I also needed to split my main army because of attrition which meant that I will need to be even more careful because of Turks from Thrace and Bursa which used the situation of splited army. Also, after seeing where the wind blows, all of Ottoman allies accepted White Peace with me... all of them on the same day.
After years filled with nasty problems of rebells and Ottomans, I managed to conquer the entire Balkan (including Thrace). In other words, I was ready to invade the turkish homeland.

i109543_AAr2.bmp

Because of War Exaustion (caused mostly by attrition), Ottoman empire started falling under rebellions and my armies. Conquering their homeland was easy as beating the crap out of 500 men with an army of 500 000 men. The only true fights happened in their easternmost provinces, but they were mostly about hutnign Ottomans up and down until they were completely destroyed (Transylvania was diplomaticaly annexed in that period).

i109544_AAr2.bmp

After few months (or a year?) of suing for peace, I realized that, for some unknown reason, Ottoman empire woudn't cede more then four lousy provinces, even if they had 0% War Capacity, lost the war with 100% and had a giant War Exaustion.
After few more noths, I got few up with this stupidity so I saved the game, resigned, loaded with them and found the answer to my questions. Their emperor was...

i109545_AAr2.bmp

I had no idea how HE got there and why they choose HIM to be the Emp, but I sued for peace in his name. And please don't call this cheating because I was able to take more provinces, as well as those 350 ducats Turks had (the above picture shows why they never used them). Instead, I took only that what rightfuly belonged to Europe and what it would have been realistic to get (and what I deserve for all the pain I went through...):

i109546_AAr2.bmp

Of course, I woudn't be the „Liberator“ if I kept all those lands. So I freed albania and Wallachia and turned them into my allies. Serbia and Bulgaria would also have goten independence if tehy didn't go on my nerves every goddamn month with their rebellions...

After the war, I found out who was my potential new enemy. Poland. And that didn't make me happy. Why? Because there was a big chance I would end up fighting this thing:

i109547_AAr2.bmp

Their relationship with them was terrible to saw the least and their BB rating was giant. They also enjojed to send spies to play around my country. As did Ottomans for every 1st January. That cerated pirates. Pirates destroyed my economy. Nuff said.
Fortunately, there were no battles betewen me and Poland. At least for now...

On June 1472: Montenegro and Achaea accepted me as their sovereign.

The Ottoman empire didn't need my help to decay. They were pro's in doing it themeselves. As wre the Mamluks who lost their northern provinces (which became Syria).

i109548_AAr2.bmp

10th July 1476: Helena II died and Slavic II rose to the throne. He was also a good king.

13th May 1477: Ragusa finally acepted the fact that they are Croatians and became part Croatia again.
24th July 1477: Serbia became a catholic province. Four years later, their culture will become a tolerated culture in my kingdom.
During those four years, Denmark inheriated (again??) Sweeden and...

i109549_AAr2.bmp

...formed the kingdom of Scandinavia. Seems that marriage IS stronger the Sword​

11th March 1483: My allies from Bohemia lost the war against Austria and Poland. And they were wounded greately!

i109550_AAr2.bmp

But I was overjojed because of that! Thanks to that hit, on 3rd March 1483, they became...
i109551_AAr2.bmp

This event shall affect the future that is to come.

6th July 1487: Start of Aragonesse Succesion War. Seems the old King of Aragon died without leaving the heir so he declared the king of Castille as the new King of Aragon. However, relatives from Portugal disagreed with that decision so they, with support from England, started a war against Castille and Aragon.

16th March 1488: Achaea accepted my annexation proposal.
23rd September 1488: I became the Papal Controler, even tough I didn't bribe anyone. Still, this was useful for removing my BB score.

2nd December 1492: Stoped playing (while I didn't become the HRE emperor, most voters are supporting me)

EPILOGUE

Maps from year 1492:

Portugal, you SUCK!
i109552_AAr2.bmp


Mamluks are dying and Castille had colonies in western and eastern Africa as well as in Americas
i109553_AAr2.bmp


Japan's Golden Age ended
i109554_AAr2.bmp


And the next nation is...
i109555_AAr2.bmp

Shawnee Vs Portugal! Lets see how it looks like to play with natives against colonists​
 
Very nice war with the Ottomans.

But Shawnee?!?! :( :eek:
 
The Shawnee AAR shall be posted in few minutes... just wait until I upload the pics.
 
Wrath of Shawnee (1492 - 1496)​

-why did I choose Shawnee? Well, next bookmark was about discovery of the New World and since it was alredy discovered and colonised in some places, I decided to play with a native faction rather then a colinising simply because it is a greater challenge.

Objective: Portugal's colonies must be returned to natives.

Soon after starting the game, I saw that I have 7000 soldiers and am able to recruit 4000 more. While they were being recruited, I needed to come up with a war plan. Since Portgal can take my provinces without sieges, protection alone will not be enough. I'll need to take care that they don't even manage to enter them. Their military superiority is also dangerous, but there is no plan against that. I'll need to believe the dices.
So once the armies were recruited and splited to planed locations, I declared war. I coudn't lose time because the war in Iberia could end at every moment.

i109757_AAR3.bmp

Now I realized that most of those cities can be conquered by an assault. The morale and number of defenders was so small that it wasn't worth waiting behind sieging canons (it is fascinating how Shawnee is able to use canons and not guns, armor...)

Portugesse soldiers arrived to defend their lands. One unit was able to get past me into my lands and take my province, but my own soldiers were faster (seems that natives move faster around the map) and destroyed the Portugesse soldiers.

After few years I sued for peace and hot Chiaha and Cherokee provinces. A smart man knows when it is time to sue for peace rather then wait for Portugal to kill you.

On 18th October 1494, Portgal has bankupted. The reasons: Castilele&Aragon, Shawnee and rebells... which are supported by...

i109758_AAR3.bmp

And very soon...

i109760_AAR3.bmp

Really, I tought that this would be longer... and harder. Ah well, lets return to Europe until the bookmark ends. Natives are too boring for my tastes.

Wining and losing at the same time? Returning to Croatian throne for few years shall certanly be interesting.
i109762_AAR3.bmp

In the next episode:
-How to fight Austria and Poland?-
-Bohemia strikes back-
-Fall of a not one, but three mighty empires-
-Redemption of Portugal-
-2nd fall of the Byzantine empire-
-Return of the Ottomans-​
 
Persia inheriated the Ottoman empire, it seems.
(Da, primjetio sam ;))

BTW, would it be possible to add Novus Romanorum Regnum (New Roman kingdom [since translators don't now latin word for empire]) as an forming faction (like Spain, GB, Scandinavia...)?
The next faction (once I write the AAR #3.5) I will play will be the Papal States (tough I have been thinkign about Tuscany) and I don't want to form Italy and neither would I like to stay a Papal State. I would rather form a more centralised faction. In other words, a faction that would get greater tax income and better soldiers, but also greater rebellion risk (besides in Roma) and small maximum reputation.
Of course, it would require certain number of provinces and sliders in right positions.

So is it able to mod that in and would you consider that a legal playing for this AAR?
 
Last edited:
Yes, I know. But I confess that I am more interested into is it possible to create or not. If it is possible, then I may do it one day. But I just decided that I won't do it during this campaign.

For now, I'll choose the Papal States or Tuscany and form Italian Empire (if I choose Tuscany) or destroy the heretics (if I choose the Papal States). Both of those will require Itallian penisula under my control.
 
Last edited: