• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Closer to Novgorod or Pskov? :p
How can the Germans use heavy tanks in snowy forests of the north? Blame the AI and a silly game.
Awesome AAR I must say once again! :D
 
I'm using DiDay's common weapons add on (doesn't change any rules or events) and that gives a few specialist formations for the majors. The Red coloured infantry are guards divisions. There's a tech you can research which gives them a 5% boost on org and morale for each level, so by the time you've researched that 3-4 times they are pretty tough and, critically, recover their organisation quite quickly. Since I'm upgrading rifle divs with high experience to Guards you start by about 1943 to acquire a red army that is pretty historical - an army of quality (the armour and the guards) and an army of quantity (the rest).

I started to really notice the difference about now. A Guards division could take a real beating and be back in the line in 3-4 weeks where a normal rifle division would take around 5 weeks.

Ah hah! Guards divisions were tremendously important, so that's a nice addition -- do they have Shock divisions as well?
 
I think the German lines are groaning and cracking... Those two Panzerkorps would make excellent single-province pockets, methinks (were it not for the fact that you've played well beyond this stage of the game). If you can knock out those German armored divisions, you'd really weaken them. It seems that only the German Panzers are holding up well in straight-up fights with your Red hordes.
 
Suspending Mars was not a feasible option. The 6th battle of Leningrad was going badly and 23 Army was desparately short of ammunition. Having endured 18 months of siege, Leningrad could not be left to collapse at this stage. With all its assault formations now locked into their positions on the front line, Stavka appeared to have little choice but to try and reduce the various strongpoints that anchored the entire German front on this sector.

With this in mind, elements of 1 Tank Army hit the German salient at Marinskoye late on 15 January 1943.

The update ends at a great point, you tease! The Axis forces do seem to be struggling, although your own casualties are considerable, hopefully you can grind your way through their defences.
 
Closer to Novgorod or Pskov? :p
How can the Germans use heavy tanks in snowy forests of the north? Blame the AI and a silly game.
Awesome AAR I must say once again! :D

Pskov is a long way to the rear, but Novgorod appears on the operational maps, its just my focus is to get control of the south shore of L Ladoga, as not only will that relieve the pressure on Leningrad, but I can also pocket those German units on the Onega-Ladoga isthmus.

Ah hah! Guards divisions were tremendously important, so that's a nice addition -- do they have Shock divisions as well?

Not as such, but you could regard any rifle division with attached art, at, etc as a shock formation. In truth the Shock Armies were quite a mixed bag and more a legacy of Soviet pre-war planning when they envisaged an offensive unit as a combined tank-infantry army. Once they set up the independent tank armies this no longer held. The result was that some shock armies (i think the 3rd is a good eg) were very good formations and others (the 2nd I seem to recall) no better or worse than a normal infantry army. Especially as Stavka allocated additional artillery & independent tank brigades to any formation designated to lead a major offensive.

I think the German lines are groaning and cracking... Those two Panzerkorps would make excellent single-province pockets, methinks (were it not for the fact that you've played well beyond this stage of the game). If you can knock out those German armored divisions, you'd really weaken them. It seems that only the German Panzers are holding up well in straight-up fights with your Red hordes.

at the moment this is like the Soviet 42-43 offensive in this sector. Keeps on promising a major breakthrough but it keeps on just coming up short. The idea of pocketing those 6 panzer divisions (or at least inflicting serious damage on them) more or less dominated my planning for the rest of Mars (ie to early March)

The update ends at a great point, you tease! The Axis forces do seem to be struggling, although your own casualties are considerable, hopefully you can grind your way through their defences.

I think the Germans are struggling, noticeably their allies are becoming much weaker in relation to my forces (mainly as my equipment and doctrine techs, plus combat experience start to really improve) so that constantly unbalances their lines (in that I can often find a weak spot), but the core German units are as tough as ever. My problem is that my own manpower is dipping to dangerous levels (most of the rifle divs are at least 2000 below notional compliment) even with only routinely reinforcing armour and guards. I can't afford this sort of loss ratio much longer, unless it is leading to actual pockets where the final amount of damage I inflict more than covers the manpower losses.

There'll be a short break in updates till early May. I'm off to the Netherlands visiting family (& escaping a certain event in London next week). Since I've got a mass of (paying) work to do while away, I doubt I'll have time to put up any posts. Next will be a review of 1942 in terms of numbers, industry etc, then back to Mars. Then Leningrad, the German Smolensk offensive and a long peak at whats going on down on the shores of the Black Sea (not forgetting Central Asia).


and ... if you haven't already, don't forget to vote in the ACA awards (link in my sig). Of course if you want another AAR to read in the meantime, you can always catch up on my (rather differently written) Seven Years War one.
 
Last edited:
Since you're attempting to escape that wedding, I'm sure you'll find much to enjoy on Koninginnedag in the Netherlands. ;)

Don't envy our Dutch crownprince and his princess. First Easter, than the royal wedding in the UK which he has to attend and after that Koninginnedag. The poor guy hardly has time for himself, especially since he has three small children which are free from school now since it's springbreak. I'm wondering if he even has the time to follow up on this great AAR, so perhaps a few weeks without updates isn't such a bad idea...

Anyway, have a nice trip!
 
Since you're attempting to escape that wedding, I'm sure you'll find much to enjoy on Koninginnedag in the Netherlands. ;)

Safe travels and I'll await the resolution of Mars with bated breath. :)

well Koninginnedag was as much fun as ever, its probably good for the livers' of the Netherlands it only comes once a year

Hmm.... Our great hero escapes from wedding ??? :p

not totally, but it was almost a perfect escape

Don't envy our Dutch crownprince and his princess. First Easter, than the royal wedding in the UK which he has to attend and after that Koninginnedag. The poor guy hardly has time for himself, especially since he has three small children which are free from school now since it's springbreak. I'm wondering if he even has the time to follow up on this great AAR, so perhaps a few weeks without updates isn't such a bad idea...

Anyway, have a nice trip!

ah it was a pity for him it wasn't the other way around ... then he could have found some cheaper presents to take
 
Annex 1: The Numbers of War, Jan 1942-Jan 1943


(People and Army win together)

1942 can be seen as a year of either stalemate or dramatic shifts of the front line back and forth across Western Russia, Bielorussia and the Ukraine. At the start of the year, the front lay just north and west of Kalinin, Bryansk formed the front line and German pressure on Kursk, Kharkov and the Donets was steadily increasing. On the main front, 3 major Soviet Offensives (The Winter Counterstroke, Kuznetsov and Suvorov) had briefly led to the liberation of Kiev and the occupation of north east Rumania. The German counterstroke had taken them back to the Rybinsk reservoir in the north and allowed them to secure their main winter defense line on the Dniepr all the way to the Black Sea.



It was only in the Arctic that the year had seen a clear Soviet triumph. Archangelsk now lay well to the rear of the front line and the equivalent of 15-20 German and axis divisions had been destroyed.

If the fighting in Persia, Syria and Central Asia is discounted then the main front with the Germans can be divided into three theatres of the Arctic, the Western Axis (Western Russia and Bielorussia) and the Ukraine. In combination (combat losses and divisions destroyed in encirclements) total Soviet losses were 1,070,564 and for the Axis 1,254,922 (and the Germans alone lost 797,554 in combat and around 130,000 in encirclements). If Stavka was frustrated at the lack of clear strategic victories, it was clear that maintaining the current stalemate was costing the Germans heavily.



For both sides, the Western Axis had been the region where they sought a decisive victory. In effect, the struggle for Moscow saw over 50% of total losses for both sides. As is clear, by late 1941 both sides had concentrated the bulk of their forces in this region leading to a series of bruising battles.

However, unlike 1941, the intensity and location of combat varied across the year.



In the Ukraine, there was a period of intense combat starting with the German offensive in February and ending with the liberation of Odessa in May. On this sector, Stavka had been able to absorb the German autumn offensive by trading space, and effectively by the end of September major operations had ceased.

On the Western Front, the Soviet winter offensive had ended by late April and there was a brief lull as Stavka prepared for Suvorov. The result, and the need to contest the German counterattack, led to some of the most intense battles of the war stretching across the summer into October. November had seen something of a lull with the exception of the German offensive in the North. Mars, in turn, saw a massive increase in the intensity of the fighting.

In Central Asia, Soviet and Japanese forces more or less traded combat losses. However, the Soviet border victories in July and encirclement of the main Japanese army in October, gave the impression of a decisive outcome to the campaign.



The losses traded between the Soviets and the Germans were to have a major impact on the outcome of the 1943 battles.



In building themselves up for their Autumn offensive, the Germans had forced all their manpower reserves into the front line. As Soviet pressure increased, they were to become vulnerable, especially as they were no longer able to replace destroyed divisions. On the other hand, Soviet manpower constraints meant it was no longer feasible to rely on attrition to break the front. Mars was to be the last time that Stavka voluntarily sought to use brute force to disrupt the German front.



Despite the losses, by January 1943 the RKKA was significantly stronger than it had been in January 1942. This was both in terms of quantity and quality. The DNO divisions were mostly being converted to regular formations (and later some were disbanded to free up manpower) and some 18 Rifle Divisions had Guards status (as did 3 Tank Divisions).


(more bread for the front and rear)

The VVS was much the same size as it had been at the start of the year and the RKKH had sustained substantial losses, especially in its destroyer and submarine squadrons. However, its overall performance, meant that a substantial amount of industrial and research effort was now being allocated to building the fleet up for future operations. With the British effectively passive, it was clear that the task not just of liberating the USSR, but also of Western Europe would fall to the Soviets. Equally, the uneasy peace with Japan was bound to end at some stage.

Soviet industrial production was slowly recovering. As regions were liberated, factories were slowly brought back into production and increasing attention was being paid to production efficiency.



In consequence, IC was being concentrated on reinforcements and upgrades



and new production was increasingly being allocated to non manpower intensive uses



At this stage, the RKKH was only seeing limited investment but not only were combat losses being replaced some new capital ships were in production.

Overall leadership capacity was only slowly growing but it fluctuated substantially as major cities were liberated and lost again. However, apart from keeping a minimal level of NKVD activity in Mexico, research and increasing the officer corps were the only priorities.



Increasingly combat delays and loss of organisation due to a lack of trained officers was becoming a major constraint. This was being worsened as the new Guards Divisions were taking officers away from the bulk of the combat forces.



By the end of the year, the gap was slowly closing but it was not till mid-1943 that the RKKA had its full notional officer cadre. In reality, this was as much due to the decision to suspend the production of new land forces as the allocation of scarce leadership assets.

Research was still being carefully focussed. New equipment for the rifle divisions was skewed to dealing with the threat of German armour, and offensive weaponry was lagging. In terms of industrial research, renewed effort was being focussed on anything that would improve the manpower situation.





The new Guards formations were slowly becoming qualitatively different to the bulk of the army. They were all raised from the most experienced divisions and were now being given addition training and equipment.



 
Great update! Very interesting to see all these numbers neatly organised.

I can only imagine how much effort must have gone into collecting all this information, but it more than pays of!
 
Hats off indeed for having spent so much time to create such an informative post. A good year on the whole, there can be little doubt that the USSR is stronger now than twelve months before, whereas the same cannot be said of the Axis. Heartening to also note the advance in technology and so forth. Europe is soon to be swamped by the red tide.
 
Let me buck the trend and call for no further manpower boosts for the Germans. :) To me, it made sense to give the Germans some crutches while they were still thundering into the Soviet Union. At this stage, though, their ability to launch strategic offensives is spent. So why give them extra manpower now, when all that is going to achieve is to turn the slog towards Berlin into an even longer, seesawing slog towards Berlin?

Now, if you want to rest your Red troops before the Seelow Heights and then give the Germans some manpower and a month or two to recover, so that you'll have an epic battle for Berlin, that would be another matter... :)

Regardless of my suggestions, good overview of the year that was 1942. The Soviet Union seems poised to extend the Workers' Paradise all the way to the Atlantic.
 
Annex 1 was amazing. I cannot believe how much detail you have recorded. The table showing available manpower was particularly powerful in telling the story of the war so far and the huge crunch that is coming for the Germans (would make a good line graph).

Possibly a bit otherenthusiastic there. I must be spending too much time working with spreadsheets.

Looks like there should be a big breakthrough in 1943 (as German units run out of men). I expect you will be glad of a change of scenery.
 
When the country runs out of manpower, it collapses quickly in HOI3. It won't be an epic push for Berlin. Germany won't become gradually weaker. In sth like 2-3 months most of its army will be out of ORG and with so little strength that shattering will be extremely common. Fighting will be very easy and it will take sth like 6-7 months to reach Berlin, not a year or two. Unlike IRL, in HOI3 your MP is of the same "quality" for the entire game (which is based on laws). It's not that you will be facing old soldiers now. There will be no Volksturm. In case of the AI, when it reaches 0 MP, the challenge factor disappears.

So give them at least 400 MP to pay some of their MP debts (which are probably huge by now) or face boredom.
 
I'll do a proper response etc with the next update, but just around the issue of German manpower. Its a bit like the issues that have arisen in Redandwhite's excellent UK AAR which is wanting to both let the game run as it does, to make it fun to play (& a challenge) and to keep it on a sort of plausible dynamic. From my point of view, I think the army-combat part of the AI is pretty good (actually when it had decent resources it was pretty good in 1.3) and its not doing too much that is downright silly (remember it was my deployment in the summer of 1941 that opened up the Arctic as a major theatre). Lothos' revised lua scripts seem to have generally sorted out the production side (though I still think Germany is too naval orientated), but its clear that the supply production routine is flawed (in particular that it doesn't recognise the difference between producing enough supplies and trying to use supply production as a means to solve a supply delivery problem (which was the German problem in mid-42) ... and manpower is a bit off (the UK issue is linked to the perenial problem with modelling India).

Anyway to cut a long story short I do give the Germans two batches of 500 MP over the next 15-18 months. At this particular stage, their units are quite strong and none shatter in combat till very late in 43. So what I decided was the first time the Red Army enters the Reich proper that would trigger them in real life to start rounding up a batch of the population so far spared military service. The second one is as Stuyvesant has anticpated above is when the Red Army is pilling up on the Oder, at that stage I gave them another 500 (this time with the logic that final boost sort of reflects clearing out the training establishments and making sure that there are no combat capable soldiers hanging around in nice rear area admin work.

Neither boost allow them to launch a sustained offensive (though with the second they try) but both bring a suitable desparate air to the campaign as the Soviets enter Germany proper ....