But Rommel is the Führers favorite, like Von Paulus, how could you fire such men?
It's indeed a problem.
Giving him a nice promotion and a job away from the action, would be a good idea though.
But Rommel is the Führers favorite, like Von Paulus, how could you fire such men?
Nice picture of the donkey HE is looking at the camera (now don't tell me that donkeys are dumb )
I have a feeling that when Rommel takes Gibraltar all his past "mistakes" will be forgotten. HE will be needed for Barbarossa so the brass will happily overlook this ... blunder... in his back
Incredible achievement by the technically inferior spanish army. They have nearly cut off an entire army group from its supply line. Though without a coherent front the supplies will still get through.
Is it possible that the Spanish Fox is planning to finish off the south before the forces in his back link up?
6 million is a rough figure i found on the net. I suppose it is an estimate of the official numbers of beasts of burden that were supposed to be present in a division multiplied by the number of divisions.
I'm quite sure there were more. But then again 6 million is not a small number.
End off topic here
I only have one thing to say: Fire Rommel ASAP.
I don't want to know what consequences his incompetence could have against the Soviets...
Been following this for almost a year all lurker-like, but I've just got to say that this is easily my favourite HoI3 AAR. The attention to detail in the updates is staggering!
Now, let's hope Spain falls soon, before the AI manages to lose the entire Spanish force.
That Spain situation is getting quite tense. It seems as if you/AI have reacted too late to the threat of them Spanish cutting of your supply lines. Let it be a lesson for Russia, to always have some rearguards to take out forces that were left behind. But I am confident that these matters will be resolved in the end.
All the best!
I have done Barbarossa with AI control (at Army level) and with direct control. Direct control resulted in penetration, manoeuvre and the surrounding and destruction of pockets. AI control can create pockets but tends to be more of an avalanche. The strange thing is that the ultimate result has been similar. The destruction of pockets takes time, while the AI achieves greater over-runs of retreating enemy. Either way destroys enemy units and gets to Moscow in similar time. One big difference is that the AI loses more men. It is essential to have significant manpower reserves when letting the AI attack.
When using the AI to achieve a breakthrough, I sometimes need to turn the AI off, move the HQ and some units and turn the AI back on. This is necessary as you can not order the AI to adopt a sweeping turn. The axis of advance has to be straight and it starts from the HQ location. To achieve a breakthrough and sweep, you need to set up the intitial battle and, at the right time set the conditions for the second phase (by moving the HQ and setting a new axis of advance).
Uriah is doing a great job using the AI. It is good to continue this but accept its limitations. I think it is remaining in the spirit of his intention, to conduct multi phase AI attacks.
As for the situation in Spain, Uriah acknowledges that he allowed a situation to develop, where he had three fronts but only one AI HQ. Had he detached two corps, activated their AI and given appropriate objectives, this situation would never have occurred. The AI has plenty of faults but many of those faults can be countered by good objectives and a good axis of advance. Initially, his army was significantly mobile and used a high level of supply. In hindsight, an infantry/mountaineer based army would have been better for the initial attack, with mobile forces added to the attack force after the initial breakthrough. In addition, a reserve should be retained, to deal with unexpected circumstances. In this case, the reserve would have been sent to remove the Eastern pocket. When a reserve is committed, it must be replaced. There are some good lessons to apply before Barbarossa.
Looks like there is a new threat developing in NW Spain. The ai didn't allocate enough units to seal the pocket. At the moment, nothing to panic about, however, coupled with the threat to the south.....
I will look forward to the ai army objective Barbarossa, it should be quite a challenge. Thx for the update.
The problem should not be great, once you have more units than the AI in NE Spain they should reestablish supply.
For Russia:
Collaborate Gov+Early start = Win
Total exploit+ historical start = oops, interesting.
But Rommel is the Führers favorite, like Von Paulus, how could you fire such men?
It's indeed a problem.
Giving him a nice promotion and a job away from the action, would be a good idea though.
The new forum has some problems, in 1 of 4 postings attempts i get something like "you have logged in after loading the previous page" and I think "So what???" following the instructions doesn't seem to work either.
though at least one has “liberated” a bicycle
That is a thought - he could have an Army Group for Barbarossa.
An examination of von Kayser’s initial plans has revealed he has completely misunderstood the position. Instead of a direct push to the Mittelmeer, he has elected to loop around the captured provinces to southern Spain, where he would prepare to assault the coastal cities of Barcelona and Tarragona. He has obviously thought his mission was to capture the two cities with the least possible number of casualties. OKH has now ordered that he must also relieve the besieged city of Zaragosta and that his line of advance must be through that city.
Your units have 30 days supply on hand, perhaps you can beat them to the last, in country, VP province and tip them into surrender. What is the Spanish surrender progress %?
1. Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.
Please reload the window.
After the defeat of the encircled units at the Portugese boarder Rommel is not outnumbering the defenders and the freed divisions will make the end come faster, maybe even outflanking the defenders.
ps. I hate
Right now, it is hard to fathom who is doing the encircling.
Brilliant.
Fucking brilliant.
For the first time, I see that the enemy AI has nearly managed to trap your army into Spain.
A huge German thrust towards Madrid, in the normal Blitzkrieg-fashion that should end the war, is threatened from the flanks; guerilla like units striking from Galicia and Catalonia are threatening to cut off the entire army!
AI is better than AI!
Or the AI is more stupid than the AI!
which is why Dutch fans still delight in accusing German football supporters of 'waar is de fietsen van mijn maar'? - hadn't realised the Wehrmacht's taste for bicycle theiving had spread so widely
as ever great stuff ... wish the Germans in my game current game would leave such large inviting holes behind their front though
Yes it could be a good solution. An Army Group devoted to deep penetrations while the other ones would secure the flanks and his rear.
rather disturbingly I've been thinking about this whilst off for a run ... I too tend to use the AI at army level - it seems just the right degree of detail and control. In the main its fine/great when things are fairly linear but if the front gets complex then even with axis of advance it can go very wrong. At the core how the army AI 'sees' a position is a long way from how you do - esp if its also not sure it has enough force to do what you want. It may be an idea till you have the Spanish back under the thumb to go over to the theatre AI (just create one purely for Spain). Usually this can be frustrating as the Theatre AI brings all sorts of baggage with it, but it maybe that a bit of disorganisation to your drive south and some radical redeployments is what you need. Of course it could make a difficult situation even worse (as it did to me in my latest game briefly) but it might mean proper attention being paid to your line of communications?
The incompetence of the Italians in Africa is only rivalled by the well lead AI of the Spanish. My God, how did it get so out of hand there? You are lucky that the Spanish are so outclassed in quality or else you might have suffered a painful and shameful defeat. Well better to learn these lessons in Spain than in Russia I guess.
Oh and so nice to hear that I am always right, just like your wife. I must tell my own girlfriend that so that perhaps she will listen to me for a change, haha.
Your units have 30 days supply on hand, perhaps you can beat them to the last, in country, VP province and tip them into surrender. What is the Spanish surrender progress %?
After the defeat of the encircled units at the Portugese boarder Rommel is not outnumbering the defenders and the freed divisions will make the end come faster, maybe even outflanking the defenders.
ps. I hate
I really don't see how the invasion should fail. Even if the Spanish manage to close te gap the Iberian army i snow in place and one province away from reopening it. What concerns me more is the Coruña situation. It looks like there the balance of forces is against you. I hope your generals figure out a plan soon , if only to retreat into La Coruña proper and wait until some more troops are freed form the south. Would it be possible to allocate more bombers to this front? Some tactical bombers maybe to reduce infrastructure in the likely axis of advance of the Spanish in the north?
Love that plane picture. I already printed it and I'm goingthrough the markings with a magnifying glass. Maybe I'll figure out which unit it's from.
Also I noticed Neuling became Nehring
And I second the message that asks you to show us the surrender progress
Right now, it is hard to fathom who is doing the encircling.
aye ... maybe we need a map of Spain with overlapping Venn diagrams?
Brilliant.
Fucking brilliant.
For the first time, I see that the enemy AI has nearly managed to trap your army into Spain.
A huge German thrust towards Madrid, in the normal Blitzkrieg-fashion that should end the war, is threatened from the flanks; guerilla like units striking from Galicia and Catalonia are threatening to cut off the entire army!
AI is better than AI!
Or the AI is more stupid than the AI!
I really have trouble, thinking of this as a blitzkrieg type operation. The ai has been pushing and shoving the Spanish accross their country in a manner that would make the Kaiser proud.