Soviet-Germany B2 - C1
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOK II
RADICALISATION AND WAR
1940-1944
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter I
Power struggle and Radicalisation
1940-1941
The Socialist People’s Front entered the year 1940 enriched by war experience. On the one hand, the victory in Spain had strengthened the party since the government had gained international attention. It became infamous to the nations of Europe who had witnessed the capability of the People’s Army. Germany had become a great power again and could re-enter the arena of great power politics. This, however, raised questions within the SPF regarding the German standing towards the Soviet Union. That was the other hand point by which the war experience weakened the party, it was a matter over which it would soon split over.
As was previously discussed, Ernst Thälmann’s re-emergence to the SPF leadership in 1938 was the first step towards this split. Thälmann formed his own faction within the party; a group of old-guard Stalinist die-hards who opposed Wilhelm Pieck’s leadership and policies. Thälmann himself was by far more popular than Pieck who always lived in his shadow. Consequently, Pieck found himself the head of a "right-wing faction"; the milder faction of the party, those who wished to preserve the people's republic and the national road to socialism while keeping a friendly but independent stance towards Moscow. Thälmann, on the other hand, and his old-guard followers, believed that the People’s Republic should develop into an advanced soviet-republic like Russia.
What eventually clove the party in 1940 was the Comintern issue. The war in Spain delayed the issue and the opposing factions stood together but in early 1940, with victory at hand, the question at last remained to be answered: Was the People’s Republic of Germany to become a puppet state of the Soviet Union or an alternative to Soviet-style communism?
The Comintern Question
The Comintern question was by no means a new issue within the SPF; it was as old as the party itself. The KPD had always been the typical Comintern party; it took orders from it, and always asked for its approval before taking decisions. When the KPD took on a dominant role in government in 1933, it must take aim of the other SPF movements and the
Reichswehr. Despite this obvious obstacle to Stalin’s power in Germany, the KPD leadership in the SPF maintained a close relationship with Comintern but Comintern’s grip on the SPF slowly deteriorated over the course of the 1930s. In 1937, Wilhelm Pieck had managed to consolidate almost all
de facto political power in the country to the party, and influenced by the non-KPD SPF members and his own power ambitions he wondered; why should he now return to the pre-1933 Comintern obedience?
July 17, 1940: The eighth Comintern World Congress in Moscow where the SPF was excommunicated from the communist world.
Stalin had no physical force within the SPF, so the party factions themselves had to determine the party policy. In that regard, Germany in its current form was by no means a puppet state. This argument gave Pieck’s faction considerable support and the debate hardened during the first quarter of 1940. Pieck went as far as to openly declare the SPF an independent party which maintained goodwill and cooperation with Comintern but made its own policies.Stalin was of course outraged and turned Pieck into socialism’s enemy number one. A serious Soviet-German split was in the making. In July 1940, a Comintern world congress was held in Moscow where Pieck was accused of “rightist tendencies” and “bourgeoisie sentiments”. Other Comintern member parties in Europe were forced to severe relations with the SPF as the party was excommunicated from the communist community. The party leaders were left in a state of shock for it had never been Pieck’s intention to invoke Stalin’s hostility or a German-Soviet split.
Thälmann’s reclaimation of power
In order to appease Stalin and get his support for his party faction, Thälmann went to Moscow in August. Stalin understood he was his only hope of getting the SPF back into the Soviet sphere of influence so he assured Thälmann that he had Comintern’s full support for a party takeover. Was that to happen, Stalin would normalise relations with Germany and the SPF. When Thälmann returned to Berlin he was welcomed like a hero by his supporters whose opposition to Pieck and the current state of affairs had reached a pinnacle.
Pieck began realising that his grip on the party was beginning to slip as many of his communist supporters had switched sides. At a party congress in October he made his last attempt to form a concrete policy for his faction. He declared that the rapid armament production had quickly made the
Volksarmee one of the most advanced in Europe and this would continue. The first officially commissioned German tanks since the Great War had just been released from production and Germany had by itself been able to win a war on foreign soil and help create the third communist state in the world, where the Soviets had failed. This, he claimed, was a proof of the German non-dependence on the Soviet Union. To this he added that if the Soviet Union would further try and interfere in the SPF’s foreign policy, Germany would have to reconsider the defence pact since 1933. Just three months before, Pieck had been on the brink of resignation in shock over the German-Soviet split. Now, he and his loose band of supporters had taken a U-turn in policy. Thälmann held a promising speech after which he and his followers left the congress in protest.
Armaments produciton continued at full speed after the Spanish War. In September 1940, the first German tanks since the Great War
were commissioned. They were among the most advanced in the world. Pieck used this fact to form a new U-turn policy as a last resort to safe himself and his faction.
Pieck’s statements at the party congress were aimed at defining a clear policy for the “right-wing” faction to strengthen its position. He was mistaken. His clear cut stance worked in Thälmann’s favour who was able to rally many of Pieck’s supporters on his side in fear of Stalin. Two weeks later, the Politburo voted Pieck out of the chair of general secretary. He announced his resignation due to deteriorating health and, unsurprisingly, Thälmann took his place.
October 27, 1940: Wilhelm Pieck announces his resignation as general secretary of the Socialist People‘s Front.
Stalin wanted him dead but Thälmann spared his life by allowing him to flee into exile in Central America.
The German Soviet Republic
Thälmann formally took over the party on November 6, 1940 with a significant number of supporters at his side. He was more convinced than ever that this was the time for the People’s Republic to evolve into a genuine Marxist-Leninist soviet republic. To do this, he had to first consolidate his power within the party, and then transform the constitution. During the first weeks of December 1940, Thälmann had the entire top leadership of the party and government re-manned. First, Wilhelm Pieck and his closest associates were quietly removed from public life. These included Chancellor Anton Ackermann, Pieck’s silent workhorse in government, and almost all his cabinet. Then, a brutal party purge was initiated. Over 100 party members of all ranks; ministers, government and party officials and laymen were imprisoned and eight top ranking communists were executed. Among them was Arno von Lenski, the socialist-leaning defence minister and chief of staff, who had held the
Reichswehr at bay for so many years. Lenski was the highest ranking SPF member who was executed during the purge.
The government finally outlawed the other political parties who had had
de jure access to legislation via the
Reichstag. Their political organs, which had been censored by the ministry of information until now, were officially banned. Following the series of arrests, some executions were carried out. The former NSDAP leaders, Göring, Goebbels and Himmler were shot in their prison cells among other right-wing political leaders. Gregor Strasser, the former chancellor and a few former
Reichswehr generals were also killed. After the purge, Thälmann's power was absolute. He had become a little Stalin, although he did manage to evade his mentor's recommendation of mass-executions of former comrades.
The Soviet Socialist Republic of Germany and its new cabinet after the December
purges of the SPF, the party's dissolution and absolute takeover by Ernst Thälmann and his faction.
On January 1, 1941, the old modified Weimar constitution was replaced with a new one. The People’s Republic of Germany was transformed into the Soviet Socialist Republic of Germany – or Soviet-Germany. It was a republic based on the Russian model with some improvisations. The economic policy was left mostly intact for the time being as a complete shift towards planned economy might stir up popular unrest. The Socialist People’s Front was dissolved and its successor was the reprised Communist Party of Germany. The other parties and movements that had made up the SPF gathered in five new puppet parties with the right to sit in the
Reichstag and pose for elections. The new cabinet included almost only original KPD members. Ludwig Renn, one of the loudest voices in the Thälmann faction, was elected the president of the Supreme Soviet, thus acting as the head of state. Thälmann resumed the title of general secretary of the party but also took on the office of Chairman of the Council of Ministers, whereby becoming the head of government.
The new KPD used the modified emblem of the SPF and incorporated it into the new state flag of Soviet-Germany. All national symbols had now disappeared.
On January 15, a declaration of goodwill towards the Soviet Union and the world communist movement was released and shortly afterwards, the KPD was again invited to the ranks of the Comintern. The declaration also noted the Soviet Union’s hegemony in the communist world. Stalin immediately took what was his. On the Comintern’s demands, Thälmann initiated additional purges within the KPD itself to clean the party of all unorthodox communists, imagined and unimagined, executing 19 party members and banishing or imprisoning hundreds.
Naturally, renewed fear of a counter-revolutionary invasion from the West blossomed and the first joint staff meeting of the Germanarmy and the Soviet Red Army was held in February 1941. Indeed, the next task was to prepare for war. After almost ten years, the revolution in Germany was complete and either the capitalists would invade like they did in Russia in 1917 or, in good time, the revolution would be carried abroad. In either case, the German government continued to favour and nurture the sword and shield of the revolution: The
Volkswehr.