The Second American Civil War
June, 1936
President Hoover was presiding over a dying nation. Slumped over the Resolute, the desk of Presidents going back to Rutherford B. Hayes he marveled at how smooth the wood felt against his fingers after so many years. Previously the wood served the HMS Resolute a British exploration ship that had navigated the arctic. Given to the United States by Queen Victoria... and then the thought slipped away. After all the House of Saxe-Coburg-Gotha no longer resided in London and it was in no position to give gifts. Certainly not the gifts that the United States required.
In less than 20 years the entire world had been turned upside down. The German victory in the Weltkrieg, the word still rough in his mouth, had wrought such a terrifying tumult the shockwaves of which were still being felt today as the jumbled map that was spread across the Oval Office testified to. The fall of the British Empire, the rise of the German Empire, and the metastizing of Socialism, Syndicalism, and Bolshevism. The resultant collapse of global markets had been like a dagger pointed at the heart of American industry and commerce. Steadily exports fell, the factories grew idle, the unemployment lines grew longer and then... the financial collapse that had sparked their years of misery. Years of misery that were turning into years of lead.
Long protected by the divine providence of two enormous oceans the United States had been able to repel the threats and dangers of the outside world. But no longer. Red money, politics, and agitators flowed into the United States and what had 'merely' been agitated workers became an armed socialist camp. Paramilitary groups formed in the underground, protests became riots, agitation became assassination. Across the South the specter of populism, fundamentalism, and violence coalesced in the form of Huey Long and his American Union party. Red politicians were targeted first and the cities became battle grounds between the two camps while police and soldiers desperately tried to stem the tide. But just as in the Red strongholds soon the new political hydra turned on the government itself and it's varied supporters. From 1930-1936 the Red's and the Unionists claimed 14 Gubernatorial seats, sent a combined 210 members to Congress, and 30 Senators. They were a hairs breath away from putting loyalist and moderate Republicans and Democrats into the political corner.
Not that it mattered.
The violence was escalating to the point where police and military action was becoming impotent. State governments in the hands of either the Reds or the Unionists had managed to seize control of state police and military assets and had rendered them largely untrustworthy. This necessitated federal marshals, agents, and troops be used which with the limited resources of the US government, a divided legislature, and a diminishing tax base was impossible.
What brought him to his desk that day was a series of terrible blows that had wracked the country over the past week. Red militiamen had opened fire on a church used by Unionist supporters in the suburbs of Chicago with two America First representatives and a teenager killed. This touched off a vicious retaliation in Kentucky where Unionist party leaders led a mob to the local Syndicalist part office only to be met by defensive gunfire which rapidly escalated into a full scale battle that spanned several city blocks. Eventually the defenders were overwhelmed and everyone in the office massacred. Some 11 Reds were killed, along with 2 errant police officers. For the next five days a surge of violence, crime, and protests went through the country like a spasm. By the end of it more than 300 people had been killed and the credibility of the federal government damaged more than ever before as violence engulfed the capital and it's environs for the first time. It was after this that he took several of his most fateful decision.
The inability of highly dispersed Federal garrisons to keep the peace was extremely evident. After intense consultations General MacArthur at the War Department he agreed to begin the 'temporary' relocation of federal troops to the Washington Military District which would now encompass the urban corridor from Philadelphia to Richmond. The relocation of roughly 53,000 troops, 1,100 airmen, and close to 100,000 sailors was an extraordinary decision that many were widely hailing as cowardice. Only the risk of what might come kept both Republicans and Democrats from joining the jeering calls of Reds and Unionists for his resignation.
Still he resolved to stand fast. He could not allow the writ of the Federal government to collapse everywhere, a zone of stability was necessary of the storm to come would be weathered. He merely wondered what the storm would look like or if he'd even recognize it when it arrived.
Though for several months into the summer it seemed as though some of the worse of it had passed. Violence began to drop, federal police sweeps yielded more arrests, and in two congressional special elections the Republican party managed to snatch seats away from the Reds in Pennsylvania. Emboldened by the success President Hoover took advantage of existing Congressional authorizations to raise up three new divisions to help 'police the Mexican frontier' a pretext for which it was difficult for the Unionists to reject and so only the Syndicalists fought against it. Recruitment was carefully overseen by Federal agents to ensure that those who joined were of loyal stock much to the fury of Unionists and Reds.
Then came the September Risings.
Almost like a lightening bolt the revolution seemed to begin. Syndicalist street militias in Chicago and Detroit murdered Federal officials and state opposition leaders after overwhelming local police and federal law enforcement garrisons, Unionist supporters, factory managers, and a whole host of 'enemies' were targeted with extreme violence. These militias were beginning to fan out into the suburbs and other cities seemed on the verge of armed revolution. In the South, Long and his Unionists had formed open military formations after seizing several cities and some whispered of openly declaring a neo-Confederate government.
President Hoover found himself cloistered with his military high command in the White House. General MacArthur led the military delegation, Congressman Taft the Congressional, and Justice Cardozo the Constitutional. The choice was nothing less than whether or not to allow elections to proceed.
The political excitement surrounding the election all parties believed was likely to be enough to energize the Unionists and Syndicalists to open rebellion, and with the still scarce Federal resources such a rebellion might destroy the country. MacArthur was careful not to advocate openly for a provisional military government letting his subordinates and colleagues do it for him, but his position was clear. Taft was demur hoping for some middle ground between a military government tasked with rooting out treasonous elements and a normal government. Cardozo felt unable to offer up positive advice, his position precluded him from seriously considering the legality of electoral suspension but his intellectual capacities were capable of processing the risks.
Finally the conversation came back to Hoover. The tired old man stood up his palms spread flat across the desk "I think... President Lincoln had it easy. When the Civil War began he could count on the loyalty of a preponderance of states, he had an equally weak opponent, and the assurance that at least the government was not in danger of imminent collapse. If we go forward with these elections I am not sure that the government, let alone the country, will long survive. If for a moment I thought that the normal electoral course could continue without catastrophe I would not have called this meeting." Hesitating for a moment he looked to General MacArthur "But I will not be the man who single handedly brought an end to American Democracy, that will be a task for our enemies. General prepare contingency plans for a military government. Begin recruitment efforts and proposals for conscription if need be. If it comes to it we will do this to the utmost or we will not do it at all."
Perhaps surprised General MacArthur said nothing for a moment before standing with the crispness of a soldier "Mr. President" saluting swiftly. The rest of the delegation filed out of the room as President Hoover tented his hands and looked out at the Oval Office wondering what would come.
As it was President Hoover ended his term in office rather calmly. Though much of Michigan and Ohio as well as Louisiana and Alabama had become no-go zones for federal officials the risk of immediate rebellion seemed unfounded as Unionist and Syndicalist militias held in a holding pattern but did not seek more territory. Then came the election. Political violence and intimidation was rife however as the votes came in it was clear that the Syndicalists and Unionists would not be able to gather enough electoral votes to throw the election into the House. Due to the extraordinary circumstances of the election and the unlikely success of the incumbent Republicans the GOP had formed an emergency Constitution platform with the Democrats and actively endorsed and campaigned for their candidate Governor John Nance Garner of Texas whom they hoped would break the Unionist streak in the South---and they were rewarded.
Winning the entire Northeast, Midwest, California, and surprisingly Texas with 305 electoral votes which at any other time would have been a crushing symbolic victory. But with a popular vote margin of roughly 37% and with bubbling violence across the country he took office in the midst of a storm cloud with General MacArthur being his first appointment upon taking office.
Events began to spiral in rapid succession. As expected both the American Union Party (AUP) and the Combined Syndicalists of America (CAS) formally contested the election results. What was unexpected was the overt formation of seditious paramilitary organizations throughout both of their spheres of influence. The New York Times headline screamed 'LONG CALLS UP THE TROOPS, WAR NEXT?' and others followed suit. They entered the new year in a cloud of darkness.
-------------------
This is my return to the world of Paradox AAR's after a very long hiatus so I hope you'll forgive any rough edges. I like to really roleplay a narrative that I have set out in my head so occasionally I will manipulate events inside the game to reflect where I think the narrative should go. This AAR will ideally follow the Second American Civil War and quite possibly the aftermath of that horrifying conflict.
Last edited: