(My first attempt at an AAR, go easy on me ;D)
(NOTICE: CONVERTED TO 1.03 AND MOVED TO HERE)
History is filled with so many 'what if's...
Prior to World War II and after the Northern Expedition which firmly established the KMT as the leader of China, cooperation between China and Germany were instrumental to the China's modernization efforts. The KMT sought industrial, technological, and military assistance from Germany, while Germany's demand for raw materials brought them to the Chinese market, where the loss of their colony Qingdao after WWI actually helped them --- as they could now stand on equal footing with the Chinese without any 'Imperialistic' tendencies. Sino-German cooperation peaked during the years of 1933-1937, after the Nazis took power... Meanwhile, after the death of Sun Yat-sen, the Republic of China returned to autocratic rule in all but name, and many of its leaders believed that maybe Fascism would be the savior that would allow them to reunite China and make the middle kingdom great once again...
Historically, due to the interests of realpolitik, Germany abandoned China in favor of Japan, whom they saw as an actual world power capable of supporting them, despite the fact that Germany had far more investment and better contacts at all levels in China. With the KMT's failures to stamp out the Communists and their agreement to a Non-Aggression Pact with the Soviet Union, Hitler claimed that Japan, not China, would be the last bastion against Bolshevism in the far east.
But what if...
What if Hitler had kept up the support the Nazis spent four years (and many Germans even more) building up? What if Chiang Kai-shek proved his value and the potential of China after all? What if instead of recalling Alexander von Falkenhausen by threatening his family, Hitler actually pushed this German general who Chiang considered a personal friend and referred to as a "Friend of China" even after World War II, to forge an alliance instead?
AAR Settings:
Scenario: 1933, Dark Hour Full 1.2, No Mods
Difficulty/AI: Normal / Aggressive
Tech-Team Takeover: On (because any China campaign would be boring without this =P)
AAR Starting Time: August 1940 (after the Fall of France and the German diplomatic offensive)
As the events of HOI/DH do not support this concept, I've made the following changes:
PRELUDE (due to the slow paced infantry grind and industrial building of the early years, I'll simply sum things up):
1933: After announcing his intentions to follow Germany's successful revitalization, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek took complete and full authority over the KMT and officially brought China into Fascism (1 slider move towards Authoritarian). Orders were immediately given for a massive redeployment of the KMT Central Army, followed by a successful campaign that crushed the new Communist stronghold before they could recover or fortify themselves after the brutal and costly Long March. Then, following unsuccessful negotiations, the KMT then turned upon their puppet XiBeiSanMa, pushed aside their outdated forces and annexed them with ease.
1934: After consolidating his power (paying all dissent to 0), Chiang Kai-shek enacted the two-year service draft (to reduce building times) and began massive industrial building programs to usher China into a proper industrial revolution. Meanwhile, the KMT central army launched its Western Campaign, first by trekking up the Himalayan mountains and, with an iron fist, began to end the Tibetan's claim to autonomy after the fall of the Qing dynasty.
1935: The warlords of Yunnan were the next to fall, and before the Guangxi clique could finish planning their rebellion, they were also crushed under the boots of the Central Army and reabsorbed into China proper. With the success of the Western and Southern expeditions and of the Chinese industrial revolution, Chiang Kai-shek hailed China's return to the world stage (1 slider move towards Interventionism). Yet, after three years of constant campaigns, the KMT central army was badly depleted (no reinforcing, all industry/supply building this whole time). Generalissimo Chiang promised them an end to the wars, and ensured the Shanxi warlord Yan Xishan that he had no intentions of further aggression.
1936: The industrial revolution continues, while Tibet was finally reintegrated to China proper. (I've been occupying without annexing, bit gamey to take advantage of the wartime bonuses I know >_>)
1937: With a reborn China in sight, Generalissimo Chiang declared that he will no longer stand against further Japanese aggression (1 slider move towards Hawk). Japan however, responded by beginning its war against China in 1937 before it could grow any stronger. Chiang quickly took this opportunity to forge the United Front with the last remaining warlord: Yan Xishan of Shanxi, while spreading propaganda to begin a defensive war, starting with the inland transfer of industries. What followed however, completely astounded the world as Chiang personally lead the elite units of the Central Army, 38 modern infantry divisions (mostly upgraded from militia over the 1936-1937 year) behind a spearhead of 3 Muslim cavalry divisions plus his new HQ division, and lead a massive assault into Manchuria. Meanwhile, provoked and armed by KMT operatives, partisan uprisings began all over Inner Mongolia and Manchuria (Anti-Japanese in Inner Mongolia/Manchuria events). Despite being supplied for an offensive (Offensive Chit), the Japanese were caught completely unprepared to defend their own ground and were pushed steadily back.
(Offensive routes)
1938: Chiang was not interested in pushing deep towards the far north. He advanced along the coast, allowing less able (militias/older infantry) to defend his rear, then detached Xue Yue and von Falkenhausen with 18 divisions to take central Manchukuo while he himself lead the 24 other divisions towards Korea. By March 1938, he had retaken all of the Chinese coast and Korean border, cutting Manchukuo and Japanese forces still inland off from their home country. By April, the heavily defended Harbin had fallen to a two-pronged attack, while the weak defenses in the Korea peninsula also collapsed. Defeated on the continent, the humiliated Japanese were forced to sign a new armistice, freely Korea and giving up all Imperialistic aspirations they had in China.
China rejoiced, and Chiang promptly went back to improving the lives of his citizens (with more industry building). The liberation of Korea also provided a valuable influx of Japanese technologies (beginning air force building)...
1939: Europe was torn asunder and China didn't care (more industry building). As with the rest of the world, Chiang was still doubtful that the freshly rebuilt Wehrmacht could withstand the might of both Great Britain and France. Nevertheless, should an opportunity present itself... Chiang began to use China's historical grudge against British and French Imperialism in a massive propaganda campaign to bring Chinese public opinion to their benefactor Germany's side (1 slider move towards Interventionism).
1940: In a surprise turn of events, Hitler declined to invade Norway, and the British played their hand first in an unsuccessful attempt to cut off the Baltic iron route. Then, with the arrival of Spring and Summer, it was the Wehrmacht's turn to shock the world as they successfully defeated the allies in Battle of France. With the capture of Paris came the Axis diplomatic offensive, including an old friend returning from a recent trip...
August 23, 1940, Nanking Airport:
The greeting party was small enough that some diplomats may have been offended, but the intimate presence of the Generalissimo and Madam Chiang was not a sign Alexander von Falkenhausen could mistake: it was Director-General Chiang's way to showing something far more rare than formal respect: informal endearment, like welcoming a friend of the family rather than a stately emissary. To the Chinese whom upheld modesty as one of the highest virtues, this was truly an honor.
The swift, eager stride and bright, welcoming smile may even be considered by some diplomats as 'inappropriate'. Yet Chiang did not make a sign of caring as he walked up and extended his hand.
"Welcome back, General. How goes your trip?"
"It's good to be back, Director. To and from across the Trans-Siberian railroad proved to be polar opposites. My legs were stiff by the time they reached the fatherland, yet I cannot ask sooner for a break now. May I introduce my lovely wife and rowdy kids..." Falkenhausen presented his family, who were still descending down the plane from Vladivostok. "The Führer recommended that I bring my family back to better support me in the event that travel to the Fatherland becomes difficult in the upcoming year. However, he would not disclose why he suspects such a thing."
"Clearly, an even more Earth-shattering plan is in the works. I'm sure we'll hear it once the Führer is ready. In the meantime however, our own preparations are all but completed. The time for my people to repay the kindness the Reich has provided and show those hypocrisy-filled Democratic Imperialists that the might of a reborn China is at hand."
von Falkenhausen grinned --- more like leered with his old and wrinkled face. More a military man than a diplomat, he had been unsure of how to present the Führer and von Ribbentrop's newest proposal, but if the Generalissimo had so readily and eagerly prepared for the war plans he left behind, then maybe what needed to be said was more or less a formality.
"The Führer has named me Special Attache to the Far East and entrusted me with a formal proposition this time. It seems like his wishes already rings true to the best interests of both nations."
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Intro Part II
Operation Compass (vs British Raj):
Planning, 1, 2, 3
(NOTICE: CONVERTED TO 1.03 AND MOVED TO HERE)
History is filled with so many 'what if's...
Prior to World War II and after the Northern Expedition which firmly established the KMT as the leader of China, cooperation between China and Germany were instrumental to the China's modernization efforts. The KMT sought industrial, technological, and military assistance from Germany, while Germany's demand for raw materials brought them to the Chinese market, where the loss of their colony Qingdao after WWI actually helped them --- as they could now stand on equal footing with the Chinese without any 'Imperialistic' tendencies. Sino-German cooperation peaked during the years of 1933-1937, after the Nazis took power... Meanwhile, after the death of Sun Yat-sen, the Republic of China returned to autocratic rule in all but name, and many of its leaders believed that maybe Fascism would be the savior that would allow them to reunite China and make the middle kingdom great once again...
Historically, due to the interests of realpolitik, Germany abandoned China in favor of Japan, whom they saw as an actual world power capable of supporting them, despite the fact that Germany had far more investment and better contacts at all levels in China. With the KMT's failures to stamp out the Communists and their agreement to a Non-Aggression Pact with the Soviet Union, Hitler claimed that Japan, not China, would be the last bastion against Bolshevism in the far east.
But what if...
What if Hitler had kept up the support the Nazis spent four years (and many Germans even more) building up? What if Chiang Kai-shek proved his value and the potential of China after all? What if instead of recalling Alexander von Falkenhausen by threatening his family, Hitler actually pushed this German general who Chiang considered a personal friend and referred to as a "Friend of China" even after World War II, to forge an alliance instead?
AAR Settings:
Scenario: 1933, Dark Hour Full 1.2, No Mods
Difficulty/AI: Normal / Aggressive
Tech-Team Takeover: On (because any China campaign would be boring without this =P)
AAR Starting Time: August 1940 (after the Fall of France and the German diplomatic offensive)
As the events of HOI/DH do not support this concept, I've made the following changes:
- To represent the industrial/technical aid granted, the following blueprints were given: Mass Production (industrial), Facilities Design (industrial), Manufacturing Support Systems (industrial), and Early Mechanization (agricultural).
- In 1934, General Hans von Seeckt initially proposed an "80 division plan" to Chiang Kai-shek, providing the KMT's central army with 80 fully German-trained and German-equipped divisions. However, only 8 were finished before the onset of WWII with another 20 partially. To represent this, the blueprints for 1926 and 1931 Infantry will be given to China in 1935.
- The German AI /always/ seems to recall von Falkenhausen, so the general and tech team were added back to China manually.
- No NAP with the Soviets and no Operation Zet, as China was clearly both anti-Communist and an emerging eastern threat to the Soviets.
- Chennault removed as Fascist China was hardly an ally of America.
- Obviously, as the game isn't designed for an Axis China, a little 'Acceptall' is in order.
PRELUDE (due to the slow paced infantry grind and industrial building of the early years, I'll simply sum things up):
1933: After announcing his intentions to follow Germany's successful revitalization, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek took complete and full authority over the KMT and officially brought China into Fascism (1 slider move towards Authoritarian). Orders were immediately given for a massive redeployment of the KMT Central Army, followed by a successful campaign that crushed the new Communist stronghold before they could recover or fortify themselves after the brutal and costly Long March. Then, following unsuccessful negotiations, the KMT then turned upon their puppet XiBeiSanMa, pushed aside their outdated forces and annexed them with ease.
1934: After consolidating his power (paying all dissent to 0), Chiang Kai-shek enacted the two-year service draft (to reduce building times) and began massive industrial building programs to usher China into a proper industrial revolution. Meanwhile, the KMT central army launched its Western Campaign, first by trekking up the Himalayan mountains and, with an iron fist, began to end the Tibetan's claim to autonomy after the fall of the Qing dynasty.
1935: The warlords of Yunnan were the next to fall, and before the Guangxi clique could finish planning their rebellion, they were also crushed under the boots of the Central Army and reabsorbed into China proper. With the success of the Western and Southern expeditions and of the Chinese industrial revolution, Chiang Kai-shek hailed China's return to the world stage (1 slider move towards Interventionism). Yet, after three years of constant campaigns, the KMT central army was badly depleted (no reinforcing, all industry/supply building this whole time). Generalissimo Chiang promised them an end to the wars, and ensured the Shanxi warlord Yan Xishan that he had no intentions of further aggression.
1936: The industrial revolution continues, while Tibet was finally reintegrated to China proper. (I've been occupying without annexing, bit gamey to take advantage of the wartime bonuses I know >_>)
1937: With a reborn China in sight, Generalissimo Chiang declared that he will no longer stand against further Japanese aggression (1 slider move towards Hawk). Japan however, responded by beginning its war against China in 1937 before it could grow any stronger. Chiang quickly took this opportunity to forge the United Front with the last remaining warlord: Yan Xishan of Shanxi, while spreading propaganda to begin a defensive war, starting with the inland transfer of industries. What followed however, completely astounded the world as Chiang personally lead the elite units of the Central Army, 38 modern infantry divisions (mostly upgraded from militia over the 1936-1937 year) behind a spearhead of 3 Muslim cavalry divisions plus his new HQ division, and lead a massive assault into Manchuria. Meanwhile, provoked and armed by KMT operatives, partisan uprisings began all over Inner Mongolia and Manchuria (Anti-Japanese in Inner Mongolia/Manchuria events). Despite being supplied for an offensive (Offensive Chit), the Japanese were caught completely unprepared to defend their own ground and were pushed steadily back.
(Offensive routes)
1938: Chiang was not interested in pushing deep towards the far north. He advanced along the coast, allowing less able (militias/older infantry) to defend his rear, then detached Xue Yue and von Falkenhausen with 18 divisions to take central Manchukuo while he himself lead the 24 other divisions towards Korea. By March 1938, he had retaken all of the Chinese coast and Korean border, cutting Manchukuo and Japanese forces still inland off from their home country. By April, the heavily defended Harbin had fallen to a two-pronged attack, while the weak defenses in the Korea peninsula also collapsed. Defeated on the continent, the humiliated Japanese were forced to sign a new armistice, freely Korea and giving up all Imperialistic aspirations they had in China.
China rejoiced, and Chiang promptly went back to improving the lives of his citizens (with more industry building). The liberation of Korea also provided a valuable influx of Japanese technologies (beginning air force building)...
1939: Europe was torn asunder and China didn't care (more industry building). As with the rest of the world, Chiang was still doubtful that the freshly rebuilt Wehrmacht could withstand the might of both Great Britain and France. Nevertheless, should an opportunity present itself... Chiang began to use China's historical grudge against British and French Imperialism in a massive propaganda campaign to bring Chinese public opinion to their benefactor Germany's side (1 slider move towards Interventionism).
1940: In a surprise turn of events, Hitler declined to invade Norway, and the British played their hand first in an unsuccessful attempt to cut off the Baltic iron route. Then, with the arrival of Spring and Summer, it was the Wehrmacht's turn to shock the world as they successfully defeated the allies in Battle of France. With the capture of Paris came the Axis diplomatic offensive, including an old friend returning from a recent trip...
August 23, 1940, Nanking Airport:
The greeting party was small enough that some diplomats may have been offended, but the intimate presence of the Generalissimo and Madam Chiang was not a sign Alexander von Falkenhausen could mistake: it was Director-General Chiang's way to showing something far more rare than formal respect: informal endearment, like welcoming a friend of the family rather than a stately emissary. To the Chinese whom upheld modesty as one of the highest virtues, this was truly an honor.
The swift, eager stride and bright, welcoming smile may even be considered by some diplomats as 'inappropriate'. Yet Chiang did not make a sign of caring as he walked up and extended his hand.
"Welcome back, General. How goes your trip?"
"It's good to be back, Director. To and from across the Trans-Siberian railroad proved to be polar opposites. My legs were stiff by the time they reached the fatherland, yet I cannot ask sooner for a break now. May I introduce my lovely wife and rowdy kids..." Falkenhausen presented his family, who were still descending down the plane from Vladivostok. "The Führer recommended that I bring my family back to better support me in the event that travel to the Fatherland becomes difficult in the upcoming year. However, he would not disclose why he suspects such a thing."
"Clearly, an even more Earth-shattering plan is in the works. I'm sure we'll hear it once the Führer is ready. In the meantime however, our own preparations are all but completed. The time for my people to repay the kindness the Reich has provided and show those hypocrisy-filled Democratic Imperialists that the might of a reborn China is at hand."
von Falkenhausen grinned --- more like leered with his old and wrinkled face. More a military man than a diplomat, he had been unsure of how to present the Führer and von Ribbentrop's newest proposal, but if the Generalissimo had so readily and eagerly prepared for the war plans he left behind, then maybe what needed to be said was more or less a formality.
"The Führer has named me Special Attache to the Far East and entrusted me with a formal proposition this time. It seems like his wishes already rings true to the best interests of both nations."
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Intro Part II
Operation Compass (vs British Raj):
Planning, 1, 2, 3
Last edited: