AARland Choice AwAARds 2012 (Round 2)

[Bergioyn]

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Sweet Home Manitoba by Asalto http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/...-in-Modern-Day
2 Rebirth of the Japanese Empire by Kaiser_Mobius http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/...an-MDS-1.6-AAR
3 A House of Cards by Kurt_Steiner http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/...MDS-AAR)/page5

[Davy]

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Germany Tutorial: Take 2 from MisterBean
2 Kriegsgefahr from Rensslaer
3 Kantai Kessen from TheBromgrev
4 Panzer-MaaAARsch from Nicegil

[TKFS]

Favourite CK 1/2 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 The Norse Kings of England

Favourite EU 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Baghdad in the Sky With Diamonds

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Last Man and Shilling

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 The Red Mexican
2 Empire of the Pacific

If I could add extra votes to Saithis' AAR, I totally would

[Saithis]

Whoops :S

Okay, delete my post please and I'll vote again once I've had a chance to read to the end of the AARs I'm following to see if they're still active.

You don't need to delete your post, you can just edit it to remove the vote for yourself and put a different one in.

[Anjwalker]

Favourite EU 1/2/3 AARs

1 The Historic Inevitabilty of Epic Failure
2
3
4

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs

1 Novum Romanum Imperium
2 Of Laws, Not Men
3 Subcontinental Subtleties
4 The Fate of Nations

[Omega124]

Favourite CK 1/2 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 In the Shadow of Painful Doom
2 God's Kingdom
3 The Norse Kings of England
4 A Very Different England


Favourite EU 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 The Queen Mother's Diary
2 Glory for Ulm
3 Blood Brothers
4 Pink India

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 How Hockey Saved the Aliies
2 Last Bastidon of Freedom
3 Germany's Road to Doomsday
4 Last Man and Shilling

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Subcontinental Subleties
2 Of Laws Not Men
3 A Hot Yet Cold War
4 Mantain the Monarchy

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above (Rome, AoD, DH, Mount and Blade, Sengoku - only 1 nomination)

1 Between Heaven and Hell

[KaiserMuffin]

And a little question: Why the "rest of the games" nomination has only one candidate as they have the largest base of different AARs?

Seconded. Give DH 4 slots since it's the true inheritor of HoI2, not HoI3! *cough*

[Cybvep]

I think it's too late to change the rules now. They may be changed in the next round, though.

[Soulstrider]

Favourite CK 1/2 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 In the Shadow of Painful Doom
2 God's Kingdom


Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Carnage Al Dente - A CptEasy multiplayer AAR
2 Império Novo - An Axis Portugal AAR
3 Jiěfàng Zhànzhēng - A Chinese HPP AAR


Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs

1 The Birth and Rise of the Ishida Shogunate: Volumes 1 and 2 - An A-H Japan AAR
2 The Fate of Nations
3 Empire of the Pacific - A California AAR
4 Maintain the Monarchy: The Tsar Demands It!

Favourite AGEOD AAR (only 1 nomination)
1 Japan: another PoN newbie testing the waters

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above (Rome, AoD, DH, Mount and Blade, Sengoku - only 1 nomination)
1 The Torch of the Mediterranean: A Socialist Republic of Italy Kaiserreich AAR

[loki100]

Seconded. Give DH 4 slots since it's the true inheritor of HoI2, not HoI3! *cough*

I think it's too late to change the rules now. They may be changed in the next round, though.

Suggest you check out the thread linked to in the first post that sets out the rationale for this decision. In effect, there are relatively few active AARs in those categories and if we had 4 votes you'd end up with very little discrimination in terms of voting pattern. Reducing it to one means that if there are any ties at the end then that is a product of voting pattern not voting design. Its one reason why a discussion thread was put up immediately after the last round, plenty of time to have contributed to the debate on how best to run the ACAs at that point. Most likely there will be another discussion after thread after this round.

Soulstrider - Kneel before Zog is not eligible. As it was included in the 2011 Iron Heaart nominations, that means it has no active updates between 1 Jan 2012 and 1 June 2012.

[Soulstrider]

Soulstrider - Kneel before Zog is not eligible. As it was included in the 2011 Iron Heaart nominations, that means it has no active updates between 1 Jan 2012 and 1 June 2012.

Oh sorry, already edited it and removed it.



Though to be honest I do think the DH AAR forum is very much active, I would even dare to say it is as much active as the HoI3 and Vicky II ones.

[Saithis]

Oh sorry, already edited it and removed it.

Though to be honest I do think the DH AAR forum is very much active, I would even dare to say it is as much active as the HoI3 and Vicky II ones.

The DH AAR is quite active at the moment, but the rules were already discussed months in advance and no decisions to the contrary were made before this thread's time came up. This also isn't the place to discuss it as this is meant to be the thread for making and tallying votes, so can we save the lengthy discussion for the next round's pre-round rules discussion instead of spamming the voting thread with it? Thanks.

[Killerflood]

Favourite CK 1/2 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1
2
3
4


Favourite EU 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Bastions: Tales of the Anglo Prussians by Mr. Capiatlist
2
3
4

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1
2
3
4

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1
2
3
4

Favourite AGEOD AAR (only 1 nomination)

1

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above (Rome, AoD, DH, Mount and Blade, Sengoku - only 1 nomination)

1

[Morlak]

Favourite HOI 1/2/3 AARs
1- Sweet Home Manitoba - KR Canada in Modern Day
2- Germany Tutorial: Take 2.
3- A Collective Regime of Peace and Love - a KR Soviet Russia AAR
4- Carnage Al Dente - A CptEasy multiplayer AAR

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above
1- Vive L'Empereur: The Third French Empire - a National France Kaiserreich AAR

[Tapscott]

Favourite CK II AARs
1 - Aplestav's AAR; The Curse of Brothers - The History of Alfonso the Wise and his Descendants
2 - Tommy4ever's AAR; The Stuff of Kings - A House of Burgundy AAR

[EtzelHoveri]

Can we only vote for modded AARs such as the GoT AARs for CK2?

[Saithis]

If you wish, all of your votes can be cast for AARs about mods. There's no reason they couldn't be. They obviously don't have to be, though.

[CanadianCommie]

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1- Empire of the Pacific - A California AAR
2- Of Laws, Not Men: A New England AAR
3- So Far From God- A Mexico AHD AAR


Favourite EU 1/2/3 AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1- InTveresting Times: An AfTver Action Report

[AwesomeSauce123]

Favourite Victoria 1/2/ AARs (up to 4, please include links)

1 Subcontinental Subtleties By Selzro
2 The Fate of Nations By CanadianCommie
3 The Long Run By southpointing

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above (Rome, AoD, DH, Mount and Blade, Sengoku - only 1 nomination)

1 In the Age of Superpowers By TC Pilot

[General_Hoth]

Favourite AGEOD AAR (only 1 nomination)
Once upon a time, a revolution, Bornego

1

Favourite AAR from a game not listed above (Rome, AoD, DH, Mount and Blade, Sengoku - only 1 nomination)
VIVE l'EMPEREUR, par Antonine

1