Oh, it's over?
Okay, so, my point of view:
On night 0 I scan Johho, not a wolf.
On night 1, I scan Telesien, a wolf.
So yeah, okay, I take a chance and trust Johho to do the outing. I mean, heck, at some point I need to jump in and trust someone, no? Might as well go early.
What was the result of all this?
1) We got a number of contacts, most intriguing of which were three people all telling the same story: unclaimed apprentices who were told their role by the GM. Very strange, but since it was the same story 3 times, we trusted it.
2) Out of the blue, Randakar contacts me and Esemesas, informing us he'll contact Telesien to pose as the Sorceror. He also contacts Johho independently to inform him he's a hunter and that he's doing this undercover sting on Telesien.
3) In hindsight, probably the one stupid move that doomed the village: NO WORD FROM THE PRIEST!!! Not even after Telesien gets lynched, proven a wolf AND Johho survives the night! Nothing!
Why is that so important?
Because after Johho gets hunted, I'm all alone again and with Adamus' Priestly Powers, I'm seriously doubting if there even is a Priest. Well, alone except for Randakar, who's doing things I can't imagine a baddie doing.
So I decide to trust him.
Which I was right in doing at that time since he was still a goodie. Too bad he was cursed and got turned the very next night
Further notable occurrences: me stealing the Priest's apprentice the very same night the Priest gets hunted (and saved by the Doc). Yeah, that was a shocker, by then I had taken Steed as my Apprentice and told him everything.
There is a bloody good reason why Marty didn't contact Johho. In fact, there are many bloody good reasons.
Well, you were right at the time, but it's still pretty reckless to trust someone just because he claims he is going to infiltrate the baddies.