• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
The way I see it, the fall of Archangelsk is inevitable, and the fall of Paris is also inevitable. There will be a window of opportunity between the two, where if the Axis has 7 other objectives at any point, they will win. Given that Archangelsk is going to fall very soon, I don't understand why the Axis hasn't attacked Yugoslavia yet. Are they afraid the British will push them back? It won't matter, because by the time they're pushed out of Beograd, Paris will have been long gone, along with hope of an Axis victory.

The Japanese victory against the Americans gives hope that Japan could be more than just a distraction, and actually contribute with an invasion of the USA.
 
Edit: too the USA/Japanese players, any chance we can see the naval battle report from the carrier battle?

6 CV sunk ? Ouch ! A dreaful defeat for USA High Command. Do you have more details ?

Unfortunately, they have no screens from this. As far as I know, Japan used the information from the sub to set up a trap were the US navy had to retreat from battle into another IJN task force. Classic but deadly.

This game is getting ever more interesting. I would like to see the ships sunk list, by ship type if possible, for the important types (the flat-tops & big guns).

What was Zid up to? He'll have to enlighten us.

Hopefully, Zid will come up with a sink ship list at some point, and a few more screenies.

So the Axis are now aiming for victory conditions, to seal the fight? Looks like there's quite a few in easy reach. What about Paris, though? The Allies have that within their reach, too.

The VPs are within reach - yes - but the Axis lines are extremely stretched. But it should be possible. Yes, Paris. The Allies are puting quite the pressure here. We'll see how it turnes out. Paris is a VC of course, so if we lose it, it gets tricky.



New chapter soon.
 
Carnage al Dente

Chapter XXVII - Operation Carnival





Players: USA, UK, SPA, SOV, GERx2, JAP, ITA




Recap: Vichy has fallen to the Americans and the Allies has launched a massive attack on Western Europe. Italy has planned "Operation Carnival" to take the American ports in Vichy and cut their supply. on the East Front, the battles slowly grinds on as the Wehrmacht push for Archangelsk. Japan won a great naval victory against the Americans and now plans to go on the offensive to expand their emipre eastwards, to threat USA proper.
















1-14.jpg

April 22nd, 1942

The Americans has reached far north in the belly of occupied France. Germans forces are, however, crushing the sprouting rebellions by French partisans who rose behind the German lines. This was successful before American forces could connect with them. Except being an annoyance for the German leadership, they did not have a strategic influence on the 4th Battle of France.

Italian fighters continue to back Luftwaffe up and manage (due to my own ability for micro-management due to little else to do) quite often to find unescorted allied bombers. It was a great event the first time they met USAF-bombers and shot down plenty of them.














2-13.jpg

April 29th, 1942

The Regia Marina is prowling the Med again. She is but a fraction of what she once was, and what Il Duce imagines she would become. Still, his effort to make her grand is not completely wasted. Anew modern battle ship, named “Il Duce” has replaced those being lost and with two of these marine behemoths leading the fleet, there is still bite in it… …or so the Italian leadership hopes. With all the naval failures of this war, the Italian leadership dare not believe in success. Still, they have one factor on their side. The Allies probably do not see them as a threat anymore. At least the Brits and the Americans seem to have focused a majority of their carriers to the pacific.

Admiral da Zara has lost an enormous amount of prestige since the start of the war. He is yearning for a great victory, or it might be his life next.














3-13.jpg

April 28th-30th, 1942

As the Regia Marina was carefully sailing around Italy the Regia Aeronatica was active along the coast. Scouting fighters found a British cruiser task force seeming to guard the port that the Italian fleet was heading for. The naval bombers were immediately alerted and sent to engage the light cruisers. The cruisers anti aircraft guns worked furiously and made the skies all dotty with small black clouds. The Italian naval bombers, however, were advanced aircrafts with modern torpedoes which could be dropped with high accuracy without getting to close to the ships. Cruiser after cruiser was hit by the deadly torpedoes with quite few bombers crashing in the ocean in the return.

After little less than three days, the bomber crews were exhausted, some were wounded and most of the planes had damages from shrapnel. Two light cruisers were sunk and the other four were burning wrecks. Even though the naval bombers had to be grounded, the Italian leaderships did not want the cruisers to be able to get away….

Although this was considered being a well needed victory, it delayed Operation Carnival. Even though the cruisers meant no danger for Regia Marina, engaging them with the fleet meant alerting the Brits to their presence, thus spoiling the necessary surprise in Operation Carnival. The Regia Marina had to go into port further south and wait – just hoping no Allied reconnaissance would spot them there.















4-14.jpg

May 1st-3rd, 1942

Other Italian aircrafts followed up the work started so successfully by the naval bombers. It was a lot slower work, but with engines destroyed, the Brits could not get away. All six light cruisers were sunk with little cost for the Italians. This was a well needed revenge on the Brits. With the cruisers gone, Operation Carnival could be initiated.

Authors note: It is obvious that Zid had his attention elsewhere (the attack on France I presume) and missed this battle completely. I even wonder if he realized they were all bombed away…















5-13.jpg

May 6th, 1942

Operation Carnival is in full swing. Land attacks are initiated to open a route towards Toulon while the landing of troops directly to the port city has started. Fighters are making sure USAF cannot leave Marseille and tactical bombers are harassing several provinces.















6-13.jpg

May 7th, 1942

Fate wanted a grand US-navy task force to turn up while the disembarking of troops was still in full swing.

Authors note: This was really annoying due to the fact that the whole operation was stalled at least a day due to an ignored “invasion”-order. I know better than to trust that damn order. The damn transports just returned with their troops on. Had that not happened, the landing had been done before the Americans showed up… :(.

Nevertheless; the Americans had no carriers and da Zara could engage the way he always had wanted to. His flagship RM Il Duce (I see I spelt it wrong in the game… heh..) fired time and again and the enormous grenades hit their targets with an almost scary precision. USS Mississippi went down after a huge explosion. The USS Arkansas took two serious hits as well while Il Duce did not take a scratch. It was like magic (or that was at least how it would be described in the Italian news papers).

The problem was the ongoing disembarkment. The cowardly Americans targeted the transports and the escorting destroyers and sank several. It was hell for the troops to travel against the shore in the midst of a rain of huge caliber naval gun fire. Although several of the hit transports were empty, it was sadly not the case for all. Several thousand Italian infantrymen went down with the transports, still locked into the cargo hold.

Authors note: One division was lost at sea but two came ashore with their HQ.

In the end of the day this was still a glorious even as it was the first time the Regia Marina and da Zara had officially won a major naval battle.















7-12.jpg

May 8th, 1942

With the help of a German panzer division, the American defense in Cogolin was completely shattered and stumbled backwards leaving a trail of dead.

In the meantime, an Italian division in Toulon attacked Marseilles which was only defended by HQs who quickly fled. With a neighboring American division locked in battle, it seemed Operation Carnival was going roughly according to plan.















8-12.jpg

May 9th, 1942

In the evening the 9th, just as the Italian troops were about to enter the city of Marseille and claim final victory, a Spanish division hastily moved in and took up the fight in the suburbs. The Spanish was not an obstacle the Italians could not breech… if time would have been ample. Soon, surveillance showed Americans moving in to support the Spanish, all while the Italian stalling attacks up in the hills became tougher and tougher.

During mid day the 10th, the Italia leadership called off Operation Carnival. One of two ports had been captured, the Americans had been forced to retreat and focus on the south. Also, an Amercan battleship had been sunk and the Regia Marina had won its first victory. As such, Operation Carnival was a success. On the downside, as the American’s main port was still in their hand, they would not get the supply-problems intended. Strategically, Operation Carnival would not get any long term effects.

Still, the Allies would act a little more careful in the Med in the future.















9-10.jpg

May 4th, 1942

The battles in former France were chaotic during the time the Regia Marina moved in to initiate Operation Carnival. The Allied tried desperately to create a sack around Paris and the Axis fought, just as desperately, to keep it open. Provinces changed owner a lot more often than the poor soldiers got to change underwear. During a few hours, the sack was closed. Then the Americans ended up in a sack instead, which the Brits later managed to connect to. Just chaos.

Two Italian divisions had been trapped in the Mayhem. The Italian leadership wanted to pull them home, but simply failed to do so. They were needed to close a hole in the front or they simply had no way to go, or became under attack.















10-11.jpg

May 15th, 1942

During 10 days of intensive battle, as the same time as Operation Carneval, the Germans had managed to clean up somewhat on their back yard. On the other hand, the Allies had gotten an even firmer grip around Paris.

A German attack out of Montagis seemed to be able to once again capture some Allied units in a pocket. The German grip on that pocket seemed weak, so the Axis had little hope it would lead to anything strategically significant. The chaos would continue.














11-10.jpg

May 3rd, 1942

The Germans, aided by the Fins, are slowly closing in on Archangelsk. They fight with long supply lines and rather simple infrastructure which made the campaign go slow. Italian transport planes continued to keep a constant air-bridge of supply active, supplying the areas having shortages.















12-11.jpg

May 14th, 1942

Finally – Archangelsk is sealed off from the rest of Soviet. Almost an entire army seems to be captured in the pocket. This might evolve into a great victory. There are still a lot of Russians in the easily defended city. It is not over yet. At least some of the Red Army divisions were exhausted from resent battles, but so were the Germans after pressing on relentlessly.















13-11.jpg

May 16th, 1942

It seemed few of the Russians in Archangelsk had any fight left in them. After a few bloody skirmishes in the outskirts of the city, the exhausted soldiers simply fled – many tossing away their rifles – and chanced the wilderness in their desperation to get away from the attackers. They did not have much land left to flee to, and as far as the Axis knew, the Red Navy was in the Black Sea. It was not locked there however, so anything was possible.

Authors note: The Axis only need one more VC to win (they have 11 out of 12). The target is neutral Beograd.















14-11.jpg

May 10th, 1942

Japan launched a massive attack against Pearl Harbor. It resulted in several battles against US navy and Royal Navy. Japans worst losses were some transports with troops on. The Americans seem to have lost a battle ship but otherwise there were surprisingly few losses in relation to the huge amount of ships and CAGs involved.

The Japs had to pull back for a long repair session, but so would the Allies. It was not likely much would happen in the Pacific anytime soon. The initiative continues to belong to Japan. The Allies just do not seem to be willing to commit in the Pacific. It is obvious they concentrate their recourses on Germany.

The British Carrier Task Force with five or six carriers is still in the Pacific, along with all or a majority of the American carriers. It is useful to know for the new-born and battle-lusty Regia Marina. As long as they will not meet carriers, they can do some serious damage.



..........
 
That was close. You managed to draw the Allied attention, which is sth. If you manage to hold Paris and capture the Yugoslavian capital in time (two airborne divs should be enough), then you will finally get the well-deserved victory :).
 
Regia Marina strikes back!:cool: Now a steel resolve is required to hold Paris.
 
I wonder if the time and forces required for an attack on Yugoslavia are really good employed there. Stalingrad seemed to be relatively close by and thus a Bitter Peace would have ensured that the Allies would be kicked out of Europe within few months.
 
Bombing out that cruiser fleet was quite amusing. It just goes to show even the best players can't keep up with every single thing going on. Lots of action, lots of fun, can't wait for the next update.
 
I wonder if the time and forces required for an attack on Yugoslavia are really good employed there. Stalingrad seemed to be relatively close by and thus a Bitter Peace would have ensured that the Allies would be kicked out of Europe within few months.
I think that it will be easier to conquer Yugoslavia, a minor AI-controlled country, than take Stalingrad from the human-controlled SU.
 
Fortress Europe vs. Western Allies!

I want this AAR to continue! :D
 
A clear Axis victory would be slightly disappointing after the way this game has gone. I think CaptEasy and his cronies have played an excellent game, but Zid and the Allies have made no serious strategic errors. The conquest of Romania and the life pumped back into the Soviet southern front, the destruction of the German and Italian fleets, the Allied conquest of Spain, etc, - these were all skillful Allied victories. I just feel that if the Allies lose this one after so many cunning operations, it hints at a built-in advantage for the Axis side. The Axis strategy was no doubt very sound this game, but I wonder if any Allied coalition or different choices could have really salvaged the game given the way the Axis dictated their strategy.

Still, however it ends, it's been a spectacular game. Here's hoping some Allied paratroopers are ready to land in Belgrade at a moments' notice!
 
This is easily the best AAR I have ever read. I hope game continues after axis get their "moral" victory of having enough victory points. Too bad nukes are banned, they would be intresting add-on this late game.
 
Personally, I'd rather see the battle in France go to it's conclusion than a simple battle for Yugoslavia. Especially after Cpt.Easy's awesome victory off the coast of Marseilles.
 
Honestly I'm surprised the Axis didn't when win on this chapter. With the Axis strategy in a VP victory, I would've expected a corp of motorised/armor on the Hungrain border 3 reigions from Belgrade to come charging in. With Archangelsk fallen on the 16th and Paris still in Axis hands, the DoW on Yugo could end it way before any ally help could arrive. If it happens I hope the game progresses on to see if the allies can break the Axis in the next 3 years.

Not being a ally hater, there are plenty of Axis mistakes (which may warrant a HR to "hurt" the Axis next game).

The Allies have made a few mistakes to warrant a Axis victory.While they may have not have turned the tide, but then again.
1. They abandoned Copenhagen, letting Germany seal the Baltic. An arguement could be made that it is more important than Gibraltar. (dodges the flying kitchen roller). After all if G falls the Suez still offers access to the Med and GB should have an easy time pushing the Itailians out of North Africa and all the Med Islands, which would still leave the whole pond open to invasion. GB doesn't need a large Home fleet to keep Germany out of a Sealion while they do this.

2. GB abandoning Asia and the Pacific allowed Japan to take Port Mosbey (a VP) and India offers a substancal amount of IC and MP for Japan.Which may have not been bad until you read below.

3. As Zid mentioned his 2nd or 3rd invasion of France (the one with 3 pronges of attack), while not a defeat, was a huge missed opportunity to destroy possiblely 2 corps including armor. These attacks are what was supposed to justify leaving Japan alone and he failed to sieze it. (I know alot of armchair QBing there).

4. While I can't imagine how difficult it is to do a defense-in-depth in a MP game. The total collapse of the Soviet front, even in winter, will always lead to an Axis victory. (Truthfully, I see this happening alot unless the Carnage group figures out a way to conveince the German player to keep a real defensive force in France.(hopefully not a house rule)).
 
Amazing AAR. I don't know what other readers think, but after Axis VP victory I really want to see "real end" of this war. ;)

+1 it aint over till its over! :)
See who gets Berlin... ;)


On ITA and other VP places - ITA seems to have really weak land units (and very few) with Militia and Cav still out on the frontlines.
Easy VPs for the Allies might be had on ITA proper, in the Middle East + Iran etc. maybe shifting a few forces to grab the easy cheesy VPs would e in order.

I still wonder about Zid sacrificing his valuabel forces in FIN. Maybe he had hoped to puppet FIN really quick to give GER some pain... - whatever.

-----------------------------

Considering all the previous rounds of Carnage something needs to be checked with the 1938 scenario to balance it a bit for MP.
I fully agree with Cybveb that 1938 favours the Axis (or weekens SOV too much depending on from where you look at it.).

In all games it was frustrating to see that no SOV player couldn't stand against GER - no matter what his strategy was. Actually most of the time it wasn't even possible to slow GER down to a realistic speed/time frame.

The whole SOV bitter peace business this game and the problems of said country should warrant a discussion thread inthe Carnage MP section methinks.
 
So maybe 1936 scenario. AAR will start as always in 1938. And some new HR like: from 1936-1938 diplomacy is controlled by AI(exception Japan, maybe from 1937 diplomacy controlled by player). This should balance the game I think. What do you think? This is a suggestion and can be changed by Carnage groupe. Maybe someone has other idea?
 
Wow I just got caught up right in time for an exciting finish. Great work. One thing I would have demanded if I was an Axis player is that when the SU declined the Bitter Peace they should have required the SU go completely under AI control. For at least 6 months to represent the chaos if nothing else.

Not sure what the VC cities are but watch out for a tricky UK move to invade one somewhere in the world. Hopefully the Japan player has these well guarded.