• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Introduction

Slan

Mr. Fixit
28 Badges
Oct 30, 2009
14.409
244
  • Hearts of Iron II: Armageddon
  • Sword of the Stars
  • Sengoku
  • Semper Fi
  • Rome Gold
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Penumbra - Black Plague
  • Majesty 2 Collection
  • Majesty 2
  • Magicka
  • King Arthur II
  • Iron Cross
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • For the Motherland
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Deus Vult
  • Darkest Hour
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Arsenal of Democracy
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Victoria 2
  • 500k Club
  • Mount & Blade: Warband
  • Mount & Blade: With Fire and Sword
My Fight
Volume II

my_fight_vol_ii.png

Nation: USA
Start date: 1936
Difficulty: normal
Version: 2.04f
Mod: Historical Plausibility Project 2.0.4

This is my second promotional HPP AAR, Volume II of My Fight. This game will be played as the USA on normal difficulty with the latest non-beta version of the HPP mod, but the similarities end there. I will stick to a gameplay style instead of the diary format, so the "From the memoires..." part was dropped from the title. I will attempt to keep the same pacing though, as long as possible, so the Chapter names will be the same or very similar.

This AAR will be a bit more interactive than usual (I checked with loki100 about this and I have full permission :)), although only to a limited extent. There's a decision for the USA in the final SF version of the HPP allowing them to drop their Neutrality significantly if they are threatened enough at the cost of a huge Dissent hit (depending on the current level of Neutrality). This should make it possible to take a more interventionist stance if need be. But I will need your help to decide when I should take that step. Everyone will have a vote for interventionist or isolationist after every Chapter (from the time the decision first becomes available).

I hope you will enjoy :)


Table of contents:
 
Last edited:
Oooh! Oooh! Get Garner for President, an elderly pissed off Texan is just the sort of leadership 'Murica needs!
 
Oh, now Mr. Fixit is President! this will be fun following in combination with the Influence Wars with Japan, this way we see both sides of the story.
 
Ohm... Maybe you guys miss the point a bit. This is not an entirely interactive AAR where you vote presidents, your only input will be when I take the "They went too far!" decision :p
 
Right after the Anchluss! Show that vegan skill free weirdo not to mess with the US of A!
YEEEEHA!

Also, after the war unite north america with the Canschluss!
 
Destroy the evil forces of Parliamentary Democracy and Constitutional Monarchy! Ally with the Fascists if you must!
 
Right after the Anchluss! Show that vegan skill free weirdo not to mess with the US of A!
YEEEEHA!

Also, after the war unite north america with the Canschluss!

I'm not sure I can do that, it has some prerequisits. More on that in the first post tomorrow (I hope).

Show the world the might of American Democracy! Show em how it is stronger than other democracies.

Well, my intention was to play it nice but if people will be this bloodthirsty all the way, it might end up being a slugfest...

Destroy the evil forces of Parliamentary Democracy and Constitutional Monarchy! Ally with the Fascists if you must!

Now that I won't do. If I join any faction, that will be the Allies, but as per the previous reply, I may end up unaligned throughout the game...

Can you get more than 80% dissent from that option?

I had to check the files to get a definite answer for that. Turns out I can get as much as 100 dissent along with 15 instant revolts throughout the States. Nasty.

subscribed

Glad to have you on board :)
 
Looks interesting, will follow.
 
Now that I won't do. If I join any faction, that will be the Allies, but as per the previous reply, I may end up unaligned throughout the game...

[video=youtube;p9vP8DjEB6Y]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9vP8DjEB6Y[/video]
 
Chapter I - A New Beginning
Chapter I

A New Beginning


So, as I said in the introduction, I'll be playing the United States of America, starting from January 1st, 1936. Originally I chose the US because they have very little impact on the game for the first half (so I can show how stuff works) and they have a lot of impact on it in the second half (so I can have some fun, too). Things might turn out a bit differently this time around though. We will see. And I'm playing from '36 because that's the only starting point in the HPP. We simply don't have the manpower to make the other bookmarks work too. Maybe sometime in the future, but I'm not making any promises.

Oh, the good old US of A! The land of freedom, second chances and the Great Depression! Will you emerge as a new Superpower by the second half of the twentieth century or will you go under as many Empires have before? Only time will tell! (Although smart money says it will probably be the former. Just a hint.)

So let's take a look at how things are at the start of the game!

starting_map.png

I attached a smaller map of Alaska and the Pacific Islands. Their relative size is pretty much proportional to their importance.

As you can see from the screenshot, we have tons of base IC (probably more than all the Allies put together right now) and we have lots of resources as well. Both of these will change quickly though. The game starts with a very bad event for the US, representing the Great Depression. It has multiple phases but as it starts out, it will hurt my economy big time. I have a decent amount of manpower, which might be unexpected for vanilla players. Well, the US had quite a lot of unemployed people at the time. My Officer Ratio is 100% and I have 80% National Unity. I have 68 Diplomacy Points, but I don't really want to use them for anything right now.

starting_diplomacy.png

Note the name of the country: it's United States of America, not USA. Neat, huh?

At the start, I have three decisions I could make and three others that are not yet available. The first two would allow me to release Liberia and the Philippines from being my vassals to be completely free and independent, but I don't want to do that. Doing so would decrease my Threat level worldwide, but I don't need that and this action would have no other advantages. The third decision fires several introduction events explaining some of the main features of the mod, but I don't really need to see those, do I?

The other three decisions are "Leave the Naval Treaties", "They went too far!" and "Gearing up for War". The third is very similar to the vanilla decision, giving a small reduction in Neutrality and it can be activated if any two of the starting Faction Leaders are at war with eachother. The "They went too far!" decision reduces my Neutrality to about 50, but it needs to be below 90 to begin with, so it won't happen any time soon. (And it also has some ugly side-effects like gaining 50 Dissent or so, depending on how high was the Neutrality before that.) "Leave the Naval Treaties" is connected with the way how the naval tonnage restrictions are handled in the mod: all naval majors start the game with the basic techs of ships (the Design Principle) unavailable. During the first year, there will be an event allowing them to either sign the Second London Treaty or withdraw from the whole deal all together. This decision would allow the same.

starting_production.png

Here's a bunch of info that will become obsolete in a minute.

My faithful minion I mean respectful teammate TZoli invested a lot of time to make the starting OOBs and construction queues as accurate as possible. So I guess I will just stick to these fancy new ships. Not that I need them with all my already built ships and all, but whatever. As for the IC allocation, I'll simply put it on "Prioritize Production" for now because the Great Depression will hit me in the head very hard within a day after I press the pause button to start the game. Theoretically the effects should already be there when I load up the campaign but I thought it would be beneficial to the player to be notified about the reasons why the USA starts with crap for IC. Then again, with the Introduction events, that should be taken care of already. Maybe I should fix this. Later. Stay focused! I'm writing an AAR now, not a mod! At any rate, we will get back to the Great Depression in a minute. Let's move on to Technology!

starting_technology.png

Yes, I know, you don't see much on this single screenshot but you can't expect me to get a picture of every tab!

Now, as you can see, I start with 22 Leadership points to allocate. 20 of that comes from my Great Power Status (the US was quite powerful after the Great War) and 2 comes from being rather educated. Provinces no longer give any Leadership in the HPP. Scientists, officers, spies and diplomats all can be relocated so they are not really linked to the provinces in any way. You will still start to lose Leadership if you lose half your country though.

As you might expect, I have a few territories where I have decent level techs and even a few ahead of time (mostly Naval stuff and surprisingly to me at least, Medium Tanks) but I'm behind in a few areas. Now, I don't expect to be at war for quite a lot of time so I can (and should) neglect Doctrines for now. I will focus on modernizing my Army and and my Air Force first. The four basic Infantry tech goes first, and I also add in Engineers. I don't want to use them in Battalion size but the bonuses from their equipment will be applied to the Engineers included in Infantry Regiments and that might be helpful in the long run. I'll also update my Artillery because I like to use them. Ships will be good for now. Some bomber techs, Radio Detection Equipment, Industrial Production and Efficiency, Supply Transportation and Organisation aaaaand that's it for now. I'll put 0 to Diplomacy (let them come to me!), 4 on Spies (I'll build up some spies in the leaders of all three factions, just in case) and 4 on Officers (I start with 100% but that can go up to 150%, so there's room for improvement here).

Now you might be thinking to yourself: "Wait, what? That's only 14 points in Research! How can you get away with puting only 14 points to Research?!" Well, the thing is, the other majors also have this much. In fact, most of them start with a lot less! Germany starts the game as a Regional Power only, with only 10 Leadership. So, moving on to Politics.

starting_politics.png

Yes, I know that the National Revolt Risk modifier blends together with my next Election date, but that can't be fixed on my end, sorry.

Take a look at my cabinet! Aren't these guys awesome? Yes, I don't think they are either. Cordel Hull might have been acceptable in the first Volume but since then the Great Compromiser trait was expanded a bit and now it increases Neutrality and that won't do at all. His replacement, Arthur Vanderberg is an Iron-Fisted Brute, increasing Threat Inpact with 5% (that's the threat I generate towards others, so it doesn't really concern me) and decreases Ruling Party Support by 5%. Could be worse. For the Armament Minister post I chose George H. Dern, a Military Enterpreneur. The +20% Supplies will help a lot very soon. Hoover can stay, so much so that I put him in charge of foreign intelligence as well. The military guys have little effect for now so I won't mess with them.

As you can see, the Popularity and Organisation of the Democrats is quite a lot higher than the Republicans and all the others are pretty much insignificant. There are some well-placed events that make sure that it stays like this. My form of government is Presidential Republic, which basically means that the main man in charge is the Head of State (the President), he's the one calling the shots. It also means that there's no constitutional way of removing him so an interesting feature (holding early elections) is not available for me. This government type (like the other democratic types) gives a small reduction in National Revolt Risk, a small drifting bonus towards the Allies and others will also consider me less threatening than they would consider an autocracy. And it also determines who I can appoint into my cabinet: anyone from the democratic ideologies and also Paternal Autocrats. (If I had a Parliamentary Democracy instead, I would be allowed to appoint all democrats and Left-Wing Radicals in addition. I'm not sure about Constitutional Monarchies, but I think they can get in both ends. Or only Paternal Autocrats? Whatever.)

new_politics.png

A few ministers sacked, appointed some new ones. Didn't change any laws yet but I won't for a while anyway.


starting_intelligence.png

And here's my Intelligence window. Nice, huh?

So, I put the priority of the UK, Germany and the USSR to max as well as in my own country, put the domestic mission to Raise National Unity and left it on None in those three countries. Now you might ask: "What's the point of increasing your National Unity above 80 anyway? You will never be invaded!" The reason is the "They went too far!" decision. To use it at 90 Neutrality, I need either 85 National Unity or 50 Organisation and even though I start with 65 Organisation, I'm not sure how long it will remain that high. But you will still ask "Why don't you lower your Neutrality then?!" Because I have this funny little Strategic Effect called "Neutrality", which slows drift, boosts Ruling Party Support a little and increases Neutrality by 0.025 and another one called "Monroe Doctrine", doing the very same. 10 Spies can lower Neutrality by 0.03, so I would still be ahead with 0.02. The Monroe Doctrine will go away if I'm threatened by someone with at least 50 points, and both will go away if I have less than 85 Neutrality. But since I can't lower it manually, only events will help with that. So in effect I will need to wait until Europe goes up in flames before I could do practically anything.

Time to start the game! I won't do any reorganizing because I don't need to and I really don't feel like it right now.

great_depression.png

Farewell, 1700 manpower and half of my IC and resources...

The Great Depression. You can see the effects for yourself now. Cutting my IC in half is rather harsh but it has the fortunate sideeffect of also lowering Consumer Goods Demand. With that effect in place I have barely enough IC to feed my Production queue, let alone do any actual Upgrading (and there's like 40 IC needed for that). I'll need to sell some stuff and buy Supplies to help with that, although that will only give like 10-15 IC. Then there's the New Deal, an economical program especially to fight the Great Depression. It is modelled by a series of decisions with a three-months long effect:

new_deal.png

Free Factories!

It reduces Manpower (the unemployed people get suck up into the Industry), but it increases IC a bit and helps with the Money and Resource problems. It also increases Consumer Goods Demand though and it costs some money to get it started. But on the positive side, it has a chance of giving me some free IC, and it also helps remove the Great Depression faster. (That effect will be gradually lowered over time by recurring events and the frequency of those events highly depends on having the New Deal in effect.) For some stupid reason, the Consumer Goods Demand updates faster than the IC modifier so it gives some trouble at first, but it is quickly fixed.

I also start to get trade offers. The UK would buy Supplies from me. Problem is I don't really make them right now. How about some Fuel instead? Or maybe you could sell Supplies to me! Oh, what the hell... I need the money to keep my New Deal working. I also sell Rares to everyone who wants to buy. Right now my IC is lower than my resources could feed anyway.

So, yeah. This is pretty much how far I got in the first session. It's January 15th now. My economy stabilized, I'm pouring out resources like mad, and I've put trade on AI because I couldn't care less. Hope it own't bankrupt me though :) Oh, yeah, and I also sent spies to Japan to increase threat. They are the ones who will agrevate me the most and I want to get above that 50 Threat limit ASAP. That might help a bit. See you next week!
 
Last edited:
so the US has double the leadership of Germany? weird. then again, according to interviews with Eden, Speer and others, documents found in 1945 revealed that the Nazi's had absolutely no idea of Germany's GNP! how's that for strange?