• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Part 65


Singapore Sling

January 1945





1. Hurricane Vb fighter bomber strafing ground targets, Northern Malaya, January 1945


As 1945 began, Slim’s priority was the relief of Singapore. He needed to assure the safety of its air and naval bases from potential Japanese land offensives so that operations to retake Java and Malaya could begin in February. And that meant getting troops through the dangerous Malacca passage. The RAF was already beginning to arrive in numbers, and he could now base fighters at Rangoon which increased his control of the air over the Indian Ocean. The 18th Coastal Command Group had also arrived at the end of December, and Slim decided to risk basing them along with fighter support at Singapore itself. He would then push a fast Task Force through with land reinforcements at the end of the month. However, in the meantime, operations aimed at weakening the IJN continued.

During the opening stages of these preliminary operations, Japanese naval bombers operating from Northern Malaya caused significant damage to Tovey’s 3rd Battle Group on the 2nd, but this time, RAF fighters operating from Rangoon arrived to chase them off. It was the first time that Slim had been able to counter this threat, and by the 4th, the Navy felt sufficiently emboldened to enter the Malacca channel, and that evening a major engagement took place in the North passage between Vian’s carriers and a Japanese carrier group under Admiral Nomura. The Japanese were forced to withdraw after losing two cruisers, and the next day the RAF were also able to hit Durnai with aircraft operating from Singapore. Vian now believed he had done enough for the moment and on the morning of the 5th January decided to withdraw.















However, the Japanese then intercepted the retreating British later that afternoon, and a task force under Admiral Fukadome with the Giant Battleship Musashi clashed with Vian’s carriers again in the Sunda Trench. With no air support, the force was badly mauled by the Royal Navy, losing 3 heavy and one light cruiser’s before being forced to flee. The 6th Carrier Group was damaged and had to retire for repairs, but the tide was now slowly beginning to turn.









5th Army was now beginning to assemble at Cochin, from where it was to redeploy to Ceylon as the supply situation allowed. Slim had now decided to give the responsibility of reinforcing Singapore to Lt General Anders veteran V Corps. V Corps had been formed back in 1939 from the former WDF (Western Desert Force). It had fought along the coastline of Eygpt and Libya, taking part in Operations “Chrome” “Hammer” and “Tempest”. It had defended Cyprus from the German Airborne assaults of early 1941, and had fought the entire Italian campaign from beginning to end. It had taken part in the battles on the River Po and endured the defeats that resulted from it. And now it here in South East Asia, at the front, the first formation into action in the new offensive in the East.





2. Soldiers of the 2/9th Rajput Regiment, 29th Indian Infantry Brigade, 4th Indian Division


Meanwhile, the South Atlantic became a war zone for the first time on 20th January. Admiral Martins TF41 fought an inconclusive battle with the Brazilian Battleships Sao Paulo and Minas Gerais off the coast of Brazil. Outgunned as he was, his better trained and far more experienced crews easily managed to outfight the Brazilians, but he could inflict no losses. It served only as a warning that without carriers to dominate the South Atlantic, the Brazilians were going to be a problem for some months to come.







Two days later, “Operation Buster” began. It was to be a “fast in, fast out” operation to get the bulk of V Corps ashore at Singapore, not necessarily one designed to inflict any losses. However, with Vian’s 6th Carrier Group temporarily out of action following his fight with the Musashi, the inexperienced crews of the 10th Carrier Groups HMS Implacable and HMS Indefatigable were to take its place alongside the 5th Carrier Group. This would lead to problems later.




The operation began well enough with the RN fanning out in a protective arc around the 21st Transport Group that would take V Corps in. However, as the force began to enter the Malacca channel, the 10th Carrier Group was intercepted by Nomura with the Carriers Unyo and Chitose. The Japanese managed to beat Admiral Noble to the draw, and their strike went in first, stalling the British response and badly damaging all of the 10th’s escort vessels. Implacable herself was hit by two bombs and caught fire, while almost a third of her aircraft were destroyed or damaged on deck. It was lucky that the aircraft had not yet been armed with ordnance, or the whole ship might have been lost. Fire control teams managed to bring the blaze under control, but the 10th was forced to withdraw at the very moment of greatest risk.








The operation had to continue with the 5th Carrier Group as sole escort, although the 2nd Battle Group arrived later to give support. The objective was completed without further incident, and V Corps was delivered safely into Singapore the following day. The withdraw was also completed in good order, with only minor damage being sustained by HMS Norfolk from a mine.





3. Damage control teams tackle fires aboard HMS Implacable after she was hit by two 500lb bombs


However, the story reverberated up the command chain, serving as yet another lesson that the Japanese were still fully capable of inflicting a serious reverse on the Royal Navy. The loss of a few destroyers or cruisers was sustainable, and even a Battleship could be lived with because Britain had reserves. But the loss of a carrier, or worse still a whole carrier group, at this stage would be a serious blow. There was still much hard fighting ahead before amphibious operations in the South China sea would be possible.



.
 
Last edited:
Wow! Good stuff!
It seems strange that JAP navy you bombed in Dumai was out of supply. It might be AI not building convoys/escorts. Check in save file how many convoy transports JAP has. You might give them some to make it more fun.
 
Can you expect any help from e.g. Australia or ist it just the US and you?
Also, what's the situation in Eastern Europe?

The Aussies have contributed 2 divisions expeditionary force up till now, the rest of their army is at home. Eastern Europe is now at peace.

Great update!

Thanks

great updates, even just with Japan to deal with this is not going to be easy

Definately not. The IJN are a tougher act altogether than the Italians

Any chance to go through Indonesia and link up with the Australians in Borneo? That would remove access to resources for Japan and remove the threat of IJN raids on Australian soil at the same time.

Possibly. Though at the moment, I don't want to dissipate my effort in different directions.

Can you imagine the anger if people tried to say 'the Americans won the war' in this timeline. :L

Well, Uncle Sam should begin to bring more effort to bear soon

This , too , won't be an easy war!

Indeed. The supply situation in SE Asia is poor, which will be a fight in itself

Wow! Good stuff!
It seems strange that JAP navy you bombed in Dumai was out of supply. It might be AI not building convoys/escorts. Check in save file how many convoy transports JAP has. You might give them some to make it more fun.

Her convoys are depleted a little because both the Americans and the British have submarines in the South China Sea. This is realistic imho

Good stuff, seems like you have finally arrived with quite some force, yet it'll be tough campaign until you can turn the tide.

I wish you luck!

Its getting everything in place. Simply reorganising took an age.

Damn Americans. We saved your arse in WWII :)

Looking forward to some more carrier on carrier action.

Heh. Bless em :D
 
Amazing AAR, simply amazing!!

I really wish I had done one for my French 1938 campaign, it ended up being France and UK reasserting their colonial power all over the world.


I have a few questions though, forgive me if they're something you've been over before.

  • How did you negociate a peace with Germany? I thought Axis/Allies had to fight to the death?
  • How do you negociate with the terms for the peace treaty?

I didn't think this was possible, or are you just using them as a literary device?
 
  • How did you negociate a peace with Germany? I thought Axis/Allies had to fight to the death?
  • How do you negociate with the terms for the peace treaty?

He edited the savegame that way and converted that into the narrative.
 
Amazing AAR, simply amazing!!

I really wish I had done one for my French 1938 campaign, it ended up being France and UK reasserting their colonial power all over the world.


I have a few questions though, forgive me if they're something you've been over before.

  • How did you negociate a peace with Germany? I thought Axis/Allies had to fight to the death?
  • How do you negociate with the terms for the peace treaty?

I didn't think this was possible, or are you just using them as a literary device?

Thank you sir,

As Baltasar says, I made several edits to the save game files to achieve a negotiated peace.

While HOI3 is an excellent game, it does have many issues. These detract (imho) from writing a semi-historical AAR. And while I fully agree that the possibilities for "re-writing" history should be part of the game, they should be "achieveable" departures from history.

The edits themselves I can tell you if you want them, but the "terms" of the treaty are literary licence.
 
have just finished reading this from start to where you are currently - its brilliant griping stuff - keep it up. So glad you went for the narrative fix and looking forward to the next chapter - you've got my vote.
 
Part 66


Malacca

31st January - 10th February 1945





1. HMS Indomitable hit by Japanese bombs


Pound spoke with Field Marshall Slim towards the end of January. He was only too aware of Slims timetable and the need to gain naval superiority quickly. However, 2nd Army Groups chief was becoming impatient. Aware now of the worsening supply situation for the Japanese on Java, he had decided to mount an airborne assault to force the issue. He needed Java secured before he could mount an amphibious operation on the Malay peninsula, and the deadline Churchill had set for this was no later than mid March. Therefore Slim asked Pound not to let pressure on the IJN slip, and indeed, to step it up if he could. The chief of the Naval Staff agreed, saying that he would reinforce the Pacific Fleet still further, while Slim set the airborne operation for 25th February, and asked the Navy for a significant step up in activity during the coming month.




Pound could oblige, for even following the bruising battles of January, the next operation was already beginning. Together with 5th Carrier Group, now back to full strength following the rotation of damaged vessels, 6th Carrier Group and the 2nd and 3rd Battle Groups set off in the early hours of 1st February for another sortie into the Malacca Channel. The direct approach and the speed with which the force moved into enemy sea space bought an immediate response from the IJN, and by the following night Sommerville had encountered the Japanese carrier Soryu in the North of the Malacca channel.




Heavily outnumbered, Yamamoto used the darkness well and a game of cat and mouse ensued during which both sides suffered minor damage but no losses. By the following morning Sommerville had lost Yamamoto, and unfortunately for him, was suddenly hit by Japanese land based naval bombers who had managed to evade the British fighters at the limit of their range. 5th Carrier Group again suffered significant damage and was forced to withdraw. However, an hour later, Vian surprised 3 Siamese vessels in the North passage and destroyed them all after a brief fight.









Meanwhile the British Naval Bombers were busy again with raids on damaged vessels in Teluk naval base, but were eventually driven off by heavy anti aircraft fire. The British carriers had by now withdrawn, but the final act of this raid was carried out by Tovey who ambushed and sunk another IJN heavy cruiser. Cunningham was less fortunate, and his 2nd Battlegroup was hit by Japanese Naval Bombers in a second raid which caused significant damage, almost resulting in the loss of the 97th Destroyer flotilla. The British now withdrew once again.









2. A near miss on HMS Victorious


The operation was broadly another success with the loss of 1 heavy and 2 light enemy cruisers and a destroyer group for the loss of no British vessels. But once again, the damage sustained by the Royal Navy was high. 2nd Battle Groups damage was superficial since reserves could be rotated in to replace the damaged escorts. But no less than 3 carriers had been hit, and both HMS Indomitable and HMS Courageous would be out of action for at least 2 weeks.







The difficulty was, as Vian pointed out, that the Navy were trying to fight in the middle of the hole in Allied fighter cover. He suggested a “Feint” in Northern Malaya, where the British fighter cover would magnify the carriers power even more, and which would be bound to draw the IJN north to defend the coastline. He suggested the 21st Transport Group, now in Ceylon, be used to as bait to lure them out, whereupon the 6th and 10th Carrier Groups would engage them. Tovey’s Battleships would then attempt to cut off their retreat. He put it to Pound, whose only reservation was the improvised nature of the operation meant there would be little time to organise it, but nevertheless agreed. It would go ahead concurrently with the airborne assault on Java, and he gave it the codename “Hardball”.





There was no time to rest. Ceylon was now a massive naval base working at maximum pitch. The Navy had been in action now almost constantly since mid December and there was no possibility of a let up in the pressure. Ships were arriving back from operations with combat damage, some of it minor and some of it more serious. Across the huge Colombo base repair crews worked around the clock, and the sparks from grinders and acetylene torches lit up the night sky as turnaround times were pushed to the minimum possible. The Carriers had priority, followed by light cruisers and only then Battleships. If a ship had suffered damage that put it out of action for more than 10 days, it was rotated out to the reserve at Bombay and a replacement was bought in. As well as the battle on the open sea, it was as much a battle to get ships repaired and back into action.


.
 
Last edited:
Intense naval battles you're fighting. Very good idea to have a pool of fully combat ready reserves in Ceylon, and to send the ships which are more heavily damaged back to Colombo. This way you don't risk losing any damaged ships to a surprise portstrike by Japanese carrierbased aircraft, but still have some reserves close at hand to keep your fleets in battlecondition.

I must say I love your maps, they clearly show your intentions and plans.

Looking forward to the liberation of the Dutch East Indies and hope the Japanese sail right into the trap you've set for them.
 
Exciting read! Really gives the impression of a sustained, round-the-clock campaign centered on the aim of breaking the Japanese in Malaya.

But regarding your overall plan of operations posted on the previous page - doesn't it play to Japan's strengths if you attempt to land in Vietnam and push across Thailand, after the securing of Malaya? I would think British air and naval superiority could be better used in a more amphibious campaign - hopping north to Hainan and Taiwan, to secure them as air bases for naval interdiction and CAS for the ground forces, and only then attack Vietnam?
 
Last edited:
Interesting!

The IJN is giving you a really tough fight, we'll see in how far that will limit your possibilities for amphibious invasions in Indochina or China itself.
 
Any idea why the IJN scores so few hits on your ships? Surely the AI will always perform worse than a human player, but the IJN should still be able to deliver a considerable punsh and at least sink a escorts and stuff.
 
I agree Leviathan07. While you're strategy works in theory you'll be engaging the currently largest infantry power in the world over some of the worst possible terrain. It could work but you'll encounter the same supply problems as the Japanese. Another strategy would be doing what the US did in RL and go on an island hoping campaign. Clear out the Japanese islands and you make it very hard for Japan to function. Plus you force the Japanese navy into the fight by removing their safe havens. Eventually Japan will have to devote a large part or all of its navy to making sure it can still hold China.

The only way to kill an island naval power is to strangle it into submission. Any attempt to force your way in will lead to lots of dead people.
 
Any idea why the IJN scores so few hits on your ships? Surely the AI will always perform worse than a human player, but the IJN should still be able to deliver a considerable punsh and at least sink a escorts and stuff.

Yes. I'll tell you why that is. Because the AI builds lots of carriers, but not enough CAGs to go on them. Yet ANOTHER bug in the game. The same is true of the USA. I, being a human, have built 2 CAGs for each carrier. Any other questions?
 
Impressive naval battles! And practically a worldwide naval struggle. Love it!

Rensslaer
 
Yes. I'll tell you why that is. Because the AI builds lots of carriers, but not enough CAGs to go on them. Yet ANOTHER bug in the game. The same is true of the USA. I, being a human, have built 2 CAGs for each carrier. Any other questions?


Why only two CAGs per carrier, you could build 4 and rotate them in and out since the CAGs lose org a lot faster than their motherships :D