Thanks, everyone, for waiting patiently and also for the many wonderful suggestions regarding the Union Flag!
...As for the gameplay... wholly disappointing that England could not hold onto Gascony, take Paris, or expand into Flanders
... It seems strange that England can hold onto a PU with Byzantium but not Gascony
(I know, I'm a downer)
No downer at all, CJL. Personally I am amazed (though grateful) that Byzantium has not had a single revolt event ever since the beginning of the PU. Meanwhile, places like Malta and Scotland (and even Gibraltar, still) have a flare-up every 5 years, at minimum. If it were possible for France to have demanded an end to the PU in the 1476 peace negotiations, I am sure they would have done so (and I would surely have accepted rather than lose Gascony).
But, the game is what it is. :wacko: In gameplay terms I chalk BYZ's relative quiet up to granting the religious and political autonomy events... and in roleplay, I guess a real-life Byzantium under English rule would probably be happy if—as I have done—ENG leaves them to their own devices but does flex military muscle when the Turks get involved.
I can't believe I missed a history book AAR this good.
Thanks, and welcome aboard!
The first one doesn't have quite the strong Socialist/Communist feel, I'd say.
:rofl: Hadn't thought of that at all until you mentioned it... the People's Democratic Republic of Britannia Major and Nova Roma. By the way,
Mr. Capiatlist, thanks for the running the ACAs. First-class job and it's a great pat on the back to many terrific authors.
_________________________
As far as the flag goes, I think my personal favourites are
robb1993's idea (Union flag with CoA in white circle),
c0d5579's idea (Union flag with Byzantium B's in each quarter),
AllmyJames' first concept (1707 Union Flag with gold Byzantium cross as outline to cross of St. George), and
thekonkoe's first concept (1707 Union flag with gold Byzantium B's on each arm of St. George's cross).
I'm still thinking about what form the Union flag will take—but I can't say any more about it for fear of delving into spoiler territory.
This is also a good time to mention that
minefield has done some truly
stellar work creating wonderful
Victoria 2 and
EU3 flag packs. They'd be a fine addition to anyone's V2 or EU3 game, and I've incorporated the EU3 pack into the AAR (though you will not see them start to appear in screenshots until the early 1500s, as that's what I have played up to).
Here's an example of comparing some default EU3/MMU flags (with their super-bright primary colours) to those from
minefield's pack. The last one is my ENG rework for the AAR, using
minefield's flags as a base.
Let me also offer thanks to everyone who voted for this AAR in the ACAs. I didn't win the history-book category, but regular reader and author
gabor did! His
Single Men - Holy See MMU AAR is a worthy winner—a terrific read that also explores a lot of the Dei Gratia / MMU Catholic religion events. It can be an eye-opener if you (like me) have never really messed with playing the Papal States in MMU. Check it out!
Now, a bit of bad news: I'm probably still a day or two away from posting an update, but I will leave a semi-spoiler here for you to ponder!