• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
"Tawny, Her Customs" Central Asia April-June 1942

Despite the drama and intensity of the war with Germany, STAVKA could ill-afford to ignore the events in Central Asia. Japanese success could see Tannu Tuva and Mongolia knocked out, the Trans-Siberian Rail cut at Irkutsk and the loss of the Central Asian industrial and resource centres.


(Camels were a major part of the Soviet logistical network in this sector)

When Sinkiang fell in early January 1942, the RKKA had 4 divisions (2 Rifle, 1 DNO, 1 Garrison) in the region. From the Trans-Baikal Front, the Persian border and freshly raised forces this was increased to 10 Divisions (6 Rifle, 2 DNO, 1 Garrison and 1 Cavalry) by the end of March.


(Sinkiang/Soviet border region, showing main offensives by each side)

This force had to hold the current front till further reinforcements arrived. April saw steadily mounting Japanese pressure. On the border between Sinkiang and Kazakhstan, both Kuytun and Ulunger Hu fell on 28 April. Kuqa fell on 8 May, giving the Japanese effective control over the Tarim basin. In the meantime they also pressed northwards into the Altai region and west into Mongolia.

With the end of operations in Persia, a further 4 divisions were racing eastwards (2 Rifle, 1 Mountain, 1 Cavalry) but these would not reach the front lines till early June at the best. Aiding the Soviet defense was the sheer distances involved and the limited road networks. In effect, STAVKA ordered Stern, now in command of the Central Asian Front, to limit their gains till he had enough forces to first stop and then throw back the aggressors.



He identified the mountain pass to Kazakhstan at Khrebet Tarbagaty as a key sector and committed what was left of his operational reserves.



For almost two weeks the Japanese advanced was stalled before the Soviet lines gave way on 15 May.


(Soviet positions near Khrebet)

The result was by the time the Japanese forced the frontier, a counterattack was immediately launched by 2 freshly raised Rifle Divisions temporarily throwing their attack into confusion. Although the Japanese managed to take Yining (and thus threaten Kyrgyzstan) on 1 June,



again they were already too late as Soviet resistance was steadily stiffening as fresh forces arrived.

The result in June was their attempt to complete the occupation of the Tarim region was thrawted at Aral on 23 June. Equally, Soviet troops launched a wide counterattack from Ulunger Hu and Yining, retaking both border towns by early July.



With the Japanese thrown into some confusion (and suffering major supply problems), Khrebet Tarbagaty was quickly retaken on 30 June. In effect, the front line of early April had been restored by the end of June, but this time the Soviet forces were much stronger.


(The campaign in the Altai region of Tannu Tuva and Western Mongolia)


(Typical terrain in the western Altai)

In the meantime, the Japanese offensive in the Altai had not just been stopped, it had been thrown back. A major defensive victory by elements of 12 Corps at Tsetserleg on 16 May had halted their invasion of Mongolia. With this victory, a combination of forces from the Far East, those that had fought in the February-March battles (and had had the chance to recover) and some fresh reinforcements all attacked in an arc into the Altai.


(Soviet cavalry artillery in operation near Kyzyl)

A series of hard fought victories at Youvi Feng Hodrogo and Uliastay relieved the pressure on both Mongolia and Tannu.


(Soviet cavalry in the Altai region, as in the Arctic their mobility was invaluable and compensated for the lack of motorised or armoured formations)

Even better, they cut off a division of Japanese Marines at Oygom.

By June, Soviet forces in the region amounted to 18 Divisions and this had proved sufficient to stall the Japanese aggression. Despite all the other demands on Soviet manpower (including wanting to reinforce the forces screening Manchuria), STAVKA decided to gamble that this represented a powerful enough force to drive the Japanese back and liberate Sinkiang. Equally despite abundent evidence that Japanese forces were involved, both sides opted to maintain the fiction that this was a war between their Chinese proxies.

The pattern of losses reflecting the changing intensity of combat. Overall the Soviets lost 13,389 and the Japanese 13,689, however, over half these died in the June battles where the Soviets first stopped and then struck back at the Japanese offensive. The relatively even losses reflected the nature of the fighting where the terrain meant that neither side could ever really manouvre effectively nor was it easy to exploit any breakthroughs.
 
You come through again! :) Since you seem to know your way around this stuff, I'll ask you: is that body armor made out of cast iron? It kinda looks like they took a stove apart and roughly moulded it into a torso-shape...

They look pretty nicely crafted to me. See how they go down over the belly, protecting the guts, but still not hamper the soldiers thigh when crouching. Seems like they even have extra vests under it to take some of the pressure away from the shoulders. They gotto weigh plenty, though. The combat vest I used to use back in the days only covered chest and back, and they still weighed close to 10 kilos or something - if I remeber right. These once gotto be much heavier.

Edit: Doesnt seem like the flamer-guy have one - but its a little bit hard to tell. Might imply that only the once in the front with light weaponry had those cumbersom vests... but I'm just guessing away now.

According to the book I have it's SN-42 body armour, or one of the similar designs. 2mm thick pressed steel plates. I doesn't list a weight, unfortunately. Supposedly it stops an MP-40 bullet at around 100 metres, and obviously also helps against shrapnel and other rounds. It's supposed to be standard issue for all assault engineers, so I don't know why the one with the flame thrower isn't wearing it. Possibly the combined weight of it and of the flame thrower was too much?

By June, Soviet forces in the region amounted to 18 Divisions and this had proved sufficient to stall the Japanese aggression. Despite all the other demands on Soviet manpower (including wanting to reinforce the forces screening Manchuria), STAVKA decided to gamble that this represented a powerful enough force to drive the Japanese back and liberate Sinkiang. Equally despite abundent evidence that Japanese forces were involved, both sides opted to maintain the fiction that this was a war between their Chinese proxies.

The pattern of losses reflecting the changing intensity of combat. Overall the Soviets lost 13,389 and the Japanese 13,689, however, over half these died in the June battles where the Soviets first stopped and then struck back at the Japanese offensive. The relatively even losses reflected the nature of the fighting where the terrain meant that neither side could ever really manouvre effectively nor was it easy to exploit any breakthroughs.

As long as it stays a proxy war. I suspect you might found out it isn't when the Japanese navy start bombing your Pacific fleet in Vladivostok. ;) Though historically the Far East and Transbaikal Military Districts were quite a bit stronger in 1942 than they were in 1938/39, and the handled the Kwantung Army then.
 
Last edited:
I like the reminder that you're fighting on multiple fronts. It gives the feeling that you're hemmed in on all sides by your enemies. How many divisions do you have in place against the Japanese - the 18 you mention here are just the central Asian front, but there are more in the Far East too, aren't there?

It's a good thing you didn't strip the theatres down too much during Barbarossa.
 
Loki, just so you know I'm still watching... just a little overwhelmed, so not alot of comments! :D

Renss
 
Good stuff. It is with reports of action in this theatre that I truly am remind of just how massive Russia is and thus how large a territory you are having to defend. I'm glad to see things seem to have stabilised as I would imagine, and indeed as you alluded to, you do not exactly have a great deal of manpower to spare for every front and this has to be a theatre of less import than others.
 
Excellent update, and very interesting selection of pictures. Good to see you are stabilising the situation in Central Asia, but if things are tricky and the infrastructure holds things up you can always rely on the old Russian strategic advantage and trade space for time...plenty of space in that part of the world ;).

Where does the "tawny, her customs" quote come from?

Looking forward to the next thrilling installment...!
 
As long as it stays a proxy war. I suspect you might found out it isn't when the Japanese navy start bombing your Pacific fleet in Vladivostok. ;) Though historically the Far East and Transbaikal Military Districts were quite a bit stronger in 1942 than they were in 1938/39, and the handled the Kwantung Army then.

in reality once they pulled out the tough 1st line divisions in mid-41, the Far East was a priority for Soviet reinforcements. They really did not trust the Japanese and nor do I. The only way to encourage a player to look at the Far East divs as particularly useful in the west would be to give them a bonus around combat experience to reflect both their level of training and the 38-39 battles.

I like the reminder that you're fighting on multiple fronts. It gives the feeling that you're hemmed in on all sides by your enemies. How many divisions do you have in place against the Japanese - the 18 you mention here are just the central Asian front, but there are more in the Far East too, aren't there?

It's a good thing you didn't strip the theatres down too much during Barbarossa.

I'll slot a small Far East OOB into the next post. I'd pulled the 3 mot rifle divs out at the scenario start and the mountain divs in Central Asia (they ended up captured at Archangelsk!), ... by this stage I was wishing I'd left well alone as I could have probably defended Sinkiang with those units (due to the impassable terrain there is one key province that is hilly so an excellent defense spot, esp for mtn divs).

How do supplies even get to Sinkiang? :p
By a complex system of pullies and levers.

more or less, I've built up the infra as a spur to the Trans-Siberian down to the Sinkiang border and only have 2 brigades of armoured cars needing fuel. So my demands are low, there's are a problem for them. Xibei can neither make nor deliver enough so the AI keeps on flipping Japanese units from Xibei to japanese control depending if they are in combat. Even so, they seem to struggle which allows me to beat a somewhat larger army (I reckon they had about 35 divs, say 20 Japanese, 15 Chinese), I have around 25 (18 Soviet, 7 from my allies).

Loki, just so you know I'm still watching... just a little overwhelmed, so not alot of comments! :D

Renss
Good stuff. It is with reports of action in this theatre that I truly am remind of just how massive Russia is and thus how large a territory you are having to defend. I'm glad to see things seem to have stabilised as I would imagine, and indeed as you alluded to, you do not exactly have a great deal of manpower to spare for every front and this has to be a theatre of less import than others.

The 18 divisions are 4 that start in Central Asia, 4 from the Far East, 4 from the Caucasus (post-Persia) and worse, 6 new (that should have gone to the Arctic). Everyone I really need somewhere else. My fear was if the Japanese broke out, I'd need to use a lot of troops just to secure all the widely scattered valuable stuff over there - starting with the very vulnerable transiberian and all the IC and resources in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan. So this is the least worst of my options.

Given the poor infrastructure in Central Asia/Western China, could you even support more troops than you already have in theater?

PS: That's a badass-looking sabre in that screenshot...

as above, there are no support brigades, no real fuel needs and the front moves slowly so I just about get away with it.

as to the sabre, you get the impression he had little interest in the operational directives of using horses for mobility and fighting on foot - that is a weapon he intends to use on some representive or other of 'the aggressors against the socialist motherland'

Excellent update, and very interesting selection of pictures. Good to see you are stabilising the situation in Central Asia, but if things are tricky and the infrastructure holds things up you can always rely on the old Russian strategic advantage and trade space for time...plenty of space in that part of the world ;).

Where does the "tawny, her customs" quote come from?

Looking forward to the next thrilling installment...!

except that here if I fell back they'd be able to run amok across Siberia, not a problem in itself but near impossible to contain once they break out.

The quote is from Emily Dickinson - "Civilisation spurns the leopard", I've been mining my anthology of her poems for most of the chapter headings as they are quite gloomy with often very stark images. I think she'll see me into 1943 then I may shift to Nazim Hikmet.
 
"Deserts, Never Rebuked her Satin", Central Asia July-August 1942

July and August saw steady Soviet gains in the sector but were also marked by a periods of defeat followed by new advances. By the end of August central and western Sinkiang was back under Soviet control and the immediate threat to Soviet Central Asia averted.



However, the situation remained complex with the possibility of a successful Japanese counterattack. Equally the war was spreading in China. Yunnan had joined the axis in late July and was now recapturing French occupied territory in Guanxi as well as potentially threatening the British Imperialists in Burma. Equally, a number of partisan risings were occuring in Japanese occupied China.



Thus on the one hand, the Japanese, using their Chinese proxies were in a position to sweep into India, on the other, their hold on China itself seemed less secure.

In turn, all this fed into the debates within the GKO as to the purpose of the Central Asian campaign. Some argued that the forces should now be reduced to a minimum so as to stop a renewed Japanese offensive (and instead to rebuild the Soviet defense lines in the Far East). With the loss of forces to west Mongolia, these had been reduced to 4 Divisions (1 Mountain) in the Trans-Baikal Sector, 7 spread around north Manchuria, 8 (including 1 Mountain) in the Vladivostock sector and 4 Garrison divisions scattered around key ports. In the event of war with Japan, this was too few for an offensive and probably too few to mount an effective defense.

Others argued that now there was an opportunity to liberate all Sinkiang and knock out the Japanese warlord allies of Xibei San Ma. This would also bring Soviet forces into contact with Mao's renegade group and help convince them that their safety lay in a Soviet not a pro-Japanese alliance.



It would also weaken Japan's overall position in China, reducing the chance they would attack the Soviet Union directly.

On the Mongolian border, the encircled Japanese at Oygom were attacked on 4 July and nearly 13,000 survivors surrendered on 14 July.



This victory secured Tannu Tuva and cleared the Japanese from western Mongolia. Both sides spent the rest of July reorganising and moving forces into position for a renewed Soviet offensive in August. This swirled around the small town of Aj Bogd Uul. An initial attack from 3 to 13 August pushed the Japanese back, but they managed to rush fresh forces into the battle and by the 18th the Soviet attack was broken off.


(Soviet cavalry trying to outflank the Japanese defense lines at Aj Bogd Uul)

By late August, a renewed Soviet offensive aimed at Aj Bogd opened on 26 August, but by 6 September ended in defeat.



At the same time, the Japanese retook Govi Altay



so, overall the northern front, apart from the victory at Oygom ended in a stalemate.

The southern front had seen the border secured by the start of July. However, an attempt to regain the push across the border at Karamay was badly botched leading to a major defeat on 12 July. However, this was partially offset by regaining Kuqa in the southern sector by 14 July, completing Soviet control of the western Tarim.

From Khrebet Tarbatay, Soviet cavalry managed to take and hold Korla on 6 August and another Soviet column took Manas by 26 July in the face of weak Japanese resistance.


(Soviet cavalry in the Manas sector)

These two small victories set the scene for the Soviet offensive across the Tarim region in late July. The attempts to take Di Hua and to complete the occupation of the southern sector at Tarim Pendl both failed by 3 August.


(Soviet infantry attack on Di Hua in early August)

However, the Japanese victory at Karamay now came back to haunt them. Three divisions were trapped in a pocket and at the end of a brutal 11 day battle over 25,000 surrendered.



Again, a lull set in as both sides re-organised and Soviet troops fully occupied their new gains. The focus was now on liberating Di Hua and restoring the Sinkiang regime. A short, intense, 4 day battle saw the town in Soviet hands by 21 August



and a small Japanese counterattack beaten off on the 26th. To the south, Tarim Pendle fell on 17 August, effectively securing Soviet control over western and southern Sinkiang.



At this stage the front lines settled into a bloody stalemate that lasted till late October. In effect the Japanese forces on the Mongolian front retained a tenuous supply line south through Lop Nor. As long as they held this, they were both in danger of encirclement, but also threatened to encircle the Soviet forces in central Sinkiang.

Actual combat losses favoured the Japanese due to the number of failed offensives as the Red Army tried to force the pace of operations. In July and August some 12,990 Soviet soldiers lost their lives for 10,372 of their opponents. However 5 Divisions (4 of them Japanese) were completely eliminated and 38,247 prisoners taken. Their position was to cause significant tensions between the USSR and Japan as it was increasingly hard for either side to ignore the nature of this campaign. Equally the Japanese could not formally ask for Red Cross access as they continued to deny that their forces were engaged in the fighting. However, the risks of another Soviet-Japanese clash in Manchuria were slowly mounting.
 
So, the Japanese lost about 50,000 troops to encirclement. What is that, four or five divisions destroyed? That's a nice result, given the relatively low numbers of divisions engaged in theatre. I thought things were touch and go for a while, as you were trading minor victories and defeats with the Japanese, but in the end, you clearly tilted things in your favor.

Pending the total defeat of Germany (or at least the destruction of its ability to threaten you), what are your goals in China? Are you looking for a defensible line? Does such a thing even exist?
 
My word, the Japanese have taken a bit of a beating. Not so much in the battles but operationally where they've lost five divisions to encirclement. And their allies look worse than the German allies, in combat terms. I'd still want to avoid a full-blown war, but it's worth reinforcing your Far East front. My strategy if one broke out would be to start an all out offensive, trying to crush the Kwantung Army and overrun Manchuria and Korea before the Japanese can start reinforcing the area. But that does require significantly larger forces than you have, and tank forces for a rapid blitzkrieg.

Oh, and the Japanese Imperial Guard is a tank division. :) I'll bet some of the local Soviet anti-tank gunners are happy. Instead of German Tigers in the Ukraine, they're firing at Japanese Type 97 Chi-Ha tanks, or some of their lighter ones, in the Tarim basin. If they weren't good soviet comrades, I'd suggest offering prayers in thanks.
 
Very well done against Japan. Hopefully you have now dissuaded them from any further thoughts of taking the offensive. If things were to remain at a stalemate in this theatre, it would likely be no bad thing.
 
Great update. The sheer size of the Asian theatre must be a daunting prospect, particularly if you find you have failed to identify a potential threat and then have to react to it. Nevertheless, you have done a sterling job there, and as Morningsider says, it must surely blunt Japanese appetite in that particular region.
 
So, the Japanese lost about 50,000 troops to encirclement. What is that, four or five divisions destroyed? That's a nice result, given the relatively low numbers of divisions engaged in theatre. I thought things were touch and go for a while, as you were trading minor victories and defeats with the Japanese, but in the end, you clearly tilted things in your favor.

Pending the total defeat of Germany (or at least the destruction of its ability to threaten you), what are your goals in China? Are you looking for a defensible line? Does such a thing even exist?

I keep on changing my mind which is never a good thing in HOI, At this stage its too unstable to let up my attacks, I'm encircling the Japanese as much as they are encircling me. A bit later (Nov I think) I get a really good defense line in W Sinkiang and with hindsight should have stopped there, but it seemed as if Xibei was on its last legs so the lure of knocking them out made me press on -with near disastrous consequences.

Overall this is one of the times when my approach of trying to hustle them with lots of probing attacks really paid off. I lost more than I won, but managed to win the few that really matter (all the low infra provinces in the region mean its possible to encircle by some rather indirect approaches).

My word, the Japanese have taken a bit of a beating. Not so much in the battles but operationally where they've lost five divisions to encirclement. And their allies look worse than the German allies, in combat terms. I'd still want to avoid a full-blown war, but it's worth reinforcing your Far East front. My strategy if one broke out would be to start an all out offensive, trying to crush the Kwantung Army and overrun Manchuria and Korea before the Japanese can start reinforcing the area. But that does require significantly larger forces than you have, and tank forces for a rapid blitzkrieg.

Oh, and the Japanese Imperial Guard is a tank division. :) I'll bet some of the local Soviet anti-tank gunners are happy. Instead of German Tigers in the Ukraine, they're firing at Japanese Type 97 Chi-Ha tanks, or some of their lighter ones, in the Tarim basin. If they weren't good soviet comrades, I'd suggest offering prayers in thanks.

Linked to my answer to Stuyvesant above, the other thing I never quite get right is when (& how much) to pull out of Central Asia and use to reinforce the Far East. At this stage, I've just about got enough over there to make the inevitable defeat really painful.

when I first spotted the Tank Div I was a bit worried, but worked out that the armour cars with my cavalry divs are probably better armoured than a level I/II Japanese light tank. So yes, even the divisional AT guns utterly overwhelm them.

Keep kicking ass ^^

EDIT: Could you please show the world map :D

at your request:



Central Asian warfare, defenders win. :p

Very well done against Japan. Hopefully you have now dissuaded them from any further thoughts of taking the offensive. If things were to remain at a stalemate in this theatre, it would likely be no bad thing.

If I'd been sensible I would have had the discipline to decide that a stalemate in good defensive terrain was a pretty acceptable outcome ... unfortunately by the end of 1942, I get a bit greedy in this sector.

Great update. The sheer size of the Asian theatre must be a daunting prospect, particularly if you find you have failed to identify a potential threat and then have to react to it. Nevertheless, you have done a sterling job there, and as Morningsider says, it must surely blunt Japanese appetite in that particular region.

They give up for a while and pull out most of their surviving forces, then decide to attack again in early 43. I think they are as indecisive as to what they really want as I am ...

But yes, the size of those provinces, plus the low infra, means all movement takes an age.
 
When did UK lost its home isle o_o

early 1941, I think the Germans fully conquered it by March (except the Shetlands), so they really have nothing to do except to use all that vast army, and masses of IC and Leadership to attack me. No danger of a second front, no strat bombing etc.