Yes, that was my feelings too. That and all the people with a good RPing going also got eaten/lynched very early. This game has actually started to get interesting again just now when it actually looks like the baddies will have some opposition after all.
Dwarf Fortress!!!
To me JL dominated games are boring. You have one or two person that essentially dictate who to vote for or give very narrow choices. The targets have a very hard time defending themselves and will get loads of votes simply because they were selected, the reason for their selection is rarely made public. Since a JL is so powerful, the wolfes have to abandon all plans to eliminate the other packs and focus squarely on JL. Again, making the game dull for anyone not in JL core. Which I admit, is quite fun
( especially if you've been turned and are secretly fighting for the other side )Because of the cursed trait. Also its a lot easier to focus a JL if you have just a few people who know everything.Trespoe, what I don't get is - if Hax, Marty and the others on that list have all been scanned and considered fully clean, how comes you did not each other's identity? That makes no sense to me - only Hax Marty and their "source"(ror?) had access to the list of the "fully clean", whilst the actual "fully cleans" are all kept in the dark?
Well, I think I just got lynched, but it up to the GM to say, if I am reading this right, I have 6 votes and hebelecan has 5
As I read the list(s) not a single person on the lists are completely cleared. There are some people like me who have been seer scanned and are confirmed as "not a wolf" but that doesn't mean I can't be cultist or a sorcerer so why should the JL tell me I was semi cleared? (I would actually have preferred if they didn't tell everyone who was scanned because the wolves will probably use the list as a menu for whom to eat next since they need a lot of unscanned people to hide amongst). Then there are other people that have been priest scanned and confirmed as "not a cultist or sorcerer" but they can still be wolves.Trespoe, what I don't get is - if Hax, Marty and the others on that list have all been scanned and considered fully clean, how comes you did not each other's identity? That makes no sense to me - only Hax Marty and their "source"(ror?) had access to the list of the "fully clean", whilst the actual "fully cleans" are all kept in the dark?
Oh, I agree about JL dominated games being boring.To me JL dominated games are boring. You have one or two person that essentially dictate who to vote for or give very narrow choices. The targets have a very hard time defending themselves and will get loads of votes simply because they were selected, the reason for their selection is rarely made public. Since a JL is so powerful, the wolfes have to abandon all plans to eliminate the other packs and focus squarely on JL. Again, making the game dull for anyone not in JL core. Which I admit, is quite fun
Trespoe, what I don't get is - if Hax, Marty and the others on that list have all been scanned and considered fully clean, how comes you did not each other's identity? That makes no sense to me - only Hax Marty and their "source"(ror?) had access to the list of the "fully clean", whilst the actual "fully cleans" are all kept in the dark?
Don't be so quick to give up! The weak side almost always have a chance to claw their way back. I remember a game where half the baddies got lynched on day 2 in a gigantic epic tie, but the game still ended up being nail biting close. Jopi, the final wolf, only lost due to a heroic effort by OP.
