Chapter Twenty-Nine: In Which A Duke Talks Treason
Snaking out from between the groves of date palms and the flowering fig and pomegranate trees dotting the well-irrigated field where wheat and millet were just losing the fresh green of the early African spring and beginning to take on that golden hue of harvest time, the dirt road made its way into the village. Among the poor hovels of sun-dried mudbrick were a few larger houses, initially whitewashed, but long since ochre from the the dust carried on the hot dry winds. The men and boys of the village had all turned out and were lining the road to either side, but their faces displayed no joy at watching the colourful cavalcade of several hundred riders file by. They had been turned out by their lord to watch the spectacle, but their dusky Berber faces were all set and sullen. Try as he might, the people of Africa had little love for Duke Serlo, but they did downright hate the King, and even though they were guarded about it, it was plain enough in their faces as Serlo and his cousin were riding by.
“Don’t give me that look, cousin – you’re not my teacher anymore, and I’m not a green boy”, Bohemond laughed, shifting his weight in the saddle. “I just had to attack Mu’izz, war with Ciuccio or not. The time was perfect, my every instinct told me so – Mu’izz would’ve never thought it posible that I’d attack him while I had another war going. But you and I, we both know King Hashmaddin well enough to realize he’s a craven. I just knew that he would be cowed.”
Serlo and the King were riding to Tripoli, Serlo’s favourite residence. The Duke had set out with a host of retainers to meet his cousin’s large party and to give him honourable escort. Riding side by side like they did, in the wan of the large cavalcade but slightly apart from their many companions, was a rare opportunity for the two cousins de Hauteville to speak in some privacy, and there was much Serlo desired to learn at first hand. Bohemond had started a war against the Germans, subdued first Modena and then Ferrara and Mantua with blinding speed, and he had terribly raped the latter two counties, first and foremost to do lasting damage to the revenue King Ciuccio could draw from these lands, but also to strike terror into his heart. With the year drawing to a close and the Alpine passes already blocked up with early snows, Bohemond had left his armies in northern Italy and travelled south, to Tunis, to see to his affairs in Africa. He had only been here for a week when he had decided that the time was right to start a second little war, this time with the Hammadids, almost as if to tide him over the winter.
“While I advanced into Annaba”, Bohemond continued his account of his expedition against the Hammadids, “I sent an envoy ahead, to Hashmaddin, warning him in no uncertain terms to stay out of it. And know what? He did, he really did! While I was making war on his very own appointed governor, he sat idly by and tried to look unconcerned. God, I wish I’d have had more time, I’d conquered that coward’s remaining lands then and there. But then it's mostly worthless mountains anyhow. There are richer prizes.”
Bohemond flicked away a fly having settled on his sweaty brow; February was just turning into March, but it was already hot in Africa. “But that Mu’izz guy was made of a sterner stuff than his cowardly master”, Bohemond continued. “A fierce devil he was, and proud. He had but twelve hundred men, but he still met my three thousand in open battle. He drew up on the high ground, with a gentle but broken slope impeding our cavalry charge protecting him. I’ll give you the full account later, but suffice to say that despite his position I crushed him. Not a third of his men got away alife, while I lost less than fifty. Mu’izz himself was among the dead, he had fought bravely to the end. Makes you almost feel sorry for him, he’d have deserved better than a master who’d let him fend all for himself.”
“With Mu’izz dead and his army either slain or routed, the war was all but over. I advanced on his town, Bouna, and the citizens sent me a delegation to negotiate terms of surrender. When I told them that they could either surrender without terms or find out what I’d do if I had to take their town by force, they did quickly forget their prattle about conditions and such.”
Bohemond hawked and spat into the dust of the road before finishing: “And that was it. No more than ten weeks after setting out from Tunis I was already back in that city. The entire expedition was more like a stroll around the bailey than a proper campaign. But then I had of course been quite sure that Hashmaddin would be too frightened to oppose me.”
The Norman realm by early 1108.
Occupied lands are marked in pale red.
A mental image came to Serlo unbidden, of young Bohemod, then a neglected and dishevelled but already huge boy roaming Robert Guiscard’s household, and how he had already then struck terror into the hearts of the stablehands and serving boys. “You’ve come a long way, my lord King”, he said, one side of his mouth twisted into a tiny lopsided smile.
The King shot Serlo a sharp glance, then his mouth split into a grin. “We both have, I reckon”, he said.
“But what about this business with the Pope? I hear he has called for the liberation of the Holy Land?”
“I don’t know much more about this either”, Bohemond replied. “Clement made his address only shortly before I left for Africa, and you know what scant news comes across the sea in winter. Seems he has admonished all good Christians to charge in and free Jerusalem from the clutches of the heathen. Good luck to him, and good riddance!”
“But are others rallying to the call?”
“It’s too early to tell, but I’ve heard of none. And I don’t think many will be as mad. They will all applaud Clement’s initiative, and do nothing. But the move will gain that wily bastard quite some prestige, I’m afraid. Leadership of Christendom and all that rubbish.”
Serlo replied with one his noncomittal grunts. He didn’t like it when his cousin talked with such disrespect of the Holy Father. But then Bohemond had never shown the least piety, and the Pope’s demands half a year previous must have prejudiced him against the Holy Church ever more firmly.
“Speaking of the Pope”, Serlo resumed the conversation, “what about the war with Germany? What are your plans here, my lord King?”
Bohemond hesitated for a heartbeat before replying. “Been a bit rash there”, he said through his teeth. “Lost my temper when that worm Ciuccio tried to gainsay my perfectly legal right to Modena. Well, can’t be helped now, I have to see it through.”
Bohemond swatted again at the fly that seemed to have a special taste for royal sweat. “I left Raoul and Silvester up north”, he said, “to guard my conquests and to be ready to intercept any German army that should pass over the Alps once the snow melts. Not much of a chance for that happening, though. When they learned that their King was now also at war with me, a good handful of Ciuccio’s vassals jumped at the opportunity to shirk their duties to their lord. Thuringia, for once, and also Bavaria. Not to forget Frisia and Lower Lorraine and Meissen and quite a few counties, too, who were all pissing on Ciuccio’s name even before that. As long as he has not brought them to heel, Ciuccio can’t think of venturing into Italy. With all the trouble he’s got at his hands, I thought he might be wiling to have me off his back, so I sent him an offer of peace. ‘twould have freed him to deal with his wayward vassals, if only he would have forgone his rights to Modena, Ferrara and Spoleto.”
“Damn fool refused me. What does he hope to gain, I ask you? Does he think he stands a chance against me? All his refusal does is cause trouble for me! Now I shall have to send an army north of the Alps, to lay waste to Ciuccio’s demesne until he agrees to my demands.”
Bohemond seemed more irritatd than genuinely angry. “Ciuccio’s delaying me for no reason. It’s not his sorry German lands I’m after, the price I want is here in Africa, right there”, he said, jabbing his right towards the eastern horizon ahead of the cavalcade. “Half the trade of the Mediterranean runs by Alexandria, and I want that wealth for us Normans. And I can’t wait forever – it’s not like we were young men anymore.”
“But you don’t have any immediate plans for an attack on Egypt”, Serlo asked. He was worried that his cousin might start a war with the Fatimids, once again on the ascendence under Caliph Mukhtar, while the one with Germany was still going on.
“No, no, don’t worry”, Bohemond answered, his irritation still palpable. “How could I, with the damned Pope breathing down my neck and my northern flank exposed?”
For a short while, the King fell silent, and he and Serlo rode side by side through the lush coastal farmland surrounding Tripoli. Then, all of a sudden, without as much as even turning his head, Bohemond Spoke again. “But I shall make them pay for opposing me”, he said. “I shall make them pay dearly.”
* * *
“I’ll visit you again soon”, Serlo promised as he pushed himself off the cold, hard stone floor. His right knee, where he had been hit by a Muhammadan sword at Capua, was giving him trouble lately. He had always felt that old wound, but only since a year or two it was becoming really painful, even when riding. It had taken the joy out of hunting for Serlo, and he didn’t take to the chase anymore, as much as he had formerly loved it. His last hunt had been over half a year ago, a lion hunt held in honour of Bohemond’s visit. Serlo had grit his teeth and participated like a good host had to, but it had been more of a chore than a delight. Bohemond, on the other hand, had been as tireless as twenty years ago. Serlo’s cousin was by now far from young himself, but he seemed to be impervious to time; he even looked ten years younger than he was.
Serlo strode over to the chapel’s door, a sun-bright rectangle set in the nave’s cool semi-darkness. In front of the door he turned to the altar, dropped again to one knee and made the sign of the cross. With a last gaze at Hoel’s grave slab in front of which he had been kneeling in silent prayer, he made to leave the small church. I should’ve had him buried in the palace chapel, he thought, and damned be custom and propriety and all. Hoel had been a far better man than many entitled to such honours – but he’d also been a low-born bastard of unsure parentage, and having him buried in one of Tripoli’s common churches had been the best even a duke had been able to achieve in face of the bishop’s resitance.
Most lay in less hallowed ground, Serlo consoled himself as he stepped out into the blinding glare of the square, past the man-at-arms standing guard at the door to keep his master’s privacy of prayer. There were two other mercenaries crouching down near the tethered horses, dicing in the square’s dust, and then there was Stephen of Sidr, engaged in mock combat with Serlo’s young son, Richard. It was mainly for his benefit that he took along the guards, even though his Marshal, faithful Henry d’Acerenza, was of course right about asking Serlo to cut on the frequency of his visits to Hoel. He was in the habit of coming three times a week at least, and his visits were becoming predictable for anybody who meant him harm.
Very soon, the five men and the boy were once again mounted and making their slow way through the winding streets of Tripoli. Two men in front and two men in the back, Serlo was riding alongside Richard on his piebald pony. He tried to take his sons on as many outings as possible – he didn’t want him to grow up only in the seclusion of castles and know nothing of the people he would one day rule.
“Stephen and I have been playing knight and heathen”, Richard declared. “He has defended himself well, but I have slain him. Four times.”
“What has that heathen done to you that you needed to slay him”, Serlo asked of his son.
“He was an enemy of Jesus”, the boy said. “Father Foulques says all enemies of Jesus need to be punished.”
Father Foulques, the confessor of Serlo’s wife, was a devout and learned man and one of Richard’s teachers, but the Duke didn’t like the ideas about the Muhammadans he seemed to be placing in his son’s head. The Normans were a minority in this land, after all, and they had to live with the infidels. “Muhammadans are not bad people”, Serlo said. “They are merely in error. They have been misled by a false prophet, and they will suffer for it dearly in the afterlife.”
“Father Foulques says they are enemies. He says that this Turkish king was a great enemy of Jesus, and that we should rejoice and give thanks that the Lord did smite him.”
“Don’t repeat such nonsense, do you hear”, Serlo said, more sharply than he had wanted. “King Malik Shah was an menace to all Christians and has done our brothers in faith in Asia great harm, but he was also a brave and honourable man, a great warrior, and a great ruler. One should not rejoice at the death of such a man.”
News of the death of the Seljuk’s King had come to Tripoli only yesterday. For twenty and five years Malik Shah had sat the throne in Baghdad, and he could have sat it for ten more, had his horse not stumbled during the hunt and thrown his rider in such an unfortunate way that his neck was broken. It was a sorry way for the greatest ruler under the sun to pass away, and it did not bode well for the Christendom. His son Börü, who followed him to the throne, was said to be a fanatically devout man. With the limitless power of the Seljuk realm at his command, this was a worrying development.
“Father Foulques says that Heaven rejoices at the death of the wicked”, Richard persisted stubbornly. “Is that not so? He says Heaven will also rejoice once the King dies.”
“Hush, boy, that’s stupid, treasonous talk. The King’s my lord, and will one day be your lord. Don’t shame me or yourself by talking treason. Right or wrong, you will stand by your sworn lord, do you hear, and when you judge him let it in be in private. Your thoughts and your conscience are your own, but your loyalty does belong to your lord, always, and without reservation. I’d rather see you dead and my house come to an end than have you break a holy oath of fealty.”
“Sorry, father”, Richard said in a small, miserable voice that made Serlo rue his outbreak. It wasn’t the boy he was angry with, he knew, it was himself, for that one time when he had faltered and come so very close to commit the ultimate treason. “All’s well”, he said, bending down from his palfrey to ruffle Richard’s hair. “Just remember your duty to your lord.”
“Yes, father”, Richard said, and then, after a short pause: “Even when the lord is a heretic and an assassin?”
Serlo sighed. “The King’s no heretic. Yes, I know, the Pope says so, but when you become older, you will realize that the Pope doesn’t always speak with the voice of the Lord. Sometimes, the Pope does say things which, well, aren’t exactly lies, but not completely true either. He does not do so out of malice, like a common liar, but because he thinks that some greater good will come of it. That’s why he is saying that the King is a heretic, because he thinks that good will come of it.”
The explanation sounded lame in Serlo’s ears, but he was hoping that it was good enough for a seven year old boy. The rift between Pope Clement and Bohemond had become ever deeper in the previous half year, and Bohemond had opened himself wide to the Pope’s attack. His complete disregard for the papal appeal to free the Holy Land would have been notig in itself – nobody had followed it. But there had been other occasions, like the alleged murder of Prince Alexios Attaleiates’ eight year old son and heir Manuel to elevate Bohemond’s son Richard to the succession of Dyrrachion. There was no proof as to Bohemond’s responsibility, the boy seemed to have died of a short but violent illness, but the many unfortunate deaths in the Attaleiates family seemed to very strongly suggest Bohemond, even more so when one considered the similar stroke of misfortune having befallen the Montefeltros of Ravenna. All across Italy and well beyond, priests were laying the blame for these deeds squarely at Bohemond’s door, and the nobles were eager to listen. There were few things that upset the aristocracy so much than foul play to eradicate one noble house in favour of another, and their opinion had turned very much against Bohemond.
And there was more still. Bohemond had indeed sent an army north, into Germany, with the order to lay waste to Ciuccio’s lands. Normally, not much of what went on on the far side of the Alps became known to Serlo, but the atrocities commited by Bohemond’s warlord Raoul de Macon in the county of Steiermark had shaken all of Europe and sent their shockwaves even into distant Africa.
And Pope Clement had capitalized on all of this. He had removed himself from Rome and thus the immediate grasp of Bohemond and from the relative safety of the church’s remote holdings at Pavia was branding Bohemond a murderer and tormentor of fellow Christians. It seemed clear enough that Clement tried to create an atmosphere in which Bohemond would be viewed as some kind of Antichrist and his eventual excommunication regarded as just and justified. Nothing else could be the Pope’s aim, save maybe having Bohemond bend his knee to him – not something that was likely to happen on this side of hell, Serlo knew.
Bohemond was fighting back with all his might. He was not striking at the Pope dirctly and with armed force, as this would only provide Clement with that last proof of godlessness he needed to excommunicate Bohemond, but much more subtly. Serlo had learned that all across Europe, Bohemond was lacing the pockets of bishops and abbots with gold, buying their support against the Pope. And while many bishops and abbots spoke up publicly against the heretic Norman King, others were speaking against their Pope, questioning the lawfulness of his election at Florence and the purity of his motives in attacking Bohemond. It was a war of opinion that was being waged between Clement and Bohemond, and it was for Bohemond no less expensive than an actual war waged with armies – and more dangerous, if anything.