A New Chapter and the Election of 1896
~~
With President John W. Daniel's announcement that he would not seek re-election, the newly stocked cupboard of Progressive politicians set into each other to gain an advantage. Three distinct factions would eventually emerge both in response to how the preliminary campaigns were run. The first strong candidate to take the stage was William Vincent Allen, the Nebraska populist who had taken over much of the party's core. Allen set out to paint himself as a founder of the Populist movement, and a hero of the worker and the farmer. Allen was proclaimed by many in newspapers and on the floor of Congress, as the true author to the Worker's Bill of Rights and the true mastermind behind the success of the Populist Party.
This was a direct threat to Vice President Thomas Watson. Watson had been a great part of why Daniel had been chosen as president. Watson, a fiery speaker and a passionate leader, immediately set out to discredit Allen as a true populist. Pointing to his old ways as a Republican, Watson hoped to chip away at Allen's support within the party. Watson was not only a brilliant orator, but he was a savy politician, he ensured that any blame for the violence in Hawaii was shifted away from him and onto the shoulders of now replaced colonial governor James Henderson Blount. Watson also directed his campaign to focus on his impact in the success of the party, and his experience as Vice President. He hoped to direct his campaign like Rutherford B Hayes had in 1884 when he succeeded President Morrill after serving as Vice President.
The third candidate to emerge was another southern Populist James Paul Clarke. Clark was young, 42, and a very popular Southern Populist from Arkansas. However, he had the unfortunate luck to be surrounded by, and forced to work with, Democrats. Clarke was perhaps the most realistic of the three candidates, and was one of the key compromisers in the passing of Populist legislature in southern states. Clarke had the cleanest and kindest campaign, reminiscent of Benjamin Harrison as the kindly man seeking only to serve his country. However, he was unfavorably (and likely appropriately) compared to President Clay, the infamous compromiser.
James P. Clarke
The Republicans, nearly slain as a political party, chose to run James A. Beaver once again. Beaver was a harmless politician, and one who was very similar in ideology to the Populist mainline. The Republicans hoped to chip away at the Populist lead, and specifically regain ground in the congressional races. If parts of the North could be regained by the Republicans, then perhaps the party could rebuild and not fall the way the Wigs had many years earlier. In essence, this election, though not the Presidential one, was a race for the survival of the Republican party. Beaver, with full knowledge that his political future was in essence being sacrificed, campaigned hard for Republicans all over the North.
The Democrats had become isolated in the Deep South. Despite, or perhaps because of, their proximity, the Democrats were in the middle of a heated debate about the future of the party. The more conservative elements, led by former Mississippi governor Robert Lowry, declared that the party should return to the old ways, including the re-establishment of the Southern Christian Army. With the death of Thomas "Burnt Earth" Jackson in 1893 (at the age of 69), the Democrats had split over his message. On his death bed, Jackson quoted 1st Corinthians 10:13, "There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it. "
This final line of Jackson's left the party debating as to how he thought they should progress. Men like Lowry announced the "temptation" as the ways of the Progressive party. The more radical branch of the party led by Henry Watterson called for a free South party, one designed to create a 'southern government' to run the Deep South and believed that Jackson was calling upon the southerners to be faithful to the southern cause of Confederacy and independence. He went so far as to call for a return to the plantation slavery system of the South, and called upon the old leaders of the south, the preachers and religious men, to declare the northerners and progressives as damned. The party was split as both men put together campaigns, along with a more moderate Democrat Thomas G. Jones of Alabama.
Robert Lowry
In the end, Watson could not overcome Allen's inter-party support. More and more members of the Populist party flocked to Allen's banner, seeing him as the favorite to win the primary. When Clarke conceded and threw his support behind Allen, under the condition that Clarke become Vice President, the results were clear. Although Watson did not go down without a fight, he couldn't gain enough support to overcome the loss and eventually was forced to concede. But the resentment would remain and the rift between Watson and Allen was clear. Meanwhile the Republicans abandoned the far west to the Populists and instead focused on expanding from their New England roots. They found some success in West Virginia, and gained some congressional seats in Maryland, Ohio and Michigan, enough to survive but not enough to regain power. The Democrats, split as they were, found almost no success and lost North Texas to the Populists as farmers went over to Allen's cause. In the end, the ticket of Allen-Clarke swept the election handily.
William V. Allen and James P. Clarke- Populist- 284
James Beaver and George Edmunds- Republican- 90
Thomas G. Jones and John Y. Brown- Democrat- 12
Robert Lowry and James Z. George- Independent Democrat- 9
Henry Watterson and Francis P. Fleming- Southern Democrat- 11