Assessment and Interlude: Europe at the Death of Charles the Great
Assessment and Interlude: Europe at the Death of Charles the Great
Burgundy in 1484
We have now come to the end of the reign of Charles the Great, last Duke and first King of Burgundy. It's fitting to examine the state of the realm he left behind for his son-in-law to govern, and ask whether he has earned the esteem that history has given him.
Burgundy's prestige following the Liège-Guelders War was unsurpassed in all of Europe. The war, particularly the English blockade of Dutch ports, temporarily depressed the kingdom's economy, but it was already beginning to recover by the time Charles the Wise ascended to the throne. Nonetheless, the golden days of the 1460s and 1470s, when Burgundy's wealth, driven by the textile industries in the Low Countries, surpassed that of England, Castile, the Ottoman Empire, and France, had given way to somewhat leaner times. By far the greatest strain on Burgundy's economy was the maintenance of its large army.
The standing army that was now charged with Burgundy's defense was one of the largest in the world, and certainly one of the best trained. Yet it was less than half the size of France's. Most of the garrisons were stationed in Picardy and Cambray, merely a few days march from Paris – this would remain Burgundy's great strategic advantage over France. Smaller forces were kept in the northern Netherlands and in Burgundy Proper. As at Charles the Great's ascension, so at his death, Burgundy had no navy worth speaking of.
The late king, in taking steps to integrate his divided realm, centralized power further than it had been in Philip the Good's time, but he hesitated to move too quickly to curtail the privileges of the rich cities of the Netherlands, upon whose support he depended (an attempt to impose a salt tax, for instance, was quickly abandoned during the last war due to the protests of Dutch burghers). He also continued to support the "new learning" that was sweeping across Europe, and was an early patron of the printing press, which first arrived in Brabant in 1468 and had spread to most major cities of the kingdom over the following decade. Burgundy, particularly the Low Countries, gained a reputation as one of the most innovative lands in Europe.
Assessment of Charles the Great
Twentieth-century Irish historian Dermot Alexander once posed the question, "How great was Charles the Great?" and answered with skepticism.
In every aspect of statecraft, he was competent but never outstanding. He fought one brilliant military campaign at the outset of his reign, and won another spectacular battle towards the end (and in the latter, he had every advantage), but otherwise never proved himself anything like a genius on the battlefield. He did considerably less than his father to expand his domain, though perhaps that comparison is unfair. He was an able, even at times forward-thinking, administrator, but historians are hard-pressed to name any particularly great achievement of his on that end: he excelled in the day-to-day running of a kingdom, and knew how to appoint good men to important positions, but nothing in his record indicates the depth and breadth of vision we might expect from the title of 'the Great.' He has gained his reputation among posterity, not because of any quality of his own, but because it was upon his head that the inevitable crown first fell. When Burgundians began to speak of 'Charles the Great' – long after his death, for his grandson soon replaced him in the Burgundian consciousness – they were really applying the epithet to their country, not its founder.
To be fair, though, Alexander enjoyed taking "Greats" down a peg, and thought little better of King Alfred, Pope Gregory, or a number of other figures who hold the title. At the very least, we must give Charles I credit for establishing a new kingdom, something few in history have managed to do, and which many would argue was not as "inevitable" as Alexander claimed. Much, however, was left undone. In particular, one would have hoped to see from Charles some realization that Burgundy's safety and future glory depended on a strong navy – but he left the fleet as small as he found it thirty years earlier, no match for that of Denmark or France, much less England's or Portugal's grand navies.
Still, the reign of Charles broke the thousand-year cycle of intermittent division and conquest that had plagued Burgundy since its earliest days. For better or for worse, Burgundy was now securely a major power in Europe, and would remain so for centuries.
Europe at the Ascension of Charles the Wise
Charles II, meanwhile, had risen from a lowly count to one of the great men of Europe. We had better take a look, before we continue, at the world he faced upon his coronation. It's helpful to realize that the rise of Burgundy occurred in a time when, from Portugal to Russia, many new empires were being born.
England, at the time Burgundy's great enemy, was becoming a major power in its own right, despite the feud between James I and Edward IV, her kings' failure to make good on their claims to the French throne, and the loss of all her continental possessions. Its massive navy ensured that no enemy could set foot on English soil; this gave England free reign to deal with its immediate neighbors, Scotland and the petty kings of Ireland. An early nationalist rebellion in southeastern Ireland (1470-73), opposing both the English and Breton masters in the region, ended with England subduing the whole region to itself (as Brittany was forced to look on, too fearful to turn its back on France for even a moment). We have already seen that, shortly after the humiliating defeat of the Hundred Years' War, England miraculously fought off a Scottish invasion and, as it turned out, forever eliminated her northern neighbor as a serious threat. Within another quarter of a century, Scotland would cease to exist as an independent kingdom altogether. The transition from England to Great Britain to, in our own day, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Southern Ireland, was already in progress.
The final defeat of the Irish rebels, 1473.
In
Italy, the ambitions of Burgundy's neighbor, the Duchy of Savoy, had cost it its port city of Nice, which was now in the hands of Genoa. Genoa had already lost its control over Corsica, which was now a puppet of Florence, and its trading posts in Azov, now in the hands of the Khanate of Crimea since 1462. Its lone black sea holdout was Kaffa (modern-day Theodosia, Russia), which the Italian republic had clung to despite invasions by Crimea and a resurgent Georgia (which had annexed the last remnants of the Byzantine Empire in Trebizond, and also the Kingdom of Cyprus, despite its alliance with France).
Genoese Kaffa is a story unto itself. Under Italian control since the Middle Ages, and a Genoese possession since 1266, Kaffa was the likely source of the Black Death that decimated medieval Europe. In 1477, the Doge of Genoa invited the Dominican order to the city, and they immediately set about converting the populace using all means at their disposal. They soon convinced the authorities to issue an order to the Sunni Tartar majority: convert, leave, or die. An Inquisition was brought in to ruthlessly root out any recalcitrants, and it soon gained a reputation for cruelty even in those days. Even the future Pope Innocent VIII, then Cardinal-Archbishop of Genoa, expressed dismay at their violent methods, writing to the Doge in 1483, "Did Saint Paul slay the Greeks, or Peter the Romans? Is it not preferable to bring the true faith to the heathen by argument and example, and use the sword only in defense of Christendom?" Such moderation seems admirable to modern ears, but the Dominicans might have replied that you can't argue with success. When Crimea succeeded in driving the Italians out in 1509, it took a far more tolerant approach, and today Theodosia is the only majority-Catholic city in Russia.
The Kaffan Inquisition at work.
Meanwhile, Venice was temporarily ascendant in Greece, following the conquests of Athens and the Morea in 1475.
To the west of Burgundy,
France under Charles VIII and Henry IV had turned inward, and the kings were consolidating their power over their many stubborn vassals, determined not to let another slip away as their predecessors had done with Burgundy. The process was successful, but slow, which helps explains France's inaction against Burgundy, even while the balance of power was still in the former's favor.
When Charles the Wise came to power,
Castile and Aragon were still separate kingdoms under the joint rule of John III of Castile and his wife Isabella of Aragon. But Isabella would die in just a few more months, and John would name himself "King of all the Spains" – giving birth to Burgundy's oldest ally.
The birth of Spain in 1484. John dreamed of ruling all of Iberia, but Navarre and the Muslim kingdom of Granada would remain independent for a long time yet.
Spain's neighbor
Portugal, meanwhile, continued its explorations, reaching the Indian Ocean in 1483. A year later, a strange man came to the court of the visionary King Theodosius I, insisting that he could find a shorter route to India by travelling west. His name, of course, was Christopher Columbus. Many in the Portuguese court urged the king to dismiss this madman, but Theodosius instead gave him three ships and the provisions needed to test his theory. It's another interesting "what-if" to imagine what might have happened if the king had listened to his advisors and turned Columbus away. Where would he have gone next? Spain? England? France? Perhaps even Burgundy? We'll never know, because thanks to Theodosius, Portugal maintained its monopoly on exploration and colonization in this era.
Columbus sets out on his second voyage as the Portuguese Empire continues to grow.
On the other side of Europe, the Grand Duchy of
Moscow, under its new ruler Yuri the Terrible, subjugated the once-great republic of Novgorod in March 1484, just before Charles the Great's death. Basil wasted no time in fulfilling his ambitions – he immediately marched his armies straight from Novgorod across his realm and invaded Crimea. It would be a century and a half before all of Russia was united, but in reality, its rise had begun.
The
Ottoman Empire, after the scare it had given the Christian world in conquering Constantinople, was fairly quiet during this period, though a brief war with the Mamluk Sultanate netted it a part of Syria, and the annexation of Candar solidified its control of Asia Minor. The conquest of Greece was still some way off.
The Turks' Christian allies in
Croatia experienced a stunning rise in those days. Established in 1461 as a Turkish puppet at the expense of Hungary, it began to flex its muscles in the region after a few years of consolidating its power under its first and greatest king, Joseph I, conquering lawless Dalmatia from a distracted Venice in 1477. It then took advantage of the divided regency council ruling Bosnia, invading that country, and in 1478 annexing its southern half and forcing the underage Bosnian prince to do homage to Joseph. In 1483 it conquered the city-state of Ragusa. When Joseph died in 1489 in the middle of a war with the resurgent Hungary, it marked the end of the great period of expansion, and much of Slovenia was soon lost, but Croatia remained the dominant force in the region for generations – aided by its mighty heathen ally.
Croatia in the time of Joseph I. Bosnia would soon be definitively annexed, but Hungary was already preparing for a new war.
Following the Battle of Reszel in 1470, the Teutonic Order was defeated decisively, and
Poland-Lithuania was on the rise. Combined, these two countries formed a massive empire. Moscow defeated them in a war in the late 1470s, but won minimal gains. By all appearances, it was an up-and-coming great power. None could have imagined the ruination it would soon suffer, earning it the nickname "the Great Battleground of the Reformation." Certainly no one would have suspected in 1484 that, within a lifetime, Poland would be locked in a deadly struggle with Burgundy.
The glory days of Poland.
There remain only two other developments to discuss. The first, the controversies in the Church, we will touch upon in due time. The other is the strangest and most unexpected event all, and one that would have great consequences for Burgundy, for the Empire, for Europe, and for the whole Christian faith. So important is the Austrian Revolution that it merits a chapter of its own, so we will save those events for next time.