This AAR... just... pure... epic
I read through the whole AAR today and couldn't stop thinking about this. Very well written and most importantly illustrated AAR! That's what I like at least.
Nukes, Raaritsgorilla summarized it pretty well on the front page
It was just pure awesome-sauce to see how the fortunes of war reversed entirely, from something like +90% victory progress to clearly minus, from the Rhine and the gates of Berlin to the retreat through France and capitulation in Spain...
And EVEN further from the continental defeat to the decisively lost naval battles against Kriegsmarine (and Italian navy?) JUST OUTSIDE the harbour near Washington DC! How more incredible can one AAR simply get?!?!
Then there was the gruesome civil war with Texan armoured spearheads on top of that...
I certainly hope that the future Soviet Allied war can get going soon though. I always felt that this front had been kind of neglected I think.
Even though SU lost much of its main land and population in Bitter Peace, make no mistake, SU will have huge manpower gain with correct up to date agriculture technology and the man of the people- minister! On top of that, the late game human wave- doctrine which is nothing to sneeze at. It will surely be a titanic struggle!
PS:
Regarding the surrender of your troops in Spain though, I think it wasn't actually a bug. I know that it does sound weird, that your troops would simply all disappear after losing a combat and NOT being encircled.
Again, I'm not certain about the actual causes behind this, but this has certainly happened to me on multiple occasions, so its either working as designed or its simply a popular bug that was never fixed. This kind of "bug" has happened to me WAY before the latest Armageddon patch btw.
My personal guess, it probably has got something to do with the morale and/or near constant zero organisation of the troops in question, morale levels are hidden in-game, but continuous retreat and continuous engagements with enemy troops and further defeats, together with constantly poor supply situation surely cannot help in gaining back organisation levels as they would normally do while retreating.
I'd wager that this is possible to replicate, you could always try to for example land in france, and let yourself be cut off, but still retain large portions of inland france (no harbours though). Then you would allow yourself to be defeated and harassed by the enemy from province to province, trying, of course, to avoid retreating to enemy held provinces which indeed causes instant death as far as the formation goes.