((To the Cabinet and the his Most Christian Majesty, the King. @99KingHigh and all members of the Cabinet.))
To your Most Christian Majesty and your Cabinet,
We have completed preliminary investigation into the incident that took place in Lyon. We have found upon review of the evidence that the both the number and character of the rebels in question were highly exaggerated by those in command. However, it would be beyond the scope of our inquiry to judge that the actions undertaken by chosen in command as illegal, in the sense that there were insurrectionists engaged in anti-government activity that the military acted to counteract. On the face of these facts, we have determined it cannot be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the officers in question conspired or fabricated such an insurrection. Thus our inquiry cannot corroborate the claims made by the Police Minister that there was a conspiracy by the officers in question to fake a rebellion.
However, it is also readily apparent that the size, scope, and threat of the insurrectionists were greatly exaggerated for want of rewards and honors. We believe it would be prudent to deny such honors to the officers in question to encourage honesty, integrity, and fidelity in the King's army; after all, we cannot make decisions here in Paris if our subordinates would have the nerve to lie to our faces. We recommend no punishment for be given to the rank-and-file, who did not know better, but that General Canuel and the officers under his command who aided, or caused to aid, exaggerations in the size, scope, and threat of the insurrectionists be formally reprimanded, put on half-pay, and transferred to the Army of the Northeast where they can reclaim their honor in service of the Throne.
We must not endeavor to discourage vigorous prosecution of your Majesty's enemies, yet at the same time we would lose the trust of the people if ambitious and unscrupulous men were allowed to fake reports for benefits, and cause unwanted afflictions upon your subjects in the quest for honors. We do not believe General Canuel above redemption and it is also our opinion that any further punishment or investigation will negatively impact the on-going elections, and call into question the ultimate impartiality of the Army.
Thus we also request that Ministers Saint-Aignan and Decazes cease making public statements on this matter, as we believe that no further good can come from litigating this in public.
I have enclosed the relevant documents complied by military investigators with this letter.
Always your humble and obedient servant,
M. Saint-Cyr
To your Most Christian Majesty and your Cabinet,
We have completed preliminary investigation into the incident that took place in Lyon. We have found upon review of the evidence that the both the number and character of the rebels in question were highly exaggerated by those in command. However, it would be beyond the scope of our inquiry to judge that the actions undertaken by chosen in command as illegal, in the sense that there were insurrectionists engaged in anti-government activity that the military acted to counteract. On the face of these facts, we have determined it cannot be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the officers in question conspired or fabricated such an insurrection. Thus our inquiry cannot corroborate the claims made by the Police Minister that there was a conspiracy by the officers in question to fake a rebellion.
However, it is also readily apparent that the size, scope, and threat of the insurrectionists were greatly exaggerated for want of rewards and honors. We believe it would be prudent to deny such honors to the officers in question to encourage honesty, integrity, and fidelity in the King's army; after all, we cannot make decisions here in Paris if our subordinates would have the nerve to lie to our faces. We recommend no punishment for be given to the rank-and-file, who did not know better, but that General Canuel and the officers under his command who aided, or caused to aid, exaggerations in the size, scope, and threat of the insurrectionists be formally reprimanded, put on half-pay, and transferred to the Army of the Northeast where they can reclaim their honor in service of the Throne.
We must not endeavor to discourage vigorous prosecution of your Majesty's enemies, yet at the same time we would lose the trust of the people if ambitious and unscrupulous men were allowed to fake reports for benefits, and cause unwanted afflictions upon your subjects in the quest for honors. We do not believe General Canuel above redemption and it is also our opinion that any further punishment or investigation will negatively impact the on-going elections, and call into question the ultimate impartiality of the Army.
Thus we also request that Ministers Saint-Aignan and Decazes cease making public statements on this matter, as we believe that no further good can come from litigating this in public.
I have enclosed the relevant documents complied by military investigators with this letter.
Always your humble and obedient servant,
M. Saint-Cyr
Last edited: